Brother Adam Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 I need any sources out there for a sacraments project as far as what church fathers believed in symbolic baptism and communion (ordinances i.e. no sacramentality) and the earliest recorded occurance of anyone believe baptism or the Eucharist was only symbolic. Thanks.
shortnun Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Feb 7 2006, 08:35 PM']I need any sources out there for a sacraments project as far as what church fathers believed in symbolic baptism and communion (ordinances i.e. no sacramentality) and the earliest recorded occurance of anyone believe baptism or the Eucharist was only symbolic. Thanks. [right][snapback]879597[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I would have to start with Calvin and Zwingli (and second generation Lutherans). They would still held baptism and Eucharist as sacraments (b/c they are instituted by Christ in the scriptures), but are not considered to be "occassions" of grace b/c God's grace can't be manifest in signs as the result of a promise. [At least, this is my basic understanding of early-Protestant beliefs in the 16th century.] Is this what you're looking for, or am I off the topic completely? I have a cold, and had 6 hours of class tonight, so I may be a little out of it.
thessalonian Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 The earliests group I know that did not believe in the efficacy of the sacraments were the messalians. [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10212a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10212a.htm[/url] Sacraments they held to be useless, though harmless, the only spiritual power being prayer, by which one drove out the evil spirit which baptism had not expelled, received the indwelling of the Holy Ghost, and arrived at union with God, becoming so perfect that the passions ceased to trouble. They disregarded discipline in the matter of fasting, wandered from placa to place, and in summer were accustomed to sleep in the streets. There was also some controversy in the late first millenium. I don't recall the details but will look it up later when I have a chance. As far as Fathers, Tertullian, Augustine, and Clement of Alexandria speak of the Eucharist in a figurative manner but they of course also speak of it in a more literal manner as well. Here is an article on them and their language they used for the Eucharist. [url="http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/num29.htm"]http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/num29.htm[/url] as for baptism, I don't have alot of info on that. I am sure you can find those in the fathers who speak of it as a symbol but you will also find those very people speaking of it as giving the Holy Spirit. The Catholic faith is not either or but both and. Those who think in dichotomy cannot understand it.
shortnun Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 8 2006, 08:43 AM']There was also some controversy in the late first millenium. I don't recall the details but will look it up later when I have a chance. As far as Fathers, Tertullian, Augustine, and Clement of Alexandria speak of the Eucharist in a figurative manner but they of course also speak of it in a more literal manner as well. Here is an article on them and their language they used for the Eucharist. [url="http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/num29.htm"]http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/num29.htm[/url] [right][snapback]880063[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thess, I hope this helps Brother Adam, but it also helps me! See, this is what happens when I take Church History II before Church History I--I jump right to the Protestant reformation, without thinking of any pre-modern heresies! [quote]as for baptism, I don't have alot of info on that. I am sure you can find those in the fathers who speak of it as a symbol but you will also find those very people speaking of it as giving the Holy Spirit. [b]The Catholic faith is not either or but both and. Those who think in dichotomy cannot understand it.[/b][/quote] [b]AMEN!!![/b]
Brother Adam Posted February 8, 2006 Author Posted February 8, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 8 2006, 08:43 AM']The earliests group I know that did not believe in the efficacy of the sacraments were the messalians. [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10212a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10212a.htm[/url] Sacraments they held to be useless, though harmless, the only spiritual power being prayer, by which one drove out the evil spirit which baptism had not expelled, received the indwelling of the Holy Ghost, and arrived at union with God, becoming so perfect that the passions ceased to trouble. They disregarded discipline in the matter of fasting, wandered from placa to place, and in summer were accustomed to sleep in the streets. There was also some controversy in the late first millenium. I don't recall the details but will look it up later when I have a chance. As far as Fathers, Tertullian, Augustine, and Clement of Alexandria speak of the Eucharist in a figurative manner but they of course also speak of it in a more literal manner as well. Here is an article on them and their language they used for the Eucharist. [url="http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/num29.htm"]http://www.bringyou.to/apologetics/num29.htm[/url] as for baptism, I don't have alot of info on that. I am sure you can find those in the fathers who speak of it as a symbol but you will also find those very people speaking of it as giving the Holy Spirit. The Catholic faith is not either or but both and. Those who think in dichotomy cannot understand it. [right][snapback]880063[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thank you, that answers half of my question. The other half, I'm thinking more of what specfically protestant (post 1517) 'fathers' believed in symbolism only in the sacraments (Luther and Calvin both believing in some sort of presence). Shortnun, thank you for your comments as well. Zwingli is the only one I can think of that was possibly symbolic only.
