Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

On saturday night a friend of mine was attacked by a man with a knife demanding his money as he left a bar after visiting his friends. The attacker ended up with a dislocated shoulder and a broken leg, and my friend has a few cracked ribs. My friend however, is expriencing deep remorse because when he was attacked he had a brief minute of murderous rage as the knife came at him. I think this rage enabled his military training to kick in and probably saved his life, but he feels guilty by it. My friend is in his mid fifties, and the attacker was in his twenties.

Comments?

Posted
:unsure: i'm not sure
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 13 2006, 04:52 PM']On saturday night a friend of mine was attacked by a man with a knife demanding his money as he left a bar after visiting his friends. The attacker ended up with a dislocated shoulder and a broken leg, and my friend has a few cracked ribs. My friend  however, is expriencing deep remorse because when he was attacked he had a brief minute of murderous rage as the knife came at him. I think this rage enabled his military training to kick in and probably saved his life, but he feels guilty by it. My friend is in his mid fifties, and the attacker was in his twenties.

Comments?
[right][snapback]910735[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Maybe it was rage, but it also probably saved his life. . .the difference between 'rage' and self defense. :unsure:

Posted

First of all, good for him.

As far as the remorse goes, if he felt he was out control of himself then perhaps it is something worth confessing. On the other hand, if he was in control and his "instincts" whether trained or not took over I wouldn't worry about it. I highly doubt he will be in this situation again.

Posted

He may have felt "rage," and if he did it was most likely a bioloigically controled response. He was put in a "fight or flight" spot and had to fight, the adrenaline in his body would have been pumping. When something attacks something else, the normal "natural" response to to defend or retreat, he defended. It is also normal and natural to really defend yourself. Most likely it happened rapidly, I doubt your friend had the time to sit there and think "has the attack been disabled yet?" He most likely acted to defend himself. A similar thing can be said of most cops. In most police depts in the US, a cop is trained to empty his gun if he shoots it once. He is supposed to aim for the chest and keep pulling the trigger until nothing happens. Could one round stop the person? Yes, maybe, but not always. The person's life is at risk and his actions are taken to protect his life, he shouldn't and wouldn't stop after the person "might be down" but only after he is sure he is safe or cannot keep up the defense.

Just my two cents.

homeschoolmom
Posted

If he's still having murderous thoughts, that would be a problem, but if it was instentanious, I think it's normal....

cmotherofpirl
Posted

He is really shaken by the fact that at that brief moment he really did want to kill the guy.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 13 2006, 04:52 PM']On saturday night a friend of mine was attacked by a man with a knife demanding his money as he left a bar after visiting his friends. The attacker ended up with a dislocated shoulder and a broken leg, and my friend has a few cracked ribs. My friend  however, is expriencing deep remorse because when he was attacked he had a brief minute of murderous rage as the knife came at him. I think this rage enabled his military training to kick in and probably saved his life, but he feels guilty by it. My friend is in his mid fifties, and the attacker was in his twenties.

Comments?
[right][snapback]910735[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Your friend is freakin' awesome!
Any man in his fifties who can kick some 20-something-year-old punk's heiny has my respect. The attacker got off light in my opinon.

In my opinion, your friend has absolutely no cause for remorse. The rage is a natural reaction of adreneline, and served its purpose well. I he had deliberately pondered and intended murder for some time before-hand, that woud be another matter.

I think too many people have been conditioned by wussy liberalism to have to much "compassion" for criminals. Think about it, the scumbag probably would not have hesitated to kill an older man for his money. I have no pity for such people.

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 13 2006, 06:52 PM']On saturday night a friend of mine was attacked by a man with a knife demanding his money as he left a bar after visiting his friends. The attacker ended up with a dislocated shoulder and a broken leg, and my friend has a few cracked ribs. My friend  however, is expriencing deep remorse because when he was attacked he had a brief minute of murderous rage as the knife came at him. I think this rage enabled his military training to kick in and probably saved his life, but he feels guilty by it. My friend is in his mid fifties, and the attacker was in his twenties.

Comments?
[right][snapback]910735[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That guy...is AWESOME!

Holy cow, I bet that young punk didn't know what hit him. Or maybe he did: Your friend's fists!


I say good for him. Remorse is pointless in a life or death situation. He did what he had to do, and he didn't kill the little butthat. did I use that word correctly?

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Mar 13 2006, 09:08 PM'] and he didn't kill the little butthat.  did I use that word correctly?
[right][snapback]910839[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
yes... yes, you did. Nice application.

