Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

this conversation is going on right now

(15:50:05) Ie ne ces i to: this whole religion thing is hectic.
15:50
(15:50:37) Rei: you know i'm trying to convert you to catholicism
(15:50:46) Rei: there's no hiding it
(15:50:47) Rei: hehe
(15:50:55) Ie ne ces i to: haha. i know. but i can't.
(15:51:08) Ie ne ces i to: regardless if you tried or how upset i am with my religion.
(15:51:17) Ie ne ces i to: i don't believe in catholicism.
(15:51:25) Rei: in matters of what?
15:51
(15:51:38) Rei: divinity of christ?
(15:51:54) Ie ne ces i to: trinity. why you call a priest father.
(15:52:02) Ie ne ces i to: things like that, but i don't want to get into it.
(15:52:20) Rei: do you even read my e-mails
(15:52:28) Rei: i cc to you
(15:52:33) Ie ne ces i to: it's just going to go back and forth. and i'll get upset at one point.
(15:52:33) Rei: what i send roy
15:52
(15:52:46) Ie ne ces i to: i do, but i never finish them. too long.
(15:52:49) Rei: patience is a virtue
15:54
(15:54:40) Ie ne ces i to: i don't disagree with my religion one bit. i'm just upset because i know it's true.
(15:55:21) Rei: what is truth??
15:55
(15:55:52) Ie ne ces i to: i had premarital sex.
(15:56:00) Ie ne ces i to: i'm pregnant with a nonmenber.
(15:56:02) Rei: we all sin
(15:56:03) Ie ne ces i to: member*
(15:56:05) Ie ne ces i to: we all do.
(15:56:08) Ie ne ces i to: i know.
15:56
(15:56:37) Rei: you thirst sanctifying grace
(15:56:42) Rei: you thirst acceeptance
(15:56:49) Ie ne ces i to: ohboy.
(15:56:49) Rei: you thirst for truth
(15:57:01) Ie ne ces i to: what they're doing isn't wrong.
(15:57:01) Rei: what if i can show you?
(15:57:08) Ie ne ces i to: sorry reinnier.
(15:57:10) Ie ne ces i to: can't/
(15:57:11) Rei: i never said it was
(15:57:13) Ie ne ces i to: can't.
15:57
(15:57:31) Rei: so you're gonna be closed minded
(15:57:35) Rei: not even listen to me
(15:57:44) Ie ne ces i to: i was once catholic.
(15:57:44) Rei: all i ask is an open mind
(15:57:55) Ie ne ces i to: more than 3/4 of my family is catholic.
(15:57:56) Rei: when was that?
(15:58:07) Ie ne ces i to: i was born catholic until i was 6
(15:58:13) Ie ne ces i to: my mother was catholic.
(15:58:14) Rei: 6
(15:58:17) Rei: age of reason
(15:58:17) Ie ne ces i to: so.
(15:58:17) Rei: yes
15:58
(15:58:36) Rei: but how much did you know about catholicism to even defend it
(15:58:41) Rei: not a whole lot
(15:58:51) Ie ne ces i to: i don't need to know alot.
(15:59:05) Rei: you need to know the truth
(15:59:15) Ie ne ces i to: knowing a little is just enough to convince me, that i don't believe in that specific religion.
(15:59:19) Ie ne ces i to: truth about what?
15:59
(15:59:37) Ie ne ces i to: the truth is, i'm iglesia. jeff is catholic. and that's how it's going to be.
(15:59:57) Ie ne ces i to: my faith in God, in my religion, is stronger than you think.
(16:00:01) Rei: you're sounding really arrogant right now
(16:00:11) Rei: i know
(16:00:18) Rei: i knwo you have your faith
16:00
(16:00:25) Rei: i know you believe in INC
(16:00:32) Rei: but please don't shut me out
(16:00:36) Ie ne ces i to: i may be arrogant. but i still don't believe in catholicism.
(16:00:47) Ie ne ces i to: sorry.
(16:01:01) Rei: you say you don't believe in the trinity but you don't give me a chance to explain it
16:01
(16:01:38) Rei: you say you don't like that catholics call priest father when the gospel says call no man father and again not give me a chance to explain it
(16:02:13) Ie ne ces i to: you can explain it, i'll listen. but i still won't believe in it.
16:02
(16:02:29) Rei: even when i present you facts?
(16:02:37) Ie ne ces i to: facts about?
