Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What makes a good theologian?


Recommended Posts

Posted

As I sit and reflect on becoming a priest someday I found that a priest is in some sense the "resident theolgian" of his parish. He is the one with 8+ years of formal schooling and has the cura animorum of the parish to carry. So what is it that makes one a "good theologian?"

Is it knowing a plethora of facts and theories? Is it being able to put theological language into every day language for the people (as a friend of mine would say: "Bringing those cookies off the shelf.) Or is it being able to draw new conclusions based on known facts?Theology as a discipline can only really be tested for coherence with other known truths.

Your comments and thoughts are surely welcomed.

Brother Adam
Posted

I believe one mark would be the ability to do what a historian does, to take a great deal of information, assimilate it, draw conclusions from it, and regurgatate it in a way that others can read without doing all the research itself. It doesn't mean taking complex theories and dumbing them down.

Posted

Is the question one solely of theology . . . or is it more along the lines of how can a good priest also be a good theologian . . . I think of St. John Vianney, who is reputed to have barely squeaked through seminary, was sent to a backwater parish so he could do little "damage" and ended up as a saint . . . I can't speak to the quality of his theology . . . or how his parishioners received it . . . but he seems to have been a good priest.

Posted

I think a good theologian is someone who has an exceptional understanding of what the faith is and knows how to communicate the various aspects of it, and the meanings/implications of them, to people effectively. He or she strives to help people come to a deeper understanding and love of the faith.

Posted

Thank you everyone for your comments thus far, but in response to journeyman I have the following to offer:

I am personally torn right now between vocations. I plan on returning to seminary in August to continue studying for the priesthood (I left seminary after two years to discern a religious vocation but found out that was not for me.) I am personally torn in desiring to be a scholar but also a pastor. How much time should a pastor devout to his studies while holding the cura? Ongoing education of priests is extremely important, and a vital part to strengthening catechesis if you ask me. I love to read and study, but the question is: "What is that balance between theologian and pastor that each priest should have?" Some priests seem to be more scholarly and able to answer any question given to them. Others are more people oriented and can console people in their most trying hours where scholarly answers cannot help.

Posted

"A theologian is one who prays. One who prays is a theologian."

--Evagrius of Pontus

Posted

[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Mar 12 2006, 12:52 PM']As I sit and reflect on becoming a priest someday I found that a priest is in some sense the "resident theolgian" of his parish. He is the one with 8+ years of formal schooling and has the cura animorum of the parish to carry. So what is it that makes one a "good theologian?"

Is it knowing a plethora of facts and theories? Is it being able to put theological language into every day language for the people (as a friend of mine would say: "Bringing those cookies off the shelf.) Or is it being able to draw new conclusions based on known facts?Theology as a discipline can only really be tested for coherence with other known truths.

Your comments and thoughts are surely welcomed.
[right][snapback]909402[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

As one, I can honestly tell you that it is all of the above. A good theologian is one who can understand the nuance of the "study of God" and promote it in a truthful and absolute manner.

Yes, it is knowing a plethora of facts and theories. Yes, to a certain extent it is being able to put it into everyday language, although that should be guarded, very guarded. The grasp of language must be HUGE in order to transliterate the facts and the theories. Depending on what type of theology it is, it is being able to draw new conclusions. If one is simply a parish priest, it is best not to deviate too much, however if one is an educator or a "professional" theologian who deals in the cutting edge (such as von Hildebrand or Ratzinger) then pushing the limits are surely the case.

Theology as a discipline is promoting right thinking and promising the faithful that you will be faithful to the "study of God." As a theologian, it is often best to simply state the Truth and explain it in the best manner.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...