Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

My wife has decided she is not ready to join the church at this time. This comes after months of attending RCIA. While she agrees that none of the Church's beliefs are impossible, she lacks the trust in how the church came to such conclusions (ie Marian doctrines). Coming from the Assembly of God tradition, she is now faced with a difficult decision in trust in seeing who God is and what God has given us to believe. Before under sola scriptura, she believed that the individual, turning to the bible with a clean spirit, could find all the truths revealed by God through the guidance of the holy spirit. In becoming Catholic, she would no longer be trusting herself for the interpretation of scripture, but the Church.

How can she gain such trust?

Noel's angel
Posted

I find knowing that the Church is that instituted by Christ Himself allows me to trust that it's teachings are correct. Prayer will help immensly-its power should never be underestimated.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Mar 1 2006, 10:34 AM']My wife has decided she is not ready to join the church at this time.  This comes after months of attending RCIA.  While she agrees that none of the Church's beliefs are impossible, she lacks the trust in how the church came to such conclusions (ie Marian doctrines).  Coming from the Assembly of God tradition, she is now faced with a difficult decision in trust in seeing who God is and what God has given us to believe.  Before under sola scriptura, she believed that the individual, turning to the bible with a clean spirit, could find all the truths revealed by God through the guidance of the holy spirit.  In becoming Catholic, she would no longer be trusting herself for the interpretation of scripture, but the Church. 

How can she gain such trust?
[right][snapback]900734[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

The witness of 32,000 Protestant denominations is enough to convict Sola Scriptura of lacking any ability to lead people "into all truth" John 16.

I suggest the book "By What Authority" as a good read. She is in a good place though. Ultimately it always comes down to authority.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Mar 1 2006, 10:34 AM']My wife has decided she is not ready to join the church at this time.  This comes after months of attending RCIA.  While she agrees that none of the Church's beliefs are impossible, she lacks the trust in how the church came to such conclusions (ie Marian doctrines).  Coming from the Assembly of God tradition, she is now faced with a difficult decision in trust in seeing who God is and what God has given us to believe.  Before under sola scriptura, she believed that the individual, turning to the bible with a clean spirit, could find all the truths revealed by God through the guidance of the holy spirit.  In becoming Catholic, she would no longer be trusting herself for the interpretation of scripture, but the Church. 

How can she gain such trust?
[right][snapback]900734[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Is she sticking with personal choice theory then?

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 1 2006, 12:12 PM']Is she sticking with personal choice theory then?
[right][snapback]900845[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

She is not sticking to the personal choice theory. She is some way sticking to the fruits of the labors theory, where the church that can show the most fruits (converts, baptism in the spirit, triumphant believers) is the church God has most ordained. While she does not attest to the fruits theory, it is there subcousiously.

She got saved at a bible study with no prior faith. She began weeping uncontrolably. From there, she joined the church associated with the small group bible study. She followed the pastor's words as gospel truth.

'How can the church be as powerful and as ordained by God if so many of its children go astray?' she recently asked. She cites our RCIA leaders lack of faith in ways she feels important. Our RCIA leaders, good solid catholics, sometimes do not express their faith in a way which she can see and internalize/relate. They also are not versed how to bring people to the catholic faith from Protestantism. For example, they were astonished that my wife felt God had forgiven her for her past mortal sins, simply by praying for forgiveness (act of contrition) without a confession to a priest. My wife views their astonishment as a lack of full faith, which would be more emotional.

She also refers to how many times she saw teens break down and cry before God at one of their pentacostal services. That dramatic of a public change of heart is a rarity in RC. (I understand such change of heart truly occurs over a lifetime, not on just one occasion, for such immediate baptism of the spirit is fleeting.)

Brother Adam
Posted

How does emotional feeling have anything at all to do with faith? That is antithetical to solid biblical teaching. Faith is a decision to follow God, not getting all riled up and charasmatic. And what is her proof that most Catholics 'go astray'. I find that to be a myth. We have 1 billion members and have survived for 2000 years. I believe that those who focus on emotions are the most likely to fall away, because emotions pass away with time.

I'm not sure how we can help besides to pray, but if there is anything we can do, holla!

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Mar 1 2006, 02:44 PM']She is not sticking to the personal choice theory.  She is some way sticking to the fruits of the labors theory, where the church that can show the most fruits (converts, baptism in the spirit, triumphant believers) is the church God has most ordained.  While she does not attest to the fruits theory, it is there subcousiously.

She got saved at a bible study with no prior faith.  She began weeping uncontrolably.  From there, she joined the church associated with the small group bible study.  She followed the pastor's words as gospel truth. 

