lindsaynf Posted February 6, 2006 Posted February 6, 2006 hi everyone, i'm new to this message board, and i joined because i'm hoping to get some of my questions answered. my fiance is catholic, and i'm really trying to understand and appreciate his religion, but i still don't understand a few details about catholicism. please understand, i'm a christian, was saved when i was 7, i've been called to be a youth minister, so studying religion is my life, and i love God more than religion. I do consider the Bible to be true, and contextual, so if you have a verse reference, that would be awesome. a list to begin with: 1. Why is the eucharist truly the body and blood? why can't it be a symbol, like raising your hands in worship? 2. what's up with the crossing yourself? is there a point other than being respectful? 3. Aren't all sins the same to God? i mean, He can't be around sin, so why would one be worse than the other? 4. Purgatory. if when Christ died we were forgiven for all sins, past present and future, why is there need for more forgiveness after we die? thank you, and please understand, again, that i am not trying to turn anyone onto my beliefs, just trying to make sense of it in my head. ~linz
Brother Adam Posted February 6, 2006 Posted February 6, 2006 Welcome to Phatmass, and thank you for coming here to seek answers. You will find the answers here to be about as orthodox and biblical as they come. [quote]1. Why is the eucharist truly the body and blood? why can't it be a symbol, like raising your hands in worship?[/quote] Catholics affirm the symbolism in the Eucharist, and the reality of what the Eucharist is. We especially look to our Savior, Jesus Christ, as he teaches us about the Eucharist in John 6 and in the institution narratives in all 4 Gospels. We also look to the teachings of St. Paul in 1 Corinthans 11. The Bible undeniably teaches the Real Presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. It is what Jesus established, what is recorded in the Scriptures, and what the Church, His bridegroom has taught for 2000 years. [quote]2. what's up with the crossing yourself? is there a point other than being respectful?[/quote] It is a symbol and reminder of our belonging to Jesus Christ. It is an ancient tradition in which we remind ourselves that we have died to sin and are risen again in Christ, and that it is Christ who lives in us (Galations 2:19). [quote]3. Aren't all sins the same to God? i mean, He can't be around sin, so why would one be worse than the other?[/quote] We cannot approach God in the Beatific Vision (God as He is, glorified and unveiled in heaven), and God certianly hates sin. The Bible however states that some sins are more serious than others (murder is more serious than lying). The Bible specifically says that some sins are mortal, and others are not. Some sins cause spiritual death (becuase we are utterly rejecting God and His plan for our lives, and God, giving us free will allows us to leave Him if we choose to). 1 John 5:13-17 [quote]4. Purgatory. if when Christ died we were forgiven for all sins, past present and future, why is there need for more forgiveness after we die?[/quote] God lives outside of time, but we live in time. Christ died for our sins at Calvary, an event which is made present today through the mass, but it is a matter of taking that saving grace and applying it to our souls. In essance, how we are saved. Since I live in time, I can at any time choose to sin against God. I have to be in a state of grace (saved) in order to go to heaven when I die, but because of concupiscience (the inclination to sin) I may die in a state that isn't totally holy. I may still have attachments to things like money, and I may still be damaged by the effects of sin (becuase even when we are children of God, we still sin sometimes). Purgatory is a holy washing away of any temporary effects of sin, preparing us to be before a Thrice Holy God. It is not punishment as much as it is preparation. [quote]thank you, and please understand, again, that i am not trying to turn anyone onto my beliefs, just trying to make sense of it in my head.[/quote] Thank you for asking us what we believe instead of assuming, like so many Protestants do. I, like many at Phatmass are converts to the Catholic faith.
Paphnutius Posted February 6, 2006 Posted February 6, 2006 Since Br. Adam did a good job starting out I will try to be short and concise. [quote]1. Why is the eucharist truly the body and blood? why can't it be a symbol, like raising your hands in worship? [/quote]Because Christ said that it was. I am sure that you are familiar with being pointed to John 6. Christ told us that it was His Body and Blood and as St. Paul tells us there are real consequences for receiving it unworthily. If it were merely symbolic there would be no need to mention approaching it. As Br. Adam said though, it is both symbol and reality. [quote]2. what's up with the crossing yourself? is there a point other than being respectful?[/quote]It is a way of reminding us of Christ and His Passion. We typically begin and end prayer with it because we are told to ask in Christ's name. [quote]3. Aren't all sins the same to God? i mean, He can't be around sin, so why would one be worse than the other? [/quote]You must also consider the effects that sin has on you. Some sins are far more dangerous to your spiritual life than others, so in that sense they are unequal due to their subjective harm done. [quote]4. Purgatory. if when Christ died we were forgiven for all sins, past present and future, why is there need for more forgiveness after we die?[/quote]Purgatory is not forgiving sins, it presupposes that. Purgatory is a sanctification and purifying process. If you would like a more expounded answer on anything please let me know.
