jswranch Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 Is the following understanding correct? The church never declared the doctrine of Limbo. At best, it has been an idea or hypothosis. The question came to light by St. Thomas Aquinas who asked if baptism is necessary for salvation, what happens to those who die before baptism and the age of reason? The answer some theorized was the unbaptised before the age of reason were intrusted to the loving care of God for an eternity in a natural state of happiness. Such a state of eternal being became labeled limbo. In more recent times, a strong new argument has emerged which effectively eliminated the possibility of the existance of Limbo. The new argument contrasts the theory of Limbo with the dogma of the four final things. All face Death, Judgement, Heaven or Hell. Purgatory, which would be eternal, is not on that list. The dogma does not allow for Death, Judgement, Heaven, Hell or Purgatory. Therefore, limbo has effectively been rejected. Please comment.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 Actually, I think it first appeared with Augustine, not Aquinas.
jswranch Posted March 15, 2006 Author Posted March 15, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Mar 15 2006, 10:02 AM']Actually, I think it first appeared with Augustine, not Aquinas. [right][snapback]912342[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I stand corrected. I always mix up those two.
OLAM Dad Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 I agree with everything you posted up to where you say, [quote]In more recent times...[/quote] I don't believe that the Church has definitively proclaimed what happens to unbaptised babies who die. As such, to suggest that 'limbo' has been rejected is a bit presumptious.
thessalonian Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 While I personally don't find limbo to be a viable option, it has never been official doctrine, but speculative as far as I can see. To say that it has in any official or semi-official capacity rejected however is a stretch.
phatcatholic Posted March 15, 2006 Posted March 15, 2006 here's some articles on limbo, if anyone is interested: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/158"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/158[/url]
zunshynn Posted March 16, 2006 Posted March 16, 2006 I think limbo is absurd. Limbo is supposed to be "natural happiness" apart from God. Separation from God is what makes Hell hell. I don't care how much cookies and warm sunshine I get in eternity, if it isn't with God it is really gonna smell of elderberries. That said, I hope God is a fan of Italian food and Baklava
HisChild Posted March 16, 2006 Posted March 16, 2006 Chips n salsa too. LOL I'm not sure that's what He meant though, when He said we'd have a wedding feast.
jswranch Posted March 16, 2006 Author Posted March 16, 2006 [quote name='zunshynn' date='Mar 15 2006, 08:19 PM']I think limbo is absurd. Limbo is supposed to be "natural happiness" apart from God. Separation from God is what makes Hell hell... [right][snapback]912976[/snapback][/right] [/quote] You missunderstand. One is not apart from God in Limbo, just as one is not apart from God here in this life.
blovedwolfofgod Posted March 17, 2006 Posted March 17, 2006 umm.. im fairly certain that limbo was placed as the outermost circle of hell?
jswranch Posted March 18, 2006 Author Posted March 18, 2006 [quote name='blovedwolfofgod' date='Mar 17 2006, 03:35 PM']umm.. im fairly certain that limbo was placed as the outermost circle of hell? [right][snapback]914229[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes, I believe it was placed there by Dante, who's 'Inferno' is not considered to be inspired. His opinion is not shared by any formal level of the magisterium. A definition of Limbo as an an eternal state of natural happiness sounds better than our lives here on earth.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now