Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Altar Girls... And Latin Mass?


Recommended Posts

On Pilgrimage
Posted

[quote name='Era Might']I worked with girls when I was an altar server. I didn't feel my manhood was threatened by it.[/quote]
In defense of those who disagree with female altar servers (even though I think female altar servers are fine), it's not a sexist thing. Since altar service was formerly connected to the priesthood and was used to encourage priestly vocations, and since the Church is suffering a priestly vocation shortage, some Catholics believe that altar service should be reserved to men in order to once again connect it to the priesthood and encourage young men who serve at the altar to discern a vocation to the priesthood.

And of course, there are some Catholics who don't want female altar servers because they're sexists and think women are too unclean to be in the sanctuary. And probably still others whose manhood is threatened by women serving in lay ecclesial ministry. But I don't think you'll find many of those at Phatmass.

Posted

I was considering the Priesthood when I was an altar server, and the presence of female altar servers never affected my interest in the Priesthood. I don't think kids think about those kinds of ecclesio-political questions. Maybe I was just blessedly ignorant back then. :disguise: :blush:

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Rick777' date='Mar 21 2006, 06:04 PM']I'm not a fan of altar girls..................IDK just me.
[right][snapback]916936[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

me neither

Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Mar 21 2006, 10:18 PM']Robes?  Did someone mention robes?

"Aight, I put on my robe and wizard hat."
[right][snapback]917495[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I'm pretty sure I was the only person who got that...

Posted

[quote name='Keyser Soze' date='Mar 21 2006, 06:42 PM']Everyone knows that girls should be in the kitchen.
[right][snapback]917250[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

so totally true :D:

insert :barefoot_pregnant: smiley :saint:

Posted

Our parish will start having the Old Latin Mass! (Hopefully with no altar girls)

JudgedByGod
Posted

yeah, there definitely is only one trindetine mass in maine that i know of, and that's at the cathedral. i should see about getting one started in my area, since it's the next most populated, and we have a basilica.

crazymaine catholic
Posted

wow, ok, so that last post by JudgedByGod was definitely me. she was signed on on my computer, and never logged out, so that last post was definitely mine. whoops! :P:

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='jiyoung' date='Mar 22 2006, 02:46 AM']I'm pretty sure I was the only person who got that...
[right][snapback]917578[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

10 points to jiyoung!

prodigalson
Posted

Its an important question to ponder! One that should be taken quite seriously- the fact of the matter is that, although it may not be easy to hear for some, the Church is Patriarchal- Led by men. The position of altar server should be reserved for man because someday he might be celebrating on that altar- something a woman will never do. Does any of this make her inferior- certainly not! The Church has been the greatest protector of true femininity and feminism! It is also worth mentioning that the priests and altar servers are the only people on the altar during the consecration! Isn't it the natural flow for young men to be there with their father- certainly in my secular life there are certain things that only the men of the household did and my sisters weren't allowed to come. I think its a perfectly normal mirror in the spiritual life. Its healthy and normal for men to have time and specific jobs they do with their Fathers.

Posted

and what about helping female vocations? They can be as influenced as men. (it is a usual argument against it)

(that does not say i support either side, only asking the question that some others fail to do.)

prodigalson
Posted

That's also a great point! And I'm not sure what the answer is. Women's vocations are so awesome and help immensly to build the church. I geuss women should foster a true love and devotion to the consecrated Eucharist and to serve the church in any other ways they can because this will usually be the common lifestyle of their vocation.

argent_paladin
Posted

First, the theory:
I am in favor of altar boys only. It is a simple fact that women, at every age, are more responsible, reliable and consitent than men. Thus, when altar servers are opened to girls, they tend to crowd out the boys, who tend to be less mature.
Also, psychologically, when girls become the majority, boys see it as a "girl thing" and don't want to do it anymore. One can see this phenomenon in other ecclesial communities that have female "priests". In many of there diocese, there are fewer and fewer men being ordained an it is being taken over by women. That is actually a definite danger. We must not feminize the Church too much (although acknowleding that the Church is feminine.) What I mean is that in many cultures men between the ages of 18 and 50 don't go to mass at all and mass is seen as the province of women and effeminate men. Allowing altar girls only makes this worse.
The reason that it is important to have altar boys is because the Eucharist is the heart of the priestly vocation. Think about it, a layperson can do most other things: baptize (in emergencies), witness marriage, counsel, teach, missionize, canon law, etc. The main, daily difference of ordination is the confecting of the Eucharist. And were did most priests get their first exposure to the mystery and beauty of this sacrament? Serving at the altar.
I am not proposing a ban, but if we want to encourage vocations to the priesthood, we should make sure that boys know what priests do and who they are, the best way for this is for them to be altar servers.
Religious vocations for women are far more wideranging and altar serving is not a very good preparation for much of it.

On the practical, political level- some level of female altar servers has already been practiced in this diocese. Most of the priests are very conservative and will probably not change their practice. Several, however, will. But this allows us to compare the differing practices of the parishes and what results from it.
And, I said the pairing was brilliant because it gives something to each side so it is hard to complain. Both practices are are allowed with permission from the bishop, so it can't be criticized from an authority aspect. You can only criticize it from the prudential standpoint, as I just did. But the proof is in the pudding from these arguments. Ten years from now, if there are no vocations from the parishes that have altar girls, and if few boys want to become altar boys anymore, then we will have our proof.
Also, if the indult masses are packed with people, perhaps the bishop will allow more parishes to offer them.
I am sad in that this diocese is one of the only ones not to have altar girls. And I think that Benedict will soon allow all pastors to offer indult masses, without their bishop's permission. But we shall see.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Mar 21 2006, 09:00 PM']I don't have a problem with this.  All the real Catholics will start attending the TLM anyway and the fake Catholics can sing Haugen songs, celebrate LifeTeen, and oogle the altar girls.
[right][snapback]917274[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Amen!

Posted

they should have altar girls at the Latin Mass :mellow:

JudgedByGod
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 23 2006, 05:39 PM']they should have altar girls at the Latin Mass :mellow:
[right][snapback]919508[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Enough tradition has been taken away by allowing altar girls at NO. Latin Mass embraces tradition and it should remain that way.

Posted

i'm pretty sure i was joking :mellow:

JudgedByGod
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Mar 23 2006, 05:47 PM']i'm pretty sure i was joking :mellow:
[right][snapback]919534[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Sorry. It just didn't appear that way when I first read it. :doh:

Posted

umm, yeah :mellow: i'm just playing today :)

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

we had altar girls at the Novus Ordo mass before the TLM at mass once. it was crazy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...