Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Question about Mary as co redemptor


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

This is a statement of a protestant who was asking questions about our Catholic perspective on Mary.

[quote]It is my understanding that Pope John Paul II made it "official" that Mary is "co-redemptor" with Christ. THAT my friends, is BLASPHEMY![/quote]

I realize the Catechism refers to Mary as Mediatrix. But is the above statement accurate? Did Pope John Paul II officially proclaim that Mary is co-redemptor with Christ?

I really would appreciate your help with answering this question.

Edited by Fearful 1
Brother Adam
Posted

It is doctrine, but not dogma. And why is it blasphemy? Your friend doesn't know his Catholic doctrine. Only what his anti-catholic preachers are teaching him. What is wrong with saying Mary was the woman with the redeemer? The Catholic Church does not teach that Mary is another Jesus or a Savior.

Posted

well...the title is Co-redemptorix, not co-redemptor ...there is a gramatical nuance with that, which I am not exactly sure....JP2 referred to her using that title i believe 6 times. Though none of them were "ex cathedra" (sitting on the chair, teaching infalliably on faith and morals.)

The title means that Mary particpates in the act of redemption WITH (hence where the co- comes from) Christ not taking his place. All Christians in a way are called to particpatate in redemption.

This title is not defined dogma of the church. A person isn't in sin or a bad catholic if they don't belive it. Though I do.

There have been some who hoped it wouldn;t be defined dogmatically for some reasons including how divisive a term it could be for our protestant brothers and sister.

i hope this helps.

in Christ and Mary,
fr. Matt

phatcatholic
Posted

more info on mary as mediatrix and co-redemptrix:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/16"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/16[/url]

Posted

As a recent convert, there were two perspectives on Mary that got me through. Instead of trying to understand Mariology from the top down (from protestant perspective to Immaculate Conception), I tried to relearn it in the same way it evolved in the church, beginning with the early chruch.

1. The early church believed her to be the Ark of the New Covenant from very early on. How did the OT Jews treat the Ark of the Old Covenant? If true, what would this mean? As the new covenant is so much greater than the old, the new ark is so much greater also. Check out Rev 11-12. The ark is Mary. For Marian devotion, as the Jews took the Ark into battle against their enemies, so Catholics invite Mary to join them in their battle against evil (darkness, suffering, lack of faith etc..)

2. The new Eve. Catholics believe there were 4 people immaculatly conceived. Protestants agree on 3 of those. The old adam and eve were brought into this world without any stain of sin, so was the New Adam (Jesus). What about the New Eve? Was there one? The early church emphatically agreed yes! Mary is the new eve.

Accepting these two tenants [u]can[/u] be used as a foundation for understanding all other Marian doctrines. The next title to work with would be Theotokos.

Hope this helps

Posted

Your friend is [u]partially [/u]onto something with the 'BLASPHEMY' accusation that needs to be explored. Non-catholics throw the term around alot when refering to catholic veneration of saints, marian devotion, adoration of the blessed sacrament. They are correct [b][u]if[/u][/b] catholic dogmas are untrue. If Christ is not truely transubstantiated in the eucharist, then the worship Catholics perform to it is Blasphemy. But, if christ is transubstantiated, then all others are really missing out.

You can guess where I stand on these issues.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...