Ziggamafu Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 (edited) So some of you might remember my particularily lenient take on discernment of mortal sin. For those of you who don't, I basically hope more people end up in Purgatory than Hell and I support this hope in my understanding of what mortal sin is... Whereas some Catholics stress the third condition for mortal sin (presence of grave matter) I stress the first two (free will and full knowledge). I find support for the notion that "full knowledge" also implies full understanding (of consequences and reasoning behind the command) and that "free will" also implies deliberation (unhindered consent). This basically reduces mortal sin to a focused and intentional violation of one's own conscience and / or an explicit rejection of Love, Truth, and / or Heaven. I hope this is true. It would mean far more souls are in Purgatory and far fewer souls are in Hell. Recently, I've read in several places that in the Early Church, Confession only took place [b]once [/b]in one's lifetime and then [u]only [/u]for [b]extremely [/b]grave sins (murder, for example). It defies commonsense to think that for the first several centuries, Christians only needed to go to Confession once after Baptism if mortal sin is a commonplace "slip-up". It also defies commonsense that masturbation, cursing, or (especially) drunkenness in particular would have been any less prevelant then than they are now. Morality does not change; this an essential part of the conservatism of our Church. These things have always been grave matters. Yet the Early Church regarded MORTAL sin as something much more severe than the grave matters themselves - severe enough that the common Christian would only need Penance once in a lifetime! I personally take advantage of Confession on an extremely regular basis and believe all of us should...but I hope I'm right about mortal sin...and I wish the Magisterium would more explicitly define the topic. Thoughts / oppinions? Edited February 24, 2006 by Ziggamafu
N/A Gone Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 Sir... good post, I have been studying confession in abudance as of late and I have a few thoughts. first, on simple soteriology. Was it not St. Augustine who said we are weighted by what we loved? Love of God or love of self. Perhaps simple as that and let God be the judge? St. Augustine was also the one who said Man is bound by the sacraments but God is not. It is also much easier to picture the earlier time period as less abundant to sin. St. Thomas sited work as a method of avoiding sin because we are busy and focused. In modern world we have plenty of free time. Plenty of access to a buffet of sinful temptations. Give me 2 seconds and images.google and I can develop an addiction for who knows what. (*ive counciled people who have this) Violence is stimulated and encourgaged in many formats as well as any other sin we could crave. Sin is addicting and depreciating just a taste can hook us. So it is possible that sin is more abundant in an every depraving world. Now, my final question. This might get moved to a different thread if you wish. Suicide. Teaching has always been they go to hell. But part of me truly thinks this is wrong. I realise that they will spend much time in purgatory, but who of us wont? Most suicides are crimes of passion, situations where the worldview is so deprived that they simply want the pain to end. Would not this child be in need of our lord? How could a suicide be considered of right mind to make the conscience choice towards or away from faith? Ive heard of countless suicide notes that prayer was involved, prayer for the pain to end.
Ziggamafu Posted February 24, 2006 Author Posted February 24, 2006 [quote]1862 One commits venial sin when…he disobeys the moral law [b]in a grave matter[/b], but without [b]full [/b]knowledge or without [b]complete [/b]consent…Deliberate and unrepented venial sin disposes us little by little to commit mortal sin.[/quote] I have to start with the premise that grave sins can be venial as this quote clearly explains. [quote]1857 For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must together be met: "Mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with [b]full [/b]knowledge and [b]deliberate [/b]consent."[/quote] ...here I emphasize the words "full" and "deliberate". I don't think it's as simple as being "aware" that some book says a sin is grave and then "doing it anyway". The words "full" and "deliberate" suggest something deeper than a surface knowledge of a sin and a reluctant consent. [quote]2352 To form an equitable judgment about the subjects' moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, [b]conditions of anxiety[/b], or other psychological or [b]social factors [/b]that can lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. 2355…the immutability of the offense can be attenuated by destitution, blackmail, or [b]social pressure[/b] [/quote] Although everything in these quotes contributes to my position, I'll focus on the mention of "social factors". Today we are bombarded by sex and violence everywhere we go. The society conditions / brainwashes us to accept flipant sex, wrath, resentment, and revenge. This does not remove the seriousness of such sins, but rather illustrates that a person committing them under such circumstances would be very different from a person committing them in a nineteenth century Amish environment. [quote]1860 Unintentional ignorance can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense. But no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man. [b]The promptings of feelings and passions can also diminish the voluntary and free character of the offense, as can external pressures or pathological disorders.[/b] Sin committed through malice, by deliberate choice of evil, is the gravest.[/quote] This might be the strongest backing for my hopes that mortal sin isn't as common as you might think. If passions make a grave sin venial then this directly corresponds with my position that a mortal sin must be a cold and premeditated rejection of moral or spiritual truth.