thessalonian Posted February 6, 2006 Posted February 6, 2006 (edited) Wel come. [quote]a list to begin with: 1. Why is the eucharist truly the body and blood? why can't it be a symbol, like raising your hands in worship?[/quote] Well first of all it is a symbol. It is symbolic of the molding together of the faithful in to the body of Christ (roman 12, 1 cor 12). We though many become one body. As the many grains are crushed and become one loaf or the many grapes crushed to become one cup of wine, so we are crushed and unified to become one body. Why is it not JUST symbolic? First of all because our Lord said it was not in John 6 at least 4 times. As I explain this it should also be noted that John 6 parrelles Matt 26. Both occured near the passover (john 6 4). In fact Jhn 6 was 1 year before matt 26.. John 6 50: This is the bread which comes down from heaven, that a man may eat of it and not die. 51: I am the living bread which came down from heaven; if any one eats of this bread, he will live for ever; and the bread which I shall give for the life of the world is my flesh." 52: The Jews then disputed among themselves, saying, "How can this man give us his flesh to eat?" Get that. The Jews took him literally. Okay so he must correct their misunderstanding, right? NOPE. He more strongly affirms it. 53: So Jesus said to them, "[b]TRULY, TRULY [/b]I say to you, unless you [b]eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you; [/b]54: he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. 55:[b] For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed[/b]. (this parrellels matt 26 where he says "this is my body...this is my blood")/ 56: [b]He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him. [/b]57: As the living Father sent me, and I live because of the Father, so he who eats me will live because of me. 58: This is the bread which came down from heaven, not such as the fathers ate and died; he who eats this bread will live for ever." Note that in v. 66 some of his own disciples leave him. Then he asks peter and the boys if they will leave him also. They indicate how difficult this teaching is (no kidding) but acknowledge their faith in him at the end of the chapter. There is much more of course such as the whole old testatement teaching on the pascal sacrifice. In Ex 12, the lamb who forshadowed christ was to be eaten before the dawn of a new day. Bottom line we take Jesus at his word especially when the evidence, both scriptural and historical (ever heard of the Early Church Fathers) is so overwhelming. [quote]2. what's up with the crossing yourself? is there a point other than being respectful?[/quote] It's a reminder of our baptism and the God whom we serve. It is symbolic only. [quote]3. Aren't all sins the same to God? i mean, He can't be around sin, so why would one be worse than the other?[/quote] Well judging by the priest scandal it is obvious that noone really believes that. Any priest who is even accused of it seems damned to hell by Protestants who believe that stealing a cookie is the same as robbing a bank. It is not logical of course. John makes a distinction: 1 John 5 16: If any one sees his brother committing what is not a mortal sin, he will ask, and God will give him life for those whose sin is not mortal. [b]There is sin which is mortal[/b]; I do not say that one is to pray for that. 17: All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin [b]which is not mortal[/b]. There are also varying levels of culpability. For in Luke 12 it says "the one who new will be treated with the unbeliever, but the one who did not know, will recieve but few lashes.". [quote]4. Purgatory. if when Christ died we were forgiven for all sins, past present and future, why is there need for more forgiveness after we die?[/quote] Purgatory is not about the forgiveness of sins first of all. One who is in purgatory has all of his sins forgiven. But he still has the affects of those sins on his soul. He still has sinful habits. These things must be purged from him for the book of revelations says "nothing unclean shall enter". I would assume you believe in imputed righteousness, i.e. that the new Christian is positionally righteous but not truly rightous. So tell me how one gets from being one to the other. We can't just be snow covered dung in heaven. We must be cleansed. You will likely say by the process of sanctification. Amen. But what happens if sanctification is not completed by death? The position of imputed righteousness makes purgatory more neccessary than the catholic view of infused righteousness. We do not believe that future sins are forgiven. This is not logical or scriptural. There are examples where scripture speaks of "fallen from grace" gal 5 or being "severed from Christ" gal 5 or "cut off from Christ" Rom 11, by sin. We therefore can sin to the point where we are separated from the body of Christ so we do not believe in Eternal Security or Once Saved Always saved. One cannot be said to have fallen from a tree he was never in or severed from something he was never a part of. There are many more verses that I could site that refute these doctrines, such as: 1 Cor 15 2: by which you are saved, if you hold it fast -- unless you believed in vain. Heb 6 4: For it is impossible to restore again to repentance those who have once been enlightened, who have tasted the heavenly gift, and have become partakers of the Holy Spirit, 5: and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, 6: if they then commit apostasy, since they crucify the Son of God on their own account and hold him up to contempt. Hope that helps. It is breif. You might want to check out a book called "born fundamentalist, born again Catholic" by David Curie. It will help you understand how we view things. Blessings Edited February 6, 2006 by thessalonian
