cmotherofpirl Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 Do we obey the local ordinary or the GIRM and Rome when it comes to liturgical norms? This is specifically referring to the discussion in open mic. I am torn by this.
thessalonian Posted March 8, 2006 Posted March 8, 2006 It shouldn't be an either/or if the local ordinary is following the GIRM. The GIRM is what is to be followed. This is modified for the United States by the USSCB and the modifications are approved by Rome. The local ordinary I think has a little discression but not that much.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 The same fight is going on in Bishop Trautmans Pa diocese as well. He orders everyone to stand up at communion until everyone is done and back at the pew. BLAH!
Era Might Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 If it's not intrinsically evil, I would say put up with it, and maybe try to write to your Bishop and reason with him, and if you feel it will help, seek assistance from the Holy See. If it is really serious or evil (eg, invalid matter), consult the Holy See immediately.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 I cannot in good conscience go against the GIRM and the Magisterium. Did you read the thread in open mic? This is not my church [praise GOD], but I really feel for these people.
Era Might Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 The Church does not ask you to do the impossible. Unless it were a grave matter or a question of evil, I think the Church would understand your deference to the Bishop. He will answer for his decisions, not you. For the sake of peace, I don't think it would be sin if your Bishop did not provide an opportunity to obey the GIRM in one way or another, again, unless it were a serious matter. Standing after communion is not wrong in itself, it's just not the norm layed down by the Church.
Era Might Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 Oh, and I haven't seen the original thread. Sorry if I'm retreading old ground.
HisChild Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 It's not my diocese either, although I DID get the 'you're an ignorant tourist' look, when I knelt during my vacation last week when I was in CA. My thoughts are, it is the norm that we kneel for Jesus after the Agnus Dei. I kneel for God. I stand for a president or other dignitary or judge. just IMHO.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 9, 2006 Author Posted March 9, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' date='Mar 8 2006, 07:25 PM']The Church does not ask you to do the impossible. Unless it were a grave matter or a question of evil, I think the Church would understand your deference to the Bishop. He will answer for his decisions, not you. For the sake of peace, I don't think it would be sin if your Bishop did not provide an opportunity to obey the GIRM in one way or another, again, unless it were a serious matter. Standing after communion is not wrong in itself, it's just not the norm layed down by the Church. [right][snapback]906887[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I just cannot undestand any bishop that would go against the GIRM.
phatcatholic Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 ya know, this standing after the Agnus Dei and until everyone has received pisses me off more than anything in the Church right now. i was never able to come to a decision on what to do. maybe i just didn't research enough, i dont know. what i was able to figure out is this: --it would appear, altho i am not entirely sure, that the bishop has the authority to make his congregation stand after the Agnus Dei (instead of kneeling while u wait to receive communion). that part is a little up in the air. however, the Church has clarified thru various dubiums that a person can in fact kneel after returning to his pew from receiving communion and that the GIRM never intended to deny that practice. so, standing after you receive has been resolved. however, from what i can tell, standing after the Agnus Dei and before you receive has not. i hope that helps. i can provide the dubium(s) if u wish pax christi, phatcatholic
phatcatholic Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 this clarifies what the GIRM intended to say (as opposed to what a few bishops and liturgists are pretending it says): RESPONSES TO QUESTIONS Cardinal Jorge A. Medina Estévez [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDWADORI.HTM#kneeling"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDWADORI.HTM#kneeling[/url] On November 7, 2000, Cardinal Jorge Arturo Medina Estévez, prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments, sent a response to the questions of an American bishop about the new regulations for the celebration of Mass [Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani]. The questions [dubia] concerned the posture and gestures of the people at Mass, and placement of the tabernacle. A facsimile of the response, written in English, appears below. CONGREGATIO DE CULTU DIVINO ET DISCIPLINA SACRAMENTORUM Prot. n. 2372/00/L Responses to Dubia 1. Is it the case that the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, by No. 43 of the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani, intends to prohibit the faithful from kneeling during any part of the Mass except during the Consecration, that is, to prohibit the faithful from kneeling after the Agnus Dei and following the reception of Holy Communion? Resp.: Negative. 2. Does the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments intend by Nos. 160-162, 244, or elsewhere in the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani, that the people may no longer genuflect or bow as a sign of reverence to the Blessed Sacrament immediately before they receive Holy Communion? Resp.: Negative. 3. Does the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments in the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani Nos. 314-315, or elsewhere, intend that a separate chapel for the reservation of the Most Blessed Sacrament within parish churches is to be preferred to a prominent and central location within the main body of the church, thus visible to the faithful during the celebration of the Mass? Resp.: Negative, et ad mentem. Mens: Within the norms specified by law, it pertains to the diocesan Bishop, in his capacity as moderator of the Sacred Liturgy in the particular Church entrusted to him, to exercise judgment regarding the most appropriate place for the reservation of the Most Blessed Sacrament, bearing foremost in mind the purpose of encouraging and enabling the faithful to visit and adore the Most Blessed Sacrament. Vatican City, 7 November 2000 Jorge A. Card. MEDINA ESTÉVEZ, Cardinal Prefect Francesco Pio Tamburrino Archbishop Secretary -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Congregation responded on September 25, 2000, to a European cardinal’s question about the position of the priest during the liturgy of the Eucharist. Adoremus’s translation of the original letter, written in Italian, appears here. Responses such as these two letters are later published in Notitiae, the official publication of the congregation of Divine Worship. CONGREGATIO DE CULTU DIVINO ET DISCIPLINA SACRAMENTORUM Prot. No 2086/00/L The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments has been asked whether the expression in no. 299 of the Instituto Generalis