Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Guest Rick777
Posted

When was this study conducted again? The 60's?

Posted

the late 60's, early 70's... well after the Surgeon General's research was conducted (1964) that confirmed what everyone basically already knew or suspected, cigarrette smoking is dangerous for your health...

Anyway, I've noticed I've never seen a Surgeon General's Warning on a bag of my pipe tobacco :cool:

Guest Rick777
Posted

I should look into that................................

Posted

If you'll look at this artical: [url="http://www.meerschaumstore.com/health.htm"]http://www.meerschaumstore.com/health.htm[/url]

you'll find a study was done in 1979 concluded that pipe smokers who smoked four or fewer bowls of tobacco per day (that's way more than I do, I don't even average once a day most of the time) had a lower mortality rate than non-smokers

in 1982 the surgeon general compiled a bunch of sweeping generalized reports about anyone who smoked pipe tobacco and found them 2-4.3 more likely to have lung cancer... but they didn't look at how often people were pipe smoking and whether they were inhaling.

the 1979 study accurately shows that smoking a pipe reasonably is actually not a hazard and can actually reduce stress to the point of prolonging life. the smoker of a pipe can more easily keep himself in control and practice temperence than a cigarrette smoker, so there really is very little danger in taking up moderate pipe smoking.

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Feb 7 2006, 02:23 AM']I know it isn't for everybody, like singing eh?  singing's got some great symbolism, but it isn't for everyone!

haha anyway a week ago I would have been very hardlined agreeing with you that it isn't ladylike, but now I'm startin to see how claypipes are different and there are claypipes specifically designed for women.  I think there is a ladylike way to smoke a lady's clay pipe

anyway, I'm not sayin all laypeople must smoke pipes.  just like incence in a church, it's an optional little thing... rich in symbolism in our culture but the symbolism can be accomplished in other ways.

side note, the native americans when they converted would often be smoking during mass.. not sure whether the Church really approved of it but it happened, and seeing as the Native American culture had a very religious connotation to their smoking, even moreso probably than our European adoption of it took on, it was a good example of inculturation.
[right][snapback]878427[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
it would be funny if Catholics started smoking the hooka.... they did that a lot where I went to college.

but singing is for everyone :)

do you think clay pipes are superior to other pipes?

Posted

I think a female-designed clay pipe is probably the only pipe smoking I would picture a dignified lady participating in

but as to whether clay pipes are better... I donno, after tryin this clay pipe I just got I am amazed by the difference. maybe it's just cause I haven't cleaned out my other pipe thouroughly in a while, but the clay pipe smoking seemed to have a whole other charecter... like the regular pipe would be smoked in the presence of common men, and a clay pipe would be reserved for something more refined

but I don't really know much, just tryin to come up with a nice view of the differences between the types of pipes.

Posted

[img]http://www.massmoments.org/mo_home/04_28_05.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 7 2006, 01:38 AM']it would be funny if Catholics started smoking the hooka....  they did that a lot where I went to college.

but singing is for everyone :) 

do you think clay pipes are superior to other pipes?
[right][snapback]878444[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
my friend who I shared my first pipe smoke with was tellin me about that, from what he says it's just a really refined and sweet form of tobacco? it's interesting, I don't know if I'm ready to try that just yet, I'm still overwhelmed by this immense world of pipes I have discovered

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Feb 7 2006, 01:43 AM'][img]http://www.massmoments.org/mo_home/04_28_05.jpg[/img]
[right][snapback]878446[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
A guy like that (or Art Rooney in my avatar for that matter)smokin a cigar makes perfect sense according to that first things artical... it's amazing how accurate that artical is in describing who smokes what and why, since it's such a visceral choice no one even really thinks about why they're using one form of tobacco over another

:cool:

[url="http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9704/foley.html"]http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9704/foley.html[/url]

Guest Rick777
Posted

Maybe I'll take up pipe smoking, it sounds real cool. If its so healthy no one will care that I'm under 18 right?

Posted

[quote name='Rick777' date='Feb 7 2006, 02:48 AM']Maybe I'll take up pipe smoking, it sounds real cool. If its so healthy no one will care that I'm under 18 right?
[right][snapback]878452[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Definitely not. You might even get an appearance on "Extreme Makeover: Lung Edition"...

[img]http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/drobson26a.jpg[/img]

:)

Posted

haha... o boy if you're serious I can see that phatmass day-time version will absolutely CRUCIFY ME over this one :ninja:

I have no problem with anyone taking up pipe smoking so long as they practice temperence, moderation, and right reason. but for minors I'm gonna take the official stance that you shouldn't do it without talking to your parents first.

