Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

...and now for something completely different...


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Conservative Catholics support Bush's insane war DESPITE John Paul II's admonition against it. Liberal Catholics agreed with His Holiness.

It's a devious, self-obsessed and pernicious cognitive dissonance from which you suffer if you think that John Paul was a holy man and possibly a saint but that he was wrong in his arguments against the Gulf War. Let me explain something to you: if my pope and my president disagree, my pope wins. But, I can imagine that you and other conservatives would be confused by Bush's arguments. He insists that he's never made a mistake in his administration (in Catholicism, we're taught only God can claim perfection.) Another bit of confusion could arise from the fact that Bush claims to receive direct communiqués from God. When Mary was asked to become the Mother of my Lord, God only sent an angel to visit her with the message. Maybe you ought to change your religion…you've got a new messiah and you've already voted for him twice.

And by the way, after waging an immoral and useless war that the American people had to have been lied to in its inception, effect and cost, Bush has yet to stop a single abortion in the United States, Afghanistan nor in Iraq. If the Republications were the "Chosen Party" and Bush has God's "mandate" they'd put an end to abortion. You claimed that abortion was THE single issue of any importance. If so, why did you vote for Bush? There has been no reduction in the number of abortions since he got into office. He's not shut down a single abortion clinic. There is no end to the number of zygotes in fertility centers that are destroyed every day. What are the Republicans waiting for? They're the ruling party. During the previous administration they claimed that the Democrats were "stalling" them. WOW! Thank God Bush is against abortion!

Also…a fact that many benighted, conservative Catholics eagerly wish to ignore, Bush is the ONLY US president to have signed a law that allowed stem-cell research into legislation. I'm sure you're proud of yourself in a blind, warped and twisted way. But, I'm sure you're too embarrassed to explain yourself herein. The problem, however, is that you have to explain yourself to God when He questions you at the End of Days.

You are absolutely wrong in the way you lionize conservatives and condemn and alienate liberals but you're unwilling to admit your error. As you refuse to be reasonable in this discussion, you can win it if you'd like…I won't be playing your anti-intellectual games anymore.

Edited by Kismet
Posted

I bolded your quotations again, FYI.


[b]Conservative Catholics support Bush's insane war DESPITE John Paul II's admonition against it. Liberal Catholics agreed with His Holiness.[/b]

I'm not sure why you brought up the war, but since you did:

[quote]Not all moral issues have the same moral weight as abortion and euthanasia. [b]For example, if a Catholic were to be at odds with the Holy Father on the application of capital punishment or on the decision to wage war, he would not for that reason be considered unworthy to present himself to receive Holy Communion[/b]. While the Church exhorts civil authorities to seek peace, not war, and to exercise discretion and mercy in imposing punishment on criminals, it may still be permissible to take up arms to repel an aggressor or to have recourse to capital punishment. [b]There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war[/b] and applying the death penalty, but not however with regard to abortion and euthanasia.

--Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, Letter to Theodore Cardinal McCarrick, 2004[/quote]


[b]It's a devious, self-obsessed and pernicious cognitive dissonance from which you suffer if you think that John Paul was a holy man and possibly a saint but that he was wrong in his arguments against the Gulf War.[/b]

Again, I have no idea what has provoked you to think I support the war.

By way of disclosure, I had no opinion on the war, for or against it. I do have strong opinions on a theoretical level, and have expressed them here on Phatmass, but I'm not much for application. If you would like to know my thoughts on war and peace, you can read them here:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=46569&view=findpost&p=866474"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...st&p=866474[/url]

Here are some thoughts I had on John Paul and his stance on the war in Iraq:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=45426&hl="]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...c=45426&hl=[/url]

[b]But, I can imagine that you and other conservatives would be confused by Bush's arguments.[/b]

I am not a "conservative". I do not identify myself with the "conservative" political movement or the Republican party.

[b]Maybe you ought to change your religion…you've got a new messiah and you've already voted for him twice.[/b]

Why the vehemence? You assume (falsely) that I somehow supported the war, that I blindly support George Bush, and now you suggest I am not fit to be Catholic?

You need to get a grip.

[b]If the Republications were the "Chosen Party" and Bush has God's "mandate" they'd put an end to abortion.[/b]

Yes, that's a big if. Thankfully, I never claimed either.

[b]You claimed that abortion was THE single issue of any importance.[/b]

No, I did not. There are plenty of issues "of any importance". What I said was abortion is the most important issue. Let's say 100,000 people died in the war. Millions of babies will be slaughtered this year. See the difference?

[b]If so, why did you vote for Bush?[/b]

Because he has a modicum of concern in the efforts of the pro-life movement. I could not in good conscience vote for someone so engrossed in the slaughter of the unborn that he would do anything to keep it in existence (namely, John Kerry).

If you felt the need to vote for John Kerry, that is between you and God. It's none of my business who you voted for.

[b]During the previous administration they claimed that the Democrats were "stalling" them. WOW! Thank God Bush is against abortion![/b]

You might want to start a new thread to discuss the political merits. Frankly, I am not interested, although there are others here who would be more than willing (and far more capable than I) to look intelligently at specifically political questions. I am a theological man myself.

[b]I'm sure you're proud of yourself in a blind, warped and twisted way.[/b]

Again, what would make you "sure" of such a thing?

[b]But, I'm sure you're too embarrassed to explain yourself herein. The problem, however, is that you have to explain yourself to God when He questions you at the End of Days.[/b]

Not at all. I'm actually embarrassed for you, first, for accusing me of things wholly out of touch with the reality of my thought, and second, for abandoning any civility we had in this discussion.

[b]You are absolutely wrong in the way you lionize conservatives and condemn and alienate liberals but you're unwilling to admit your error. As you refuse to be reasonable in this discussion, you can win it if you'd like…I won't be playing your anti-intellectual games anymore.[/b]

You apparantly have concluded that this discussion is about political conservativism. It is not. It is about people who identify themselves as a "Conservative Catholic" and as a "Liberal Catholic". As I said above, these titles generally don't have anything to do with politics, in themselves. They have to do with how someone understands themselves in relation to the Church.

You have apparantly associated me with some "conservative" boogeyman, and have decided to pigeon hole me into that role.

So be it.

I leave this thread with no ill will. If I have been uncharitable, I apologize.

We disagree.

There is nothing more to say.

God bless.

Posted

Another relevant post of mine, for documentation purposes:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=46569&view=findpost&p=867386"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...ndpost&p=867386[/url]

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

Well said, Era.

Not all "conservative catholics" supported the war.

I went on a big diatribe as to why the Democratic party isn't the more "Catholic" party, and while the GOP isn't so great, the Democratic party is even worse -- but anyway I'm sure that we've all been through this before.

What I can say is that Catholics being 50% split down the middle policially doesn't really tell us anything. If 50% of Catholics were faithful to the magesterium on ALL teachings, then maybe we'd be getting somewhere, but as it is, that statistic is practically a dream scenario compared to the way it is now.

Edited by Ash Wednesday

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...