Sojourner Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 15 2006, 09:15 AM']Sojourner, I've been reading your posts for some time though I don't often respond to them. If I might be honest I find them to be annoying. I've talked with many people who are Catholic and Democrat. Those who want to ride the fence. (I'm not what I would consider to be a republican by the way) . You sound in your posts on this and other threads like someone who wants to stay democrat but struggles with issues with the party. Why do you feel you have to in some way counter what people say here, cutting at the corners and chipping away at the edges, while stopping short of an all out assult. Do you agree with boycotts or don't you? Do you think we should be a moral voice, a light on a hill for all to see, children of the light? Or should we just be quite about all this gay stuff and abortion? (See your democrats letter thread) . If you think they are only concerned about the bottom line then it seems to me a boycott is just the thing. "Would that you were hot or cold but that you are lukewarm I vomit you out of my sight" Where do you stand? I can't tell. [right][snapback]912204[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Are you asking me to write a manifesto of my beliefs regarding political activism and Christians?
thessalonian Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Mar 15 2006, 07:40 AM']Are you asking me to write a manifesto of my beliefs regarding political activism and Christians? [right][snapback]912221[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Do what you like. Keep it at self examination and off the boards if you like. But do something. Get off the beaver dam fence.
Sojourner Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 15 2006, 09:43 AM']Do what you like. Keep it at self examination and off the boards if you like. But do something. Get off the beaver dam fence. [right][snapback]912224[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well I find you annoying to. So there. : Edited to say: On second thought, maybe I will post a response here.
Norseman82 Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Mar 15 2006, 07:38 AM']When you think about it, to buy Ford isn't really to buy American anymore. It's hard to buy according to national loyalty or tell where a car comes from these days... given that parts are made from around the world and cars generally are assembled worldwide. [right][snapback]912218[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm aware of that, I was just doing it for humor sake... But keeping up with what brands everyone else says is immoral to buy or what should be boycotted is getting to be an impossible task. One minute we should buy American, next minute we can't buy American because of some boycott - but if we do boycott, then we are condemned for jobs moving overseas. We can't do anything right these days, it seems.
Sojourner Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 Thess, I have never voted Democrat in a presidential election. I am not now nor have I ever been a registered Democrat. Nor am I a registered Republican; I am registered with no political party. I avoid voting in the primaries specifically to avoid having to register. I have spent many, many years immersed in the conservative Christian subculture, although I only recently became Catholic. My experience in that (very politically active) culture has led me to seriously question many of the methods conservative Christians typically use to make their views known. Where I once would have supported boycotts as an effective means of getting a point across to companies, now I’m not so sure. Particularly when, as in this case, the ads have been out for more than two years. I think a well-organized, well-timed boycott could be quite effective. This boycott doesn’t seem to fall into that category. Instead, it seems to be aimed at getting people riled up at Ford without providing an effective means of addressing the situation. You’re a parent ... how effective is discipline when it happens two years after your child misbehaves? Is she going to truly learn from it that her behavior was wrong, or is she going to think that your discipline is a bit behind the times? This type of thing happens often, and frankly it makes us look stupid. When we don’t respond to things until years after they’ve happened, it makes any sort of action pointless in my book. Heck, I’ve seen threads here posted as being “news” dealing with things that, with a little digging, I found to be no longer accurate – more than four years behind the times in at least one case. And, in this case it seems pointless to just boycott Ford, when other companies have also been marketing to gay families -- some for much, much longer than Ford has been. That strikes me as someone having a beef with Ford rather than wanting to seriously address the issue at hand. So yes, I’m much more likely to question that validity of a call for action than immediately jump on board. It takes a little more than “the sky is falling” to get my adrenaline pumping. As a journalist, I spend a lot of time observing people in all walks of life, and I see Christians having an impact on their communities for good or for ill in all sorts of ways. I really struggle with how Christians should be involved in the public sector. To what extent should we force people who don’t believe as we do to follow our prescriptions for life? How can we communicate the truth in a loving way that encourages people toward repentance? How far should government go in legislating the beliefs of one segment of society? When it comes to abortion, I have no qualms about saying I am unabashedly pro-life in the fullest sense of that term. However, I think being pro-life means understanding the reasons people think they need to terminate a pregnancy. Until those underlying fears and concerns are addressed, there will not be an end to abortion in this country. Abortion existed before Roe and it will continue to exist as long as femininity, motherhood, and children are not valued in our society. I don’t have any qualms about being vocal and politically involved on this issue. I’m not sure what you mean by your reference to the Democrat statement thread, since you didn’t post in it, and I never said in there that I believe we should not be politically involved on this topic. Regarding homosexuality, I’m a little less eager to get into hardcore political activism. My view on this, as I’ve clearly stated in the past, is that government should stay out of the business of defining marriage altogether. That’s been argued and re-hashed to death. I don’t think gay “marriage” should be legal, but I also think government should keep its hands off defining marriage -- something which falls squarely into the province of the church. I also think Christians as a group have failed miserably at helping their brothers and sisters who struggle with homosexuality to find healing and wholeness. There’s definitely room for improvement in the way in which we address homosexuality, both in political and personal arenas. So do I think we should be a moral voice, a light on a hill for all to see, children of the light? Of course. I just don’t always agree with you on the mechanisms through which that voice and light should be displayed. Does this answer your questions?
