Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I need a little help...


Recommended Posts

sweetpea316
Posted

Ok so... I've been debating/discussing some things with my mother since I've decided to convert. She's a strong sola-scriptura believer, so maybe that will help the angle of your responses...

Anyways, she asked me to not go into detail about different Catholic teachings and beliefs that people usually misunderstand cause she doesn't want to learn about it. All she wanted to know was for me to tell her simply why I would rather be Catholic than Lutheran. I mentioned that the Church was founded by Jesus Christ, has the fullness of the truth, and then of course the body and blood of Christ in the sacrament of communion. (she had no problem with this last one)

But, this is how she responded about the rest.

"Where in the bible does it say that Jesus Christ started the Catholic Church? I'd like to know where to find that to start with. What 'fullness of truth' do the Catholics have that the Lutheran's don't? We believe in the bible. How much more truthful then that can you get?"

Ack. Please help! :pinch:

Thanks in advance, and God bless!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 2 2006, 11:05 PM']"Where in the bible does it say that Jesus Christ started the Catholic Church?[/quote]While it never mentions the words "Catholic Church" Christ did indeed found the Church which has been preserved through apostolic succession. Christ's first followers (the apostles and disciples) were the beginnings of the Church. I forget the Greek word used (because I took Latin instead), but it refers to a church. It would be interesting to point out that the Church was not called Catholic until divisions occured (the Great Schism, the Reformation, etc...) and there was a need. Before then it was understood that the Church was we know today as the Catholic Church. That is it in a nutshell without getting too deep into things. Just remember apostolic succesion and that the apostles were the beginnings of the Church.

[quote]What 'fullness of truth' do the Catholics have that the Lutheran's don't?[/quote]I would recommend reading [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20000806_dominus-iesus_en.html"]Dominus Jesus[/url] to start with on this topic.

Edited by Paphnutius
Myles Domini
Posted (edited)

Where in the Bible does it say 'Sola Scriptura'? :huh: Without the Church, that is the pilar and foundation of truth (cf 1 Tim 3:15), how would you even know which books should be in the Bible? Its no surprise that St Ireneaus uses the testimony of the Apostolic See to confound the gnostics. After all if the false gospel of Nicodemus says one thing and the canonical gospel of John says another how do you know which to believe if the oldest witness, that is the Church, isnt there to tell you?

Have a read of [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/most/getwork.cfm?worknum=113"]Luther Writes Obituary of His Own Church [/url] by Fr William Most.

Edited by Myles
thessalonian
Posted (edited)

Yes, first off ask her where SS is in the Bible? If it's not in the Bible it's a tradition that violates it's rule. A circular arguement. So where does it say that Catholicism is the Church Christ started? Well I think you have to start with Matt 16:18. Peter thou art rock and on this rock I will build my Church and the gates of hell shall not prevail. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.

This verse clearly is presenting an authority on Peter that none of the other Apostles have. None are given the keys. There are many other evidences of Peter's high standing. For instance he is named far more than any other of the twelve. 190 times to about 30 for John the beloved. He is the one who answers when the group is asked a question. (see matt 16:15-19, John 6:68-72, Acts 2:36-29 and a few others). He is always named first when the Apostles are named, even though Andrew was the first chosen, he alone is said to strengthen the others after the crusifixion. I think this is in Luke 21. There are other things that single Peter out as prime among the Apostles as well.

Now she may say, so why do you think the Pope today has that authority. Well then you hit her with Is 22-24. This is the prophecy of the transition of power of the steward from Shebna who was corrupt to Eliakim. It literally occured and can be seen in I think it is 2 Kings 18. Now the Steward was the spokesman for the king. If you note in in 2 Kings 18 Eliakim goes out and speaks for the king to the Assyrian commander. What is interesting about Is 22 is that this passage directly parrellels Matt 16:18. There are the keys which are passed from Shebna to Eliakim. There is the Opening and shutting which is analogous in rabinical language to binding and looseing. No Jew would have missed Jesus drawing on that passage. The point is that Shebna was a Steward in a long line of Stewards of the Davidic Kingdom. This indicates that the office that Jesus is bestowing on Peter is one of succession as well. Also the keys are to be passed on. If I buy a house I recieve keys which give me access and authority and control over that house. I can delegate the keys to wife and kids. When I sell the house I pass them on to the next owner. Quite simple. Now we have clear evidence from the writings in the early Church that the chair of Peter was passed on. You can go to any secular Encylcopedia, look up Pope and see 2000 years of Popes.

Final note: She says we have the Bible, what more do we need. Well there are 30,000 denominations out there and growing. Seems like we need a bit more than the Bible to keep us together. 2 Thes 2:15 is key. Point this verse out to her carefully. "Hold fast to the TRADITIONS you have recieved, whether by WORD OF MOUTH or in letter from us. Here Paul quite clearly states that the truth has been given both orally and in writing. Point out to her that before Sola Scriptura there were only Catholic and Orthodox (who split off around the turn of the first millenium 1054, reunited and then split again in the 14th century) and some come and go small sects. Within a few years afterward, Christianity started dividing like a cancerous sore. It's the most devisive doctrine known to man because it rejects proper authority and makes the individual arbitar of truth.