Fides_et_Ratio Posted February 6, 2006 Posted February 6, 2006 Welcome to the boards! Don't hesitate to ask questions (especially follow-up questions!) Though Bro. Adam & Paphnutius & Thessalonian did a fine job, I'm going to jump in with my two cents on a few. [quote]4. Purgatory. if when Christ died we were forgiven for all sins, past present and future, why is there need for more forgiveness after we die?[/quote] "the Sacred Heart of Jesus is a burning furnace of Charity" (a way awesome priest said that) and it fits in well with the idea of Purgatory (a final washing away of our sins)--because "nothing unclean shall enter Heaven" (Rev. 21:27). When we die, though forgiven of our sins, we still remain "attached" so to speak to the world. Our hearts are not entirely purified while we are still on earth (as was mentioned--we still experience temptation and the inclination to sin). Purgatory burns all that away in the love of Christ. I always like to use the image Paul provides in 1 Corinthians 3:15... that which we've done in life that's good (i.e., friendships, love, faith, etc.) is like silver and gold and only becomes more refined in the firery love of Christ. But that which we've done that isn't good (sin, temptation, our attachments to things of the world, etc.) are like paper and straw, and burn up the closer we draw to the Lord-- at first it hurts (to a greater or lesser degree depending upon how deep those attachments run), but when you've reached the end, you're perfectly clean and free from anything and everything that would hold you back from the Lord in His loving embrace. I hope that helps. [quote]thank you, and please understand, again, that i am not trying to turn anyone onto my beliefs, just trying to make sense of it in my head. [right][snapback]877487[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Perfectly fine! Again, don't hesitate to ask further questions about anything.
Church Punk Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 [quote]1. Why is the eucharist truly the body and blood? why can't it be a symbol, like raising your hands in worship?[/quote] Like everyone else said... John 6. "Truely I tell you, flesh is food indeed and my blood is drink". [quote]2. what's up with the crossing yourself? is there a point other than being respectful?[/quote] Well Protestants say "In the name of Jesus" after every prayer. Jesus even said what ever you ask in my name I will grant! Catholics make the sign of the cross that is say In the Name of the Father and of The Son and of the Holy Spirit, evoking the Trinity before and after each prayer. We also say in the Name of Jesus as well. It is a way of addressing God as the 3 persons of the Trinity, The Father, the Son, and Holy Ghost. [quote]3. Aren't all sins the same to God? i mean, He can't be around sin, so why would one be worse than the other?[/quote] If you were to steal a loaf of bread, do you think you are of the same guilt of Adolph Hitler in the geneocide of Jews? Even in our world as messed up as it is it is clear that there is different levels of sin. Or if you were to smack a friend would He forgive you soon about it? Now if you shot him, it might be a different story! We are all sinful, we need His mercy no matter what. However in comparsion does Mother Teresa deserve the same punishment as a man like Hitler? Now this will naturally bring you to your next question about Catholicism... Sola Fide that is Saved by Faith Alone. As you can see from everyone else post we as Catholics believe in by Faith and Works. [quote]4. Purgatory. if when Christ died we were forgiven for all sins, past present and future, why is there need for more forgiveness after we die?[/quote] Like Fides et Ratio said. Gods love is reflected of fire. This is evident through out the old testement as well. Abramham after making his sacrifice, God came and consumed it appearing as a torch of fire. In Able's sacrifice of wheat, his offering is consumed by fire. (also a foreshaddowing of Jesus sacrifice). Moses encountered a burning bush. Before we are entered into heaven we are purged Gods love removing the tendancy to sin. I think the other guys said it well already.
curtins Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 Welcome- Regaurding your question on the Eucharist- Jesus at the last supper said- "THIS IS MY BODY" - not this is a symbol- if he was lying then that means he's not God. And if he meant other wise that means that God screwed up because for the last 2000 years his church has been doing the completly wrong thing than what he intended- that means satan won- or "the gates of hell" overcame the church- in which case Jesus(God) would have been lying again. And if God fails then he can't be God and we're basically all doomed.
