Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mary: Forth Person in the Godhead?


Recommended Posts

Posted

A Protestant friend of mine said that he was told that there was Papal encyclical that elevated Mary to being a fourth person in the godhead. I told him that the Catholic Church does not teach this. I searched the web and I found the following quote on several Protestant web sites...

[i]Pope Pius XII in 1954: "Mary is indeed worthy to receive honour and might and glory. [b]She is exalted to hypostatic union with the Blessed Trinity.[/b]"[/i]

I know the Church does not teach this, however, where is this "fact" coming from? Did Pope Pius ever say this and if so, in what context was it meant to be taken. How should I answer my friend? What can I show him to counter this claim?

Thanks for your help.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Without a document title... it's most likely a fabricated quote. Or a really poor mistranslation.

(and if it's only on protestant websites.. then there's definitely something fishy going on...)

Posted

They are lying through their teeth....

On Proclaiming the Queenship of Mary...
Encyclical of Pope Pius XII

AD CAELI REGINAM

St. Andrew of Crete frequently attributes the dignity of a Queen to the Virgin Mary. For example, he writes, "Today He transports from her earthly dwelling, as Queen of the human race, His ever-Virgin Mother, from whose womb He, the living God, took on human form."[19]



18. And in another place he speaks of "the Queen of the entire human race faithful to the exact meaning of her name, who is exalted above [b]all things save only God himself
[/b]

34. As We have already mentioned, Venerable Brothers, according to ancient tradition and the sacred liturgy the main principle on which the royal dignity of Mary rests is without doubt her Divine Motherhood. In Holy Writ, concerning the Son whom Mary will conceive, We read this sentence: "He shall be called the Son of the most High, and the Lord God shall give unto him the throne of David his father, and he shall reign in the house of Jacob forever, and of his kingdom there will be no end,"[40] and in addition Mary is called "Mother of the Lord";[41] from this it is easily concluded that she is a Queen, since she bore a son who, at the very moment of His conception, [b]because of the hypostatic union of the human nature with the Word[/b], was also as man King and Lord of all things. So with complete justice St. John Damascene could write: "When she became Mother of the Creator, she truly became Queen of every creature."[42] Likewise, it can be said that the heavenly voice of the Archangel Gabriel was the first to proclaim Mary's royal office

Posted (edited)

I couldn't find anything close to it in his 1954 Encyclicals at www.papalencyclicals.net and noone who quotes it says where Pius XII said it in 1954. They need to post their ref before I would put any stock in him saying it. In fact I am quite sure he didn't and that it is a distortion of something he actually said. Looks like anyone one of those distortions passed around from one protestant to another like that same loaf of fruitcake from Christmass to Christmass. They will of course believe it because they want to.

Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

how ridiculous. is it possible to be intellectually honest and still be anti-catholic? i'm inclined to think not.......

Posted

Ridiculous!

It was posted around here before if I am not mistaken that the mulsims, or islam sees Mary as the third person in the trinity for some reason and that this can be quoted in the Koran; is this true? How can this fact be substantiated?

Other than that I have no comments.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Feb 6 2006, 04:44 PM']Ridiculous!

It was posted around here before if I am not mistaken that the mulsims, or islam sees Mary as the third person in the trinity for some reason and that this can be quoted in the Koran; is this true?  How can this fact be substantiated?

Other than that I have no comments.
[right][snapback]877204[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I cant remember which Surah it is--I've not picked up a Koran for a long time--but indeed the Koran has Jesus put to question as to whether or not He was commanded to make of himself and his mother gods. Plus there are statements such as God would need a wife if Jesus was God's son.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...