Monoxide Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 A man has killed hundreds before, lacking remorse. He has promised to kill hundreds more in the future, and anything short of a God granted miricle will not change this man's mind. The man even takes money to kill these people. Let's say I have a gun. If I see him in the act of murdering another, knowing that he will do it again in the future, can I be justified in giving him a ticket to discuss his life with the Master? (shoot him in the head) Also, the people are all innocent of any real crime that could justify their death. Please, this is a dilemma in my mind. -Monoxide
Paphnutius Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 (edited) Well first the phrasing of the question is wrong for the following reasons: 1)Murder is defined and the wilfull taking of an innocent life. In the situation you described [quote]If I see him in the act of murdering another[/quote] he is not innocent. You have caught him in the act of committing a crime so it cannot be termed murder for he is not innocent. 2) Murder is always wrong by its very nature. If the killing of an innocent is the direct end of an act (such as murder) the act can never be justified for one may not do evil so that good may come from it. Now what one is to do in this situation is to exhaust all real possibilities of stoping him from murdering the other person. One may use physical threats and violence if they seem plausable that it will keep from killing the other. One may only use lethal force if the aggressor is using lethal force as well. So if it is certain that the person is going to kill an innocent, and you have exhausted all other real possibilites, yes lethal force would be justified. In this case, however, it is not murder for you are defending the life of an innocent from an unjust aggressor. Edit: In this specific scenario it is inconsequential as to what his future actions might be for you have caught him in the act of homocide. You must be morally certain, though, that he is an unust aggressor before you use lethal force. Edited March 6, 2006 by Paphnutius
Monoxide Posted March 6, 2006 Author Posted March 6, 2006 Sorry if I was not as clear as I intended. This man HAS killed before. He is in the scope of my RIFLE, where I gaze upon him preparing to kill another being. If I were to interrupt him I would probably not be killed, but he would find another day to kill, possibly another place and another time where I might not catch him in the act. Do I need to wait until he is in the act? If it is absolutely certain that he will do it again. For thought, if one innocent man (possibly myself) dies as well as the evil creature, can it still be justified? It will prevent more murder in the future and the one currently being preformed.
Paphnutius Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Monoxide' date='Mar 5 2006, 09:55 PM']Do I need to wait until he is in the act? If it is absolutely certain that he will do it again.[/quote]You must be certain that it is a murder that is taking place or is about to take place and have exhausted all other real and possible attempts and preventing the murder. [quote]For thought, if one innocent man (possibly myself) dies as well as the evil creature, can it still be justified? [/quote]If the death of the innocent is not the end of the act but merely a consequence and it was not the means to the end then yes that would be justified as long as the killer poses a real threat to others. edit: Did you understand my point that if he is an unust aggressor then killing him would not be murder? Edited March 6, 2006 by Paphnutius
Monoxide Posted March 6, 2006 Author Posted March 6, 2006 My mistake, I misnamed my poll, yet I find that murder seems a far more powerful word. Thank you for the time. I have another point to elaborate on, possibly in a couple hours when I develop it further in my mind.
prose Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 Sounds like you are talking about a doctor in an abortion clinic. Is this what you are insinuating?
Monoxide Posted March 6, 2006 Author Posted March 6, 2006 (edited) You ruined my punchline, but yes. Why can't someone with a gun or explosives destroy these disgusting people? Edited March 6, 2006 by Monoxide
Paphnutius Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 [quote name='Monoxide' date='Mar 5 2006, 10:19 PM']Why can't someone with a gun or explosives destroy these disgusting people? [right][snapback]903903[/snapback][/right] [/quote]Emphasis on the: exhausted all real possible alternatives.
Dreamweaver Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 Well, if we're talking about abortion, no matter how disgusting their job is, God still has a plan for them. Ever heard of Dr. Bernard Nathanson? He was a founder of NARAL, performed thousands of abortions. He later converted, and is a big player in the pro-life scene.
Old_Joe Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 The man can still choose not to kill. Though given his history, it would seem very unlikely.
Monoxide Posted March 6, 2006 Author Posted March 6, 2006 The horrible sinner who believes himself to be damned could wish to at least sacrifice his very soul for the lives of thousands of unborns? The man who assasinates select doctors condemns himself, but prevents their practice in the future! WE ARE A CULTURE OF DEATH AND FEAR It has effected in the past, when the psycotic man preforms these evil acts of destroying the lives of the abortionists, other evil men fear for their own bodies, and in their selfish ways, stop the evil practice. Blegh, I hate the idea of killing anyone, even a Stalin or a Mao. I could never do it and I feel dirty about discussing it. But that being said it must be discussed.
dimco926 Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 Two things come to mind. First, who are we to judge anyone? Second, the commandments are there for a reason.