Brother Adam Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 (edited) As you can see, when you ask one question here, you will get many, if not dozens of responses. Please do not feel obligated to answer each and every one. Please read and respond to what you personally feel is pertinent to yourself and your fiance. Feel free to continue along as well and ask any other questions that come to mind. We're here to help in any way that we can. Edited February 7, 2006 by Brother Adam
Norseman82 Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 Additionally, regarding the Eucharist, the Church has believed in the Real Presence from the beginning: 1 Cor. 11:27-29 :" This means that whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily sins against the body and blood of the Lord. A man should examine himself first; only then should he eat of ther bread and drink of the cup. He who eats and drinks without recognizing the body eats and drinks a judgment on himself". Also, Ignatius of Antioch in "Letter to the Smyrneans" - written around 100-110 AD - wrote "Take note of those who hold heterodox opinions on the grace of Jesus Christ which has come to us, and see how contrary their opinions are to the mind of God. For love they have no care, nor for the widow, nor for the orphan, nor for the distressed, nor for those in prison orfreed from prison, nor for the hungry and thirsty. They abstain from the Eucharist and prayer, because they do not confess that the Eucharist is the Flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ, Flesh which suffered for our sins and which the Father, in His goodness, raised up again."
lindsaynf Posted February 7, 2006 Author Posted February 7, 2006 wow. you guys are all amazing. thank you so much for all of your wonderful and spirit-filled responses. okay, so i basically get everything except this eucharist thing. i dunno, maybe it's my upbringing in the baptist church. i mean, Christ also refered to himself as living water...did he mean that litereally? He also refered to himself as a lamb prepared for the slaughter did He mean he was a sheep? He also said I am the vine. So which was it, water, ram, or plant? and when He says "truly truly" at the Lord's supper, i think you have to remember that this was at the very end of his ministry on Earth, and He was probably getting tierd of these disciples and thier stupidity. I mean, He told them He was going to die and come back on the 3rd day, but they never saw it comeing. i read that passage and see Him saying it over and over again so they might get that He is our bread, meaning our suffiency, and our wine, meaning our abundence. that we need to remember Him and remember that He is the only way. get back to me!! ~linz
Brother Adam Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 [quote]wow. you guys are all amazing. thank you so much for all of your wonderful and spirit-filled responses.[/quote] Glad we're able to help in some way answer your questions about our beliefs. : [quote]okay, so i basically get everything except this eucharist thing. i dunno, maybe it's my upbringing in the baptist church.[/quote] Well, sure. I was baptist for three years, it really is difficult to see things another way, even if you are only trying to understand. I spent three years here reading every book I could get my hands on until I finally 'got it' and realized it was the answer I was looking for to the divisions in the Christian Church (that or someone hit me over the head with a frying pan and dragged me in ) [quote]i mean, Christ also refered to himself as living water...did he mean that litereally? He also refered to himself as a lamb prepared for the slaughter did He mean he was a sheep? He also said I am the vine. So which was it, water, ram, or plant?[/quote] The scriptures are kinda funny that way. We can't always interpret them in a literalist manner. The Catechism of the Catholic Church describes some of the principles for biblical interpretation that way. If we are to always take them literally without considering context, what the rest of the Bible says, culture, authors intent, what would we make of passages like Matthew 27:9 where the author is flat out wrong about the quote being in Jeremiah (it is actually in Zecheriah)? We need to be sure we are taking everything into account. I think that was one of the things I did as a baptist - I had a collection of verses (John 3:15, Ephesians 2:8-9, Romans 3:23,6:23) and forced the rest of scripture to fit into my own collection of passages instead of considering the 'forest for the trees'. We need in some way, ironically, to understand that the passage on the living bread is both literal and symbolic. For instance, Jesus really was the "lamb" of God lead to the slaughter. This is typological to the Old Testament sacrifice of the passover - Jesus died, as the Son of God, as the Lamb of God, for the sins of the people, instituting a new Covenant, so the people would no longer have to make yearly sacrifices for their sins - Jesus becomes the mediator instead. John 6, nor the institution narratives give us any indication that Jesus is speaking only symbolically. If he was, he would be telling the Jews "hate me, insult me and my family, do not love me or follow me" by telling them 'to eat my flesh and drink my blood'. That is how Jews understood something like that. In John 6 though, they took him literally, he said "yep, you get it, it is literal", and they then saw it as a hard teaching, somewhat like you do (and I did!). Jesus didn't correct them and say it was only symbolic, he let them leave. There is also the example of the feeding of the 4 and 5000 as pointing to the Eucharist, and the bread that never runs out. But we can get more into this later, for now I digress. [quote]and when He says "truly truly" at the Lord's supper, i think you have to remember that this was at the very end of his ministry on Earth, and He was probably getting tierd of these disciples and thier stupidity.[/quote] I'm not trying to be mean, but my gut feeling is you are trying to make the passage serve your own purposes without considering some of those interpretive princples. Blessings, Adam
