Anastasia13 Posted February 20, 2006 Posted February 20, 2006 Most of the threads and stuff I've read seem to indicate that it is only good if it's open to life and otherwise it's selfish. You have to have sex with no birth control or not have sex. Then a married couple not having sex could be as bad as a couple using birth control because they were commanded to reproduce and they would not be open to life for whatever likely selfish reasons. So if there is something so the wife could die if she had another baby are pretty much in trouble either way except that in that case they could get a medical excuse to use birth control. Two questions from here: 1. What is the point then of having sex anyway? 2. Is a medical excuse [i]always[/i] a good one for allowing what would otherwise be considered sin?* *if this answer is no, how do you determine which case it is?
Pio Nono Posted February 20, 2006 Posted February 20, 2006 JMJ 2/20 - Seventh Monday Light and Truth, I'm not entirely sure what it is you're asking, but I'll try to answer it as best I can. 1.) Sex has a twofold purpose - it is unitive (it is where the "two become one flesh", cf. Gen. 2:24; Matt. 19:5; Mark 10:8) and procreative. When one aspect is missing, sex loses its good character - instead of being a servant, it becomes the slave-driver; instead of being man's prayer to God, it is the self-glorification of man. Any form of birth control acts against the procreative aspect by its very nature; many things other than birth control act against the unitive (ie. sexual activity while drunk, while thinking of someone else, &c.). 2.) There are those who hold that the medical use of birth control is morally legitimate, especially for unmarried women who are (a) sexually active and (b) have medical problems that birth control can treat. One is able to interpret Catholic theology in this way, and legitimately so. However, there is another way to interpret Catholic theology (this is my preference, mostly because I think it's right) that does not allow for the use of birth control in any circumstance. Though it may have medical benefits (ie. preventing growth spurts, rectifying persistent acne, &c.), the side effects are so incredibly harmful to a woman's body (ie. weight gain, moodiness, greater chance of multiple kinds of cancer, greater chance of permanent sterilization) that it is not justifiable to prescribe contraceptives. There are many doctors who think this way as well, and will prescribe other drugs and treatment methods that will produce similar or better results than birth control. Hope this helps. Yours, Pio Nono
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now