Dennis Posted February 9, 2006 Posted February 9, 2006 I'm discussing the Eucharist on a fundamentalist board as it is explained in John 6. I have maintained that John 6 is to be taken [i]literally.[/i] I was countered with, if we take it [i]literally[/i], then it is needed to gain eternal life because of John 6:53-54 [quote]Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, ye have no life in you. Whoso eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day. - John 6:53-54 (King James Version)[/quote] I've tried to counter that it is a Sacrament (channel of grace) to get closer to God, but he won't listen. Keeps insisting that if John 6 is literal, then the Eucharist is needed for eternal life. Any ideas? I'm trying to stay "Sola Scriptura" to avoid the "extra-biblical" authority argument...
thessalonian Posted February 21, 2006 Posted February 21, 2006 [quote name='Dennis' date='Feb 9 2006, 03:21 PM']I'm discussing the Eucharist on a fundamentalist board as it is explained in John 6. I have maintained that John 6 is to be taken [i]literally.[/i] I was countered with, if we take it [i]literally[/i], then it is needed to gain eternal life because of John 6:53-54 I've tried to counter that it is a Sacrament (channel of grace) to get closer to God, but he won't listen. Keeps insisting that if John 6 is literal, then the Eucharist is needed for eternal life. Any ideas? I'm trying to stay "Sola Scriptura" to avoid the "extra-biblical" authority argument... [right][snapback]882043[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well I would actually say that normatively he is correct. "Unless you eat the flesh of the son of man and drink his blood you shall not have life within you" makes it pretty plain. The same is true of baptism. Mark.16 [16] He who believes and is baptized will be saved; but he who does not believe will be condemned. But I said "normatively". This means that any Christian who hears and understands (given the grace to do so) the words of Christ in the scriptures is bound by them. But God is not bound by his sacraments. This is the key. As I look at John 6 there were four groups that are of concern in the passage. There are those who were Jews, heard his words and rejected them (v. 53). There were those who were his disciples and rejected them (v 66). There were Jesus Apostles and disciples who accepted them, albeit with some difficulty (v. 68). But there were those also who never heard them and a case can be made for those who heard but could not understand. These we leave God to judge. These we hold hope that the responsibility that God's word hold are not laid upon them because of invincible ignorance. We are judged according to the grace God gives each of us. Some who are not given the grace to know may not be accountable for that. Luke.12 [48] But he who did not know, and did what deserved a beating, shall receive a light beating. Every one to whom much is given, of him will much be required; and of him to whom men commit much they will demand the more. See James 3:1 as well. Hope this helps.
Myles Domini Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 (edited) There was a really excellent post on the topic of Eucharist made by Phatcatholic recently about why the Eucharist had to be really Christ and really eaten. I think it was in a post contra Colin, Phatty if you can fish that out it will save me from having to restate your points so I'd appreciate it? Anyways the reason why the Eucharist is neccessary for salvation goes to the very heart of the Christian faith. Indeed, without the Eucharist salvation is [b]absolutely impossible[/b]. Why is that? Well quite simply because the Eucharist is the sacrifice of the 'new covenant' as Jesus states clearly in the institution narratives. A covenant is the exchange of persons not property. Whenever God makes a covenant with someone He is giving Himself in return. 'I will be your God and you will be my people'. Now there's no need to state the argument at length because the New Testament particularly, for instance, the letter to the Hebrews does that especially well. But because of man's limitedness he could never make an unlimited sacrifice which was required so that God's infinite justice can be sated. Hence, the Word became flesh took on a human nature and sacrificed Himself. So far so good, all very basic Christian teaching, yeah? But what do you notice about the covenants of the Old Testament? And indeed about the 'new covenant'? Here's a clue 'do this in memory of me'? In the Old Testament when God makes covenants he expects them to be continued. However when Jews celebrate Passover it doesn't mean they're celebrating a new passover but the same passover under a different form. Jesus by becoming the paschal lamb did not change this understanding of the pascha but indeed he underscored it by telling his apostles to do it in memory as you read in 1 Cor 10:16 and following. Our participation in the saving death of Christ comes through our celebration of the Eucharist because the Eucharist is the sign of our covenant with God. For God's saving life of grace to be given to you the Eucharist is essential because without a covenant sacrifice the covenant would cease to be efficacious. If, for instance, Christians simply ceased to celebrate the Eucharist they would become estranged from God. The early Christians had a strong sense of this which is why food sacrifced to idols was so viciously assailed by the Apostles. Eating the food sacrificed to an idol was to enter into a covenant with that idol, which meant one could no longer be in a covenant with Christ. The Bride can have but one husband, the Lamb, not a multitude. Without the Eucharist nobody would be saved. Because nobody can make such a sacrifice because of our finite natures. If we do not unite ourselves to Christ through the Eucharist and if we refuse to partake in the Eucharist we have no covenant with God. Jesus' words from John 6 highlight that because the formula 'Amen, Amen' as we learn from Tractate 41 on John is that of a sworn oath. A covenant meal is actually just a type of unsaid oath, the sacrifice offered is the fate of those who refuse to uphold the covenant. This is why when Pliny the Younger writes to Rome to report on Christians meeting for a meal and swearing sacramentum asking how he should treat them he doesn't give the formula for the oath. The meal itself was sacramentum (type of oath sworn by Roman army to Emperor and goddess Roma) from whence we get the word 'sacrament'. The sacraments are the oaths of the covenant and if we break our oaths or refuse to uphold our oaths we cannot have any part of the covenant. This is why Rome teaches that anyone who is saved is saved by being an annoymous Catholic by invicible ignorance. If you dont partake in the covenantal sacramentum and you know you should you have no part in the covenant and its blessings and hence you are damned. So the person you're talking to is right the Eucharist is needed for salvation and if he knows this and refuses to partake of it then he's in trouble. Edited February 27, 2006 by Myles
zunshynn Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 Every time I talk about John 6, protestants and Mormons center in on the part that says "This is not of flesh but of spirit." How do you respond to that? They say it negates reading it as truly His body and blood. I kind of figured it just means that it is something you have to have faith in, and will not physically be able to comprehend.