Fides_et_Ratio Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 Again, just adding to what Bro. Adam said (don't feel overwhelmed!)... Also... the Last Supper Accounts and the Bread of Life Discourse (in John 6) the word "this" is used. When Jesus compares Himself to a door, a vine, light, etc. He never uses the word "this"--He's never referring to a specific thing. But He is during the Last Supper and while telling the disciples that they must eat His body and drink His blood. Mathew 26:26 "And as they were eating, Jesus took bread, and blessed it, and broke it, and gave it to the disciples, and said, Take, eat; this(5124) is my body." Mark 14:22 "And as they did eat, Jesus took bread, and blessed, and broke it, and gave to them, and said, Take, eat: this(5124) is my body." Luke 22:19 "And he took bread, and gave thanks, and broke it, and gave unto them, saying, This(5124) is my body which is given for you: this do in remembrance of me." John 6:50 "This(3778) is the bread which cometh down from heaven, that a man may eat thereof, and not die." The "this" is this passage from John 6 is in place of a pronoun... Jesus is pointing to Himself. Thus, without physical bread for them to see and Him to proclaim "THIS is my body", Jesus instead turns it around and points to Himself proclaiming "THIS is the bread". (all the numbers in the verses coincide with Strong's concordance so that you can see that the "this" is a thing (i.e., the bread) and that it is also a pronoun (i.e., referring to Jesus Himself) Hope that helps. Remember, you are always free to ask follow up questions! Just keep praying and seek the Truth in all things.
thessalonian Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 [quote name='lindsaynf' date='Feb 7 2006, 12:47 AM']wow. you guys are all amazing. thank you so much for all of your wonderful and spirit-filled responses.[/quote] I think I speak for the group when I say we're glad to help. : [quote]okay, so i basically get everything except this eucharist thing. i dunno, maybe it's my upbringing in the baptist church.[/quote] Could be. My wife however was baptist when we met. When faced with the words of John 6 however she could not deny them and eventually took Christ at his word. i[quote] mean, Christ also refered to himself as living water...did he mean that litereally? He also refered to himself as a lamb prepared for the slaughter did He mean he was a sheep? He also said I am the vine. So which was it, water, ram, or plant?[/quote] There are many types of literary forms in the scriptures. Metaphore, allegory, myth (which doesn't mean false or it didn't really happen, just that typology and allegory are used to tell the story in a way which gives it spiritual meaning). [quote]and when He says "truly truly" at the Lord's supper, i think you have to remember that this was at the very end of his ministry on Earth, and He was probably getting tierd of these disciples and thier stupidity[/quote]. Actually no. John 6 was 1 year before the end of his ministry. That is when he says it. [quote]I mean, He told them He was going to die and come back on the 3rd day, but they never saw it comeing. i read that passage and see Him saying it over and over again so they might get that He is our bread, meaning our suffiency, and our wine, meaning our abundence. that we need to remember Him and remember that He is the only way.[/quote] What you have said here is good. But there is much more too it and it is beyond our comprehension but not beyond reason. I mean that as it is said. God is all powerful. Don't limit him. In all the metaphores, door, branches, vine, lving water, etc. His words are always "I am the x". Never "this x is me". He is so emphatic about this that it cannot be mistaken as simply metaphore, though it is in fact metaphorical for he does say "I am the bread of life". But there is a far greater reality. As I have said there is tons in the scriptures that point to it. You simply need to allow yourself to see it. No he was not a lamb literally, but the lamb foreshadowed his sacrifice. We must examine the scriptures carefully and understand the different senses and wording in which things are to be taken. What he says in John 6 is VERY different from the other metaphores he uses. The way the people take it is VERY different. They do take him literally and he makes no attempt to correct them "oh, it's only a metaphore guys". Show me another example where people walk away because he says he is a door or a vine or a branch. They understood his language and they left him over this one because "this saying is hard, who can bear it?". His own disciples said this. [66] After this many of his disciples drew back and no longer went about with him. [67] Jesus said to the twelve, "Do you also wish to go away?" Well, do you? Blessings
thessalonian Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 Here is what Paul has to say: 1 Cor 11 24] and when he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, "This is my body which is for you. Do this in remembrance of me." [25] In the same way also the cup, after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me." [26] For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes. [27] [b]Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord. [/b] So if you take a piece of bread and some wine unworthily that is a terrible sin? No, this makes much more sense in the context of John 6 and the reality of the Lord's Supper. For 1600 years NOONE except for a small group called the Messalians in the 4th century denied the true prescence of Christ in the Eucharist. There was some squabbling in I think it was the 8th or 10th century about the exact nature of it but it was a deeply held belief until some of the reformers (actually luther and calvin and wesly believed it to a degree, zwingli denied it) decieded they new better. Blessings
thessalonian Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 I might also add that the Eucharist is our manna in the desert of life. It is food for our soul that gives us strength against sin and for overcoming sin in our lives. It is God's grace in our lives giving us the strength to do the work that he wants to do in us and through us.
