Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

major public dissent in Canada


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

I got the following back from one of them.

Monsieur Hunt,

Vous êtes plus sévère que les évêques eux-mêmes ! Voir le fichier attaché.
Dieu vous bénisse.
:blink:

To which I replied:

Monsieur Belle,

I don't speak french. Hope you weren't swearing. :shock:

Posted

At least they were prompt.

Posted

I speak French, and he wasn't swearing. Here's a translation:

[quote]Mr. Hunt,

You're more severe than the bishops themselves!  See the attached file.  God bless you.[/quote]

That obviously doesn't say much for the Canadian bishops. :sadder:

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Dave' date='Mar 9 2006, 11:57 AM']I speak French, and he wasn't swearing.  Here's a translation:
That obviously doesn't say much for the Canadian bishops. :sadder:
[right][snapback]907306[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Thanks for the translation. Is it any wonder why they are such a mess if what he says is true.

thessalonian
Posted

Dear Mr. Belle,

A friend translated it for me. I guess I shouldn't be surprized considering the mess the Catholic Church is in in Canada. It didn't get that way with devout leadership. I take it you find 1 Cor 5 severe. Well it's alot less severe then leaving your errors for final judgement. Paul was speaking mercy for the man who was living with his father's wife in all truth. Eternal hellfire is a long time. The Catholic Church still teaches that you know.

Once again you have my prayers.

Blessings

Posted

you should have sent a letter back in Latin with a note attached "This is the official international language of the Church. If you will not send me a letter back in the language I sent mine to you, please send it in the Church's universal language."

Myles Domini
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Mar 9 2006, 06:48 PM']you should have sent a letter back in Latin with a note attached "This is the official international language of the Church.  If you will not send me a letter back in the language I sent mine to you, please send it in the Church's universal language."
[right][snapback]907346[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

:lol_sign:

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Mar 9 2006, 12:48 PM']you should have sent a letter back in Latin with a note attached "This is the official international language of the Church.  If you will not send me a letter back in the language I sent mine to you, please send it in the Church's universal language."
[right][snapback]907346[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


That would have been good. But I don't know latin either. :idontknow:

Posted

I look forward to hearing what he says. Although... a saying comes to mind. To those who believe, no explanation is necessary. To those who don't, none is possible

Those who are in error, very rarely, if ever, have they turned from their ways, especially after going so far. Their obstinance will continue. . .although much prayer on our parts can perhaps open their hearts to much grace.

God be with you.

Denise

thessalonian
Posted

The next guy says I'm a big meanie. :(

It would be nice to know a bit about you. Your comments sound very condemning. You are responding to a media release of an original document. The media are not always accurate in the way they present things. I selected a quote from the document that may help you to understand the intent of the letter.
It is important that the Message be taken in its entire context and not just one portion of it. It is a discussion of what we have accomplished as Church, what we want to improve on and our desires for the future. These desires are not demands. They are the areas where there needs to be more discussion and listening by all partners in our Church: clergy, religious and laity. The desires are born from the daily experience of working in community groups, parishes, schools and many other areas where we Religious are engaged. They are born from our experience as people of prayer. They are our dreams for the future and part of our prophetic commitment as Religious women and men.



Your reaction shuts down communication rather than encouraging discussion. Let the words and actions of Jesus resonate in our hearts,

"Let the one who is without sin cast the first stone." Maybe your prayers will lead you to a deeper sense of compassion.

Posted

Jesus worked with sinners every day as well, but never once did He ever pander to those sinners by telling them that their sins were not sins. If one truly wants to toss Jesus' words and actions at others, perhaps they might best remember that as well.

thessalonian
Posted

My compassion is that they and those whom they encourage and in the process I and my children all make it to heaven. Can't we all just get along isn't going to get everyone there.

toledo_jesus
Posted

hmph. I can't say what I'm thinking.

Posted

Quebec Bishops Downplay Rebel Priests


Saturday March 11, 2006 2:01 AM

By PHIL COUVRETTE

Associated Press Writer

MONTREAL (AP) - Quebec's Catholic bishops Friday downplayed a recent public outburst of 19 priests against the Vatican's stand on homosexuality, but called for an internal debate on the matter.

The Quebec Conference of Catholic Bishops held this week precedes an upcoming visit of Canadian bishops to the Vatican in May, where the issue will be among the ``principal aspects'' of discussions with Pope Benedict XVI.

The bishops said they regretted that dissident priests had made their views public through the media last month, but agreed it provoked needed dialogue within the church on a variety of topics, including gay marriage.

The Feb. 26 letter was a rare case of public dissent within Quebec's Catholic church. In it, the priests criticized the Vatican for opposing gay marriage and forbidding homosexuals from the priesthood. They suggested the church needed to evolve, rather than have ``the last word on the mysteries of political, social, family and sexual life.''

The bishops issued a news release Thursday, calling the letter ``food for thought.''

``We regret, however, that we have been brought into this by force of circumstance; it is a confrontational dynamic that threats to harden positions,'' the bishops said.

The bishops said their coming meeting with the pope would explore various topics about Quebec society, including ``ethical questions such as civil union and the definition of marriage.''

Canada last year legalized same-sex marriage nationwide, a move many clerics of all religions opposed.

There are about 13 million Catholics in Canada, about 43 percent of the country's population, with nearly half living in the French-speaking province of Quebec.

  • 3 months later...
Posted

Ma pauvre patrie; quand cesseras-t-elle de se meurtrier et de se mutiler dans sont intransigeante insistance envers le vice?

J'en pleure souvent.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...