thessalonian Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 Some versions of that verse say "the flesh profiteth nothing". The question is what flesh is being talked about? Christ's flesh? If it was of no profit for us then why was it hung on a cross. Jesus says earlier in John 6, "the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world" so his flesh is definitely of profit for us. If it is our flesh, do they believe in the ressurection of the body. But in answer to your translation of that same verse, I think your understanding is accurate. They see with their eyes what he is saying and reject it as the Jews and some of his own disciples did. We see with the spirit what he is saying and it is marvelous indeed. His flesh and blood sacrificed for us, providing food eternal, providing life eternal on the path through the desert of life. We cannot open the eyes of the spirit for them. They seem to like to do verse trumping. We must keep the birds eye view of scripture and recognize that only God can open the locked door of their hearts. Pray for them after you have explained the truth. Blessings
Myles Domini Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 The Spirit giving life to the Eucharist has also been interpreted by the Fathers of the Church as an allusion to the fact that in the Holy Mass it is the Spirit which causes the Eucharist to become the true body and blood. Moreover, the prescence of Christ in the Eucharist is in his glorified flesh not the kind of flesh that you slice up and eat. When the priest breaks the bread Christ is no longer divided because his glorified body quickened by the Spirit does not exist as our physical bodies exist.
Myles Domini Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 [url="http://www.star.ucl.ac.uk/~vgg/rc/aplgtc/hahn/m5/scmnt4.html"]COMMUNION AS REUNION [/url] by Dr Scott Hahn.
phatcatholic Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 [quote name='Myles' date='Feb 27 2006, 12:43 PM']There was a really excellent post on the topic of Eucharist made by Phatcatholic recently about why the Eucharist had to be really Christ and really eaten. I think it was in a post contra Colin, Phatty if you can fish that out it will save me from having to restate your points so I'd appreciate it?[/quote] here is the post you are referring to: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=47214&view=findpost&p=879114"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...ndpost&p=879114[/url] i provided a link to it in my very short exchange with Colin ([url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=47342"][b]here[/b][/url]) in hopes that he would respond to it. here is the portion that emphasizes actually eating the paschal lamb (instead of just cutting it up and looking at it ):[list]although it is common knowledge that Jesus is the "paschal lamb" (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+5%3A7§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=jer&NavGo=33&NavCurrentChapter=33"][b]1 Cor 5:7[/b][/url]), what is often forgotten is that the lamb [i][b]must be eaten[/b][/i]. this is seen in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+12%3A8%2C11§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=5&NavCurrentChapter=5"][b]Exo 12:8,11[/b][/url] where the Israelites were told to eat the lamb so that the angel would pass over them. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+29%3A33§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=12&NavCurrentChapter=12"][b]Exo 29:33[/b][/url] "they shall eat those things wherewith the atonement was made, to consecrate and to sanctify them". in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Lev+7%3A15§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=29&NavCurrentChapter=29"][b]Lev 7:15[/b][/url] the flesh of the sacrifice must be eaten. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Chron+30%3A15-17§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=le&NavGo=7&NavCurrentChapter=7"][b]2 Chron 30:15-17[/b][/url] (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Chron+35%3A1%2C6%2C11%2C13§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=2ch&NavGo=30&NavCurrentChapter=30"][b]2 Chron 35:1,6,11,13[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezra+6%3A20-21§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=2ch&NavGo=35&NavCurrentChapter=35"][b]Ezr 6:20-21[/b][/url]) the lamb is eaten so as to achieve purification. also, in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezekiel+2%3A8-10§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ezr&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]Ezek 2:8-10[/b][/url] and [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezekiel+3%3A1-3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=eze&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"][b]3:1-3[/b][/url] Ezekiel is commanded by God to eat the scroll--the Word of God--which was in his mouth "as honey for sweetness." all of these verses forshadow Jesus Christ, the lamb and the Word of God, who must be eaten. [/list] [quote name='zunshynn' date='Feb 27 2006, 01:04 PM']Every time I talk about John 6, protestants and Mormons center in on the part that says "This is not of flesh but of spirit." How do you respond to that? They say it negates reading it as truly His body and blood. I kind of figured it just means that it is something you have to have faith in, and will not physically be able to comprehend. [right][snapback]898877[/snapback][/right][/quote] here's the section from the post i linked to above which addresses this very argument:[list]it is often asserted here that, by saying that his words are spirit and life that he is meaning to clarify that he was only speaking symbolically. i find no merit in this claim. for one, nowhere in the bible is the word "spirit" meant to mean "symbol" and nowhere else is something said to be symbolic b/c it is spiritual. instead, what we find here is a comparison between the spirit and the flesh