lindsaynf Posted February 7, 2006 Author Posted February 7, 2006 i can't seem toi thank you guys enough. it's very important for me to be able to see little things like this through and through. i mentioned many times that i was raised in the baptist church. well, about 3 years ago i started moving away from that particular denomination, and i fought hard for my faith with everyone including my family, and it's the little things that i consider mini battles towards a clearer picture of God. i know i will never understand Him, but it really draws Him closer to me to work these things out in my heart. and it's not just catholisism, i've studyed other religions too, so that i know mine is the truth. and i do understand that these aren't nessecities to salvation, and that, just like predestination and speaking in tougnes, they are just another expression of His glory. so i thank you. and if you have any futher input, i will gladly receive it. and i'm sure to be back as my wedding gets closer (we're having a joint ceremony, but in a catholic church). God bless. ~linz (my email: lindsaynf@gmail.com)
scardella Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 [quote name='lindsaynf' date='Feb 6 2006, 02:01 PM']1. Why is the eucharist truly the body and blood? why can't it be a symbol, like raising your hands in worship? [/quote] Hopefully, I don't sound trite (and hopefully won't run it off-topic), but here's my stab at it: [b]That's what the Magisterium (the teaching authority of the Catholic Church) teaches.[/b] Baptists do not have an flesh and bone authority to decisively say "this is how we interpret this and that part of Scripture." What's to be taken literally? What's to be taken symbolically? The easy answer is that many of those things have already been considered, debated and settled a long time ago by people much holier and more learned than I. Here's the other short answer: The Eucharist is truly the Body and Blood of Jesus because if it weren't, then it wouldn't be the Eucharist. It literally makes us one body. It is true Communion (union-with). It incorporates us into the Paschal Mystery: Jesus' life, death and resurrection. Why give thanks (Eucharist) for a mere symbol?
phatcatholic Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 lindsay...............here is a defense of the Eucharist that i wrote a while back. i hope it helps. in the OT there are many forshadowings of the eucharistic sacrifice. first, in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Malachi+1%3A11§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mal&NavGo=1&NavCurrentChapter=1"][b]Mal 1:11[/b][/url] we see that in every place a burnt offering [or a sacrifice] will be made. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+12%3A14§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mal&NavGo=1&NavCurrentChapter=1"][b]Exo 12:14[/b][/url] we see that the feast of the paschal lamb is a perpetual ordinance. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Jer+33%3A17-18§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=12&NavCurrentChapter=12"][b]Jer 33:17-18[/b][/url] says that the house of Israel shall never want of a priest "to do sacrifice continually." the Eucharistic Sacrifice fulfills all of these prophecies. next, although it is common knowledge that Jesus is the "paschal lamb" (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+5%3A7§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=jer&NavGo=33&NavCurrentChapter=33"][b]1 Cor 5:7[/b][/url]), what is often forgotten is that the lamb [i][b]must be eaten[/b][/i]. this is seen in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+12%3A8%2C11§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=5&NavCurrentChapter=5"][b]Exo 12:8,11[/b][/url] where the Israelites were told to eat the lamb so that the angel would pass over them. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+29%3A33§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=12&NavCurrentChapter=12"][b]Exo 29:33[/b][/url] "they shall eat those things wherewith the atonement was made, to consecrate and to sanctify them". in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Lev+7%3A15§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=29&NavCurrentChapter=29"][b]Lev 7:15[/b][/url] the flesh of the sacrifice must be eaten. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Chron+30%3A15-17§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=le&NavGo=7&NavCurrentChapter=7"][b]2 Chron 30:15-17[/b][/url] (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Chron+35%3A1%2C6%2C11%2C13§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=2ch&NavGo=30&NavCurrentChapter=30"][b]2 Chron 35:1,6,11,13[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezra+6%3A20-21§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=2ch&NavGo=35&NavCurrentChapter=35"][b]Ezr 6:20-21[/b][/url]) the lamb is eaten so as to achieve purification. also, in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezekiel+2%3A8-10§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ezr&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]Ezek 2:8-10[/b][/url] and [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezekiel+3%3A1-3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=eze&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"][b]3:1-3[/b][/url] Ezekiel is commanded by God to eat the scroll--the Word of God--which was in his mouth "as honey for