rkwright Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 Soj look to what I posted earlier... there are many other car companies before Ford that ran gay ads... Saturn, Saab (both GM), Volkswagen, Subaru... Thess is right when he says (or will say) that it doesn't really detract from the current boycott and I agree there. The current one has good reasons. Either way, an unintentional double standard has been created. Why should Ford alone take the hit?? One cannot after reading that turn the blind eye anymore. A boycott of all companies who run gay ads is more consistant with its own position in my opinion.
thessalonian Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 (edited) Thank you for your clarification. I apologize for the democrat comments. I misjudged your positioning on these matters. It does help me better understand where you are coming from. As far as looking foolish, sometimes Christians have looked foolish in how they respond and sometimes they look foolish simply because the world is going to view them that way. We must distinguish between the two. I don't think your analogy is quite correct. If Ford is CURRENTLY still marketing to gays it would be like my kid getting in to a bad habbit, for instance not going to bed on time. I allow this to go on for 6 months and finally get some parental backbone and do something about it. This I do not find to be futile. I think that we should avoid buying from any company that is not consistent with Catholic moral teachings and have always, when choosing a brand given fair consideration to this in making a choice of one over another or none at all. I am glad this website has informed me about Ford, though hell would freeze over before I buy from them again anyway. My worst vehicle ever was a Ford Winstar and I hated my dad's Ford Pickups. I don't think we have much choice in the gay marriage issue but to try and force the state to set limits. Your Church setting the definition of marriage simply will not work in such a culture as we find ourselves in today. Societies need to make a stand. Marriage is an issue that needs to go accross religious bounds for obvious reasons of respecting spousal boundaries and norms. These are etched in each man's hearts according to Romans 2:15. But this is off topic so I will persue it no further. Edited March 15, 2006 by thessalonian
thessalonian Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 (edited) [quote name='rkwright' date='Mar 15 2006, 11:01 AM']Soj look to what I posted earlier... there are many other car companies before Ford that ran gay ads... Saturn, Saab (both GM), Volkswagen, Subaru... Thess is right when he says (or will say) that it doesn't really detract from the current boycott and I agree there. The current one has good reasons. Either way, an unintentional double standard has been created. Why should Ford alone take the hit?? One cannot after reading that turn the blind eye anymore. A boycott of all companies who run gay ads is more consistant with its own position in my opinion. [right][snapback]912498[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I honestly doudt the website would disagree with what you have said except the double standard thing. If I lash out at John Kerry about his statements on abortion, does that mean that I approve of Richard Gepharts position or that I have somehow given tacit approval to his or unduly attacked John Kerry's position. No. It means I am more informed about John Kerry's position seems more likely to me or perhaps have a more compelling reason for confronting him, such as this bozo is Catholic. No double standard. If I know about Gephart's position I give him the business as well. The mentioning of Ford by the website does not logically imply anything about their position on other companies and their support of a boycott against them as well. Edited March 15, 2006 by thessalonian
Sojourner Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 15 2006, 01:05 PM']Thank you for your clarification. I apologize for the democrat comments. I misjudged your positioning on these matters. It does help me better understand where you are coming from. As far as looking foolish, sometimes Christians have looked foolish in how they respond and sometimes they look foolish simply because the world is going to view them that way. We must distinguish between the two. [right][snapback]912508[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Agreed. No issue with any of this. [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 15 2006, 01:05 PM']I don't think your analogy is quite correct. If Ford is CURRENTLY still marketing to gays it would be like my kid getting in to a bad habbit, for instance not going to bed on time. I allow this to go on for 6 months and finally get some parental backbone and do something about it. This I do not find to be futile. I think that we should avoid buying from any company that is not consistent with Catholic moral teachings and have always, when choosing a brand given fair consideration to this in making a choice of one over another or none at all. I am glad this website has informed me about Ford, though hell would freeze over before I buy from them again anyway. My worst vehicle ever was a Ford Winstar and I hated my dad's Ford Pickups. [right][snapback]912508[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Right there with you on not buying a Ford anyway. I also