Missalis Romani constitutes a norm according to which, during the Eucharistic liturgy, the position of the priest versus absidem [facing towards the apse] is to be excluded. The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, after mature reflection and in light of liturgical precedents, responds: Negative, and in accordance with the following explanation. The explanation includes different elements which must be taken into account. It is in the first place to be borne in mind that the word expedit does not constitute an obligation, but a suggestion that refers to the construction of the altar a pariete sejunctum [detached from the wall] and to the celebration versus populum [towards the people]. The clause ubi possibile sit [where it is possible] refers to different elements, as, for example, the topography of the place, the availability of space, the artistic value of the existing altar, the sensibility of the people participating in the celebrations in a particular church, etc. It reaffirms that the position towards the assembly seems more convenient inasmuch as it makes communication easier (Cf. the editorial in Notitiae 29 [1993] 245-249), without excluding, however, the other possibility. However, whatever may be the position of the celebrating priest, it is clear that the Eucharistic Sacrifice is offered to the one and triune God, and that the principal, eternal, and high priest is Jesus Christ, who acts through the ministry of the priest who visibly presides as his instrument. The liturgical assembly participates in the celebration in virtue of the common priesthood of the faithful which requires the ministry of the ordained priest to be exercised in the Eucharistic Synaxis. The physical position, especially with respect to the communication among the various members of the assembly, must be distinguished from the interior spiritual orientation of all. It would be a grave error to imagine that the principle orientation of the sacrificial action is [toward] the community. If the priest celebrates versus populum, which is a legitimate and often advisable, his spiritual attitude ought always to, be versus Deum per Jesus Christum [towards God through Jesus Christ], as representative of the entire Church. The Church as well, which takes concrete form in the assembly which participates, is entirely turned versus Deum [towards God] as its first spiritual movement. It appears that the ancient tradition, though not without exception, was that the celebrant and the praying community were turned versus orientem [towards the East], the direction from which the Light which is Christ comes. It is not unusual for ancient churches to be "oriented" so that the priest and the people were turned versus orientem during public prayer. It may be that when there were problems of space, or of some other kind, the apse represented the East symbolically. Today the expression versus orientem often means versus apsidem, and in speaking of versus populum it is not the west but rather the community present that is meant. In the ancient architecture of churches, the place of the Bishop or the celebrating priest was in the center of the apse where, seated and turned towards the community, the proclamation of the readings was listened to, Now this presidential place was not ascribed to the human person of the bishop or the priest, nor to his intellectual gifts and not even to his personal holiness, but to his role as an instrument of the invisible Pontiff, who is the Lord Jesus. When it is a question of ancient churches, or of great artistic value, it is appropriate, moreover, to keep in mind civil legislation regarding changes or renovations. Adding another altar may not always be a worthy solution. There is no need to give excessive importance to elements which have changed throughout the centuries. What always remains is the event celebrated in the liturgy: this is manifested through rites, signs, symbols and words which express various aspects of the mystery without, however, exhausting it, because it transcends them. Taking a rigid position and absolutizing it could become a rejection of some aspect of the truth which merits respect and acceptance. Vatican City, 25 September 2000. Jorge A. Card. MEDINA ESTÉVEZ Cardinal Prefect Francesco Pio Tamburrino Archbishop Secretary -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Taken from: ADOREMUS BULLETIN © 2001 December 2000 - January 2001, page 6 Office: PO Box 300561 St. Louis, MO 63130 Phone: (314) 863-8385 Fax: (314) 863-5858 ADOREMUS BULLETIN sent on request to members. Phone: (314) 862-6845 E-mail: info@adoremus.org Web site: www.adoremus.org -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Provided Courtesy of: Eternal Word Television Network 5817 Old Leeds Road Irondale, AL 35210 www.ewtn.com
phatcatholic Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 see also this from Cardinal Arinze on kneeling after communion: [url="http://www.adoremus.org/Kneeling-after-Communion.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/Kneeling-after-Communion.html[/url] Concerning the practice of kneeling after receiving Holy Communion, Cardinal Francis George, chairman of the Committee on the Liturgy, submitted a dubium [question] to the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments [CDW] on May 26, 2003: Dubium: In many places, the faithful are accustomed to kneeling or sitting in personal prayer upon returning to their places after having individually received Holy Communion during Mass. Is it the intention of the Missale Romanum, editio typical tertia, to forbid this practice? Cardinal Francis Arinze, Prefect of the CDW, responded to the question on June 5, 2003 (Prot. N. 855/03/L): Responsum:Negative, et ad mentem (No, for this reason). The mens [reason] is that the prescription of the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani, no. 43, is intended, on the one hand to ensure within broad limits a certain uniformity of posture within the congregation for the various parts of the celebration of Holy Mass, and on the other, not to regulate posture rigidly in such a way that those who wish to kneel or sit would no longer be free. The dubium and response appear in the July 2003 edition of the BCL Newsletter, published by the US Bishops Committee on the Liturgy. Earlier, the CDW re-affirmed kneeling after the Ecce Agnus Dei [Behold, the Lamb of God] when it amended the relevant paragraph (no. 43) of the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani for the universal Church by adding the following clarifying sentence: "Where it is the custom that the people remain kneeling from the end of the Sanctus until the end of the Eucharistic Prayer, and before Communion when the priest says Ecce Agnus Dei, this is laudably retained". (See AB March 2003, p 4 sidebar. This sentence does not appear in the Institutio [or GIRM] as adapted for the United States, since this period of kneeling is explicitly affirmed in the adapted version of no. 43, "unless the Diocesan Bishop determines otherwise"..) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Site copyright © 2003 - Adoremus
phatcatholic Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 this thread may help as well (or it may just confuse u further, i dunno): [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=35208"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=35208[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now