(16:02:47) Rei: everything
(16:03:22) Ie ne ces i to: i know my facts.. about my religion.
16:03
16:07
(16:07:39) Ie ne ces i to: i know you may be upset with me. but i like being and believing in my religion.
(16:07:47) Ie ne ces i to: i find nothing wrong with my religion.
(16:07:55) Ie ne ces i to: i grew up, yes, in my religion.
(16:08:04) Ie ne ces i to: and, i'm happy to say i'm staying in my religion.
(16:08:07) Rei: but please let me show you mine
(16:08:10) Ie ne ces i to: i believe in GOd.
(16:08:13) Rei: i know
(16:08:13) Ie ne ces i to: God*
(16:08:18) Ie ne ces i to: no, i don't want to.
16:08
(16:08:37) Ie ne ces i to: i was already catholic.
(16:08:43) Rei: yes
(16:08:46) Rei: i know
(16:09:02) Rei: i'm still gonna love you even if you decide to stay
(16:09:07) Rei: I PROMISE YOU THAT
(16:09:17) Rei: just let me show you mine please
16:09
(16:09:27) Ie ne ces i to: there's nothing convincing me
(16:09:40) Rei: you've made it clear
(16:09:54) Rei: but please at least don't shut me out
(16:09:57) Ie ne ces i to: most of my family is catholic. i've seen it. i've attended
(16:10:10) Ie ne ces i to: my grandmother is die hard catholic.
(16:10:18) Rei: yes
(16:10:21) Ie ne ces i to: but regardless, i'm still Iglesia.
16:10
(16:10:25) Rei: ok
(16:10:28) Ie ne ces i to: she tried to convert me, thank you.
(16:10:33) Rei: so you are iglesia
(16:10:39) Rei: alright we got that down
(16:10:47) Rei: you believe it's the truth
(16:10:53) Ie ne ces i to: i know it's the truth/.
(16:11:00) Rei: YOU KNOW IT'S THE TRUTH
(16:11:14) Rei: so what do you have to lose if i explain mine
16:11
(16:11:55) Ie ne ces i to: i already know!
(16:12:01) Ie ne ces i to: all of my family is catholic.
(16:12:05) Rei: no you don't
(16:12:15) Ie ne ces i to: my mom was once catholic
(16:12:19) Ie ne ces i to: well i don't want toooooo
(16:12:23) Rei: i'm a catholic my whole life i didn't kwno all that i'm about to tell you
16:12
(16:12:38) Ie ne ces i to: i'm not shutting you out. but there's no point in explaining it to me.
(16:12:54) Ie ne ces i to: there isn't/
(16:13:03) Ie ne ces i to: i'm happy where i'm at.
16:13
(16:13:26) Rei: if you're so sure that INC is the truth then what's the harm in me saying something
(16:14:00) Ie ne ces i to: because i don't want to hear it. i already heard it enough from my grandmother from florida.
(16:14:20) Rei: doesn't sound fair
16:14
(16:14:34) Ie ne ces i to: how so
(16:15:22) Ie ne ces i to: i have a right to decide my religion as much as you have a freedom of expression. but it's up to the person that wants to hear about it.
16:15
(16:15:54) Rei: yes you do have that right i'm not trying to take that from you
(16:16:13) Ie ne ces i to: yes, but it comes up to the point where you're forcing me to listen.
(16:16:20) Rei: i'm not
16:16
(16:16:31) Rei: i'm just asking for a chance to let me explain
(16:16:43) Rei: i'm asking i'm not forcing
(16:16:55) Ie ne ces i to: i don't want to, though.
(16:17:06) Rei: why?
(16:17:21) Ie ne ces i to: because i'm content where i am at
16:17
(16:17:34) Rei: ok
(16:17:35) Ie ne ces i to: i choose not to hear it anymore.
(16:18:06) Ie ne ces i to: the whole reason why i'm not going back to florida is because i was forced to go to church with them every sunday.
(16:18:15) Ie ne ces i to: i had to go to my church along with theirs.
(16:18:24) Rei: i'm not forcing you
16:18
(16:18:27) Rei: this is me
(16:18:29) Rei: not them
(16:18:34) Ie ne ces i to: at night, when i come home from work, i have to sit in the room, while they're doing rosary.
(16:18:39) Ie ne ces i to: well i dont want to listen anymore
(16:18:42) Ie ne ces i to: im sorry, no.
16:19

