thessalonian Posted March 19, 2006 Posted March 19, 2006 (edited) I got in to a firefight on another board about Peter never being in Rome. The "most persuasive" arguement they have is that the Bible doesn't tell us he was. The also use the arguement that Peter was "apostle to the Jews". I think the following that hit me recently is a solid rebuttal and I haven't heard it before so I wanted to share it with you in case you run in to this nonsense. Am I missing something here or is this arguement as plain as the nose on my face. Thoughts? It has been said in this thread that Peter was to be the Apostle to the gentiles and therefore he no longer at some point had a ministry to the gentiles but to the Jews alone. Seems we have a bit of a problem however. In making this arguement, those who use it fail to notice an important thing. Paul, the note is to be the Apostle to the gentiles. In using good for the goose and gander logical application, therefore if being "apostle to" means that the ministry is limited to that group, then why does Paul preach in ephuses, thessalonica, and berea to JEWS. Why does he write the book of HEBREWS. Some might say he preached to jews before he was declared apostle to the gentiles. All well and good but the book of hebrews was written AFTER he was declared apostle to the Jews. Another problematic point of illuded to with my example of Martin Luther above. I will make a similar arguement that should hit closer to home for those bible students. The Bible is really silent on who wrote Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John as well as Hebrews for that matter. Those books do not identify their author. Some speculation might be made of course using parts of the text. But no definitive statements can be made. The titles of the boods i.e. "the Gospel of John" were a tradition carried on. They were not penned by the writers themselvs. Now in some sense this is not that important. It is the message that is important. But in anothre it is. For the councils that were guided by the Holy Spirit to the conclusion that the books we now have in the New Testament are the Word of God made their decision in part on the basis of the witness. Therefore they used the same historical authors that I am in arguing that Peter was in Rome for some time. Another matter the Bible is silent on. There is no verse that says he was in Rome. But there is no verse that says he wasn't. And we know that he did go to Anitoch so he did not always stay in Jerusalemn. Historical records indicate he was in Antioch for at least a few years. The bottom line is that where the bible is silent we do have historical records that are quite reliable in the naming of the books where scripture is silent. We also have historical records from many people in distant lands who had little contact with one another. Why do we fight so hard to ignore them and say Peter was never in Rome based on an arguement of silence, a poor logical position, from scripture. Does it hurt the Protestant doctrinal position? It shouldn't really. But this quesion of Peter being in Rome must bother you alot because it sure comes up on sites such as this one alot. Food for thought. God bless. Edited March 19, 2006 by thessalonian
phatcatholic Posted March 19, 2006 Posted March 19, 2006 i think this is a good argument. two other points i would add: 1. along with showing where Paul ministered to Jews, you could also show where Peter ministered to gentiles. it was Peter who received the vision from the Lord that gentiles should be brought into the fold, and after that vision he went and baptized Cornelius. this is just one instance i can think of off the top of my head. there are probably a few others too. 2. Peter's presence in Rome is an [i]historical[/i] matter, not a doctrinal one. thus, unless we are to assume that the bible was meant to be an exhaustive history book, we should not expect it to inform us of [i]all[/i] matters of historical importance. when u want to know what happened a long time ago, u look to ancient documents and witness. granted, the bible is such a source, but so is also the writings of our earliest Christians. note that we aren't turning to them to settle some matter of doctrine or b/c we think they are infallible or above Scripture. we are simply doing what all historians do when they want information on centuries past. i hope that helps pax christi, phatcatholic
thessalonian Posted March 19, 2006 Author Posted March 19, 2006 (edited) Thanks phat. Your input is always appreciated. 1) I had previously made that arguement. I brought up Cornelisu and also where Peter was ministering to the Jews in Antioch and then when some Jewish Christian leaders showed up he started catering to the Jews as written in Gal 2. He countered that it was BEFORE supposedly Paul was declared minister to the gentiles. l That precipitated my thoughts above. I also showed historical evidence that there were at least 40,000 Jews in Rome so the point stands. If there were Jews there then Peter was needed there as well. Edited March 19, 2006 by thessalonian
phatcatholic Posted March 19, 2006 Posted March 19, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 19 2006, 02:06 PM']Thanks phat. Your input is always appreciated. [right][snapback]915126[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Lord knows i'm good at giving input......
thessalonian Posted March 20, 2006 Author Posted March 20, 2006 1) I had previously made that arguement. I brought up Cornelisu and also where Peter was ministering to the Jews in Antioch and then when some Jewish Christian leaders showed up he started catering to the Jews as written in Gal 2. He countered that it was BEFORE supposedly Paul was declared minister to the gentiles. l That precipitated my thoughts above. I also showed historical evidence that there were at least 40,000 Jews in Rome so the point stands. If there were Jews there then Peter was needed there as well.
thessalonian Posted March 23, 2006 Author Posted March 23, 2006 Another observation. I've been asked many times why Paul didn't mention Peter in Romans. The whole letter is geared toward gentile Christians. If we look at the list of names that Paul greet's, allegedly neglecting Peter, they are Roman/Gentile names(except perhaps Mary), consistent with the gentile tone of the letter. He is addressing the gentile Christians. If Paul was the Apostle to the Jews then he would not according to the way they use this fact, have been among the gentile Christians.
thessalonian Posted March 23, 2006 Author Posted March 23, 2006 By the way when they claim that Peter was never in Rome because he was apostle to the Jews, Acts 28 shows there were Jews in Rome.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted March 24, 2006 Posted March 24, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Mar 23 2006, 03:00 PM']By the way when they claim that Peter was never in Rome because he was apostle to the Jews, Acts 28 shows there were Jews in Rome. [right][snapback]919234[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Judaism had some followers in Rome, including converts. It was not at all unusual for Roman citizens to take great interest in Eastern religions and cults and there were certainly Jews in Rome.
jswranch Posted March 28, 2006 Posted March 28, 2006 Question#1: Who was the first man to step foot on the moon? Answer: Neil Armstrong Rebuttle: Where is that in the bible? How can you proclaim it as truth? Response: The lunar landing was after the Apostles died. Question#2: When did the Romans destroy the Temple of Jerusalem? Answer: Approx 72AD. Rebuttle: Where is that in the bible? It did happen before the Apostles died. Response:......!!!!!!
missionseeker Posted March 30, 2006 Posted March 30, 2006 Maybe you could google scavi tour of the Vatican. It's the mosuleums underneath and all. When I was in Rome, I saw it and there is so much evidence of Peter burried there/ having been there. It's been three years though so I couldn't tell you all that's under there. But there may be some website that has that and that might help.
thessalonian Posted March 30, 2006 Author Posted March 30, 2006 [quote name='missionseeker' date='Mar 29 2006, 09:50 PM']Maybe you could google scavi tour of the Vatican. It's the mosuleums underneath and all. When I was in Rome, I saw it and there is so much evidence of Peter burried there/ having been there. It's been three years though so I couldn't tell you all that's under there. But there may be some website that has that and that might help. [right][snapback]927978[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I heard some of this on Catholic radio one day. They said the feet were cut off (and missing) and this was consistent with Peter being crucified upside down. Also that there was purple dye associated with the body indicating it was someone of great importance. As I recall there was an inscription with Peter's name on it as well. A rather uncommon name back then. It was directly under the new altar which was built directly under the old altar to the milimeter. It is a longstanding Catholic tradition to have a relic of a saint buried directly under the altar. Wish I remembered more as well.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now