agree, and have noted, that there needs to be a consistent approach to these companies, rather than singling out just one. By focusing on Ford to the exclusion of other companies doing the same thing, any boycott is less effective. And, as I've stated before, the boycott has to clearly show that it's in Ford's financial interest to kowtow to heterosexual families. I really don't think Ford has bowed to gay interests out of a desire to promote one lifestyle over another -- they're doing it because they are wanting to secure a legitimate market share there, and I'm guessing that the potential gain they see there is less than the losses they could face by siding with the AFA. [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 15 2006, 01:05 PM']I don't think we have much choice in the gay marriage issue but to try and force the state to set limits. Your Church setting the definition of marriage simply will not work in such a culture as we find ourselves in today. Societies need to make a stand. Marriage is an issue that needs to go accross religious bounds for obvious reasons of respecting spousal boundaries and norms. These are etched in each man's hearts according to Romans 2:15. But this is off topic so I will persue it no further. [right][snapback]912508[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I disagree with you here, but as it's been argued several other places we'll leave it at that.
Socrates Posted March 16, 2006 Posted March 16, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Mar 15 2006, 08:54 AM']Thess, I have never voted Democrat in a presidential election. I am not now nor have I ever been a registered Democrat. Nor am I a registered Republican; I am registered with no political party. I avoid voting in the primaries specifically to avoid having to register. I have spent many, many years immersed in the conservative Christian subculture, although I only recently became Catholic. My experience in that (very politically active) culture has led me to seriously question many of the methods conservative Christians typically use to make their views known. Where I once would have supported boycotts as an effective means of getting a point across to companies, now I’m not so sure. Particularly when, as in this case, the ads have been out for more than two years. I think a well-organized, well-timed boycott could be quite effective. This boycott doesn’t seem to fall into that category. Instead, it seems to be aimed at getting people riled up at Ford without providing an effective means of addressing the situation. You’re a parent ... how effective is discipline when it happens two years after your child misbehaves? Is she going to truly learn from it that her behavior was wrong, or is she going to think that your discipline is a bit behind the times? This type of thing happens often, and frankly it makes us look stupid. When we don’t respond to things until years after they’ve happened, it makes any sort of action pointless in my book. Heck, I’ve seen threads here posted as being “news” dealing with things that, with a little digging, I found to be no longer accurate – more than four years behind the times in at least one case. And, in this case it seems pointless to just boycott Ford, when other companies have also been marketing to gay families -- some for much, much longer than Ford has been. That strikes me as someone having a beef with Ford rather than wanting to seriously address the issue at hand. So yes, I’m much more likely to question that validity of a call for action than immediately jump on board. It takes a little more than “the sky is falling” to get my adrenaline pumping. As a journalist, I spend a lot of time observing people in all walks of life, and I see Christians having an impact on their communities for good or for ill in all sorts of ways. I really struggle with how Christians should be involved in the public sector. To what extent should we force people who don’t believe as we do to follow our prescriptions for life? How can we communicate the truth in a loving way that encourages people toward repentance? How far should government go in legislating the beliefs of one segment of society? When it comes to abortion, I have no qualms about saying I am unabashedly pro-life in the fullest sense of that term. However, I think being pro-life means understanding the reasons people think they need to terminate a pregnancy. Until those underlying fears and concerns are addressed, there will not be an end to abortion in this country. Abortion existed before Roe and it will continue to exist as long as femininity, motherhood, and children are not valued in our society. I don’t have any qualms about being vocal and politically involved on this issue. I’m not sure what you mean by your reference to the Democrat statement thread, since you didn’t post in it, and I never said in there that I believe we should not be politically involved on this topic. Regarding homosexuality, I’m a little less eager to get into hardcore political activism. My view on this, as I’ve clearly stated in the past, is that government should stay out of the business of defining marriage altogether. That’s been argued and re-hashed to death. I don’t think gay “marriage” should be legal, but I also think government should keep its hands off defining marriage -- something which falls squarely into the province of the church. I also think Christians as a group