Posted (edited)

i need your help pham

what should i do?

she is the mother of my cousin's unborn baby

Edited by ReinnieR
Posted (edited)

Doesn't sound like she's ready to listen. You'll have to set a good Catholic example simply by your actions, not by your words. If you continue to harass her, you'll likely just push her away more.

Edited by Cow of Shame
Posted

Prayers, sacrifice, and a good example. Also LOVE.

I'll be praying too!

Theologian in Training
Posted

While I understand your zeal and desire, I would recommend that you not be so forceful in your approach since, as Cow of Shame said, you may push her away all the more. Also, instead of trying to force many issues, try to simplify it a bit by asking her what the main issue is. The problem is clearly not just her inability or unwillingness to believe, but if you listen, you can tell there is something else going on there.

I think, also, you need listen to what she has to say, and instead of explicitly asking her to let you share your religion, do so in a different way. Sometimes you don't need to talk about your religion, per se, in order for her to understand what you mean. I don't mean watering it down, but I do mean finding another way, since this way does not seem to be too effective and actually seems to be pushing her away.

Remember, above else, that we never convert a single soul, we are the mere instruments through which God works. You may have to endure her saying some things that you don't agree with, but if you dismiss them immediately she will close back down and not be open to further dialogue. The best example I can tell you about is when a Protestant minister was clearly and blatantly trying to convert me. I listened to him, took his pamphlet, read them, returned to him, asked him a few questions, and seeing how I did not "put up a fight," as it were, agreed to let me give him a pamphlet: "Pillar of Fire Pillar of Truth." He loved that pamphlet and learned a lot. I don't know what ever happened to him because I met him in a hospital, but had I turned him down immediately the conversation would not have lasted.

Listen to the person, and don't try to force yourself, rather, take your time, let them speak, and eventually you will find the root of the problem. In fact, from this conversation alone, it is clear that religion is not the issue, but there is something underlying that which you keep touching upon and she keeps shutting you out as a result. However, if you continue to force yourself, as it were, you may not get any further.

My recommendation: take a moment, pray for guidance, and listen.

God Bless

Posted

Thanks Pham

Posted

this is how it ended

(16:18:34) Ie ne ces i to: at night, when i come home from work, i have to sit in the room, while they're doing rosary.
(16:18:39) Ie ne ces i to: well i dont want to listen anymore
(16:18:42) Ie ne ces i to: im sorry, no.
16:19
16:31
(16:31:34) Rei: k
(16:31:46) Rei: are you calm?
16:32
16:34
(16:34:50) Rei: anyways
(16:35:01) Rei: i have to go
(16:35:08) Rei: i'll talk to you later
(16:35:11) Rei: i still love you
(16:35:15) Rei: mwa
16:35
16:37
(16:37:19) Ie ne ces i to: bye bye.
(16:37:23) Ie ne ces i to: love you,too.
16:37
(17:03:57) Ie ne ces i to logged out.

photosynthesis
Posted

well, I'd say that the points Pope Benedict makes in his new Encyclical are good advice for you in this situation. Basically he explains to us that God is Love, and we are created in His image to love Him and love one another. It is in our very nature to love, but this love is not just a feeling, it goes beyond warm fuzzy feelings into self-sacrifice.

When we love others by putting their needs before our own and genuinely being concerned for their welfare and having compassion on their suffering, we show them who Jesus is without handing out a single tract. A person can hear the Gospel simply by seeing Jesus in who YOU are as a person. When you go to confession, receive Jesus in the Eucharist and let Him transform You, she is going to know. She might already be seeing Him in you and that is why her heart is hard, because she knows deep down that Catholicism is contagious.

So my advice is to spend more time with Jesus in the Sacraments and through reading the Bible, so that you know who HE is more. And then imitate Him so that she can meet Him through knowing you. And if necessary, use words so that she can make the connection between His sacrifice on the cross and your self-sacrificing love for her.

Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 9 2006, 10:25 PM']well, I'd say that the points Pope Benedict makes in his new Encyclical are good advice for you in this situation.  Basically he explains to us that God is Love, and we are created in His image to love Him and love one another.  It is in our very nature to love, but this love is not just a feeling, it goes beyond warm fuzzy feelings into self-sacrifice.

When we love others by putting their needs before our own and genuinely being concerned for their welfare and having compassion on their suffering, we show them who Jesus is without handing out a single tract.  A person can hear the Gospel simply by seeing Jesus in who YOU are as a person.  When you go to confession, receive Jesus in the Eucharist and let Him transform You, she is going to know.  She might already be seeing Him in you and that is why her heart is hard, because she knows deep down that Catholicism is contagious.

So my advice is to spend more time with Jesus in the Sacraments and through reading the Bible, so that you know who HE is more.  And then imitate Him so that she can meet Him through knowing you.  And if necessary, use words so that she can make the connection between His sacrifice on the cross and your self-sacrificing love for her.
[right][snapback]882588[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


i would love to be the example for her but alas you are closer to her than i am.
you are in the same state as her

photosynthesis
Posted

well, not currently but i will be tomorrow :)

you are laying your life down for her in the air force. if that's not self-sacrifice, I don't know what is.

Posted

i doubt you'll be home before 12 tomorrow huh

but you need to be home before 12 tomorrow

photosynthesis
Posted

I don't think that works with my schedule.

photosynthesis
Posted

why is 1200 such an important time?

Posted

i guess you'll just have to be home before 1200 to find out

photosynthesis
Posted

i'm starting to be a little creeped out

Posted

sorry don't mean to

i should just learn to shut up

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...