Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Hi pham, I don't usually ask for spiritual help from you all, but I've been having a hard time lately. A friend was asking me about it and I found myself describing it pretty accurately...maybe someone has advice:

I used to feel so genuine and lately I've felt like such a phony. It seems no matter what I do, I feel like it's not real. I go to Adoration, Mass, pray the rosary, etc., and I feel like God isn't listening and sometimes as if He's not there (I don't consent to these feelings...they're just a nagging thought). I feel like instead of trying to please God, I'm trying to make myself pleasing to Him (and thus, its self-centered instead of God-centered). I feel like I'm trying to put too many expectations on myself and trying to conform myself into a mold I'm not meant to be. I don't feel attracted to some of my devotions, but I feel like if I give those devotions up, I'll be sinning, because I've been doing them for so long. I feel like I'm lukewarm...like I want to throw myself to God and be on fire, but I feel like I don't trust Him enough, like He won't come through for me. I ask Him for blessings, but I fail to see the blessings He's given me already. I ask Him to help my future, but fail to act in the present. I'm a largely-depressed, unfulfilled, spiritual wreck, or so I feel. I have felt this way for a long time and it's growing on me...it's not humble, it's self-hating, and therefore, in a sense, arrogant...and yet, I do not know how to be humble enough, poor enough in spirit, etc., and I do not know how to pray. I come to God for help and there's nothing there...or rarely.

I want to love God...I want to know Him...but I feel so lost and dry and forsaken sometimes (although not always).

My only solace is to cling stubbornly to what I know--He is who is and He is love, even though I cannot feel it and am tempted to constant doubt.

One thing I know, I look at Jennie and see her love for me and I see Him there, working...she has been a sign to me of His love and she always helps me keep sight of Him, although it's not always He whom I think about.

Brother Adam
Posted

Its odd that you are not the first person to describe this. I wonder if it isn't the Lenten season. I've been feeling the same way as well, so that is three. Perhaps we are to spend out time in the wilderness.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

i feel similar. I felt really genuine right at the beginning of lent, not i do not.

GuyWithAFoil
Posted

I dont know what to say other than try and pray about it and see if that helps

It just reminded me though, Mother Teresa felt like what you described for over twenty years! not feeling Gods presence at all. and she obviously turned out all right :)

*Prayers*

Posted

Mary has you in her mantle, whether or not you feel it. :)

Keep fighting!

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 7 2006, 10:29 PM']Its odd that you are not the first person to describe this. I wonder if it isn't the Lenten season. I've been feeling the same way as well, so that is three. Perhaps we are to spend out time in the wilderness.
[right][snapback]906064[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
It's not Lent, at least not for me...I've had this for maybe a year or more, but it's grown more and more over time and fluctuated back and forth a bit.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='GuyWithAFoil' date='Mar 7 2006, 10:37 PM']I dont know what to say other than try and pray about it and see if that helps

It just reminded me though, Mother Teresa felt like what you described for over twenty years! not feeling Gods presence at all. and she obviously turned out all right  :)

*Prayers*
[right][snapback]906079[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I feel God's presence at times...it's just...hard...I can't really describe it. It's kind of like there's a shadowy veil over the problem keeping even me from really knowing what I feel like.

...and I don't have Bl. Mother Teresa's holiness or boldness or humility or patience or...

Posted

When I express stuff like that to myself I have to add a clause at the beginning that this is just the way I feel and not what I believe. Otherwise I continually have to interupt myself.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Maria' date='Mar 7 2006, 10:46 PM']When I express stuff like that to myself I have to add a clause at the beginning that this is just the way I feel and not what I believe. Otherwise I continually have to interupt myself.
[right][snapback]906102[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Of course...these are feelings and temptations, not beliefs.

Posted

exactly, but I still feel the need to make it clear (to who, I don't know) that I don't actually believe the statements I make.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Mar 7 2006, 08:19 PM']I want to love God...I want to know Him...but I feel so lost and dry and forsaken sometimes (although not always).

My only solace is to cling stubbornly to what I know--He is who is and He is love, even though I cannot feel it and am tempted to constant doubt.
[right][snapback]906047[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Seems that God is treating you like a grownup. I think you should -- as much as possible -- be happy and take advantage of the opportunity.