have failed miserably at helping their brothers and sisters who struggle with homosexuality to find healing and wholeness. There’s definitely room for improvement in the way in which we address homosexuality, both in political and personal arenas. So do I think we should be a moral voice, a light on a hill for all to see, children of the light? Of course. I just don’t always agree with you on the mechanisms through which that voice and light should be displayed. Does this answer your questions? [right][snapback]912269[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Ok, I realize this thread is hijacked beyond all return at this point, but there are some things here I thought I should respond to. I definitely see where Thessalonian is coming from on this one. While the reality may be more complex, your postings on Phatmass would give most people the impression you are rather liberal. You typically take the liberal position on most issues, and in general have little positive to say about conservatives or conservative ideas, and little negative to say about liberals or liberal ideas. This is not intended as a personal attack, simply an observation. While you generally seem quite critical of "Christian conservative" positions and tactics, this begs the question of how [b]do[/b] you believe the Christian/Catholic should act in matters of public policy? Do you believe all Christians should just stay out of politics as much as possible? Your language in this post sounds unfortunately like the typical liberal rhetoric that Christians should not "impose their values" on others. (ie. - "force people who don’t believe as we do to follow our prescriptions for life," "legislating the beliefs of one segment of society," etc.) It's not clear what specifically you are referring to, but this is the language secularist liberals typically use when opposing any laws that reflect Christian morality (such as laws against abortion, or not giving legal privileges to "gays," etc.). As for abortion, do you beleive in laws restricting abortion or overturning Roe v. Wade? Obviously, merely changing laws is not enough, but this is no reason to oppose working for change in this area. Contrary to liberal myth, abortion was not widely accepted and practiced prior to Roe. The main problem leading to the increased practice and acceptance of abortion was a moral one. Abortion and its acceptance is not caused chiefly by economics, as many liberals imply. A return to Christian standards of morality will be the primary "social factor" to end abortion. Also, while this has indeed been "argued to death" elsewhere, I find the rhetoric misleading regarding "gay marriage," etc., misleading. Voting against "gay marriage" does not give the state any new powers over marriage; it is simply keeping things the way they always were: marriage being only recognized as between a man and a woman. Nothing else used to be recognized by the state (or anybody) as marriage. It is the homosexual lobby that is trying to force their agenda on the state and society, not Christians. (We are merely standing up against the homosexualist assault.) [b]How do [/b]you recommend the Church and Christians deal with the homosexual problem? Are we simply to let the "gay lobby" redefine family and morality on their own terms and push their agenda as Christians sit silently on the sidelines? How indeed [b]should [/b]we "address homosexuality, both in political and personal arenas"? You seem to imply we should be more "nice" and "gentle" with the gay lobby and do nothing which might upset them. Society as a whole ("Christians" included) has gotten ever more "sympathetic" and "tolerant," yet the "gay" lobby presses ever onwards. This is a much bigger problem now than in the "old days" when homosexuality was regarded by nearly every Christian as a grave sin, and this was not even a public issue. Feel free to answer this in another thread, or even in pm or email, if you would prefer this not be discussed in the public arena. I feel these are important issues.
HisChild Posted March 16, 2006 Posted March 16, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Mar 15 2006, 08:54 AM'] Regarding homosexuality, I’m a little less eager to get into hardcore political activism. My view on this, as I’ve clearly stated in the past, is that government should stay out of the business of defining marriage altogether. That’s been argued and re-hashed to death. I don’t think gay “marriage” should be legal, but I also think government should keep its hands off defining marriage -- something which falls squarely into the province of the church. [right][snapback]912269[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm not sure I understand what you are saying here. When two people go to get married, they have to apply for a marriage license, provided by the state. There's no way around that. Therefore, if the state wants (because of the gay lobby) to change what they will allow on the application, meaning that they want to know allow two male or two female applicants to apply for license, I think we, as a Catholic voice need to stand up and say that's not acceptable. So, as Thess said, we really don't have a choice, do we? As long as the gay lobby continues to dig their claws into marital inclusiveness, we too have to stand up , as a voice and say Because, just because the Church sets limits and definitions, doesn't mean the state will go along.