sweetness." all of these verses forshadow Jesus Christ, the lamb and the Word of God, who must be eaten. from here we move to the new testament. the first thing to note about the "Eucharistic Discourse" (as it is often called) from John 6 is that it occurs on the eve of the Passover, when the lambs are slaughtered and eaten (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A4§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=eze&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]John 6:4[/b][/url]). this adds greater significance to his words and further points to him as the paschal lamb that must be eaten. after this, [i][b]he begins to gradually call the Jews to a greater act of faith[/b][/i]. first, Jesus multiplies the loaves and the fishes. this points to the Eucharist in many ways. Jesus will be their nourishment and they will never grow hungry. also noteworthy is the fact that the account of the miracle begins with almost the same words as those which the synoptics and st. paul use to describe the institution of the Eucharist (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mat+26%3A26§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]Mat 26:26[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mark+14%3A22§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mt&NavGo=26&NavCurrentChapter=26"][b]Mark 14:22[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Luke+22%3A19§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mr&NavGo=14&NavCurrentChapter=14"][b]Luke 22:19[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Corinthians+11%3A23-24§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=11&NavCurrentChapter=11"][b]1 Cor 11:23-24[/b][/url]). this indicates that the miracle is a symbol of the Eucharist, about which our Lord will speak shortly. upon this miracle, the people begin to believe, but their beleif is imperfect b/c they see him as an earthly savior and wish to make him king (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A14-15§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=11&NavCurrentChapter=11"][b]John 6:14-15[/b][/url]). [i][b]from this act of faith, he calls for one still greater[/b][/i]. next, he compares himself to the manna which came from heaven. but, while the manna nourished for a time, if they will only believe in him, the true bread, they will be filled forever (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A32-35§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=Johh+6%3A32-35"][b]John 6:32-35[/b][/url]). this is no small claim, to compare oneself to that very bread that saved the Israelites. but this is what Jesus has done........and on top of that, asking that they believe in Him as their spiritual savior. yet again, the Jews show their lack of faith (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A36%2C41§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 6:36,41[/b][/url]). [i][b]but, Jesus is not done, for he demands the most sublime act of faith[/b][/i]. and what is this sublime act of faith, that will weed out the unbelievers and even cause some of his very disciples to depart from him? it is to eat his flesh and drink his blood. he begins by saying that this bread from heaven which they will eat is his flesh (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A51§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 6:51[/b][/url]). the greek word used for "eat" here is [i]favgomai[/i] (or "phago"), which means "to eat or consume." in response, the Jews obviously take him literally; they "strove among themselves" ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A52§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 6:52[/b][/url]). if he was still speaking metaphorically, would this not have been the time to clarify himself? afterall, he wasn't getting the act of faith he was looking for and it seemed to be b/c of how they were understanding him. also, we know that in many similar instances, Jesus explains himself to the people, or at least to the 12 on the side (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mat+16%3A11-12§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]Mat 16:11-12[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mark+4%3A34§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mt&NavGo=16&NavCurrentChapter=16"][b]Mark 4:34[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+3%3A3-11§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mr&NavGo=4&NavCurrentChapter=4"][b]John 3:3-11[/b][/url]) whenever he intends a meaning other than the one they understood. [i][b]but, he does not do that here. instead, he is even more persistent.