Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

ACLU opposes creation of 'Catholic town'


Recommended Posts

Posted

Debate over pizza mogul's Catholic town


After Florida Governor Jeb Bush joined Domino's Pizza founder Thomas S. Monaghan in turning the first sod this month at the new university town of Ave Maria, the American Civil Lilberties Union (ACLU) complained that a religious group was attempting to exercise governmental power in the town.

Catholic News Agency reports that Florida ACLU executive director Howard Simon told local media presenter Tucker Carlson that his organisation's opposition has nothing to do with anti-Catholicism. Rather, he said: "It's a story about any religious group trying to exercise governmental power."

The university and town have been funded by Monaghan.

"You've to make a distinction between just encouraging like-minded people to come and live in the same place with a town organised on religious principles, in which the religious group is given governmental authority," said Simon.

About a year ago, Monaghan indicated that he would own all the commercial real estate, residents would not be able to buy pornography or contraception, and the town would determine what cable system it would have.

Carlson pointed out that towns everywhere decide what cable system it has, what types of stores it will have and if pornography can be sold. "That's called zoning," he said.

Simon continued to defend his position, citing the 10-year-old US Supreme Court decision, which ruled that a group of Hasidic Jews in upper New York state in a town called Kiryas Joel, could not receive government funding because it was organized around sectarian religious principles.

"And when you‘re required to conform to religious principles, that town is not fitting for governmental authority," he said.

"It's his hand, and if he wants a pharmacy that doesn't sell condoms or the pill, it‘s not your business. It's not my business," Carlson told his guest.

SOURCE
ACLU opposes creation of 'Catholic town' (Catholic News Agency 23/2/06)

photosynthesis
Posted

I hate the ACLU.

and the author is right about towns controlling commerce + businesses and such. My town's chamber of commerce will not allow any fast-food restaurants to open up business.

It seems like the ACLU wants people to have civil liberties as long as they are politically correct about it. grr.

homeschoolmom
Posted

My husband grew up in a town that was completely mapped out and planned as a Christian city-- Zion, Illinois. The streets are layed out like a Union Jack and have names like "Joppa" and "Jethro" and "Galilee"... I think it's still dry or maybe recently changed that law....

crazymaine catholic
Posted

the aclu was at the conservative political action conference. i wanted to say a few choice but inapporpriate words at them, but i refrained.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Feb 23 2006, 10:50 PM']My husband grew up in a town that was completely mapped out and planned as a Christian city-- Zion, Illinois. The streets are layed out like a Union Jack and have names like "Joppa" and "Jethro" and "Galilee"... I think it's still dry or maybe recently changed that law....
[right][snapback]895857[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Do you have it's location? i'd like to see that..

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Hahahahahaha..."That's called zoning!" Go Tucker. :hehe:
I can't stand the ACLU.

Posted

how can they fight a town that doesn't exist yet?

crazymaine catholic
Posted

the same way they find problems with civil issues that don't even exist.

Posted

They must be very bored. Is the world otherwise so perfect that they really need to be spending their time on the ridiculous things they do?

MissScripture
Posted

The ACLU is just plain ridiculous. Besides, if people don't agree with the town they don't have to move there...it's not like he's taken over somewhere already in exsistance and forced anything on anyone...

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='jezic' date='Feb 23 2006, 09:00 PM']how can they fight a town that doesn't exist yet?
[right][snapback]896191[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Hate. They hate God. They hate His people. They hate His Church. So they would hate even the idea of a town run by Gods people. It is hate....

photosynthesis
Posted

I wonder what they'd do if a bunch of atheists wanted to start a town based on Atheist principles, with a big atheist university in the center. I bet they'd be thrilled, even though they would prohibit churches, synagogues + other houses of worship from forming.

photosynthesis
Posted

Plus no one is living in the town, so they arent' infringing on anyone's rights. If the town were in existence, and someone decided to make it a "Catholic town" but other people who weren't Catholic lived int hte town + opposed the religious influence, I could see why they would have a problem. But no one even lives there, so they are starting from scratch.

homeschoolmom
Posted (edited)

[quote name='RandomProddy' date='Feb 23 2006, 07:03 PM']Do you have it's location? i'd like to see that..
[right][snapback]895972[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
[url="http://www.encyclopedia.chicagohistory.org/pages/1399.html"]Zion, IL[/url]

I'm looking for a map of the city...

