Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is It Ok To Feel This Way?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Yes, but the song implies that Mary was just a sinner like the rest of us, which is false.  Yes, it was by the merits (albeit anticipated) of Jesus' death that she was immaculately conceived, but that's just the point -- she was delivered from the moment of her conception, not at a later time!  Unlike everyone else, she didn't have to wait.

Hi, Dave.. My priest was talking about this in his homily a couple of weeks ago. Mary was saved by Jesus, and was made new by Jesus, because if Jesus had never been born, there would have been no reason for her to be born without original sin. So yes, she was saved and made new by Jesus.

God bless! :)

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Did you know that your baby boy

has come to make you new;

this child that you delivered

will soon deliver you.

In a way though, could one possibly apply it to the assumption? Or am I out in left field? Probably. :D

Posted

In a way though, could one possibly apply it to the assumption? Or am I out in left field? Probably. :D

That's a cool thought.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Yes, but the song implies that Mary was just a sinner like the rest of us, which is false.  Yes, it was by the merits (albeit anticipated) of Jesus' death that she was immaculately conceived, but that's just the point -- she was delivered from the moment of her conception, not at a later time!  Unlike everyone else, she didn't have to wait.

Maybe it implies that to you but not to me.

I think its an excellent song and we sing it every Lent.

Posted

hmm, my guidance counselor used to sing this during communion at some of the masses. I've never looked at the lyrics until now, and certainly never thought the song to be ...for lack of a better word, heretical. If anything i thought it was a beautiful devotion to the blessed mother

hyperdulia again
Posted

ah...maria...

Posted

Mary, Did you know that your child would make you new?

Mary, did you know that your one day He would deliver you?

Not exact because my memory stinks and I do not know how to post other's quotes in my own to make my point.

This song was (beautiful as it is...) composed by a Protestant. (I'm willing to bet)

The above lyrics seem to imply that Mary had yet to be delivered from sin and thus negates her Imaculate Conception.

Does anyone else see this?

That's why I think this song was banned. - God bless! - Muschi

Posted

Mary, Did you know that your child would make you new?

Mary, did you know that your one day He would deliver you?

Not exact because my memory stinks and I do not know how to post other's quotes in my own to make my point.

This song was (beautiful as it is...) composed by a Protestant. (I'm willing to bet)

The above lyrics seem to imply that Mary had yet to be delivered from sin and thus negates her Imaculate Conception.

Does anyone else see this?

That's why I think this song was banned. - God bless! - Muschi

I agree with you!

Posted

It's about time somebody noticed and agreed with me!

Posted

I usually read the first, and the last post, and then compromise what everyone is talking about!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Marry needed a Savior just like the rest of us.

Posted

Marry needed a Savior just like the rest of us.

NO ONE has denied that, Cmom. But the song IS denying her Immaculate Conception, even if only implicitly.

Posted

ah...maria...

since i've been here i've noticed how close you are to mary hyper. That's really beautiful and inspires me to try and have that relationship with her as well. but i'm curious, why does she have such a special meaning to you (if you don't mind sharing)?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...