It's easy to pray and do good when it feels right, and you get the emotional benefits. But, is it worthwhile? When it feels good, you might just be pleasing yourself.

[i]Now[/i], you have the chance to practice real virtue, and love God with your will. Sounds to me like you're doing everything right.

It's all good. Everything is working fine. You're supposed to have times like this. Make the best of it.

(I know it's still difficult. :console:)

Posted

JMJ
3/7 - Sts. Perpetua and Felicity

One of those who used to be very active on Phatmass said that she has grown less fervent as of late because she felt like she was putting up a facade and was acting proud. I thought that it made sense (if it feels bad, don't do it, right?), but now I realize that she bought in to a lie. The good Lord would never ask us to stop praying or desiring to be close to Him. Anything that suggests such a course of action is from the Evil One. Read St. Ignatius' [i]Rules for the Discernment of Spirits[/i] in his [i]Spiritual Exercises[/i].

Fr. Benedict Groeschel says in [i]Stumbling Blocks and Stepping Stones[/i] that temptations to disbelief are overcome only by acting like a believer. Other saints tell us that seemingly less profitable times in our spiritual lives come about either (a) by our sin or (b) by God's will. If it's (a), we take care of it and move on; if (b), we rejoice and are glad, because that's where real growth takes place. It happens to us all at one time or another...and another...and another...:P:

Know of my prayers, bro. Hang in there.

Posted

Bro,
You're going to feel a lot of different things from time to time. I totally understand what you are going through.

The Way by St. Josemaria Escriva... very wise words... read them, and read them again and again... along with his other books... Furrow is another great one.
[url="http://www.escrivaworks.org/book/the_way/contents"]http://www.escrivaworks.org/book/the_way/contents[/url]

When we get feeling like this, this is where discipline gets us through... Repetition of prayers and devotion helps program us the right way.

Here are some of the quotes that have helped me through times like this...

[b]The Way 90 [/b] You say that you don't know how to pray? Put yourself in the presence of God, and once you have said, 'Lord, I don't know how to pray!' rest assured that you have begun to do so.

[b]The Way 101 [/b] Persevere in prayer. Persevere, even when your efforts seem barren. Prayer is always fruitful.

[b]The Way 994[/b] 'My enthusiasm is gone', you write. You have to work not out of enthusiasm but out of Love: conscious of duty, which means self-denial.

[b]The Way 996 [/b] You have a poor idea of your way, if lack of enthusiasm makes you think you have lost it. Can't you see that it is the moment of trial? That is why you have been deprived of sensible consolations.

[b]The Way 998 [/b] Oh blessed perseverance of the donkey that turns the water-wheel! Always the same pace. Always the same circles. One day after another: everyday the same.

Without that, there would be no ripeness in the fruit, nor blossom in the orchard, nor scent of flowers in the garden.

Carry this thought to your interior life.


[b]Furrow 463 [/b] Your prayer will sometimes be intellectual; less often, it may be full of fervour; and, perhaps often, dry, dry, dry. But what matters is that you, with the help of God, are not disheartened.

Consider the sentry on duty. He does not know if the King or the Head of State is in the palace: he is not told what he might be doing, and generally the public figure does not know who is on guard.

It is not at all like that with our God. He lives where you live, He cares for you and knows your inmost thoughts. Do not abandon the guard-duty of your prayer!


[b]Furrow 464[/b] Look at the set of senseless reasons the enemy gives you for abandoning your prayer. “I have no time” — when you are constantly wasting it. “This is not for me.” “My heart is dry ... ”

Prayer is not a question of what you say or feel, but of love. And you love when you try hard to say something to the Lord, even though you might not actually say anything.

[b]Furrow 468[/b] Do not be discouraged. However unworthy the person is, however imperfect the prayer turns out to be, if it is offered with humility and perseverance, God always hears it.