thessalonian Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 What this discussion boils down to for me is that we leave it up to God to judge sins. Even our own. It may be that many of the times we think we have committed a mortal sin it is a serious venial sin. The Church however says we are to confess all GRAVE sins. So the focus with regard to confession should be on whether they are grave or not and we should assume mortal even though it may not be from a will standpoint. As far as confession in the early Church I'll try to find my book by Scott Hahn, Lord have mercy. It gets in to this and there is some indication that there was other confession. It was the capital sins that could only be confessed once in a lifetime as I recall. The danger I find it professing this "everybody goes to purgatory" theology is that it sets the goal as purgatory and not heaven for the end of this life. Hopefully people won't fall short of the runway. Further it undermines confession. I've seen it in my parish. The priest teaches this thinking and nobody goes to confession. Then people have a tendancy to not overcome sin which will eventually weaken them. Further there is the danger of sacralidgous communion which is ALWAYS a mortal sin. Further I have a problem with your theories in that in 1 Cor 11 Paul speaks in a much more general way about the dangers of sacraligeous commuion. I can't see that passage as Paul thinking that only a few of them were committing this sin. That passage is for us today to be dilligent against sin. As for suicide most certainly God will judge those who kill themselves. Some are mentally ill I am sure. Some however have committed a series of sins which led them to that point and have not turned toward God or taken advantage of the great graces available in the Catholic Church to keep them from getting to this point. We are responsible for what does not form our conscience and will rightly as well so if our will is compromised out of neglect of the graces we have been given we may end up like the servant in luke 12 "to whom much has been GIVEN much is expected" . He was treated as the UNBELIEVER. Not good. Mortal sin can be the culmination of a process of grave venial sins is my point. Bottom line I don't recommend you perpetuate this theology if you hold it. I won't say it is heretical but it has some serious issues with it. We should let God be the judge and just confess what is grave (or venial if you like). Hope that helps. Blessings
N/A Gone Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 24 2006, 08:59 AM']As far as confession in the early Church I'll try to find my book by Scott Hahn, Lord have mercy. It gets in to this and there is some indication that there was other confession. It was the capital sins that could only be confessed once in a lifetime as I recall. [right][snapback]896505[/snapback][/right] [/quote] im reading it now.. purgatory is to finish the process, but the key is to be on the process first. Like augustine says..where is your love? purgatory doesnt save us, it finishes the process
thessalonian Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' date='Feb 24 2006, 11:13 AM']im reading it now.. purgatory is to finish the process, but the key is to be on the process first. Like augustine says..where is your love? purgatory doesnt save us, it finishes the process [right][snapback]896652[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Purgatory is for if the process isn't finished. Here we can participate in our sanctification and root the sins out. There we can do nothing for our selves. We need to strive to finish the process in the here and now. By the way the Church was not and is not wrong about suicide being damning. For those who are culpable of their action it is. They have never said that anyone who committed suicide went to hell. They have never had a list of those in hell. Suicide is a grave matter however because it is a final act of disobeince to God before death.
