Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

phatcatholic
Posted

for those who don't know, i just started the grad theology program at FUS. i thought i'd share the first paper i've had to write for class. i just finished it :) its a book review on [i]Sacramental Theology: A General Introduction[/i], by Kenan B. Osborne, O.F.M. its only 525 words (that was the limit my teacher set) so its not very long. let me know what u think.

peace,
nick


SACRAMENTAL THEOLOGY: A GENERAL INTRODUCTION. By Kenan B. Osborne, O.F.M. New York: Paulist Press, 1988. Pp. v + 154. $9.95.

Since 1987, when he wrote [i]The Christian Sacraments of Initiation: Baptism, Confirmation, Eucharist[/i], Kenan Osborne has written seven books on individual sacraments and on general sacramental theology. In almost all of them, we find this theme: Jesus as the “fundamental” or “primordial” sacrament and the Church as the “basic” sacrament (10). These two sacraments stand, not [i]alongside[/i] our traditional seven sacraments, but [i]beyond them[/i], influencing our understanding of them and in a sense departing from the Council of Trent. The implications of this theme on a renewed sacramental theology are the focus of this, his second book.

Osborne is not the first to address the sacramentality of Jesus and the Church. He credits Otto Semmelroth’s work [i]Die Kirche als Ursakrament [/i](1953) as the first to substantially address the issue and to make it theologically acceptable. Schillebeeckx’s work [i]Christus, Sacrament van de Godsontmoeting[/i] (1960) and Rahner’s [i]Kirche und Sakrament[/i] (1961) follow soon thereafter, preventing Semmelroth’s work from being merely the talk of a few German theologians (10). Osborne relies mostly upon these last two theologians, but he is also indebted to the Second Vatican Council, which presented this theme intermittently throughout its documents (11-12).

Osborne begins [i]Sacramental Theology[/i] by outlining four factors that have occasioned the present renewal: scholarly research into the history of the sacraments; the development of the Church and the humanity of Jesus as sacraments; the ecumenical movement; and liberation theology (1-2). From here, he moves to an historical account of the word “sacrament” and a treatment on how our use of this word has evolved over time. This is significant because our understanding of “sacrament” must develop even further before it can encompass Jesus Christ and the Church. According to Osborne, such development has begun, but there is still much left to do. Next, Osborne outlines the methodologies that work to further shape our understanding of the sacraments. These include methods of interpreting the scriptural and historical evidence for the sacraments, but more importantly, Christological and phenomenological methods. After laying this groundwork, he comes to the crux of the work: Jesus Christ as primordial sacrament and the Church as basic sacrament. He concludes with an overview of the solemn teaching of the Church regarding the sacraments, and a reflection on how all of this works to enrich our spiritual lives as Christians.

His presentation of Jesus as the sign of the real presence of God, and the Church as the sign of the real presence of Jesus is indeed compelling. He turns to many well-respected theologians and to the very documents of the Church to legitimize this understanding, and he is interested in presenting it not as a break with tradition, but as a revivification of it. However, this is only a first step. More must be done to effectively reconcile this more encompassing understanding of “sacrament” with the clear statement of the Council of Trent that there are neither more nor fewer than [i]seven[/i] sacraments. It is not enough merely to assert that the context of Trent influenced a fixation on seven that is too restrictive for today. One hopes that in his later works, this tension is more definitively resolved.[list]Nicholas Hardesty
Franciscan University of Steubenville
525 words
[/list]

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Post it on Amazon. :)

Link: [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0809129450/qid=1141873356/sr=1-3/ref=sr_1_3/002-9050685-1330433?s=books&v=glance&n=283155"]http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/080912945...glance&n=283155[/url]

Also, would you comment on this negative review:
[quote]Unfortunately, this book is not usable because it teaches heresy. Fr. Osborne, who I believe one could safely term a modernist, says in this book that baptism does not take away original sin or actual sins for adults (p. 64). He also glorifies the common modernists like Karl Rahner and Edward Schillebeeckx. So, in short, hands off that book. There are GOOD sacramental theology books out there; don't waste your money on this one.[/quote]
So what does page 64 really say? :detective:

Posted
[color=330000]My sister goes to FUS
[/color]
Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Mateo el Feo' date='Mar 8 2006, 09:15 PM']Post it on Amazon.  :)

Link:  [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0809129450/qid=1141873356/sr=1-3/ref=sr_1_3/002-9050685-1330433?s=books&v=glance&n=283155"]http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/080912945...glance&n=283155[/url]

Also, would you comment on this negative review:

So what does page 64 really say?  :detective:
[right][snapback]906955[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Interesting. I've always been a fan of Michael Schmaus myself.

franciscanheart
Posted

i didn't read it but good job!! :D:

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Mateo el Feo' date='Mar 8 2006, 10:15 PM']Post it on Amazon.  :)

Link:  [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0809129450/qid=1141873356/sr=1-3/ref=sr_1_3/002-9050685-1330433?s=books&v=glance&n=283155"]http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/080912945...glance&n=283155[/url]

Also, would you comment on this negative review:

So what does page 64 really say?  :detective:
[right][snapback]906955[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
ya know, i put a big question mark on that page when i read it, but since i only had 525 words to review this book, i could only focus on the main theme of it. anyway, here's the paragraph in question:[list]1. [i]Baptism[/i]. Baptism is said to take away original sin and give us sanctifying grace. These ideas fit well with an infant baptism, but in the case of an adult baptism t hese ideas are not operable. In the Scholastic theology of sacraments, an adult faced only two alternatives to one's life: heaven or hell. For an adult, there was no "limbo," which means that an adult would not be sent to hell simply for original sin, nor could an adult enter heaven if there were original sin. One went to hell for serious, actual sins, and one went to heaven with no win whatsoever. For an adult, original sin had been taken away, long before baptism and long before even the desire of baptism. This also means that long before baptism or even the desire of baptism, an adult had received sanctifying grace or perhaps lost sanctifying grace (the only reason one goes to hell). What, then, does baptism do in the case of an adult?
[/list]

Brother Adam
Posted

If you look at the index he does make liberal use of modernists like Heidegger, Rahner, and Schillebeeckx, Duns Scotus

phatcatholic
Posted

his use of heidegger is actually rather helpful tho, in explaining the nature of a symbol.

Posted

wow, that's frightening. why would FUS be using a book that is so obviously denying some long-held tenets of Catholicism?

Posted

wow, that's frightening. why would FUS be using a book that is so obviously denying some long-held tenets of Catholicism?

franciscanheart
Posted

:applause:

i only have one criticism. as it is above, third paragraph: third line about mid way through. "From here he moves to an historical account..." which should actually be "From here he moves to a historical account..."... otherwise... very nice. :thumbsup:

:saint:

Mateo el Feo
Posted (edited)

A couple comments:
1) I don't really like theologians who discard orthodoxy and offer their own pet theories as a replacement. You mentioned his discussion of Trent, and I wanted to bring up one thing: it is a hallmark of dissident theologians to take Catholic terms and twist their meaning slowly into something else. Then, with the new meaning, they quote old texts and re-interpret them in ways that have nothing to do with the original text's meaning. Instead of the author admitting that he is contradicting Trent, he simply redefines terms; and presto-chango, he's "revivifying" it! LOL

Regarding Trent and Baptism, in contrast to the author's conjectures:

[quote]COUNCIL OF TRENT FIFTH SESSION CELEBRATED ON THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF JUNE, 1546

