Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Some phatmassers know that my recent inquiry and interview with the dioceses about college seminary, know that they diocese feels it is in my best interest not to attend College Seminary.

They feel that I have many issues in my life to sort through. Being an only child, never dating, and things of the sort. Since I have never dated they feel that I have not even looked at a possibility of marriage, and thus I need to "date" as they say here in America.

Quite ironically, the day before I got the letter (which I received on Saturday) I went downhill skiing and thought a lot about stuff. And recalled this one girl I use to talk with a lot from a retreat that I attended int he summer of 2004. Contact grew slim and far between and then ended ebfore the end of 2004 because that is when my computer died, got kicked out of the library and had to move to Europe for a few months. In all that excitment all communication haulted.

When I was on the ski lift Friday I recalled this girl, and I though I should get in contact with her. I got home, checked my old email account and found her email, I sent her an email and such. Yesterday, (still before I got the letter) anticiapting a response (which I haven't received yet) I looked at the email address and recalled it was her parents. I looked at the email address and figured out that the three letters int he beginning and three letters at the end, (six letters) were the parents name. I looked up on 411.com her parent's first and last name, called the first one, disconnected, called the second, and gosh golly her father answered the phone, she wasn't home but said she wouldn't be until 5:30.

Now I'm faced with a few situations:

I could not call her.

I could call her and ask her to do something like go to a Hockey game at the local Sports Center on Saturday

I could call her and chit chat (which I'd do above as well) mention that I am going to green bay three times this week, talk about her school. My school is playing a Catholic School in GB on Tuesday which I anticipate attending so I could see if this girl would like to go (as friends of course and a time to get reacquainted,)

Or do you have another suggestion?

I think I misunderstand what american dating is all about. Anyways what are your thoughts.

Posted

I think you should date, but let your little friends know what your considering.

Posted

ok...


is this girl local? if not then forget it.

To date someone, all you have to do is find a girl you're interested in and see if she'd like to hang out. Movies, coffee, whatever. It's not a big deal. Rather, it's as big a deal as you make it.

Posted

umm... she lives 30 miles away.... and i go to green bay 3-4 times a week. When I say Date I mean I'd like to get to her more. I actually met this girl 1 1/2 years a ago. and we have lost touch.

Posted

She maybe spoken for.

Posted

Don't be discouraged by this, Eddie. If you have a vocation to the Priesthood, it will all come to fruition in the appointed time. Just continue to discern the will of God, and try to grow as a person.

Posted

Well, I called her up. I talked to her, and well we're not going to do anything this week, because she's going on vacation, but she is a freshman and homeschooled, (dont' know the age) and she goes to a homeschool catholic youth group, so she told me I should go sometime and we can meet up there.

If anything would evolve after getting re-acquainted it would of course would be very very slow, the way it should be. I'm not a big fan of American Dating.

Just an update!

Yours in Christ,

Eddy Lee

Posted

I think it is beyond absurd that they would reject you because you haven't 'dated'. I'm sorry.

God the Father
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Feb 26 2006, 04:45 PM']I think it is beyond absurd that they would reject you because you haven't 'dated'. I'm sorry.
[right][snapback]898314[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I was going to say something like this, but didn't really have the words. Beyond absurd, that's what I was looking for. Good thinking.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Feb 26 2006, 02:45 PM']I think it is beyond absurd that they would reject you because you haven't 'dated'. I'm sorry.
[right][snapback]898314[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
This is silly. You've never considered marriage because you've never dated? I guess the thought has never crossed my 22 year old mind then. 'Course there are people my age who are getting engaged and even married. Well, maybe they have some good reasoning and maybe if you become a priest you can use the experience to relate to others or something.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Feb 26 2006, 09:45 PM']I think it is beyond absurd that they would reject you because you haven't 'dated'. I'm sorry.
[right][snapback]898314[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

:applause:

I was listening to Fr Benedict Groeschel critique the infiltration of the Church by modern psychological ideas earlier and I think this latest example provided by Eddie illustrates his case in point. I wonder if when St Padre Pio became a Capuchin novice at 16 his directors said "dont you think you should date?" <_<