'How can the church be as powerful and as ordained by God if so many of its children go astray?' she recently asked.  She cites our RCIA leaders lack of faith in ways she feels important.  Our RCIA leaders, good solid catholics, sometimes do not express their faith in a way  which she can see and internalize/relate.  They also are not versed how to bring people to the catholic faith from Protestantism.  For example, they were astonished that my wife felt God had forgiven her for her past mortal sins, simply by praying for forgiveness (act of contrition) without a confession to a priest.  My wife views their astonishment as a lack of full faith, which would be more emotional.

She also refers to how many times she saw teens break down and cry before God at one of their pentacostal services. That dramatic of a public change of heart is a rarity in RC.  (I understand such change of heart truly occurs over a lifetime, not on just one occasion, for such immediate baptism of the spirit is fleeting.)
[right][snapback]900909[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Lack of emotion does not mean lack of faith. God does grant us joys along the way as encouragement, just the same as in a love relationship with another person. But "falling in love" with God is not the same as loving God, just as "falling in love" is not the same love that gets you thru 20 years of marriage. Faith in some ways is a choice, not just a feeling.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 2 2006, 07:40 AM']Lack of emotion does not mean lack of faith.  God does grant us joys along the way as encouragement, just the same as in a love relationship with another person. But "falling in love"  with God is not the same as loving God, just as "falling in love" is not the same love that gets you thru 20 years of marriage. Faith in some ways is a choice, not just a feeling.
[right][snapback]901398[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


My wife would agree, but it does not make it [lack of visible faith is USA catholics] easier.

The original question was for tips on how she can increase trust in the church decisions.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Mar 10 2006, 01:11 PM']My wife would agree, but it does not make it [lack of visible faith is USA catholics] easier.

The original question was for tips on how she can increase trust in the church decisions.
[right][snapback]908201[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Have we helped on taht question, or do you need more?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 10 2006, 02:43 PM']Have we helped on taht question, or do you need more?
[right][snapback]908354[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I suppose some personal testimonies or additional logic may help. I am also trying to hook her up with some of the 'Catholic Answers Live' folks (ie Tim Staples).

Posted

Welcome,

I would first tell you, and your wife that she is by no means alone. The authority issue is a big one, and is hard to overcome for many reasons. One of those is simply that our spirit seems to delight in rebellion.

I would recommend asking several of the saints for intercession. St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Thomas More, and the blessed Mother all come to mind as having good experience in this matter.

Secondly, I would recommend "Swimming with Scapulars" as a book. The author, Matthew Liccona, shares the struggles of a cradle Catholic who wants to live a live according to the Church. His honesty, and his determination are a great testimony. Many of his questions have direct bearing on this issue.

peace...

Dust's Sister
Posted

if she is interested in reading, I recommend Rome Sweet Home by Scott Hahn.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Mar 1 2006, 03:44 PM']She also refers to how many times she saw teens break down and cry before God at one of their pentacostal services. That dramatic of a public change of heart is a rarity in RC.  (I understand such change of heart truly occurs over a lifetime, not on just one occasion, for such immediate baptism of the spirit is fleeting.)
[right][snapback]900909[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Really? I have... just take her to a charismatic retreat :woot:

What you don't see is how people live their lives after their emotional "salvation" experience. Maybe they were genuine... maybe they were just caught up in the moment.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 2 2006, 07:40 AM']Lack of emotion does not mean lack of faith.  God does grant us joys along the way as encouragement, just the same as in a love relationship with another person. But "falling in love"  with God is not the same as loving God, just as "falling in love" is not the same love that gets you thru 20 years of marriage. Faith in some ways is a choice, not just a feeling.
[right][snapback]901398[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
cmom taught me this, it has totally helped my faith life.

Posted

Topic close out.


Wife will be joining the church after Easter (already baptized protestant). Having finally felt peace about the decision after a few realizations:

-She kept waiting for the strong, undeniable emotional confirmation of peace, which she agreed might never happen.

-Learned it is ok to love the church and profess the faith despite the lack of faith and dedication by some catholics: christ's truth is truth despite his followers. It is ok to become catholic while disagreeing with the lack of spiritual experience or spiritual enlightenment by some in places of authority (Catechism/RCIA graduates and instructors, priest....).

-Supported NFP, rejected contraception, rejected the solas, embraced transubstantiation, laughs at Luther (HT to Crocker's "Triumph...") and conceeded her conversion is just a matter of time anyway.

Posted

wonderful news!