Guest Rick777
Posted

lol. Don't worry. I won't be starting that habit for some time.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Feb 7 2006, 01:51 AM']Definitely not. You might even get an appearance on "Extreme Makeover: Lung Edition"...

[img]http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/drobson26a.jpg[/img]

:)
[right][snapback]878454[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
somebody hasn't been listening to the discussion on the distinction between smart pipe-smoking

read the articals on the first post and stop being so much like hitler!

(lol, just kiddin there, I think it's absolutely hilarious that that one artical picks Hitler as the example of anti-smoking activists though :cool:)

Guest Rick777
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Feb 6 2006, 11:52 PM']haha... o boy if you're serious I can see that phatmass day-time version will absolutely CRUCIFY ME over this one :ninja:

I have no problem with anyone taking up pipe smoking so long as they practice temperence, moderation, and right reason.  but for minors I'm gonna take the official stance that you shouldn't do it without talking to your parents first.
[right][snapback]878457[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


:lol_roll: I wonder what the MOMS would think?lol.

Posted

oh gosh... i better make myself scarce on PM tomarrow...

Posted

i posted this in the music thread as part of my revenge against photosynthesis for hijacking my pipe thread with music... so i'll just post it here too: my thoughts on the root causes, culture, and symbolism of tobacco smoking

It truly is amazing when you discover the greatness outside of the anti-smoking propaganda. People who are taught to dislike smoking really don't know much about why people smoke in the first place, other than "peer pressure"... but of course that explanation can't hold... take it down an Aristotelian path of reason and you gotta come to the "un-peer pressured peer pressurer"... why did he take up tobacco smoking? cool.gif and that's where you discover the real beauty and symbolism of the whole thing


I think when it comes down to it, some Native American way back when had to come up with the bright idea of burning this tobacco leaf and letting the fumes pass through his body. There was no peer pressure for this guy, he's the first guy to come up with the idea. Why did he do it? Likely saw a religious symbolism in smoke rising to heaven, then as he was burning one particular leaf he discovered the soothing nature of the aroma of the tobacco leaf. He did it because he was enamoured with the idea, with the symbols and with the effects.

So too when you reach the European meeting of Native Americans... why did they adopt this habit from the Native Americans? okay, so now you could just say "peer pressure"... but to the Europeans Native Americans were not their peers, they were barbarians and savages! The European settlers more likely noticed the symbolism of the smoke passing through the body and rising to heaven and its calming effect on their soul... they noticed the loosening of the tongue to great intellectual conversation; they adopted the pipe and held it up as a symbol of the highest intellectual classes because they recognized the symbolism.

no public school health class talking about why people smoke will take that direction. it's all peer pressure and evil tobacco companies, which okay those are various material causes, but what is the formal cause? there is a great symbolism attached to smoking in our culture that is very much ignored by the current medical rage against smoking.

what is the symbolism? in my estimation it is the spiritual symbolism of smoke passing through your body and rising to heaven, the emotional symbolism of the calming of nerves, the intellectual symbolism of the stimulation of great thoughts and conversations as you sit and pass the time with this symbol

Guest Rick777
Posted

I think it's okay for a pipe smoker to have an occasional smoke, but usually he will just get addicted.

Posted

I've had more women approach me in public (in a positive manner) for smoking a pipe than for all other reasons combined. The odd thing is that pipe smoking is very harsh on the mouth but attracts lots of compliments, whereas smoking cigars is usually more pleasurable but acquires nothing but ire. Then again, certain cigars are far worse on the mouth than any pipe tobacco--Montecristos and Cubans for instance tend to give me leucoplasts within a matter of minutes.

When I lived in France I asked a guy in a Parisian Tabac what tobacco he recommended for me, and he gave me this stuff called Amsterdamer. I bought it sufficiently of the reason that I loved the packaging (which I scanned and made into my avatar). It smelled and tasted absolutely awful, but it was so uniquely awful that you had to love it in some way. For better or worse, I've never seen it for sale in the US.

Why does the Coeternalist smoke the hookah? Because it's the most complicated and drawn-out way to blow hot air.

Posted

haha

did you check out that firstthings artical, snarf? it's a really interesting analysis of the different types of tobacco smoking you'd probably like

[url="http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9704/foley.html"]http://www.firstthings.com/ftissues/ft9704/foley.html[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...