Myles Domini Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Feb 24 2006, 02:49 AM']So some of you might remember my particularily lenient take on discernment of mortal sin. For those of you who don't, I basically hope more people end up in Purgatory than Hell and I support this hope in my understanding of what mortal sin is... Whereas some Catholics stress the third condition for mortal sin (presence of grave matter) I stress the first two (free will and full knowledge). I find support for the notion that "full knowledge" also implies full understanding (of consequences and reasoning behind the command) and that "free will" also implies deliberation (unhindered consent). This basically reduces mortal sin to a focused and intentional violation of one's own conscience and / or an explicit rejection of Love, Truth, and / or Heaven. I hope this is true. It would mean far more souls are in Purgatory and far fewer souls are in Hell. Recently, I've read in several places that in the Early Church, Confession only took place [b]once [/b]in one's lifetime and then [u]only [/u]for [b]extremely [/b]grave sins (murder, for example). It defies commonsense to think that for the first several centuries, Christians only needed to go to Confession once after Baptism if mortal sin is a commonplace "slip-up". It also defies commonsense that masturbation, cursing, or (especially) drunkenness in particular would have been any less prevelant then than they are now. Morality does not change; this an essential part of the conservatism of our Church. These things have always been grave matters. Yet the Early Church regarded MORTAL sin as something much more severe than the grave matters themselves - severe enough that the common Christian would only need Penance once in a lifetime! I personally take advantage of Confession on an extremely regular basis and believe all of us should...but I hope I'm right about mortal sin...and I wish the Magisterium would more explicitly define the topic. Thoughts / oppinions? [right][snapback]896174[/snapback][/right] [/quote] To aptly answer this post one has to first understand the developments in the Church's understanding of the sacrament of Penance. What exactly constituted grave matter and how grave those sins were was a matter of fierce controversy in early Church. The once in a lifetime confession that you speak of was wholly public and involved not only penance but a period of exclusion from the sacraments. It was known as [i]exomologesis[/i] and according to Hippolytus' prayer of episcopal consecration it seems to have been reserved to the Bishops--though there is evidence that they could delegate to priests. From Origen's homilies on Numbers 10 however we have evidence that sinners were encouraged to open their hearts to a priest but what this amounted to at this early stage is unclear from the source texts though its subsequent development seems clear. Exomologesis on the other hand was a solemn affair which not only was once in a lifetime but which was not to be given more than once. If you fell back into grave sin after recieving the exomologesis for the most part you were considered reprobate. Indeed, some sins e.g. apostasy were considered unforgivable even by exomologesis! This comes across strongly in Hippolytus' protests against Pope Callistus and Tertullian's rigorism which emerged as he fell into the montanist heresy. Origen also speaks of Bishops being able to forgive only sins that are forgiveable. As highlighted it was Pope Callistus who began to tone down the rigorism of the Church and try and hammer out a more comprehensive understanding of penance. He it was, for example, who first took an understanding attitude towards sins of the flesh being redeemable and this idea began to take hold and his successors would continue this development much to the ire of St Cyprian. Though as the teaching of the [i]Didascalia Apostolorum[/i] proves in its exhortation to Bishops to reconcile all repentant sinners the Church at large came to be the accepted norm. The 4th and 5th century abound with great doctors of the Church who wrote fiercely against Novatianism and the idea of its adherents that mortal sins was absolutely unforgiveable. Yet those who did so e.g. the Cappadocians, Ambrose and Augustine still envisioned the public penance of the exomologesis for mortal sins. Nonetheless, there was not as yet a consensus on what sins were considered mortal enough to warrant exomologesis although the traditional ones e.g. abortion, murder, adultery seem to appear on the various lists given by St Basil the Great, St Augustine and even as lenient a writer as St Gregory of Nyssa. It seems to me that as time went by and the understanding of what constituted mortal and venial sins became clearer following the great period of consoldation of doctrine in the post-Nicene era the understanding of the private confession with the priest mentioned by Origen came to be understood as the normal means of remitting mortal sin rather than the exomologesis. By the third council of Toledo 589AD this is a given canon 2 of the council which simply presumes the practice illustrates.
