Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Sex is great . . . it's God's gift


Recommended Posts

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Mrs. Bro. Adam' date='Feb 19 2006, 09:40 PM']Remember, though, that there are worse sins.  Fornication is misplaced love.
[right][snapback]892213[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
There are worse sins, but mortal sin is mortal sin is mortal sin.

Doesn't much matter when you'll never see the face of God.

:( Poor sinners...poor me! God save us from the clutches of death!

Posted

[quote name='Mrs. Bro. Adam' date='Feb 19 2006, 07:40 PM']Remember, though, that there are worse sins.  Fornication is misplaced love.
[right][snapback]892213[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
No one said it was the worst sin.
However, it is still a mortal sin, and is still condemned by the Church.

Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Feb 19 2006, 07:43 PM']There are worse sins, but mortal sin is mortal sin is mortal sin.

Doesn't much matter when you'll never see the face of God.

:( Poor sinners...poor me!  God save us from the clutches of death!
[right][snapback]892218[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


It isn't automatically a mortal sin. Remember what it takes to become a mortal sin. Many of those who partake are not completely culpable because of how they were raised. ;)

Posted

it is objectively talked about as a mortal sin. if in any subjective case if one is not culpable, the mortal sin has still been committed it is just not blamed on them-- therefore it is always a mortal sin, because it has mortal capacity, the ability to kill grace in a soul.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Feb 20 2006, 12:56 PM']it is objectively talked about as a mortal sin.  if in any subjective case if one is not culpable, the mortal sin has still been committed it is just not blamed on them-- therefore it is always a mortal sin, because it has mortal capacity, the ability to kill grace in a soul.
[right][snapback]892234[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I don't know if this is a help in the discussion but it is a good article on culpability,

The Question of Culpability and sin
Sin is an offense against reason, truth, and right conscience; it is failure in genuine love for God and neighbor caused by a perverse attachment to certain goods. It wounds the nature of man and injures human solidarity. It has been defined as "an utterance, a deed, or a desire contrary to the eternal law."121 (CCC, 1849). Catholicism regards sin as a generally bad thing. It’s not looked too highly upon, and there is quite a bit of discussion over what is a sin and what is not, and many people are offended by the judgments arising from such discussions. Comment sometime in a crowd you believe such and such to be a sin, and someone will likely be incensed that you are judging him because the act in question is something performed regularly by the objector. Lawyers and telemarketers are unusually susceptible to this, but thankfully, the Pope has forbade us to associate with them freely. (I am kidding, the Pope only warned us to sprinkle them liberally with Holy Water and wear sprigs of garlic.)
To judge an action as a sin is not the same as labeling a person as culpable for that sin, even if that person commits the act labeled as sinful. One may commit a sinful act and not have sinned. Not because the act itself is different, but because something internal to that person mitigated his culpability. Alternatively, one’s culpability may be reduced, but not completely gone.
Note the word “internal”. It is exceedingly difficult (if not impossible) to judge an individual’s culpability for the sinfulness of a particular act. We see the external, may have some insight to the internal, but the latter is limited to a degree that one usually may, at most, merely speculate as to someone’s culpability.
“Moral Theology” by Fr. Heribert Jone (TAN Books), divides things quite simply for us:
The knowledge must embrace:
1. The action itself: The so-called ‘motus primo primi’ are not human acts and consequently have no moral character, e.g., thoughts imagination and tendencies which are elicited by the intellectual or volitional faculties of man before he becomes aware of them, e.g., an impulse of anger, aversion, etc.
2. The object of the action with all its proximate circumstances: An action is human, and therefore, good or bad, only in so far as its object is known. If one kills another knowing him to be his father, he is guilty of patricide. If he thinks his victim is a stranger he is guilty of homicide. If he believes it is an animal which he may lawfully hunt, he commits no sin at all.
3. The possibility of not acting or of acting otherwise: Only when this possibility is recognized can there be free consent of the will, without which neither good nor evil deeds are imputable.
Anything interfering with these three things is termed an “obstacle”, and can reduce or eliminate the imputability of an act. These include fear, threats of violence to the agent (that’s moral theology talk, there) or, habit, mental disorders, etc. (Jone, 4). The involvement of the will is paramount in deciding the culpability for a sin, and it is easy to imagine cases, and thereby cut people some slack for actions they may not be responsible for. What I mean to say is, don’t assume someone is a Hell-bound sinner just because he performs the actions of one. What I am absolutely NOT saying is to allow such situations to remain thus; but when trying to inform someone of the evil nature of an act, be charitable, and be ready to catch someone who may crumble with remorse at the reality of his deeds. Christianity is not a hit and run exercise, nor is it always tidy and full of hymns, pancake breakfasts and coffee socials. Sometimes, Christianity is about cleaning away the blood the drying of tears, the mending of the wounds of this world. Like MASH, but sans all the wit.
The purpose of discussing sin is not to condemn individual people, but to enlighten all people, to give them the opportunity to not merely avoid sinning, but to actually DO good (having to will the good results of an act to have them imputed to you is another topic, but comes from this one). When the Church comes out and says this or that is evil, she has not just declared all people committing that act are next on the Charcoal Express, she is merely doing her job, which is to teach us all how to attain Heaven, not merely by avoiding offending the Big Guy, but by pleasing Him as well. I highly recommend picking up Fr. Jone’s book. It’s arranged like the Catechism, which makes it very handy.

Jone, Fr. Heribert. (1961). Moral Theology. (Fr. Urban Adelman, O.F.M. Cap., J.C.D., trans.) Rockford: TAN.

Posted
:D: add to your knowledge base of the wonders of Marital Relations :D: (a.k.a. SEX) :blush:
and read
Good News about Sex and Marriage by Christopher West

WONDERFUL book that talks about just what the title says.....Great thing to read up on if you are engaged, already married, or mature enough to think you might get married someday. It is never to early to begin to educate yourself in the truth, and put off the info the world is trying to shove down your throat.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...