[/b][/i] starting with vs. 54, we find Jesus telling the crowd 4 more times that they must eat his flesh and 2 more times that they must drink his blood: [b]54 [/b]he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day. [b]55 [/b]For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed. [b]56 [/b]He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him. [b]57 [/b]As the living Father sent me, and I live because of the Father, so he who eats me will live because of me. [b]58 [/b]This is the bread which came down from heaven, not such as the fathers ate and died; he who eats this bread will live for ever." despite using repitition to drive the point home, he even uses a new, much harsher and more explicit word for "eat." in these instances, the greek word is [i]trwvgw[/i] (or "trogo") which means "to gnaw, crunch, or chew." while "phago" may have a spiritual application, "trogo" is never used metaphorically in Greek. it occurs only two other times outside this discourse (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mat+24%3A38§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]Mat 24:38[/b][/url] and [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+13%3A18§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mt&NavGo=24&NavCurrentChapter=24"][b]John 13:18[/b][/url]) and in both cases means a literal eating. it is undeniable what Jesus is asking of them. they must eat his flesh and drink his blood. vs. 55 from this passage is also quite significant. for one, we are to eat, not his "body" ([i]sw'ma[/i], or "soma"), which often has a metaphorical meaning in the bible, but his [i][b]flesh[/b][/i]. the greek word here is [i]savrx[/i] (or "sarx") and it is always used for literal flesh in the bible (proof [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/Lexicons/Greek/grk.cgi?number=4561&version=kjv"][b]here[/b][/url]). also, his flesh is meat [i]indeed[/i], his blood drink [i]indeed[/i]. the greek word here is [i]ajlhqw'ß[/i] (or "alethos"). it means "truly, of a truth, in reality, most certainly" and Jesus uses it to dispel any doubts concerning the reality of His flesh and blood as being food and drink. in response to this they walk away, including many of his very beloved disciples. but [i][b]even now, even when he has lost many of his followers, he does not back down[/b][/i]. he turns to the faithful remnant, who acknowledge that His is "a hard saying" ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?new=1&word=John+6%3A60§ion=0&version=rsv&language=en"][b]John 6:60[/b][/url]), and says to them, "Do you take offense at this?" ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A61§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 6:61[/b][/url]). "Do you also wish to go away?" ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+6%3A67§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 6:67[/b][/url]). he does not intend to retract his statement or to explain it away. instead, he explains [i]to them[/i] why they don't believe it: [b]61 [/b]But Jesus, knowing in himself that his disciples murmured at it, said to them, "Do you take offense at this? [b]62 [/b]Then what if you were to see the Son of man ascending where he was before? [b]63 [/b]It is the spirit that gives life, the flesh is of no avail; the words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life. [b]64 [/b]But there are some of you that do not believe." For Jesus knew from the first who those were that did not believe, and who it was that would betray him it is often asserted here that, by saying that his words are spirit and life that he is meaning to clarify that he was only speaking symbolically. i find no merit in this claim. for one, nowhere in the bible is the word "spirit" meant to mean "symbol" and nowhere else is something said to be symbolic b/c it is spiritual. instead, what we find here is a comparison between the spirit and the flesh that is often used throughout the bible to mean one thing: human wisdom vs. supernatural faith. both Jesus and Paul use this terminology quite often to point out that we must go beyond the natural to comprehend the supernatural (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+3%3A6§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 3:6[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mark+14%3A38§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]Mark 14:38[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+2%3A14§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mr&NavGo=14&NavCurrentChapter=14"][b]1 Cor 2:14[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Corinthians+3%3A3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"][b]3:3[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Rom+8%3A5§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]Rom 8:5[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Gal+5%3A17§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ro&NavGo=8&NavCurrentChapter=8"][b]Gal 5:17[/b][/url]). in response to all of this, we find the words of Peter in one of my favorite passages from the Bible: [b]68 [/b]Simon Peter answered him, "Lord, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life; [b]69 [/b]and we have believed, and have come to know, that you are the Holy One of God." [i][b]here Jesus has finally received that most sublime act of faith that he requires from every one of us.[/b][/i] hopefully, this will suffice as an introductory defense of the Real Presence of the Eucharist. sorry it was so long. believe it or not, much more could be said pax christi, phatcatholic
franciscanheart Posted February 7, 2006 Posted February 7, 2006 You have already received many responses (and I am not nearly as knowledgable as those who have responded thus far) so I will refrain from responding to your questions thus far. I wanted, however, to extend a warm welcome to phatmass. Your thirst for Truth is wonderful and a real delight. I hope you enjoy your time here -- and don't be scared to venture into other parts of the board! many prayers for you and your fiance as the wedding approaches!
jezic Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 i think you might have to email that stuff to her.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now