Guest theconfusableman Posted February 21, 2006 Posted February 21, 2006 Could you critique my current understanding of Vatican II? It was NOT and infallible unless it was reiterating previous infallible teachings. This is the impression given by the Theological note of the council. The majority of the pronouncements were pastoral in nature and they were completely contradictory to the decrees of previous popes, especially Blessed Pius IX as was said by then Cardinal Ratzinger. “If it is desirable to offer a diagnosis of the text [Gaudium et Spes] as a whole, we might say that (in conjunction with the texts on religious liberty and world religions) it is a revision of the Syllabus of Pius IX, a kind of countersyllabus. [...] Let us be content to say that the text serves as a countersyllabus and, as such, represents, on the part of the Church, an attempt at an official reconciliation with the new era inaugurated in 1789.” (Principles of Catholic Theology, 1987, pp. 381-2, Ignatius Press 1987) Since this is an obvious change and is not subject to continuity Catholics can have reservations and even work to have these pastoral decrees changed, so long as they respect the RIGHT and the AUTHORITY of the Church to implement pastoral changes. Catholics must follow the wishes of their prelates with obedience. Behavior like that of Archbishop Marcel Levebvre which incurred de jure excommunication is not acceptable. Obedience is the only way to ensure that one remains a loyal son of the Catholic Church. Obedience is necessary, but outside of Faith and Morals agreement is not necessary. Mirari Vos seems incompatible with the Vatican II and idea that the Church requires renewal. Testem Benevolentiae Nostra and Quas Primas appear to me to be irreconcilable with the post-conciliar view of government. Neither does Unam Sanctam seem compatible with the post-conciliar idea of ecumenism. The same goes for Mediator Dei and the way the Pauline Rite Mass is usually celebrated. I don’t understand how these pre-conciliar and post-conciliar documents and practices can be reconciled. They seem to be utterly opposed. Yes, Pope John Paul II, who was unquestionably holy and pious, accepted the Council and quoted it often, but I seriously doubt that Blessed Pius IX would have done so. Is this understanding of the council okay to hold or is it schismatic?
Pontifex Posted February 22, 2006 Posted February 22, 2006 I will only comment on this in brief. It would be a grave error to critique Vatican II as anything less than a movement of the Holy Spirit. I find this piece of writing to be very reactionary. We must work from the foundational line of thinking, that Vatican II was and is a movement of the Holy Spirit. What is being reacted to here are the abuses and subsequent actions done in the "Spirit of Vatican II". Many things were implemented in the Spirit of Vatican II that were completely wrong. We are still in the process of cleaning up that mess. I think John Paul the Great would see it the same way. He and Benedict were huge pioneers in the Council, but broke with those that wanted to push the Council beyond the Spirit's lead. This type of reactionary thinking will only damage any effort to stabilize the Church in the midst of turmoil. I would recommend a great book entitled, "John Paul the Great: Maker of the post-conciliar Church". It is a collection of writings from some wonderful theologians. In Christ, Fr. Burns
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now