Sojourner Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 A friend just sent me this question: Are you supposed to keep your ashes on your forehead? I learned that you shouldn't wipe them off until after sundown, but someone just said you should wipe them off b/c you're not supposed to make a "big deal" out of it. I couldn't find anything in a quick search, so thought someone here would know.
homeschoolmom Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 I think Pontifex said it was okay to wash them off... I least I thought I read that in Q/A...
homeschoolmom Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 It was cappie (which is what I thought at first...) [quote]No it's not wrong to wash off the ashes, and yes one may receive the ashes even if you can't go to Holy Communion just in the same way as you can bless yourself with holy water. Ashes are sacramentals..Sacramentals are part and parcel of our faith. However, they are only aids in the expression of our beliefs. There is nothing magical about them, nor can any sacramental come close to the importance and significance of the seven sacraments as signs of God’s grace. [/quote]
Sojourner Posted March 1, 2006 Author Posted March 1, 2006 Cool! I didn't see that. Thanks for the info.
homeschoolmom Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 But that still doesn't answer the question if one should wash them off-- only that one may do so... I'm assuming that because one may do it if one so chooses, one needn't do it if one chooses not to.
Sojourner Posted March 1, 2006 Author Posted March 1, 2006 [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Mar 1 2006, 01:39 PM']But that still doesn't answer the question if one should wash them off-- only that one may do so... [right][snapback]900825[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I don't get mine until evening, so it's not that big a deal. BUT I wait until evening mass so that I don't have to walk around with ashes on my forehead all day. I don't mind people knowing that I'm Catholic, but advertising it with a sign on my forehead is a little discomfiting.
franciscanheart Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 This is a highly debated subject among many Catholics. This is close to an answer... "If we take the ashes as simply a habit or something we use to show off and draw attention then they are not truly serving their purpose. If, however, they are used to remind us of our humble beginnings and of our sinful nature then they have served their purpose. If they are used as a catalyst into the sacrifices and personal intraspection of this Lenten season then they have served their purpose and have not been in vain." Some answers from other Catholics... [quote]In my RCIA class our priest also pointed out the sin of pride in leaving on the ashes. I vacillate from year to year based on your two very valid arguments ...[/quote] [quote]Rub them off whenever you feel like it. The point is that you went to mass and remembered where you came from and where you are going. Religion and faith is of course not something that goes out the window because you rubbed off the ashes. Furthermore, don't feel guilty about wiping ashes off your forehead - they are just ashes. Don't worry about it.[/quote] [quote]Definitely leave them on. All of the signs, symbols, things, and "stuff" of the Holy Faith are extremely important (if they weren't, then advertisers wouldn't spend so much money trying to plant their logos everywhere, and anti-Catholics wouldn't be so busy trying to remove creches from the public square). This "stuff" also gives a sense of Catholicism's profound understanding of the meaning of the Incarnation and the ability of God to sanctify matter. The Second Person of the Trinity became man, and mere things point to truths beyond themselves. It is beautiful. The ashes are a sign to us -- to everyone who sees them -- to stop and ponder the inevitable; such a sign is so much more needed now than at any time in History. We've gone from living with death as those did during the Bubonic Plague and the like, to euphemizing it away, to frantically trying to defeat it even as we are flippant about it. Death needs to be looked at -- and hard. As to what others think, it doesn't matter except that the presence of ashes affords one an opportunity to explain what they mean; they can actually be a tool for evangelization. As to pride, chances are that unless you live in medieval Europe, the ashes will bring more embarrassment than pride, and this is a chance to share in Christ's humiliation. But if you live in a place where a weird look and whispering behind the back wouldn't be the typical response, if you keep your focus on the meaning of the ashes, there is no way pride can do much damage. Every time you think of them, every time you look in the mirror, remember that those ashes are you. Without Christ, that is all you will become and all you will remain forever.