[url="http://www.mapquest.com/maps/map.adp?ovi=1&zoom=8&mapdata=Fha1P5i%2fM%2fUDcHxJJEToQR5vvPniFaQ%2fuJZhSnMZk6RovckP%2bDudMSf8lvV9jK%2byiqujORZF2XetjGqAYLxfyfAAJd2QdH0uU240N1q6A4h5FY2AXAMdg6S1Jf9JDW7Imc%2bSkl4BzaacyMPbGj%2favNshr3A7McL587HUaNvyItSsrVrnYF2YyfJysS2yMrMh%2bFICq9E%2bMY9WSmTN4mCuDKxAYBqldam1v4yvOHOAsNY6UTchZcGtV234JxIYcAUc1fu3d132WWdgxhQvD9nFncXhiLyn9I16kyBGT4UZxBlXlpreKgELb5jh7ON%2fq3WhDLelWeLZVtYv8QvMU9FsR6Mic12MsG0UU9qVx8BYbKAhETHpj54mfdmOQF5CU%2ftPFrYB320%2b3%2fuK9lki5sWKfYzxNyR4z%2f%2bMS8WpQ1tXWWqcAoztUuIPb2U7x81gy%2fCSqMJaMlwfxr00eccNAz10%2fq5T0H9kc8DoosZBIaHekycr9Qx78GWU90KEhQjEVCHwFzCtA3r5vNMntvykpos8wjZFCtM3KniiD3nyBJKiYMhFY0pkUzZr%2bpJCzoaJEY2aMC7PtR2FmTeSNKjT3HY9xA%3d%3d#map1-link"]Zion map[/url]

Okay, I found it. There's been a lot of construction over the years, but you can see that Bethlehem and Lebenon Aves are the angled streets. Shiloh Park is in the center.

Oh, carp. I can't get the map to link. Mapquest has a pretty good map of it... Also, the founding church-- Christian Catholic Apostolic Church has changed its name because people kept thinking it was Catholic....

Edited by homeschoolmom
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Feb 23 2006, 05:50 PM']My husband grew up in a town that was completely mapped out and planned as a Christian city-- Zion, Illinois. The streets are layed out like a Union Jack and have names like "Joppa" and "Jethro" and "Galilee"... I think it's still dry or maybe recently changed that law....
[right][snapback]895857[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Better than Gahanna, Ohio.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Feb 24 2006, 08:41 AM'][url="http://www.encyclopedia.chicagohistory.org/pages/1399.html"]Zion, IL[/url]

I'm looking for a map of the city...

[url="http://www.mapquest.com/maps/map.adp?ovi=1&zoom=8&mapdata=Fha1P5i%2fM%2fUDcHxJJEToQR5vvPniFaQ%2fuJZhSnMZk6RovckP%2bDudMSf8lvV9jK%2byiqujORZF2XetjGqAYLxfyfAAJd2QdH0uU240N1q6A4h5FY2AXAMdg6S1Jf9JDW7Imc%2bSkl4BzaacyMPbGj%2favNshr3A7McL587HUaNvyItSsrVrnYF2YyfJysS2yMrMh%2bFICq9E%2bMY9WSmTN4mCuDKxAYBqldam1v4yvOHOAsNY6UTchZcGtV234JxIYcAUc1fu3d132WWdgxhQvD9nFncXhiLyn9I16kyBGT4UZxBlXlpreKgELb5jh7ON%2fq3WhDLelWeLZVtYv8QvMU9FsR6Mic12MsG0UU9qVx8BYbKAhETHpj54mfdmOQF5CU%2ftPFrYB320%2b3%2fuK9lki5sWKfYzxNyR4z%2f%2bMS8WpQ1tXWWqcAoztUuIPb2U7x81gy%2fCSqMJaMlwfxr00eccNAz10%2fq5T0H9kc8DoosZBIaHekycr9Qx78GWU90KEhQjEVCHwFzCtA3r5vNMntvykpos8wjZFCtM3KniiD3nyBJKiYMhFY0pkUzZr%2bpJCzoaJEY2aMC7PtR2FmTeSNKjT3HY9xA%3d%3d#map1-link"]Zion map[/url]

Okay, I found it. There's been a lot of construction over the years, but you can see that Bethlehem and Lebenon Aves are the angled streets. Shiloh Park is in the center.

Oh, carp. I can't get the map to link. Mapquest has a pretty good map of it... Also, the founding church-- Christian Catholic Apostolic Church has changed its name because people kept thinking it was Catholic....
[right][snapback]896471[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

They should change street names from Paul St. to St. Paul...

:hehe:

God the Father
Posted

A catholic ghetto?

Guest Infinite42
Posted

As much as I love the idea, I don't think that Ave Maria's law school should be moved down to Florida. They've made quite a reputation for themselves in Michigan, and the idea to found the school was borne by several local professors. The legitimacy of the school has already been compromised by the talk of its moving to Florida. I know that several administrators have already resigned, and there is quite a rift between the two factions (those that want to stay and those that want to go).

At any rate, the ACLU is ridiculous and has zero credibility.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...