Decree Concerning Original Sin

3. If anyone asserts that this sin of Adam, which in its origin is one, and by propagation, not by imitation, transfused into all, which is in each one as something that is his own, is taken away either by the forces of human nature or by a remedy other than the merit of the one mediator, our Lord Jesus Christ,[9] who has reconciled us to God in his own blood, made unto us justice, sanctification and redemption;[10] or if he denies that that merit of Jesus Christ is applied both to adults and to infants by the sacrament of baptism rightly administered in the form of the Church, let him be anathema; for there is no other name under heaven given to men, whereby we must be saved.[11] Whence that declaration: Behold the Lamb of God, behold him who taketh away the sins of the world;[12] and that other: As many of you as have been baptized, have put on Christ.[13]

5. If anyone denies that by the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ which is conferred in baptism, the guilt of original sin is remitted, or says that the whole of that which belongs to the essence of sin is not taken away, but says that it is only canceled or not imputed, let him be anathema. For in those who are born again God hates nothing, because there is no condemnation to those who are truly buried together with Christ by baptism unto death,[18] who walk not according to the flesh,[19] but, putting off the old man and putting on the new one who is created according to God,[20] are made innocent, immaculate, pure, guiltless and beloved of God, heirs indeed of God, joint heirs with Christ;[21] so that there is nothing whatever to hinder their entrance into heaven. But this holy council perceives and confesses that in the one baptized there remains concupiscence or an inclination to sin, which, since it is left for us to wrestle with, cannot injure those who do not acquiesce but resist manfully by the grace of Jesus Christ; indeed, he who shall have striven lawfully shall be crowned.[22] This concupiscence, which the Apostle sometimes calls sin,[23] the holy council declares the Catholic Church has never understood to be called sin in the sense that it is truly and properly sin in those born again, but in the sense that it is of sin and inclines to sin. But if anyone is of the contrary opinion, let him be anathema.[/quote]

2) From what I read in your report, this author seems to be part of the chorus of academics who are trying to enshrine Liberation Theology, as if it's supportive of and complementary to Catholic orthodoxy. I'm baffled at his making the claim that Liberation Theology would be the cause of a renewal of Catholic sacramental life.

The whole Liberation Theology fad should have realized that its fifteen minute of fame had passed a long time ago...like when the Soviet Union collapsed. Back when this book was written (1988), Liberation Theology was being pushed by all the "cool" theologians. Thank goodness, they've all got gray hair now. If only they'd stop publishing books that only sell because like-minded professors force them on their students...

Edited by Mateo el Feo
Mateo el Feo
Posted

Just out of curiousity, did the professor assigned this book to the entire class?

Posted

Awesome! :cool:

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Mar 8 2006, 10:29 PM']i only have one criticism. as it is above, third paragraph: third line about mid way through. "From here he moves to an historical account..." which should actually be "From here he moves to a historical account..."... otherwise... very nice. :thumbsup:
[right][snapback]907012[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

That's technically not an error though. In formal writing, H is treated as a vowel. As to why that is, I'll have to find out. :idontknow:

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='azaelia' date='Mar 9 2006, 11:01 AM']Awesome! :cool:
That's technically not an error though. In formal writing, H is treated as a vowel. As to why that is, I'll have to find out. :idontknow:
[right][snapback]907243[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That annoys the carp out of me. I always use an "a" and I've yet to have a professor tell me to fix it (or point it out).

and as for you... :annoyed: always showing me up. :sadder:


oh and it also annoys me when people dont pronounce the h in my last name... :maddest:

Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Mar 9 2006, 11:04 AM']and as for you...  :annoyed: always showing me up. :sadder:
[right][snapback]907245[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I sowwy. I won't do it again. :unsure:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted
:yahoo:
Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Mar 9 2006, 04:04 PM']That annoys the carp out of me. I always use an "a" and I've yet to have a professor tell me to fix it (or point it out).

and as for you...  :annoyed: always showing me up. :sadder:
oh and it also annoys me when people dont pronounce the h in my last name...  :maddest:
[right][snapback]907245[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

As far as I'm aware (info. given by my English friend) if the 'h' is in a word like 'hospital' where the 'h' sound is heard, then you write 'a' however if it is used in say 'hour' where the 'h' sound isn't heard, then you write 'an'

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...