HomeTeamFamily Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 i dont know whether or not to put this in this section or the debate section but i figured id start here to get only catholics first lol im struggling with the notion of free will as it relates to the idea that God does not send people to hell. i understand the idea that he does not force us to make any decisions and what not but if he is omniscent, doesnt he know who is going to hell? why would he allow someone to go to hell? hopefully this will get things started, im sure the rest of my thoughts will come out as it evolves thanks pham gaaaa can a mod move this to the regular apologetics board grrrr
Paphnutius Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 (edited) [quote name='VoloHumilisEsse' date='Mar 28 2006, 09:54 PM']i understand the idea that he does not force us to make any decisions and what not but if he is omniscent, doesnt he know who is going to hell?[/quote]Yes. [quote]why would he allow someone to go to hell? [/quote]He loves us that much. I understand this may sound strange but perhaps an analogy will be of use. Let us say that a parent knows that his child is straying away from the family and wishes to bring the child back in. While the parent cannot make the choice for the child, the parent does what is in his power as a father to welcome the child and bring him home. The child may still wish to be self-absorbed and abandon the family for whatever reason. The parent, out of his love for his child, must let the child go his own way although he knows the consequences. Substitute God for the parent. God loves us and will do everything He can to bring us closer to Him, but we must still make that choice and cooperate with His grace. Edited March 29, 2006 by Paphnutius
HomeTeamFamily Posted March 29, 2006 Author Posted March 29, 2006 but the parent does not know, above all, that his child wont come back
Paphnutius Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 [quote name='VoloHumilisEsse' date='Mar 28 2006, 10:55 PM']but the parent does not know, above all, that his child wont come back [right][snapback]926458[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Omniscience is not essential in the analogy. The parent does not have to know with certainty that the child will not come back for the parent to still allow the kid to go his own way.
thessalonian Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 The fact of the matter is that God gives ALL men ALL the grace that they need for their own personal salvation. Thus we cannot say that God sends men to hell any more than we can say that God caused sin because he created men. He created men whom he allows to sin. He allows them to go there. Primarily by their actions and deeds in this life in rejection of his grace. All men recieve grace and they are accountable for what they recieve and do not put to use in their salvation. Even the aboriginee out in Austrailia can see in nature that there is a God and so has some responsibility to direct his life according to the dictates of the law planted on his heart (romans 2:14-15). These laws themselves are on his heart by grace.
heyyoimjohnny Posted March 29, 2006 Posted March 29, 2006 (edited) It's all been said. But I figure I'll say it in my own words. The people who go to Heaven say to God, "Thy will be done." The people who go to hell, God says to them, "thy will be done." It's a choice. Getting sent to hell comes from a conscious turning away from God and His grace. We all know that a mortal sin, a conscious turning away from God that destroys our sactifying grace, requires full knowledge to commit. Since we were all created for love, this free will, this ability to say yes or no to His grace, needs to exist. Paph said it in a sentence, "because He loves us so much." Unfortunately, not everyone has the knowledge that a mortal sin is a mortal sin. This seems pretty gray to me. It also seems this is where the concience would kick in, since that's what it comes down to. But anyways. Sorry, I ramble. Basic point. He lets people go to hell because they choose to. It hurts Him. I heard a priest say part of Christ's agony in the garden came from the knowledge that not everyone would accept His grace and be saved. But for God to take that choice away would also take love out of the equasion, since free will is necessary for love. So He'd contradict Himself. Haha... I posted my thoughts for the sake of clarity (I think along my own lines, unfortunately...), but I'm afraid they'll cause more confusion! Edited March 29, 2006 by heyyoimjohnny
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 12, 2006 Author Posted April 12, 2006 but the fact remains that God knows that some people will choose Hell
heyyoimjohnny Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 Correct. And He lets them make that choice, because if He interfered, it would remove that person's free will. And free will is necessary for love; it needs to be a choice, and He gives the people the freedom of that choice, whether He likes the choice they make or not.
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 19, 2006 Author Posted April 19, 2006 so God knows who is going to hell then
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now