Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What are the best arguments for Catholicism?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Not Bible-based.
Not history-based.

I'm talking about arguments based on practicality and meaningfulness. What do you think is the psychological genius of Catholicism? What makes it so inspirational? What are the arguments from culture and sociology?

Posted

this is just the first thing that popped into my head......

i like how catholicism is the best example of the Lord meeting us where we are, taking the very thing that we are enslaved to (the world) and using it as the means with which to lift us back up to him. catholicism is a sensual religion, and i think that, in a sensual world, this can be appealing. the Lord effects every way in which humans perceive and take in their world (sight, sound, touch, taste, smell) in order to effect real change in our lives.

Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Feb 22 2006, 08:42 PM']Not Bible-based.
Not history-based.

I'm talking about arguments based on practicality and meaningfulness. What do you think is the psychological genius of Catholicism? What makes it so inspirational? What are the arguments from culture and sociology?
[right][snapback]895164[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Practicality, meaningfullness, psychological genius, inspiration, culture and sociology...... hmmmm

Our faith/church is [b]sacramental[/b]. The images and signs we have that express our beliefs are universally significant. (The Gospel message is universal!!!) Likewise, those same images and signs have the capacity to take on further significance for each individual person.

Posted

I'd recommend Chesterton's "Orthodoxy" for some good ideas. He wrote it before converting to the Faith, but he nevertheless presents a good defense of Christianity based on reason and common sense (or at least the reasons that moved him to convert).

You can read it [url="http://www.leaderu.com/cyber/books/orthodoxy/orthodoxy.html"]online, here[/url].

Posted

I have seen eyes opened to the glory of the church by good confessions, practice of NFP and marital chastity, Theology of the body, our roll before God (Lumen Gentium and other sources). VII documents hold lots of astonishing things.

Posted

Confession is psychological genius - even if one were an athiest, going through "the motions" of Confession would bring relief and peace from one's own accusing conscience.

The notion of Mass as Family Supper is also genius. It allows civilization to become "One Family" and transcend petty arguments through ritual family practice.

Posted

I LOVE Orthodoxy!! It is my favorite book.

Posted

Who churns out holy people like the Catholic Church?

Coincidence? I think no.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Feb 25 2006, 03:39 PM']Who churns out holy people like the Catholic Church?

Coincidence? I think no.
[right][snapback]897659[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Well, to be fair we do have a black list of SOB's

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Feb 25 2006, 11:02 PM']Well, to be fair we do have a black list of SOB's
[right][snapback]897845[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Yes, we do, but that only goes to support the Church's claims. 2,000 years of Scoundrels, and yet the Saints have prevailed, and the Church has remained what she is through it all.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Feb 26 2006, 06:37 PM']Yes, we do, but that only goes to support the Church's claims. 2,000 years of Scoundrels, and yet the Saints have prevailed, and the Church has remained what she is through it all.
[right][snapback]898406[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]



Amen.

Does anyone have the interview with thePontif formally know as Ratzinter and EWTN's Raymond Arroyo from a few years ago? Ratzinger really hit the ball out of the park talking about the sex scandal. First he stumbled with english, then switched to italian. He summed up with a scripture about how Jesus promised the fallen would always be with us in the church, the that the church would prevail.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Feb 25 2006, 04:39 PM']Who churns out holy people like the Catholic Church?

Coincidence? I think no.
[right][snapback]897659[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I've asked people this question before, it really is an intriguing question.

Name the protestant/non-Christian equivalent to:

Mother Theresa
John Paul II
Maximilian Kolbe
Fulton Sheen
Mother Angelica

These are more or less our contempories. If you were to reach back into history the list grows quickly.

Who are the protestant equivalents?

What was it about these people that enabled them to live lives of such extraordinary holiness?

Posted

[quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Feb 27 2006, 05:07 AM']I've asked people this question before, it really is an intriguing question.

