p-hawk Posted February 18, 2006 Posted February 18, 2006 I'm in the middle of reading Luciana Frassati's biography of Bl. Pier Giorgio Frassati, and as a huge fan of Dominicans, I was thrilled to learn that Pier Giorgio was a Third Order Dominican. He was really excited to take Savonarola's first name as his Third Order name. Luciana calls Savonarola "the Dominican martyr Savonarola". When I looked up Savonarola on the internets, I found out from Catholic Encyclopedia that, although he wasn't a heretic, he was unjustifiably disobediant to Rome, to the point where he was excommunicated. Am I missing something here? Am I supposed to like him or not? I suppose that any of his writings are theologically sound, but beyond that, I don't know.
Tindomiel Posted February 18, 2006 Posted February 18, 2006 I don't really know, I had that question myself when reading that book. The only thing I can think of is that he might have lived around the times of one of the bad popes...
Birgitta Noel Posted February 18, 2006 Posted February 18, 2006 And remember that Saints aren't infaillable. So.... (yes, I know he's not a saint yet, but he could be in the future....)
HisChild Posted February 19, 2006 Posted February 19, 2006 Savonarola, a Dominican priest, was excommunicated by Alexander VI, one of the most controversial and secular of Popes. Savonarola was known for very radical things like making sodomy a capital punishment (now how would the homosexual population like that one??), burning books etc. In fact, he was known for the 'real' Bonfire of the Vanities.' The people went for it for a while, until there were mass riots and he was excommunicated and hanged. there are people who claim he was the 'father' of the Reformation, because he tried to get rid of the sexual sins that were rampant of the time, including in the Church. The Dominicans want him canonized. The Jesuits, are apparently against it.
Birgitta Noel Posted February 19, 2006 Posted February 19, 2006 [quote name='PCPA2Be' date='Feb 19 2006, 08:59 AM']The Dominicans want him canonized. The Jesuits, are apparently against it. [right][snapback]891717[/snapback][/right] [/quote] HAHAHAHAHA, that is the funniest thing I've heard all day. But, why does that not surprise me!
HisChild Posted February 19, 2006 Posted February 19, 2006 well, not sure WHY the Society of Jesus doesn't like him. . . but
shortnun Posted February 20, 2006 Posted February 20, 2006 [quote name='p-hawk' date='Feb 18 2006, 01:16 PM']Am I missing something here? Am I supposed to like him or not? I suppose that any of his writings are theologically sound, but beyond that, I don't know. [right][snapback]891234[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well, in addition to urging you to do a little more reading on your own, so that YOU can decide if you are "supposed to like him or not"..... here's my two cents. (This comes notes taken from my graduate level Church History class-- and the prof is a Dominican and former employee of a well-known Jesuit institution.) Looking at the state of Europe as it existed in the 15th century, there are a number of influences worthy of noting. First, the rise of humanism--a movement which focused on human ability, human possiblity, and human perfectability. Second, the state of the church. Definitions of "clergy" and "laity" were no longer found to be satisfactory. There was a cry to "return to the sources"--for [i]reform[/i]. How are the laity to live a life of value? How can the church as a whole heighten individual awareness about the importance of a healthy interior life--regardless of class, job, etc? How can the Church encourage those in religious life should return to the ancient ways of their founders? Girolamo Savonarola, OP was a Florentine preacher who urged reform among Italian Dominicans of the mid-late 15th century. He preached fire and brimstone (preaching of the apocalypse, etc), burned books (and other things such as lavish clothing and makeup), was seen (by civil leaders) as a real threat with the potential to disrupt Italian society. He was a well-educated man and wrote a number of influential religious treatises. He saw the abuses of the clergy (ie, they wouldn't attach themselves to a parish, they would just collect a paycheck from them and live in a fancy house on the beach) and shouted out quite loudly for some action to be taken against such men. Additionally, Savonarola preached against the pope--Alexander VI--himself. The pope forbade him to preach, and basically Savonarola blatently disobeyed. He was later excommunicated. And eventually captured, tortured, hanged and burned with two other Dominicans, accused of schism and heresy. My brief comments about the Jesuits not being a fan of the effort of Savonarola's canonization are two-fold: 1) The Jesuits and Dominicans like to talk about things in the present as if they were as big of a deal as their differences in the past have been. (It also appears to me as if this continual disagreement is instigated by the Dominicans and largely ignored by the Jesuits.) 2) During the Reformation and following, in terms of "styles of reform," the SJs leaned more toward the Huminists, and the OPs more toward internal, structural, hierarchical reform.
Tindomiel Posted February 20, 2006 Posted February 20, 2006 Aahhhh, Alexander VI. Well that clears some things up for me.
Ziggamafu Posted February 20, 2006 Posted February 20, 2006 Savonarola is cool because he's an example of how to work for reform from within the Church. He never left the Church, even after the Pope excommunicated him.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now