Myles Domini Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Feb 24 2006, 01:41 PM']I have to start with the premise that grave sins can be venial as this quote clearly explains. ...here I emphasize the words "full" and "deliberate". I don't think it's as simple as being "aware" that some book says a sin is grave and then "doing it anyway". The words "full" and "deliberate" suggest something deeper than a surface knowledge of a sin and a reluctant consent. Although everything in these quotes contributes to my position, I'll focus on the mention of "social factors". Today we are bombarded by sex and violence everywhere we go. The society conditions / brainwashes us to accept flipant sex, wrath, resentment, and revenge. This does not remove the seriousness of such sins, but rather illustrates that a person committing them under such circumstances would be very different from a person committing them in a nineteenth century Amish environment. This might be the strongest backing for my hopes that mortal sin isn't as common as you might think. If passions make a grave sin venial then this directly corresponds with my position that a mortal sin must be a cold and premeditated rejection of moral or spiritual truth. [right][snapback]896494[/snapback][/right] [/quote] In spite of the fact, as my last post illustrates, that I believe your reference to exomologesis does not adequately account for the developing understanding of mortal and venial sin in the ante-Niene era I do believe there is some wisdom in this post. It is true as the Catechism states that some instances of grave violation of the moral law can be considered venial sin. Moreover it is true that outside factors, ignorance and the like can reduce culpability. As you've illustrated this is merely the catechetical teaching of the Church but do not forget one thing: [quote]and unrepented venial sin disposes us little by little to commit mortal sin.[/quote] I think it was St John Chrysostom who said nobody blames a man who goes out to battle and is injured its the one's who desert and cower on the sidelines that are detested. If one is aware that one has an aquired habit which contravenes the moral law and simply says 'ah well' then that in itself is a mortal sin. After all mortal sin is merely another way of saying with Satan 'I will not serve'. To know that you are habitually sinning against the moral law and to make little to no effort to amend that fact is a mortal sin in itself. If you went out to battle clothed in the armour of God and were hacked to pieces on the first step you would not be culpable. But a) knowing what you're doing is wrong and b) consenting to it by refusing to fight your concupisent drives is a matter of mortal sin. You're right society does bombard us and its even better at showing of the immorality of the world than the Corinthians were. But just because we are placed in a position, for instance, where temptation is tossed at us it does not give us the right to cease fire or to conform to the world. There must be some element of resistence, even if your ability to resist is severely impaired because of your habitual laxity. If you make no effort at all then there can be no doubt that the sin is mortal. Everyone know's for instance that there is a great difference between being unwittingly subjected to temptation and just nonchalantly walking into occassions of sin. Everyone is aware of the difference between holding out against temptation until you can struggle no more and it overwhelms you and simply giving in at the first inclination to evil. Even if it means you're so addicted to a certain sin that you can only hold out for 10 seconds before going back to it, if you know you can hold out for that 10 seconds and you give up after 2 then you are condemning yourself.
N/A Gone Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Feb 24 2006, 12:22 PM']By the way the Church was not and is not wrong about suicide being damning. For those who are culpable of their action it is. They have never said that anyone who committed suicide went to hell. They have never had a list of those in hell. Suicide is a grave matter however because it is a final act of disobeince to God before death. [right][snapback]896661[/snapback][/right] [/quote] something boths me about this statement still. Perhaps it is the psychology involved in suicide. Often moral responsability is not something the person has. Maybe this is what you mean by culpable? Ive heard of a suicide person being denied a catholic funeral I just dont see how jesus would have acted in this way towards a suicide it kind of boils down to that
Myles Domini Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' date='Feb 24 2006, 08:03 PM']something boths me about this statement still. Perhaps it is the psychology involved in suicide. Often moral responsability is not something the person has. Maybe this is what you mean by culpable? Ive heard of a suicide person being denied a catholic funeral I just dont see how jesus would have acted in this way towards a suicide it kind of boils down to that [right][snapback]896816[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Providing the person has full knowledge and full consent of the wrongs of their action they have sinned against the moral law. Ritual suicide in the past has indeed been a way of taking a swipe at the Church. However, as the quotes provided by Ziggy on this thread show one's culpability can be lessened by one's psychological state of mind. It is probable that the vast majority of people who kill themselves these days are not gnostics or nihilists but just deeply troubled...