God Bless,
ironmonk

Posted

Love winter when the plant says nothing

MilesChristi
Posted

[quote]I used to feel so genuine and lately I've felt like such a phony. It seems no matter what I do, I feel like it's not real. I go to Adoration, Mass, pray the rosary, etc., and I feel like God isn't listening and sometimes as if He's not there (I don't consent to these feelings...they're just a nagging thought). I feel like instead of trying to please God, I'm trying to make myself pleasing to Him (and thus, its self-centered instead of God-centered). I feel like I'm trying to put too many expectations on myself and trying to conform myself into a mold I'm not meant to be. I don't feel attracted to some of my devotions, but I feel like if I give those devotions up, I'll be sinning, because I've been doing them for so long. I feel like I'm lukewarm...like I want to throw myself to God and be on fire, but I feel like I don't trust Him enough, like He won't come through for me. I ask Him for blessings, but I fail to see the blessings He's given me already. I ask Him to help my future, but fail to act in the present. I'm a largely-depressed, unfulfilled, spiritual wreck, or so I feel. I have felt this way for a long time and it's growing on me...it's not humble, it's self-hating, and therefore, in a sense, arrogant...and yet, I do not know how to be humble enough, poor enough in spirit, etc., and I do not know how to pray. I come to God for help and there's nothing there...or rarely.

I want to love God...I want to know Him...but I feel so lost and dry and forsaken sometimes (although not always).

My only solace is to cling stubbornly to what I know--He is who is and He is love, even though I cannot feel it and am tempted to constant doubt.

One thing I know, I look at Jennie and see her love for me and I see Him there, working...she has been a sign to me of His love and she always helps me keep sight of Him, although it's not always He whom I think about.[/quote]

Well, if I were in your position, I would go to Adoration and tell all this to Jesus, if you haven't already.

I think love of God consists more in the choices we make than our feelings. We may not have control over our feelings, but we do exercise our will in the decisions we make. So, resolve again and again that you will serve God. "Lord, though I cannot see you or feel you at this time, I will do your Will if you grant me the aid of your grace. Purify my heart, strengthen my resolution, and grasp me by the hand, for I cannot see the way. I surrender myself into your care."

It's been my experience that having a spiritual director can really be helpful. Perhaps you know a holy priest who can give you guidance on a regular basis.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

I'd like to quote a couple books that helped my spiritual journey when I read them last year.

The two books are:
1) [b]The Imitation of Christ [/b][i]by Thomas a Kempis [/i]([url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0375700188/002-9050685-1330433?%5Fencoding=UTF8&v=glance&n=283155"]link[/url])
2) [b]Introduction to the Devout Life [/b][i]by Francis de Sales [/i]([url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0385030096/ref=sr_11_1/002-9050685-1330433?%5Fencoding=UTF8"]link[/url])

Buy them :) . Anyway...

[quote name='Imitation of Christ' date=' Book 2, Chapter 9 (Slightly Abridged)'][b]Lacking All Consolation[/b]
It is not difficult to despise human consolation while you are enjoying divine consolation.  But it is great and wonderful to be able to do without all consolation, both human and divine, and for God's honor gladly endure the heart's interior exile and not seek one's self nor think of one's deserts.

Is there anything exceptional in being happy and feeling devout when God's grace touches you?  Everybody looks forward to such a time.  The man who is carried along by God's grace indeed rides smoothly and it is no wonder that he feels no drag since he is supported by the Almighty and led by the Supreme Guide.
...
When God gives you some spiritual consolation accept it with thanksgiving and realize that it is a gift from God and not due you because of any merit on your part.  So, do not yield to pride, nor be overly joyous, nor foolishly give in to presumption; rather, that gift of consolation should make you more humble, more prudent, and more cautious in your actions, for your hour of joy will pass and temptation will follow in its place.

And when consoloation does leave you do not give up hope immediately, but with patient humility wait for a visit from on high, for God is able to give you a still greater consolation in its place.  To those who have experienced the ways of God this manner of acting is neither new nor strange, for the greater saints and ancient prophets have often experienced such exchanges. ([color=blue]note: Mother Teresa was mentioned above as someone who had these trials[/color])

When the Psalmist experienced grace within himself he said: "[i]In my abundance I shall never be moved[/i]," but when that grace was withdrawn he experienced a different feeling and said: "[i]You have turned Your face from me and I was dismayed[/i]."  Still the Psalmist did not dispair but prayed the more earnestly to God saying: "[i]To You, O Lord, I wil cry out and to my God I will make my prayer[/i]."  Finally, when he obtains his request he testifies that his prayer has been answered: "[i]The Lord has Heard me and has had pity on me.  The Lord has become my helper[/i]."  What did the Lord do?  [i]You have changed my mourning into joy and have surrounded me with gladness[/i].