If you know that your vocation to the priesthood is real then no amount of dating is going to change that fact. Indeed, dating in spite of this knowledge would be very wrong. What's say you start getting involved with someone who really develops deep affections for you, then what? Is it fair on her that you're effectively using her as a tool to test your vocation? Does the counsel given you reflect the dignity of the human person preached by John Paul II in his theology of the body? Oh sorry honey didn't mean to make you fall in love with me and break your heart but I always figured I was gonna be a priest and I was just taking you for a test drive to make sure! :thumbsdown:

Eddie don't listen to this nonsense. Perhaps you do have issues to sort out in your personal life but getting involved with someone is not the best way to do that. Indeed, that will simply thrust open you other often confusing thoughts and feelings which will make it harder to sift through the [i]baggage[/i] you're already carrying. Rather than getting romantic with someone as an experiment I'd recommend you take the path that St Thomas More did when he was deciding on whether or not he had a vocation to the clerical state:

[quote]Meanwhile he applied his whole mind to exercises of piety, looking to and pondering on the priesthood in vigils, fasts and prayers and similar austerities. In which matter he proved himself far more prudent than most candidates who thrust themselves rashly into that arduous profession without any previous trial of their powers. The one thing that prevented him from giving himself to that kind of life was that he could not shake off the desire of the married state. He chose, therefore, to be a chaste husband rather than an impure priest.--Erasmus, Epistle 447 [/quote]

Get in touch with an orthodox priest who can counsel you impartially and properly. Moreover, if you find through your prayer that you God is indeed calling you to become a priest and the diocese still wont accept you get in touch with the people at [url="http://www.casabalthasar.org/"]Casa Balthasar[/url]. [url="http://www.adoremus.org/999-casab.html"]A house of discernment[/url] founded in 1989 by Father Jacques Servais, SJ, then Father (now Cardinal) Christoph Schönborn, OP, Fr. Mark Ouillett, SS, and Father Joseph Fessio, SJ, with its Cardinal Protector as then Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger.

Edited by Myles
Posted

Eddie, many prayers of comfort and wisdom. I pray that your eyes and heart might be open to God's will for your life.



To all others,

I agree that if Eddie's diocese did not accept him merely on the grounds that he's not dated, then this would be absurd. However, I doubt that his dating life was the only factor in their decision. Eddie himself wrote in his first post that there were other issues he was encouraged to work out.
[quote name='Myles' date='Feb 26 2006, 05:24 PM']Perhaps you do have issues to sort out in your personal life but getting involved with someone is not the best way to do that. Indeed, that will simply thrust open you other often confusing thoughts and feelings which will make it harder to sift through the [i]baggage[/i] you're already carrying.
[right][snapback]898342[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Eddie, you are 15 years old. This is a public forum on the internet. [i]You are by no means obligated to pour out your personal life to us![/i] By recognizing that you need to understand yourself more and grow in that knowledge and discovery, you are following God's path for your life. Do not begin dating with the mindset of "oh well, might as well try this next." Do what you know in your heart God is calling you to do. Discuss these feelings and thoughts with your spiritual director!

And all the while, you remain held in our prayers...

Posted

I was always lead to believe that one shouldnt date unless one is considering marriage?
Since Eddie has discerned to become a priest then why in the world would he date? This is absolutely ridiculous.

Eddie, dont do it. Those guys are way off.

Posted

Ok so who all here wants to become a nun?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Besides... isn't Eddie a bit young? I don't mean that in a bad way... only that dating is for those who are seeking marriage. You don't date just to date. That's ridiculous.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Feb 26 2006, 04:45 PM']I think it is beyond absurd that they would reject you because you haven't 'dated'. I'm sorry.
[right][snapback]898314[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I agree.

Posted

We gotta find Eddie a girl.

Posted

I agree that it would be rather superfluous to reject a young man from a college seminary program on the basis of his having no past dating experience. However, we must trust that this is all in the Lord's will. Eddy, pour over this with your Spiritual Director and take it to a lot of prayer. Be obedient to what your SD tells you, and know that if the Lord wills you to be a priest, you will be one. His ways are above ours, and He alone knows what graces He has planned to pour on you during your time of discernment and waiting.

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 26 2006, 06:06 PM']Ok so who all here wants to become a nun?
[right][snapback]898377[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Definitely not me!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...