Brother Adam
Posted

its funny, I just listened to a talk on Anger and Forgiveness by a Catholic deacon and doctor (psychologist). He talked about four types of sinful anger (of which I have issues with two types that I need to work out) and righteous anger which he called indignation, the kind of anger that is upset by injustice. I'd say that that guy was totally right in his rage in the moment.

Posted

Rage is probably second to fear as the most common response for someone under attack. I think the most important thing is he didn't act on that emotion. He instead restrained himself and used force legitimately.

Takin' the three necessaries for mortal sin, I think he didn't have intent; it seems pretty clear to me that rage was an instinctive response, not an emotion he chose to have.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Mar 13 2006, 09:51 PM']its funny, I just listened to a talk on Anger and Forgiveness by a Catholic deacon and doctor (psychologist). He talked about four types of sinful anger (of which I have issues with two types that I need to work out) and righteous anger which he called indignation, the kind of anger that is upset by injustice. I'd say that that guy was totally right in his rage in the moment.
[right][snapback]910874[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Adam if you would like to start a thread on the four types of sinful anger it would be helpful.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 13 2006, 06:52 PM']On saturday night a friend of mine was attacked by a man with a knife demanding his money as he left a bar after visiting his friends. The attacker ended up with a dislocated shoulder and a broken leg, and my friend has a few cracked ribs. My friend  however, is expriencing deep remorse because when he was attacked he had a brief minute of murderous rage as the knife came at him. I think this rage enabled his military training to kick in and probably saved his life, but he feels guilty by it. My friend is in his mid fifties, and the attacker was in his twenties.

Comments?
[right][snapback]910735[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


He could have saved the life of the attacker or someone elses... if the attacker got away with that crime, then it would have lead to other crimes more serious in nature.

The attacker learned a needed lesson.

As long as he forgives the attacker, he should have nothing to worry about. The "rage" might not have been rage but the reflex action he was trained to do. He didn't kill the man, and I'm sure he could of if he wanted to.


God Bless,
ironmonk

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Mar 13 2006, 04:52 PM']On saturday night a friend of mine was attacked by a man with a knife demanding his money as he left a bar after visiting his friends. The attacker ended up with a dislocated shoulder and a broken leg, and my friend has a few cracked ribs. My friend  however, is expriencing deep remorse because when he was attacked he had a brief minute of murderous rage as the knife came at him. I think this rage enabled his military training to kick in and probably saved his life, but he feels guilty by it. My friend is in his mid fifties, and the attacker was in his twenties.

Comments?
[right][snapback]910735[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm with Socrates on this one. It probably was more adrenaline than rage.

And if he still feels guilty, just point him to the part of the Catechism that refers to legitimate defense.

Just say a prayer that the the attacker doesn't sue your friend. It's a shame that people even have to appear in court just for defending themselves.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' date='Mar 13 2006, 11:04 PM']I'm with Socrates on this one.  It probably was more adrenaline than rage. 

And if he still feels guilty, just point him to the part of the Catechism that refers to legitimate defense.

Just say a prayer that the the attacker doesn't sue your friend.  It's a shame that people even have to appear in court just for defending themselves.
[right][snapback]910917[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Actually there was an undercover cop in the parking lot who came over to break up the fight, but it was over by the time he got there. The attacker had several outstanding warrents so he is in a hospital jail ward. They took my friends information and have called him back for various details, but he is in the clear. He doesn't want to appear in court, so the guy doesn't get his address, he figures two casts is punishment enough.
He is just shocked at the emotions involved.

Posted

Prayers for your friend, it makes sense the emotions shocked and are shocking to him.

Posted

All in all, I'd have to agree with all the guys here, but one additional note:

Considering that this is a highly unusual situation, I'm not really surprised at his questioning of his emotions and such during the fight. I think its a natural thing, but it's something he has to come to grips with. I'd say he needs to trust that he did what was best in his judgement (and, being removed, it sounds like he did take the best course of action).

cmotherofpirl
Posted

He is working on it. Because he isn't religious, he doesn't have the benefit of confession or a spiritual advisor.

Posted

When a person is involved in any sort of trauma that involves violence, the potential for guilt is almost a given. I've seen that countless times, working at the County ER/Trauma. It's too bad that he doesn't have a spiritual advisor, but please share that he was the VICTIM in this situation and has no need of guilt. God bless him. I'll pray for his healing.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...