Name the protestant/non-Christian equivalent to:

Mother Theresa
John Paul II
Maximilian Kolbe
Fulton Sheen
Mother Angelica

These are more or less our contempories.  If you were to reach back into history the list grows quickly.

Who are the protestant equivalents?
[right][snapback]898697[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

protestants dont get the pub that catholics do. So as far as fame is considered it is a bias discussion.

Mother Theresa
-I know of a handlful of people from my college alone that have dedicated their entire life to a people group from the philippians or africa. Thus the same intention and lifestyle is there. Mother Theresa is a great woman, but she is known as an icon. There are others who are doing the same thing

JPII
-Obviouslly the protestant church doesnt have a visiable leader in the camera and the position to make the impact of JPII. We can leave that simply to a result of eccesiology. But if you are asking for a pastoral church leader that can seek unity, hyper-intell, charistmatic on some levels. Once again an iconic figure. Most protestants consider JPII to be an amazing christian. But based on the structure of the protestant church there is not a center-figure out there. Yet the protestant church brings Billy graham, Robert Schuller, and other leaders and pastors.

I dont know enough about Kolbe, perhaps if you share? Same with Mother Anglicia. DIdnt she start EWTN?

Fulton SHeen? All respect due friends, but CS lewis, Greg Boyd, Max luciodo, NT Wright, John MacArthur, John Eldridge, William Lane Craig, Craig Blomberg, JP Moreland.

You need to remember, friends, Most protestants use catholic theologians/people the same way they use their own theologians. They dont give either authority, yet use them to infulence and develop faith.

Posted

Hauerwas for sure, Volf is important, John Milbank has been very important. I dunno, any such list is pretty personal depending on the believer and the topic. My current favorite writer is William Cavanaugh, who is Catholic.

Posted

Mother Anglicia has EWTN, but protestants have the veggie tales..

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' date='Mar 1 2006, 02:44 PM']protestants dont get the pub that catholics do. So as far as fame is considered it is a bias discussion.
[right][snapback]900862[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

This is not a coincidence, either.

There's no doubt that there are holy men and women outside the visible boundaries of the Catholic Church (and even moreso than in Protestantism, the Eastern Orthodox have a rich tradition of Saints). But only the Catholic Church enjoys the Saints who stand out in amazing splendor. John Paul, Mother Teresa, Thomas Aquinas, John of the Cross, Terese of Lisieux. Why does Catholicism have so many outstanding personages in her history? Because she is set apart as Christ's true Church. She is a city set on a hill, and Christ manifests his glory through her, most perfectly in the Saints. This visiblity of the Catholic Church is of divine providence. God loves all those holy Protestant men and women you mentioned. But he did not glorify them in the same way he does Catholic Saints, because Catholic Saints point to something greater than themselves: his mystical Bride.

Posted

actually it might be because there are way more catholics than protestants, more books in publication, and cnn always seems to be focusing on catholics. Look at the priest sex scandal. The southern baptist have been having that problem for a long time. Yet we never hear about it.

I like your answer, it sounds nice. But in saturational media it isnt valid.

Id like to append my list and put mark noll and Moltman on there also..hehe

Posted

btw, brother..

Im not saying protestants>>>>>>catholics. I am responding to the challenge of a protestant who can be in the same class as the list mentioned above. For the sake of bein ecumenical I believe we must see the true value in protestant minds. Otherwise we battled the battled of degrading them to arrogant children. As someone trained in protestant biblical and theological studies (*my story has been told already, no need to repeat my rep on that side) I can attest to the value found.

Posted

JMJ
3/1 - Ash Wednesday
[quote name='Revprodeji' date='Mar 1 2006, 12:44 PM']Yet the protestant church brings Billy graham, Robert Schuller, and other leaders and pastors.[right][snapback]900862[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I don't mean to hijack the thread, but football fans will appreciate it...

What do the Indianapolis Colts and Billy Graham have in common?























Both of them can make 70,000 people stand up and shout, "Jesus Christ!" :lol_roll:

Posted

thats funny...i like it

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...