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 24 2006, 02:34 PM']wonderful news!
[right][snapback]920667[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

She was really blown away today by the RCIA retreat. She learned:

-Obedience to the Church results in spiritual blessings. She did not see the point in being confirmed if she has already been baptized and has faith. She feared she would only be going through the motions. After a discussion with our pastor, she finally conceeeded. The next portion of the retreat was a period of silence. God gave her a new peace and she has an 'oh now I get it!"

-Hand of God in her life. She sees working on her life behind the scenes to bring her to this point. I look forward to getting home and discussing how God works on us for our entire lives.

-Release from fear in apologetics. Initially she hesitated in joining the church due to lack of confidence in herself to defend her decision and the church doctines to her protestant friends and family (she expects a bit of flack for her 'coming home'). She feared being shredded by someone skilled in protestant apologetics. During the retreat, she felt God tell her (paraphrase), "I will give you what you need, when you need it. You will find strength and truth in simply giving account of what you have learned and experienced." This reminds me of two bible stories. 1st, Moses telling God how he does not have the skills to speak well, then God rolling his eyes and providing. 2nd, it reminds me of the man cured of blindness by Jesus who testified before the teachers of the law and could not defend who Jesus was, but could only confess what had happened to him.

She and I are very excited.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

TACO PARTY!!! :)
Invite your wife to phatmass convert board and
welcome home :grouphug:

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' date='Mar 25 2006, 05:32 PM']-Obedience to the Church results in spiritual blessings.  She did not see the point in being confirmed if she has already been baptized and has faith.  She feared she would only be going through the motions.  After a discussion with our pastor, she finally conceeeded.  The next portion of the retreat was a period of silence.  God gave her a new peace and she has an 'oh now I get it!"

-Hand of God in her life.  She sees working on her life behind the scenes to bring her to this point.  I look forward to getting home and discussing how God works on us for our entire lives.

-Release from fear in apologetics.  Initially she hesitated in joining the church due to lack of confidence in herself to defend her decision and the church doctines to her protestant friends and family (she expects a bit of flack for her 'coming home').  She feared being shredded by someone skilled in protestant apologetics.  During the retreat, she felt God tell her (paraphrase), "I will give you what you need, when you need it.  You will find strength and truth in simply giving account of what you have learned and experienced."  This reminds me of two bible stories.  1st, Moses telling God how he does not have the skills to speak well, then God rolling his eyes and providing.  2nd, it reminds me of the man cured of blindness by Jesus who testified before the teachers of the law and could not defend who Jesus was, but could only confess what had happened to him.

She and I are very excited.[right][snapback]922215[/snapback][/right][/quote]
God bless you and your wife! :D:

  • 4 weeks later...
MichaelFilo
Posted

Give her some good ol' Bible for her Bible loving needs, right?

But, before you can do that, you gotta know what you are talking about, and I am certainly not the one to help you attain that knowledge. Regardless, I do have these nifty verses (which if you haven't read already, I am surprised, but meditation on these will bring greater clarity to false beliefs).

"He who hears you hears me, and he who rejects you rejects me" (Luke 10:16)
Jesus gave teaching authority to the Apostles, but that authority is really nothing more than the Spirit working through them, however, it is only to the Apostles, not for everyone.

"[W]hat you have heard from me before many witnesses entrust to faithful men who will be able to teach others also" (2 Tim. 2:2)
A direct proclamation that the Apostles intended to keep certain teachers who would teach all men, but he didn't designate all those who heard him teach as also being valid teachers (the witnesses that is).

"what was not made known to human beings in other generations as it has now been revealed to his holy apostles and prophets by the Spirit" (Eph 3:5)
Knowledge about Christ is entrusted to the heirarchy, and it remains their job to be the source of it; as even if men should forget something, the Spirit will work through the top levels of the Church to remind them.

"members of the household of God bult upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets" (Eph 2:19,20)
"you should know to behave in the hosuehold of God, which is the church of the Living God, the pillar and foundation of truth" (1 Tim 3:15)
The Church is the pillar of Truth, who'se foundation is the apostles and Prophets. The Truth is therefore from Jesus (the Capstone) and then to the Apostles and prophets, whose job it is to proclaim the good news as they have received it, which is protected from error (in infalliable and more minute ways) throughout the Church.

Ponder those, you and her, or just her, or you can pretend to ponder with her but instead ponder other things, or you can close your eyes and fake pondering altogether. Regardless, these verses tend to lean towards a more reasonable understanding of where Truth comes from, and who gives it to us ultimaty (and then realitisticly).

God bless,
Mikey

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...