that is often used throughout the bible to mean one thing: human wisdom vs. supernatural faith. both Jesus and Paul use this terminology quite often to point out that we must go beyond the natural to comprehend the supernatural (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+3%3A6§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 3:6[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mark+14%3A38§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]Mark 14:38[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+2%3A14§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mr&NavGo=14&NavCurrentChapter=14"][b]1 Cor 2:14[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Corinthians+3%3A3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"][b]3:3[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Rom+8%3A5§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]Rom 8:5[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Gal+5%3A17§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ro&NavGo=8&NavCurrentChapter=8"][b]Gal 5:17[/b][/url]). [/list]i hope that helps. pax christi, phatcatholic
Myles Domini Posted February 27, 2006 Posted February 27, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' date='Feb 27 2006, 06:56 PM']here is the post you are referring to: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=47214&view=findpost&p=879114"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...ndpost&p=879114[/url] i provided a link to it in my very short exchange with Colin ([url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=47342"][b]here[/b][/url]) in hopes that he would respond to it. here is the portion that emphasizes actually eating the paschal lamb (instead of just cutting it up and looking at it ):[list]although it is common knowledge that Jesus is the "paschal lamb" (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+5%3A7§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=jer&NavGo=33&NavCurrentChapter=33"][b]1 Cor 5:7[/b][/url]), what is often forgotten is that the lamb [i][b]must be eaten[/b][/i]. this is seen in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+12%3A8%2C11§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=5&NavCurrentChapter=5"][b]Exo 12:8,11[/b][/url] where the Israelites were told to eat the lamb so that the angel would pass over them. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Exodus+29%3A33§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=12&NavCurrentChapter=12"][b]Exo 29:33[/b][/url] "they shall eat those things wherewith the atonement was made, to consecrate and to sanctify them". in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Lev+7%3A15§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ex&NavGo=29&NavCurrentChapter=29"][b]Lev 7:15[/b][/url] the flesh of the sacrifice must be eaten. in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Chron+30%3A15-17§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=le&NavGo=7&NavCurrentChapter=7"][b]2 Chron 30:15-17[/b][/url] (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=2+Chron+35%3A1%2C6%2C11%2C13§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=2ch&NavGo=30&NavCurrentChapter=30"][b]2 Chron 35:1,6,11,13[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezra+6%3A20-21§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=2ch&NavGo=35&NavCurrentChapter=35"][b]Ezr 6:20-21[/b][/url]) the lamb is eaten so as to achieve purification. also, in [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezekiel+2%3A8-10§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ezr&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]Ezek 2:8-10[/b][/url] and [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Ezekiel+3%3A1-3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=eze&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"][b]3:1-3[/b][/url] Ezekiel is commanded by God to eat the scroll--the Word of God--which was in his mouth "as honey for sweetness." all of these verses forshadow Jesus Christ, the lamb and the Word of God, who must be eaten. [/list] here's the section from the post i linked to above which addresses this very argument:[list]it is often asserted here that, by saying that his words are spirit and life that he is meaning to clarify that he was only speaking symbolically. i find no merit in this claim. for one, nowhere in the bible is the word "spirit" meant to mean "symbol" and nowhere else is something said to be symbolic b/c it is spiritual. instead, what we find here is a comparison between the spirit and the flesh that is often used throughout the bible to mean one thing: human wisdom vs. supernatural faith. both Jesus and Paul use this terminology quite often to point out that we must go beyond the natural to comprehend the supernatural (cf. [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=John+3%3A6§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=6&NavCurrentChapter=6"][b]John 3:6[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Mark+14%3A38§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=joh&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]Mark 14:38[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Cor+2%3A14§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=mr&NavGo=14&NavCurrentChapter=14"][b]1 Cor 2:14[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1+Corinthians+3%3A3§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=2&NavCurrentChapter=2"][b]3:3[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Rom+8%3A5§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=1co&NavGo=3&NavCurrentChapter=3"][b]Rom 8:5[/b][/url]; [url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=Gal+5%3A17§ion=0&version=rsv&new=1&oq=&NavBook=ro&NavGo=8&NavCurrentChapter=8"][b]Gal 5:17[/b][/url]). [/list]i hope that helps. pax christi, phatcatholic [right][snapback]899002[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thats why he's called Phatcatholic
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now