If this is the way God has dealt with great saints, then we poor weaklings ought not to be discouraged if we sometimes find ourselves fervent and at other times frigid.  This is due to the Spirit who comes and goes according to His own good pleasure.  Thus, holy Job says: "[i]You visited him early in the morning and suddenly You tested him[/i]."
...
I have never encountered anyone, no matter how devout and religous, who did not sometimes experience a withdrawal of grace or a decrease in devotion.  No saint has been so enraptured or so illuminated as not to have had temptations sooner or later.  The man who has not been tested by some trial for God's sake is not worthy of the sublime contemplation of God.  Temptation is the usual sign that consolation will follow, and heavenly consolation is promised to those who have been proven by temptation: "[i]To him, who conquers[/i]," our Lord says, "[i]I will grant to eat of the tree of Life[/i]."

Divine consolation is given a man so that he may better be able to endure adversity, and the temptation that follows is to keep him from becoming proud about his good deeds.  Since the devil does not sleep and since your flesh is not yet dead, never stop readying yourself for combat.  Your enemy is on your right and on your left and is ever watching.[/quote]

[quote name='Introduction to the Devout Life' date=' Second Part, Chapter 9'][b]The Dryness Sometimes Experienced in Meditation[/b]

If it should happen that you find no joy or comfort in meditation, Philothea, I urge you not to be disturbed but to open your heart's door to words of vocal prayer.  Express sorrow for yourself to our Lord, confess your unworthiness, ask him to help you, kiss his image if you have it near you, and repeat Jacob's words, "Lord, I will not let you go until you bless me," or those of the Canaanite woman "Yes, Lord, 'I am a dog,' for the whelps also eat the crumbs that fall from their master's table."  At other times, turn to some spiritual book and read it attentively until your mind is awakened and restored within you.  Sometimes you can arouse your heart by some act or movement of exterior devotion, such as prostrating yourself on the ground, crossing your hands before your breast, or embracing a crucifix.  It is understood that you are in some retired place.

After this if you have not received any consolation do not be disturbed, no matter how great the dryness may be, but continue to keep a devout posture before God.  How many courtiers go a hundred times a year into the prince's audience chamber without any hope of speaking to him but merely to be seen by him and do their duty.  We too, my dear Philothea, ought to approach holy prayer purely and simply do our duty and testify to our fidelity.  If it pleases his Divine Majesty to speak to us and aid us by his holy inspirations and interior consolations, it is certainly a great honor and the sweetest of delights. But if it does not please him to grant his favor and he leaves without speaking to us, just as if he did not see us at all or we were not in his presence, we must not leave on that account.  On the contrary, we must remain with a respectful and devtional bearing in the presence of his sovereign goodness.  He will unfailingly be pleased with our patience and take note of our diligence and perseverence, so that when we again come before him he will favor and help us by his consolations and enable us to see how sweet is holy prayer.  Yet if he does not do so, Philothea, let us be content that it is the very greatest honor for us to stand before him and in his sight.[/quote].

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Mar 7 2006, 08:19 PM']Hi pham, I don't usually ask for spiritual help from you all, but I've been having a hard time lately.  A friend was asking me about it and I found myself describing it pretty accurately...maybe someone has advice:

I used to feel so genuine and lately I've felt like such a phony.  It seems no matter what I do, I feel like it's not real.  I go to Adoration, Mass, pray the rosary, etc., and I feel like God isn't listening and sometimes as if He's not there (I don't consent to these feelings...they're just a nagging thought).  I feel like instead of trying to please God, I'm trying to make myself pleasing to Him (and thus, its self-centered instead of God-centered).  I feel like I'm trying to put too many expectations on myself and trying to conform myself into a mold I'm not meant to be.  I don't feel attracted to some of my devotions, but I feel like if I give those devotions up, I'll be sinning, because I've been doing them for so long.  I feel like I'm lukewarm...like I want to throw myself to God and be on fire, but I feel like I don't trust Him enough, like He won't come through for me.  I ask Him for blessings, but I fail to see the blessings He's given me already.  I ask Him to help my future, but fail to act in the present.  I'm a largely-depressed, unfulfilled, spiritual wreck, or so I feel.  I have felt this way for a long time and it's growing on me...it's not humble, it's self-hating, and therefore, in a sense, arrogant...and yet, I do not know how to be humble enough, poor enough in spirit, etc., and I do not know how to pray.  I come to God for help and there's nothing there...or rarely.