thessalonian Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 (edited) Yes, luther believed in the current lutheran view of consubstantiation, in, through, and around the bread. Whatever that means. Calvin and Wesley believed in a spiritual prescence. Zwingli was the one who denied any prescence and believed it to be symbolic only. This was one of the points of contention between he an Martin Luther. They did not like eachother. [url="http://demo.lutherproductions.com/historytutor/basic/reformation/genknow/lords_supper.htm"]http://demo.lutherproductions.com/historyt...ords_supper.htm[/url] Lutheran: Martin Luther's understanding of the Holy Communion went through several phases. As his teaching developed, Luther taught that the Holy Communion was not a sacrifice but the last will and testament of Jesus, a promise, in which he bequeathed to believers the forgiveness of sins secured by his death on the cross. For Luther, this trustworthy promise could be met by either faith or unbelief. Although repudiating transubstantiation as a philosophical invention unworthy of Christian theology, Luther laid great weight on the real presence of Christ in the Holy Communion, claiming that Christ's body and blood were eaten and drunk by believers and unbelievers alike. Believers, he taught, ate and drank at the Lord's Supper to their blessing, while unbelievers ate and drank to their own condemnation. Reformed: Huldrych Zwingli advanced the first Reformed doctrine of the Holy Communion. Unlike Luther, Zwingli thought of the elements or signs in the Lord's Supper not as means by which God communicates grace to the faithful, but as signs by which the faithful declare that they have received grace and belong to the body of the faithful. For Zwingli the Holy Communion was essentially a communal profession of faith, a celebrative thanksgiving in which the church declared its gratitude and faithfulness to God. Later Reformed theologians, including Martin Bucer, Heinrich Bullinger, and John Calvin, sought a middle way between Luther's position and that of Zwingli. Against Zwingli they argued that Christ was certainly present in the signs of bread and wine, but against Luther they argued that Christians could not rightly comprehend the mode of Christ's presence. Like Luther, they considered the Holy Communion to be constituted by Christ's promise and like Zwingli they thought that it rightly included an element of eucharistic thanksgiving. It's funny but if you put them all together you are closer to the Catholic view. Edited February 8, 2006 by thessalonian
thessalonian Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 (edited) This shows that there was some animosity between the two and that they were competing with eachother on the meaning of the Lord's Supper. [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15772a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15772a.htm[/url] In Zurich Zwingli was now the commanding personality in all ecclesiastical and political questions. He was "burgomaster, secretary, and council" in one, and showed himself daily more overbearing. His insolence indeed prevented an agreement with Luther regarding the doctrine of the Lord's Supper, when a disputation was arranged between the two heresiarchs at Marfurt in October, 1529. As a statesman, Zwingli embarked in secular politics with ambitious plans. "Within three years", he writes, "Italy, Spain and Germany will take our view". This also looks like it might be helpful to you. [url="http://www.hornes.org/theologia/content/david_bromlow/what_is_meant_by_the_spiritual_presence_of_christ_in_the_lords_supper.htm"]http://www.hornes.org/theologia/content/da...ords_supper.htm[/url] Edited February 8, 2006 by thessalonian
Brother Adam Posted February 8, 2006 Author Posted February 8, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 8 2006, 11:15 AM']Yes, luther believed in the current lutheran view of consubstantiation, in, through, and around the bread. Whatever that means. Calvin and Wesley believed in a spiritual prescence. Zwingli was the one who denied any prescence and believed it to be symbolic only. This was one of the points of contention between he an Martin Luther. They did not like eachother. [url="http://demo.lutherproductions.com/historytutor/basic/reformation/genknow/lords_supper.htm"]http://demo.lutherproductions.com/historyt...ords_supper.htm[/url] Lutheran: Martin Luther's understanding of the Holy Communion went through several phases. As his teaching developed, Luther taught that the Holy Communion was not a sacrifice but the last will and testament of Jesus, a promise, in which he bequeathed to believers the forgiveness of sins secured by his death on the cross. For Luther, this trustworthy promise could be met by either faith or unbelief. Although repudiating transubstantiation as a philosophical invention unworthy of Christian theology, Luther laid great weight on the real presence of Christ in the Holy Communion, claiming that Christ's body and blood were eaten and drunk by believers and unbelievers alike. Believers, he taught, ate and drank at the Lord's Supper to their blessing, while unbelievers ate and drank to their own condemnation. Reformed: Huldrych Zwingli advanced the first Reformed doctrine of the Holy Communion. Unlike Luther, Zwingli thought of the elements or signs in the Lord's Supper not as means by which God communicates grace to the faithful, but as signs by which the faithful declare that they have received grace and belong to the body of the faithful. For Zwingli the Holy Communion was essentially a communal profession of faith, a celebrative thanksgiving in which the church declared its gratitude and faithfulness to God. Later Reformed theologians, including Martin Bucer, Heinrich Bullinger, and John Calvin, sought a middle way between Luther's position and that of Zwingli. Against Zwingli they argued that Christ was certainly present in the signs of bread and wine, but against Luther they argued that Christians could not rightly comprehend the mode of Christ's presence. Like Luther, they considered the Holy Communion to be constituted by Christ's promise and like Zwingli they thought that it rightly included an element of eucharistic thanksgiving. It's funny but if you put them all together you are closer to the Catholic view. [right][snapback]880306[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thanks again. That is kinda what I was thinking was the case, but for some reason our sacraments teacher proposed that Zwingli believed in some type of presence. Do we know who Zwingli's major disciples were that continued his views on symbolism only, any other significant names?
