Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Please help me validate or refute a claim


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I was reading an online article about Catholic Spirituality ([url="http://www.commonwealmagazine.org/article.php?id_article=1528"]link[/url]) in Commonweal's current issue. It claims of Vatican II:
[quote]Still, the council urged a reform of the liturgy; [b]cautioned against holding on to antiquated customs in religious life[/b].[/quote]
So my question for those who know the documents of Vatican II ([url="http://www.stjosef.at/council/search/"]link[/url]): do the council documents make such a claim (i.e. against "antiquated customs")? If so, what exactly does it state?

Thanks!

Edited by Mateo el Feo
Posted

JMJ
2/23 - St. Polycarp

I say we exorcize the spirit of Vatican II.

Posted

[quote name='Mateo el Feo' date='Feb 23 2006, 04:20 PM']I was reading an online article about Catholic Spirituality ([url="http://www.commonwealmagazine.org/article.php?id_article=1528"]link[/url]) in Commonweal's current issue.  It claims of Vatican II:

So my question for those who know the documents of Vatican II ([url="http://www.stjosef.at/council/search/"]link[/url]): do the council documents make such a claim (i.e. against "antiquated customs")?  If so, what exactly does it state?

Thanks!
[right][snapback]895892[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
:maddest: It did not!!! I am sorry but that would merit a hot button issue with me. Read Perfectaa Caritatis, plus the post-conciliar documents. It urged the religious "to go back to the roots of their founders." That is pretty much verbatim and means: go back to your founding traditions. That means the Cistercians ought to go back to the lay brothers (the conversi) distinction for it was in their founder's spirit, and such. Here is a quote from the document:[quote]b) It redounds to the good of the Church that institutes have their own particular characteristics and work. Therefore let their [i]founders' spirit [/i]and special aims they set before them as well [b]as their sound traditions[/b]-all of which make up the patrimony of each institute-be faithfully held in honor.[/quote]

AND[quote]9. The monastic life, that venerable institution which in the course of a long history has won for itself notable renown in the Church and in human society, should be preserved with care and its authentic spirit permitted to shine forth ever more splendidly both in the East and the West. The principal duty of monks is to offer a service to the divine majesty at once humble and noble within the walls of the monastery, whether they dedicate themselves entirely to divine worship in the contemplative life or have legitimately undertaken some apostolate or work of Christian charity. Retaining, therefore, the characteristics of the way of life proper to them, they should [b]revive their ancient traditions [/b]of service and so adapt them to the needs of today that monasteries will become institutions dedicated to the edification of the Christian people.[/quote]Meaning go back to your traditions and modify where [i]needed[/i] so that same tradition and practice will aid the people today.

AND[quote]17. The religious habit, an outward mark of consecration to God, should be simple and modest, poor and at the same becoming. In addition it must meet the requirements of health and be suited to the circumstances of time and place and to the needs of the ministry involved. The habits of both men and women religious which do not conform to these norms must be changed.[/quote] That means wear a habit!

Sorry, but like I said this is a hot-button topic for me. Here is the [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_decree_19651028_perfectae-caritatis_en.html"]link to the document[/url].

Commonweal is not a faithful magazine. >:( I have helped to refute a claim in their magazine that the Catholic understanding of transubstansiation is closer to consubstansiation.

We are not amused. <_<

Posted

I would quote you the statements from V II that say such a thing so I could refute him properly but there are none so I cannot. In other words it is nonsense. Ask them to support the claim.

Posted

sean..................u got anything on this?

Posted

[quote name='Pio Nono' date='Feb 23 2006, 07:46 PM']
JMJ
2/23 - St. Polycarp

I say we exorcize the spirit of Vatican II.
[right][snapback]896064[/snapback][/right]


Some humor on the topic from our 'Separated blog brethern' over at curt Jester

[url="http://www.splendoroftruth.com/curtjester/archives/006495.php"]http://www.splendoroftruth.com/curtjester/...ives/006495.php[/url]


[QUOTE][color=blue]New Rite of Exorcism

I have received a copy of a proposal for a new rite of exorcism currently being considered by the by the Congregation for Divine Worship..... The new document is called The Rite of Exorcism for the Spirit of Vatican II. The Spirit of Vatican II Exorcists will be designated as one of the minor orders and these priests will be drawn from those who have already been designated to the Exorcistate and are experienced in expelling demons. The reason behind this I assume that expelling demons is a breeze compared to expelling the spirit of Vatican II from subjects. I will posts parts of this new document with some commentary... [/color][/QUOTE]

Posted

Quick update:

I e-mailed the author ([url="http://www.nd.edu/~theo/faculty/cunningham.html"]link[/url]), who is a professor of theology at Notre Dame.

I'll let you guys know if/when I receive a response.

Posted

Hi all,

I received the following response from the author:
[quote]I had in mind the instructions in #3 of <Perfectae Caritatis>.
[/quote]

Quoting [url="http://www.cin.org/v2relig.html"]Perfectae Caritatis, Paragraph 3 (link)[/url]:
[quote name='Perfectae Caritatis']3. The manner of living, praying and working should be suitably adapted everywhere, but especially in mission territories, to the modern physical and psychological circumstances of the members and also, as required by the nature of each institute, to the necessities of the apostolate. the demands of culture, and social and economic circumstances.

According to the same criteria let the manner of governing the institutes also be examined.

Therefore let constitutions, directories, custom books, hooks of prayers and ceremonies and such like be suitably reedited and, obsolete laws being suppressed, be adapted to the decrees of this sacred synod.
[/quote]

Posted

Then his language in the article was stronger than the document he cited. I also find it odd that he ignored the several other places where Perfectae Caritatis exhorted the orders to go back to their founders (ancient cutsoms and traditions for most) and to revive their ancient traditions (paragraph 9). The document does say that they ought to be adapted, but it does not say that they should abolish all tradition either. The emphasis of the council in this area was not [i]reform[/i] which sounds like what the author wanted (to throw out the old for the sake of the new), but [i]revival[/i] meaning revive the ancient customs and apply them today.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...