ReinnieR Posted March 16, 2006 Posted March 16, 2006 [quote]i love my honda like i love my ganja i smoke a V8 like i smoke marijuana[/quote]
Sojourner Posted March 16, 2006 Posted March 16, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Mar 15 2006, 07:46 PM']Feel free to answer this in another thread, or even in pm or email, if you would prefer this not be discussed in the public arena. I feel these are important issues. [right][snapback]912890[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm sure you do feel they are important. I just don't care to discuss them with you. Thanks for asking, though.
Cow of Shame Posted March 20, 2006 Posted March 20, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' date='Mar 15 2006, 07:46 PM'] how [b]do[/b] you believe the Christian/Catholic should act in matters of public policy? Do you believe all Christians should just stay out of politics as much as possible? As for abortion, do you beleive in laws restricting abortion or overturning Roe v. Wade? [b]How do [/b]you recommend the Church and Christians deal with the homosexual problem? Are we simply to let the "gay lobby" redefine family and morality on their own terms and push their agenda as Christians sit silently on the sidelines? How indeed [b]should [/b]we "address homosexuality, both in political and personal arenas"? Feel free to answer this in another thread, or even in pm or email, if you would prefer this not be discussed in the public arena. I feel these are important issues. [right][snapback]912890[/snapback][/right] [/quote] How do you intent to solve world hunger? What are you doing to get rid of crippling poverty? Should we get rid of the penny? What is the question to life, the universe, and everything? [b]Who would win a fight to the death between Picard and Kirk?[/b] Sojourner, I feel these are important issues. Feel free to answer in this thread only.
ironmonk Posted March 20, 2006 Author Posted March 20, 2006 [quote name='Sojourner' date='Mar 14 2006, 03:03 PM'] Corporations are guided by no compass other than their bottom line. [right][snapback]911554[/snapback][/right] [/quote] It's amazing how little you know about corporations since you claim to write about them. You watch way too much TV or are a victim of the leftist fabrications in the media. Corporations are run by people. People have agendas. The people running corporations tend to use the corporations to support their agendas. Sitting down with with people for interivews is totally different than being around them 40-plus hours a week. God Bless, ironmonk
Cow of Shame Posted March 20, 2006 Posted March 20, 2006 [quote name='ironmonk' date='Mar 20 2006, 05:07 PM']Corporations are run by people. People have agendas. The people running corporations tend to use the corporations to support their agendas. [right][snapback]915900[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Exactly. Their agendas to make lots & lots of money.
Sojourner Posted March 21, 2006 Posted March 21, 2006 [quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Mar 20 2006, 04:02 PM']How do you intent to solve world hunger? What are you doing to get rid of crippling poverty? Should we get rid of the penny? What is the question to life, the universe, and everything? [b]Who would win a fight to the death between Picard and Kirk?[/b] Sojourner, I feel these are important issues. Feel free to answer in this thread only. [right][snapback]915828[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Feed people Nothing No I don't know, but the answer is 42. Picard. [quote name='ironmonk' date='Mar 20 2006, 05:07 PM']It's amazing how little you know about corporations since you claim to write about them. You watch way too much TV or are a victim of the leftist fabrications in the media. Corporations are run by people. People have agendas. The people running corporations tend to use the corporations to support their agendas. Sitting down with with people for interivews is totally different than being around them 40-plus hours a week. God Bless, ironmonk [right][snapback]915900[/snapback][/right] [/quote] What's so wrong about saying corporations are ultimately driven by their bottom lines? I don't understand why this is such a contentious statement. Any for-profit corporation has to, by definition, make a profit in order to stay in existence. If it doesn't make a profit, it goes under. No company is going to be going around willy-nilly giving away money without having some sort of profitable aim in mind. Corporate "gifts" are always given with the intent of somehow benefitting the corporate bottom line, by creating goodwill, increasing name recognition, and so on. This is true for any corporation, regardless of the whether the market they're trying to reach is conservative or liberal. A corporation's "agenda" is ultimately driven by $$$$.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now