thessalonian Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 (edited) This may be of some help as well. [url="http://www.hornes.org/theologia/content/david_bromlow/what_is_meant_by_the_spiritual_presence_of_christ_in_the_lords_supper.htm"]http://www.hornes.org/theologia/content/da...ords_supper.htm[/url] The endnotes seem to confuse the matter of zwingli and indicate that he believed in some form of prescence. 1. None of the views accredited to these men are rightfully theirs. Luther was dogmatized by later Lutherans, Zwingli was mischaracterized by his opponents and Calvin was unoriginal. While the Lutheran view is largely the view held by Luther, he was never so dogmatic about it as his theological heirs, who refused to associate with their reformed brothers over this singular issue. Concerning Zwingli's view, Elmer S. Freeman [The Lord's Supper in Protestantism (New York: Macmillan, 1945), 62] has shown that Zwingli was not a Zwinglian by quoting from a confession written by Zwingli to King Francis: "If I have called this a commemoration, I have done so in order to controvert those who would make of it a sacrifice. . . . We believe that Christ is truly present in the Lord's Supper; yea, that there is no communion without such presence. . . . We believe that the true Body of Christ is eaten in Communion, not in a gross and carnal manner, but in a spiritual and sacramental manner, by the religious, believing, and pious heart." And Calvin's views were first held by Martin Bucer and several others. 2. Zwingli held to a far lower view of the sacrament than did most of his contemporaries, celebrating it only quarterly, and emphasizing the memorial aspect of the Lord's Supper. This certainly lends weight to the truncated view that has been accredited to him. Edited February 8, 2006 by thessalonian
Fides_et_Ratio Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 What's the time frame you're looking for Bro. Adam? How late is too late/too modern? Wesley, Knox, and Cartwright are a couple names I didn't notice above...
shortnun Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 8 2006, 02:25 PM']What's the time frame you're looking for Bro. Adam? How late is too late/too modern? Wesley, Knox, and Cartwright are a couple names I didn't notice above... [right][snapback]880615[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yeah.... I didn't think about how the non-mainland Reformers came into play. I'll have to consult my history book at home (I'm at school currently), and see what it has to offer in terms of additional names and followers of Zwingli.
phatcatholic Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 read an interesting paragraph on [url="http://mb-soft.com/believe/text/lastsupp.htm"][b]this page[/b][/url] [emphasis mine]:[list]The doctrine of the Lord's Supper first occasioned discord in the church in the [i][b]ninth century[/b][/i] when Radbertus, influenced by the hankering for the mysterious and supernatural which characterized his time, taught that a miracle takes place at the words of institution in the Supper. The elements are changed into the actual body and blood of Christ. Radbertus was opposed by [i][b]Ratramnus[/b][/i], who held the Augustinian position that Christ's presence in the Supper is spiritual. The teaching and practice of the church moved in Radbertus's direction, a doctrine of transubstantiation; namely, that in the Supper the substance in the elements of bread and wine is changed into the substance of the body and blood of Christ while the accidents, i.e., the appearance, taste, touch, and smell, remain the same. In the [i][b]eleventh century[/b][/i] [i][b]Berengar[/b][/i] objected to the current idea that pieces of Christ's flesh are eaten during Communion and that some of his blood is drunk. [/list]maybe there's something there you can look into. the entire article is actually rather informative, altho the truth waxes and wanes throughout......
phatcatholic Posted February 8, 2006 Posted February 8, 2006 btw, Quakers don't believe in ANY sacraments.
thessalonian Posted February 9, 2006 Posted February 9, 2006 It is amazing how distorted history is for them when they don't have the mind of Catholicism.
Cre8d4Youth Posted February 9, 2006 Posted February 9, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 8 2006, 12:15 PM']they argued that Christians could not rightly comprehend the mode of Christ's presence. [right][snapback]880306[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Only thing that confounds me is...if we can't understand it, they just took it out all together?? I mean, I don't [i]understand[/i] how He's present...but I have faith to accept that He is. [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 8 2006, 03:25 PM']Cartwright are a couple names I didn't notice above... [right][snapback]880615[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Cartwright! The huge wall of a man, bar-brawling, Gospel preachin' greatest Methodist! Man...I loved the stories they told about him when I was growing up!! "What?! You don't like my God? Put 'em up!"
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now