I want to love God...I want to know Him...but I feel so lost and dry and forsaken sometimes (although not always).

My only solace is to cling stubbornly to what I know--He is who is and He is love, even though I cannot feel it and am tempted to constant doubt.

One thing I know, I look at Jennie and see her love for me and I see Him there, working...she has been a sign to me of His love and she always helps me keep sight of Him, although it's not always He whom I think about.
[right][snapback]906047[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I fee like I'm going through pretty much the same thing. This might sound a little spiteful, but it's not meant to be; at least you have Jennie. There's little I can add except this:

When things go wrong as they sometimes will,
When the road you're trudging seems all up hill,
When the funds are low and the debts are high
And you want to smile, but you have to sigh,
When care is pressing you down a bit,
Rest , if you must, but don't you quit.
Life is qwerty with its twists and turns,
As everyone of us sometimes learns,
And many a failure turns about
When he might have won had he stuck it out;
Don't give up though the pace seems slow
You may succeed with another blow.
Success is failure turned inside out
The silver tine of clouds of doubt.
And you never can tell how close you are,
It may be near when it seems so far;
So stick to the fight when you're hardest hit
It's when things seem worst that you must not quit.

and my personal favorite:

Let us sing alleluia here on earth,
while we still live inanxiety,
so that we may sing it one day in heaven
in full security.
Even here admidst trials and temptation
let us sing alleluia.
Whenyou are put into the oven
of tribulation,
keep your thoughts on the time
when you will be taken out again;
for God is faithful, and He will guard
both your going in and your coming out.
So then, let us sing now,
not in order to enjoy a life leisure,
but in order to lighten our labors.
You should sing as wayfarers do:
sing, but continue your journey.
Sing, but keep on going,
keep on making progress.
If you make progress,
you will be continuing your journey.
But be sure that your progress is in virtue,
true faith and right living.
Sing then, but keep on going.

-St. Augustine

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Thank you, everyone.

I'm aware of dry periods and what they mean...I just hadn't considered this to be a dry period. While it was devoid of consolation (or at least, they were few and far between), I thought that it was because of my own sins and my own pride holding me back, but when I'd do an examination, I can never find anything mortal, even though from feelings I fear that I must be on the quick road to hell...yet I must not rely on feelings, for good or for bad...and I must resolve to get up and follow...because as Pio Nono said, if this is not because of my sins (at least not directly) as would be the case with mortal sin, then I must be given this challenge by God...I suppose it is a dry feeling...and that it is involving emotions...just at a much deeper level than I ever thought.

The tough thing, though, is fighting despair...it feels like I should...and when I fight it, the temptation becomes, "oh, well, yeah, you shouldn't despair, but it's your fault everything's like this" and when I discern that, it becomes, "you're just trying to make excuses because of your pride."

I am a prideful person and I'm aware of that...but my knowledge of my pridefulness is used against me and every time I pray for humility, the tempter's voice says, "you only pray for humility so that you can be known as humble." Sometimes the thought crosses my mind, but as an act of will, I do not want to be known as holy...I want to be known as what I am, even if I'm inclined by fallen nature to pride, I want to be humble.

It feels like it's a pit I can never rise out of...and how would I? It is a steep pit with no sloping walls...others trudge along, bit by bit, but I seem completely lost and do not know which way is up or which is down...I do not know how to do anything that I must do...and if I knew how, I would not know whether I trusted myself to know correctly.

Posted

Remember...

Everything will pass.

Feelings are always temporary. Even when they last a lifetime - still temporary, what is that compared to eternity?

God Bless,
ironmonk

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='ironmonk' date='Mar 8 2006, 08:12 AM']Remember...

Everything will pass.

Feelings are always temporary. Even when they last a lifetime - still temporary, what is that compared to eternity?

God Bless,
ironmonk
[right][snapback]906340[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I've thought about Opus Dei before...may have to join sometime.

Thank you for the excerpts above, Ironmonk.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...