MagiDragon Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 [quote name='dimco926' date='Mar 6 2006, 06:32 AM']Two things come to mind. First, who are we to judge anyone? Second, the commandments are there for a reason. [right][snapback]903981[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Ahh, but the commandments *don't* say "Thou shalt not kill." Rather, they say "Thou shalt not murder." The distinction is whether the one being killed is innocent or not. This is exactly the point that is being discussed: Is the killing of an abortionist murder or simple killing?
dimco926 Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 [quote name='MagiDragon' date='Mar 6 2006, 08:37 AM']Ahh, but the commandments *don't* say "Thou shalt not kill." Rather, they say "Thou shalt not murder." The distinction is whether the one being killed is innocent or not. This is exactly the point that is being discussed: Is the killing of an abortionist murder or simple killing? [right][snapback]903982[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I guess I am confused then. According to my Catholic Bible, it states "You shall not kill" and I was always taught that killing for any reason is not justified in the eyes of God. This does make for an interesting discussion, but I do not believe that killing an abortionist will end abortion; another abortionist will just take his/her place. Just as it is discussed with people contemplating abortion that killing is not an answer, killing will not solve the problems and that killing is wrong and sinful, and then we say it is okay in this instance (killing the abortionist), then wouldn't we be hypocrites?
MagiDragon Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 [quote name='dimco926' date='Mar 6 2006, 06:52 AM']I guess I am confused then. According to my Catholic Bible, it states "You shall not kill" and I was always taught that killing for any reason is not justified in the eyes of God. This does make for an interesting discussion, but I do not believe that killing an abortionist will end abortion; another abortionist will just take his/her place. Just as it is discussed with people contemplating abortion that killing is not an answer, killing will not solve the problems and that killing is wrong and sinful, and then we say it is okay in this instance (killing the abortionist), then wouldn't we be hypocrites? [right][snapback]903990[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Actually, you've again hit on one of the main points of debate: if this makes us hypocrites, then it is wrong. (Which I think it is.) But in response to whether it would stop abortions: it very well might. Already there is a shortage of abortionists, and the shortage is making it difficult to keep abortion mills open. The trouble that I see with this way of thinking, is that the murder of abortionists does a horrific amount of harm to the pro-life movement. I doubt that i'm the only one that has to face pro-aborts and defend the pro-life movement against those that would kill the abortionists.
MagiDragon Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 oh, and the translation of "murder" to "kill" is close enough that it's rare to have a case where the distinction matters. The main cases where it comes up are talking about self-defense, abortionists, and wars.
Anastasia13 Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 [quote name='Monoxide' date='Mar 5 2006, 09:19 PM']Why can't someone with a gun or explosives destroy these disgusting people? [right][snapback]903903[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Wow, I'm just in awe of your compassion for those who don't know God as they should.
Paphnutius Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 (edited) 1) These doctors are still human and people, they deserve at least that. It is not right to call them "creatures" in a demeaning sort of manner. Remember that you yourself are a creature as well 2)[quote]The horrible sinner who believes himself to be damned [/quote]What do you mean by that? One is never to sacrifice the state of one's own soul for even the salvific benefit of another. That is, one is never to beaver dam oneself so that another may be saved. 3) As I have said before, one must exhaust all other real possible alternatives before resorting to lethal force. This leaves little room for lethal force to be justified. Edited March 6, 2006 by Paphnutius
heavenseeker Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 Mabye becaus e he should be stoped but then violence is not the ancer to violence.
Monoxide Posted March 6, 2006 Author Posted March 6, 2006 logic, discussion, debates, protests, etc.etc.etc. have all consistantly failed when brought into play. In fact the only way that we have a victory is when we railroad a healthy politition into the state who in turn outlaws it without seeking popular approval (it works) aka South Dakota. I think that alone is enough to justify the end of the monsters. Have you ever spoken to an abortionist? Invite one for dinner and discuss his practice with him, murder is as desensatized as removing a zit. ALTERNATIVE Could I rightfully arrange myself and my group of confidents to kidnap and hold indefinately the doctors? There is in existance a compound in the middle of nowhere that would be quite acceptable to hold them. It is stocked with a library and enough arable land to sustain itself as well as a creek.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now