Ziggamafu Posted February 24, 2006 Author Posted February 24, 2006 [quote name='Myles' date='Feb 24 2006, 01:38 PM']In spite of the fact, as my last post illustrates, that I believe your reference to exomologesis does not adequately account for the developing understanding of mortal and venial sin in the ante-Niene era I do believe there is some wisdom in this post. It is true as the Catechism states that some instances of grave violation of the moral law can be considered venial sin. Moreover it is true that outside factors, ignorance and the like can reduce culpability. As you've illustrated this is merely the catechetical teaching of the Church but do not forget one thing: I think it was St John Chrysostom who said nobody blames a man who goes out to battle and is injured its the one's who desert and cower on the sidelines that are detested. If one is aware that one has an aquired habit which contravenes the moral law and simply says 'ah well' then that in itself is a mortal sin. After all mortal sin is merely another way of saying with Satan 'I will not serve'. To know that you are habitually sinning against the moral law and to make little to no effort to amend that fact is a mortal sin in itself. If you went out to battle clothed in the armour of God and were hacked to pieces on the first step you would not be culpable. But a) knowing what you're doing is wrong and b) consenting to it by refusing to fight your concupisent drives is a matter of mortal sin. You're right society does bombard us and its even better at showing of the immorality of the world than the Corinthians were. But just because we are placed in a position, for instance, where temptation is tossed at us it does not give us the right to cease fire or to conform to the world. There must be some element of resistence, even if your ability to resist is severely impaired because of your habitual laxity. If you make no effort at all then there can be no doubt that the sin is mortal. Everyone know's for instance that there is a great difference between being unwittingly subjected to temptation and just nonchalantly walking into occassions of sin. Everyone is aware of the difference between holding out against temptation until you can struggle no more and it overwhelms you and simply giving in at the first inclination to evil. Even if it means you're so addicted to a certain sin that you can only hold out for 10 seconds before going back to it, if you know you can hold out for that 10 seconds and you give up after 2 then you are condemning yourself. [right][snapback]896766[/snapback][/right] [/quote] How does any of that disagree with what I posted? That's my point - it is the effort that is important. If you try as hard as you can and if you're miserable in the sin, then you obviously couldn't have had "full consent".
Myles Domini Posted February 24, 2006 Posted February 24, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Feb 24 2006, 08:49 PM']How does any of that disagree with what I posted? That's my point - it is the effort that is important. If you try as hard as you can and if you're miserable in the sin, then you obviously couldn't have had "full consent". [right][snapback]896886[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I figured as much but I felt like underscoring the point for posterity's sake. There are lurkers around you know PS) Misery in the sin doesn't neccessarily equate to atrition. Edited February 24, 2006 by Myles
Ziggamafu Posted February 25, 2006 Author Posted February 25, 2006 I really wish this would be officially clarified...scrupulous folk such as myself would be helped out quite a bit. I've literally had priests express annoyance and frustration that I bother them so often for Confession.
Myles Domini Posted February 25, 2006 Posted February 25, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Feb 24 2006, 11:56 PM']I really wish this would be officially clarified...scrupulous folk such as myself would be helped out quite a bit. I've literally had priests express annoyance and frustration that I bother them so often for Confession. [right][snapback]897043[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Atrition is a decision it can be accompanied by emotions or none whatsoever. You simply start trying to be better, thats atrition. Feelings can come from numerous places including from pride about having fallen which is not even atrition but condemnation. Best way to measure your atrition is by how you react to sin? 1) Do you want to be better 2) Do you want to be better because God has been disrespected by your sin 3) Do you acknowledge that without grace you could do no good and are you certain that only through praying for grace you will avoid sin in the future? If you answer all three in the affirmative no need to stress you're on the right road
Norseman82 Posted February 25, 2006 Posted February 25, 2006 From what I was taught, the three sins considered "mortal" in the early Church were murder, apostasy, and adultery (this may take in other sexual sins as well). Yes, you were limited to one penance after baptism. You had to do public penance and even after you were readmitted you might still be under sanctions (including sexual abstinance for the rest of one's life, even if one were married!!!). This is why I tell my Protestant friends that I'll take 5 Our Fathers from the man behind the screen any day!!!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now