That's what I would hit her with for starters.

Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
sweetpea316
Posted

Thanks for the help yall. This will definitely be a good start. :)

franciscanheart
Posted

I am not so good at finding quick resources for these things but you can be assured of my prayers for the Holy Spirit to guide your every word with her. :)

Church Punk
Posted

Sweetpea...

I would suggest you pick up a copy of Rome Sweet Home. You should read it first then give it to your Mother to read. Essentially it is the story of how the Hahn's descovered that the Catholic Church is the one true Church, with out any Catholic influence! That is for the most part by the teachings of the Bible alone!

You can find a link to order it online in the referance sections here:

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/store/books.php"]http://www.phatmass.com/store/books.php[/url]

Its very easy to read, it only took me a couple days to go through the whole book. I think it will help answer/ bring up a lot of questions you and your mother may have.

sweetpea316
Posted

I've read that book like 5 times already, haha.

And yeah, I've definitely thought about asking my parents to read it also. Hmm, I might just have to do that. Especially since I went through the last time I read it and underlined parts that definitely pertained to issues we're having.

Thanks for the suggestion. :)

Posted

Show her how Jesus allowed certian gifts to the apostles he did not share with others.

Also use my Mormon Argument:


The 'Mormon Argument'


To a Protestant, separated breathern:

The LDS (Mormon) church believes the true message of the Gospel of Jesus was lost after the death of the 12 Apostles. What remained was farce: a twisted message. They profess that truth vanished from the face of the earth due to human pride and paganism until God brought the message back down to earth through Joseph Smith. The LDS teaching concludes no one actually received the correct teaching of Jesus to the second generation of believers (Apostles being the first generation). Apparently the gospel failed to change the hearts of the 'Christians' immediately following the crucifiction of Jesus and was not handed down in the correct form and interpretation. The Apostles apparently failed to teach Jesus effectively, taught the wrong people or the gospel was not strong enough to keep any of them from 'back sliding' into grave error. Do you believe this?

Our Protestant/separated breatheren would then respond, "Of course not, Jesus said, 'I will be with you always.' The Apostles were not failures. The true Gospel spread to every nation."

The faithull Catholic would answer:

Then why do you not heed the words and beliefs of that second and subsequent generations, which are the Early Church Fathers? They were undeniably Catholic! Nearly all the doctrines held by the Catholic Chruch today were formulated before the end of the fourth century, which is before the bible was formally canonized. This includes the authority of a set church led by a pope.

See [url="http://web.archive.org/web/20030604071746/http://ic.net/~erasmus/RAZ429.HTM"]http://web.archive.org/web/20030604071746/...smus/RAZ429.HTM[/url]

or

[url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=20510"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=20510[/url]


{The rest of you comment on my 'Mormon Argument}

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 3 2006, 12:05 AM']Ok so... I've been debating/discussing some things with my mother since I've decided to convert. She's a strong sola-scriptura believer, so maybe that will help the angle of your responses...

Anyways, she asked me to not go into detail about different Catholic teachings and beliefs that people usually misunderstand cause she doesn't want to learn about it. All she wanted to know was for me to tell her simply why I would rather be Catholic than Lutheran. I mentioned that the Church was founded by Jesus Christ, has the fullness of the truth, and then of course the body and blood of Christ in the sacrament of communion. (she had no problem with this last one)

But, this is how she responded about the rest.

"Where in the bible does it say that Jesus Christ started the Catholic Church? I'd like to know where to find that to start with. What 'fullness of truth' do the Catholics have that the Lutheran's don't? We believe in the bible. How much more truthful then that can you get?"

Ack. Please help!  :pinch:

Thanks in advance, and God bless!
[right][snapback]902103[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
The Church was in existance before the New Testament was put together because the Church picked out what writings she would hold authentic in council.
So the Church predates the bible as we know it today. When Jesus said upon this rock, He founded the church.

Posted

[quote name='sweetpea316' date='Mar 2 2006, 11:05 PM']

But, this is how she responded about the rest.

"Where in the bible does it say that Jesus Christ started the Catholic Church? I'd like to know where to find that to start with. What 'fullness of truth' do the Catholics have that the Lutheran's don't? We believe in the bible. How much more truthful then that can you get?"

Ack. Please help!  :pinch:

Thanks in advance, and God bless!
[right][snapback]902103[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

John 20 and 21 both reference things that Jesus did and said that weren't included within the book. I think I remember another book (maybe Luke or Acts) that makes the same point. So one possible answer is that the Sacred Tradition of the Church includes material not in the Bible, but still significant and relevant for the believer.

You might also visit the reference section for more structured and coherent arguments that sola scriptura is not all there is.
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/646"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/646[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...