[/quote] [quote]The pro-ashes comments have said about it all that needs to be said, but I would like to add some additional thoughts. First of all, you know your heart better than anyone else, save God. If those crushed ashes serve to remind you of your state hours after receiving them, then they're doing their job. Most importantly, think of it this way: Since when does the Catholic faith hide from outward symbols and signs? Are not the sacraments themselves visible signs of grace? Do we not make the reception of most sacraments very public affairs? Baptism, Marriage, Holy Orders, and First Communion are all public and the former three are required to be public. Just don't worry about it either way...the point is to remember from whence you came and to where you will return.[/quote] [quote]I am torn. When I was still in school, I went to morning Mass on Ash Wednesday, and left the ashes on. Now that I work in an office, I can't get to Mass until the evening, so by then the question is moot. However, if I went to morning Mass, I might rub them off simply because they wouldn't look professional.[/quote] [quote]I hope to be able to attend Mass in the morning and wear the ashes at work. I am the type that tends to avoid attracting attention to myself and I used to wipe them off out of embarasment. But in our pagan world, I think a witness needs to be born. Some had no idea and pointed out I had something on my head. But over the years, most people here know I am Catholic (6 kids is very convicting.) And bearing witness publicly helps to strengthen/remind the other Catholics. I now am trying to raise the awareness of other Catholic traditions too. I asked one manager (who usually heads up treats or chili feeds) if he was doing anything for Fat Tuesday. We had a good long chat and I found out his wife and children are Catholic. So for me, pride has nothing to do with it. Bearing witness does and the rewards are often untold.[/quote] [quote]I am on the pro-ashes side, though I admit that I never really gave much thought to it. When I was working (I interepreted for Deaf students at a college in my former life), I would go to Mass in the morning with my daughters, drop them off with Grandma, and head to work. Most of the time, I didn't remember that they were even there! That is, until someone would tell me I had a smudge of dirt on my forehead...at which time I'd simply say, "No, it's Ash Wednesday." That was the extent of it. I do like the comments that people have made about it being yet another visible sign. This year, though, I will not go until 7:30 p.m. Mass, because that is when my husband will be going. This year, he's in RCIA, and it's the first year he, too, will wear ashes. So we'll all go together. [/quote] [quote]I have usually gone to Church in the evening for the Ashes so it's been a moot point. However I commend the courage of those who wear their ashes, I am not sure I'd have the courage to go to my classes with ashes on my forehead which would surely incur snide looks from secularist professors and students.[/quote] [quote]Someone said earlier the ashes are "just ashes". No they're not. They are "blessed" ashes. That means they have been set apart so as to give glory to God. One does not just destroy (which is what wiping them off) blessed objects. That would be a minor sacrilege. Let's be honest here, which do you think is the more accurate view of the world towards folks who will be wearing ashes tomorrow: "Wow, that person must be really holy." OR "What a moron!" For the record, I think Julie D's priest has done a horrid misservice with his statement. The Church performs this ritual to remind her children to do penance AND to be a visible example to the outside world. The Church, to my recollection, never says, "Now, you go out there and feel real elite for wearing ashes." I think the Church says something along the lines of, "Rember thou art dust and unto dust thou shalt return." If a person can't retain that bit of instruction while wearing those ashes, that's on him, not the Church. If a person is so moved to pride by wearing ashes, that person should just forsake the ritual. After all, it is not binding under pain of sin to wear ashes on Ash Wednesday. Oh, and the times I've used "you" in this comment are not directed to any person here, or to the blog owner. I'm using the generic you, if that makes sense.[/quote] [quote]I am still in the RCIA process,so forgive my presumption, but my reaction to the ashes debate is this: do whatever makes you the most UNcomfortable. If you are in community/workplace with a high proprotion of Catholics and other Christians, wearing the ashes could be a prideful statement of how "holy" you are - wipe them off. If you are in a highly secular or antireligious environment (where, for example, the ashes might be seen as "unprofessional" and get you in trouble or people might regard you as some kind of fanatic) - definately wear them. The path is narrow, etc. etc. (Sometimes I think this aspect of Christianity is like George Costanza's successful strategy of taking his first instinct and "doing the opposite"...) I myself live in Cambridge, Mass., and my roomates don't even know I'm in RCIA. Needless to say, I plan to leave them on...[/quote] all comments from "[url="http://uccatholic.blogspot.com/2006/02/ashes-on-or-off.html"]ashes on or off[/url]" by [url="http://uccatholic.blogspot.com/"]Upper Canada Catholic[/url]
scardella Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Mar 1 2006, 11:41 AM']I don't mind people knowing that I'm Catholic, but advertising it with a sign on my forehead is a little discomfiting. [/quote] I prefer to advertise it by wearing a t-shirt that says "I'm Catholic."
