Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

A thoughtprovoking video about religion...


Recommended Posts

Guest ThePiff
Posted

and it's pretty funny, too!

[url="http://www.rejectionhurts.com/ejectorpew.php"] Ejected by god! [/url]

i hope none of you will get offended by this and that you people will like it :ninja:

Posted

ACtually, I don't find it offensive. It is always too easy to forget that sometimes what we say and do can hurt others - right or not.

It is just as important if not more so to be accepting of others as it is to follow a correct doctrine and this video can be a reminder of this.

On the other hand, if the 'shared' stories are used to drag religions in the mud, that would make me very angry. But no one ever does that - right?

JudgedByGod
Posted

Eh, the video was kind of funny, but definitely didn't have a very Catholic outcome. Sure, we need to be tolerant of people in the sense that we need to help them to understand the Truth and to repent. However, after reading the stories on their homepage, the United Church of Christ is trying to get everyone to live in sin and feel ok with it. Oh, and putting the mother with the crying baby on the same level as the gay couple....defintely not cool!

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='JudgedByGod' date='Apr 3 2006, 06:23 AM']Oh, and putting the mother with the crying baby on the same level as the gay couple....defintely not cool!
[right][snapback]933819[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

You know there are plenty of people at church who give parents with fussy kids the evil eye....

JudgedByGod
Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Apr 5 2006, 12:27 AM']You know there are plenty of people at church who give parents with fussy kids the evil eye....
[right][snapback]936117[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I know. People do need to be more tolerant of these precious children, but I still don't like how it was portrayed in the video.

Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Apr 4 2006, 10:27 PM']You know there are plenty of people at church who give parents with fussy kids the evil eye....
[right][snapback]936117[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I usually smile at the crying child and parent, because that baby is another Catholic, and evil eyes very rarely help the situation at all.

The only thing worse then an evil eye in a Church is when some one who talks the whole way through Mass, then after you politely ask them to be quite they give you the evil eye while talking about you and steaks during the consecration.

AND

the Video game sounds boring. I would rather play hours of Microsoft Flight simulator.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

It's funny to read the FAQs regarding the video:

[url="http://www.stillspeaking.com/campaign/faq06.htm"]http://www.stillspeaking.com/campaign/faq06.htm[/url]
[quote][b]Why is the non-minority family again portrayed as "the villain"?[/b]
Again, the appearance, the clothing, the manner are all symbols of privilege that viewers understand. [i]Viewers in the focus groups "got it" instantly.[/i] However, in response to many who have raised this question and because we believe that it is not fair to always portray this family solely in that light, we are committed to "redeeming" this stereotype in the next ad. Your continued support is critical to moving forward with the next and most likely final ad of the campaign.[/quote]

The United Church of Christ (UCC) decided to make the villians a traditional whitey husband/wife/child family. According to the website, their being the villians was clearest to their focus group.

Then, after admitting that they are reinforcing this negative stereotype, they say that they're going to "redeem" the stereotype in the next ad. While I first optimistically thought that this would mean that they were shown in a positive way, I am now starting to think that "redemption" will more probably come in the form of "whitey" coming to repentance for all the wrongs of humanity, walking with his tail between his legs.

Imagine if the focus group held another stereotype. Maybe, all Jews are cheap to the focus group. Maybe, the focus group stereotypes blacks as uneducated. Would these negative stereotypes be exploited because the focus group "got it instantly," only to be "redeemed" in a possible future video?

Ironically, the purpose of the commercial is to communicate that the UCC is not judgmental regarding things like race or sexuality; but the commercial [i]attacks[/i] certain races and sexualities as an offering to the media god of clear communication.

Oh...and their final disclaimer in the quote above: if they don't get around to making the next video to "redeem" whitey, it is [i]your [/i]fault (not the UCC's!), because you didn't support them financially.

Does all this say something about our culture and the UCC's negative bias against traditional marriage or what?

One final comment. For people that think that religion is all about arts & crafts, picnics, and feminist causes, the UCC is for you! For everyone else, the UCC is keeping a little secret: you are [u]not[/u] welcome in their church.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

PS: It is sad that the originator of this thread "ThePiff" may likely have come here just to spam Phatmass and get a buzz going for this video.

:spam: :spam_sign: :spam: :spam_sign: :spam:

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...