franciscanheart Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 I have to say that I was extremely comforted by the message which our priest brought to us today in his homily. He spoke about how it may seem contradictory to our reading for today that we wear the outward symbol of ashes but that if they serve their unique and helpful purpose then they do not contradict what the Gospel gives to us but rather acts as a catalyst for humility and acknowledgement of who and what we are during this Lenten season. If they cause us to step back and evaluate ourselves then they are not in vain and thus not against the Gospel (in which case there is no need to remove them). If however they are used as a way of boasting or somehow taking on a holier than thou attitude and causing intentional scandal then they are indeed contradictory to the Gospel for today and become a source of sin for us.
magnificat Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 Even if I wanted to rub it off before school, I don't think I could! My priest had a bit too much fun with putting it on and it's on there pretty well!
toledo_jesus Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Mar 1 2006, 01:41 PM']I don't get mine until evening, so it's not that big a deal. BUT I wait until evening mass so that I don't have to walk around with ashes on my forehead all day. I don't mind people knowing that I'm Catholic, but advertising it with a sign on my forehead is a little discomfiting. [right][snapback]900827[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I like it. you can always tell who is Catholic...so sometimes you'll see a stranger and you'll both just smile and say hello where you wouldn't before. also, sometimes you get asked questions about the Faith. That's always cool.
N/A Gone Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 I have a friend that doesnt want to get addicted to phatmass again so he wanted me to ask a question of the faithful.. 1.) Are we repreved from out lentian sacrifice on sundays. 2.) What are the fasting policys. Im slightly jewish with this and typically only have water until nightfall and than I eat. 3.)Im not sleeping tonight, so when am I done with the fast?
Brother Adam Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 I'm not gettin ashed today, but here is a joke I overheard at RCIA How to catch a bear if you are from Wisconsin If you want to catch a bear and you are from wisconsin go out into the middle of the woods, clear off a space and dig a hole, 5 feet across on each side and 8 feet deep. Fill it with 1 foot of ashes, and open a can of peas. Place peas around the edge of the hole and go into the bushes and wait. It is important not to make any noise and not to eat anything. Eventually a bear will come by. When the bear goes to take a pea, run up behind him and kick him in the ash hole.
Brother Adam Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' date='Mar 1 2006, 02:31 PM']ur dirty....go to confession [right][snapback]900899[/snapback][/right] [/quote] no one asked you.
littlebreakdowns Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 [quote]1.) Are we repreved from out lentian sacrifice on sundays.[/quote] Yes. [quote]2.) What are the fasting policys. Im slightly jewish with this and typically only have water until nightfall and than I eat. [/quote] Today and Good Friday, we abstain from meat and eat two small meals and one larger meal. No snacking. Fridays during Lent we just abstain from meat. That being said, depending on your parish, you may be cool to eat meat on St. Patrick's Day because his feast day falls on a Friday this year. [quote]3.)Im not sleeping tonight, so when am I done with the fast?[/quote] I'd think midnight, but that's just my own personal thoughts. Teresa
cmotherofpirl Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 I leave mine on. Irs nice to walk down the street and see so many Catholics. And if someone doesn't know why you have a dirty face, its an oppportunity to tell them.
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted March 1, 2006 Posted March 1, 2006 Besides, an ashen cross is more attractive than an ashen smear all over your forehead...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now