Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='dspen2005' date='Apr 3 2006, 02:01 PM']the schism??? aren't we forgetting the very CATHOLIC notion of preserving the unity of the Church...
[right][snapback]934298[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


sorry guys. i meant to say it would be great for a universal indult. mea culpa!


Sam

Myles Domini
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Apr 3 2006, 08:23 PM']sorry guys. i meant to say it would be great for a universal indult. mea culpa!
Sam
[right][snapback]934406[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I believe the universal indult is on the way. As for its practical impact... :idontknow: I should hope its revival would lead to a re-emphasis on liturgics in the seminaries so that our clergy may be formed to have a deep love and comprehension of the nature of the Mass. I remain skeptical about it bringing about reconciliation with the SSPX. Certainly some elements of the SSPX will be very happy and see it as an olive branch but to some others I fear it will be regarded as too little, too late or simply not enough.

Posted
:woot:

regardless of whether the SSPX will come back due to this, I still think it's a very good thing.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

they will not.

Posted

JMJ
4/3 - Fifth Monday of Lent

It will be interesting to see where Benedikt goes with this one. Read this...

[quote]I well know the sensibilities of those faithful who love [the 1962 Missal] - these are, to some extent, my own sensibilites.  And in that sense, I can well understand what Professor Spaemann was saying when he asserted that if you do not know the aim of a reform, however small it may be, if you are left to suppose that this is just an intermediate step towards a complete revolution, then people fell sensitive about it.  And in that sense we ahve to be very careful about any possible changes.  However, he did also say - and I emphasize this - it would be fatal for the old Liturgy to be, as it were, placed in a deep-freeze, left like a national park, a park protected for the sake of a certain kind of people, for whom one leave abailable these relics of the past.  This would be - as Professor de Mattei said to us - a kind of inculturation: 'There are also the conservationists, let that group have their own cultural version!'  If it were to be reduced to the past in that way, we would not be preserving this treasure for the Church of today, and that of tomorrow.  It seems to be that we should avoid, come what may, having this Liturgy frozen, as if in a deep-freeze, just for a certain type of people.

It must also be a Liturgy [i]of the Church[/i], and under the authoirty of the Church; and only within this [i]ecclesial dimension[/i], in a [i]fundamental[/i] relationship with the authority of the Chuch, can it give all that it has to offer.  Naturally, one can say, 'We no longer have any confidence in the authority of the Church, after all we have been through in the past thirty years.'  It is nevertheless a basic Catholic principle to trust in the authority of the Church.  I have always been much impressed by something Harnack said in a discussion with Peterson, a Protestant theologian who at that time was moving towards converting to Catholicism; Harnack answered the questions of his younger colleague by saying: it is obvious that the Catholic principle of [i]Scripture and Tradition[/i] is better, and that it is the correct principle, and that ti implies the existence of a given authority in the Church; but even if the principle in itself, the Catholic principle, is correct, we are better off living without an authority and without the actions such an authority might take.  He had confidence that the free use of reason in studying the Scriptures would bring men to the truth, and that this was better than being subject to some authority which could equally make mistakes.  That is true, authority can make mistakes, but being obedient to that authority is for us the guarantee of our being obedient to the Lord.  That is certainly a very strong admonition to those people who are exercising authority, not to exercise it in the way you exercise power.  Having authority in the Church is always an exercise in obedience.  When the Holy Father decided that the Church does not have the power to ordain women, this was an exercise in obedience towards the great Tradition of the Church and towards the Holy Spirit.  For me, it is always most interesting to see the keenest progressives and the fiercest opponents of the Church's Magisterium saying to us, 'Why, no, of course the Church can perfectly well do that!  You ought to make use of the pwoers you have available!' - No, the Church can not do everything, the Pope can not do everything.  It seems to me that, towards an authority which in the present situation is becoming more than ever a conscious exercise in obedience, everyone can have, [i]must[/i] have such confidence.

To speak more in concrete, pratical terms, I am not going to do anything in this sphere for the moment - that is clear.  But, for the future, we ought to think - it seems to me - in terms of enriching the Missal of 1962 by introducing some new saints; there are now some important figures amongst the saints - I am thinking, for example, of Maximilian Kolbe, Edith Stein, the martyrs of Spain, the martyrs of Ukraine, and so many others - but also thinking of that little Bakita in the Sudan, who came from slavery and came to freedom in her faith in the Lord; there are many really lovely figures whom we all [i]need[/i].  Thus, opening-up the calendar of the old Missal to new saints, making a well thought-out choice of these, that seems to me something which would be appropriate at present, and would not have any destructive effect on the fabric of the Liturgy.  We might also think about the Prefaces, which also come from the storehouse of wealth in the Church Fathers, for Advent, for example, and then others; why not insert those Prefaces in the old Missal?

Thus, with great sensitivity, and by showing a great deal of understanding for people's fears and preoccupations, maintaining contact with their leaders, we should be able to understand that this Missal is also a Missal [i]of the Church[/i], and under the authority of the Church, that it is not an object preserved from the past, but a living reality within the Church, [i]very much[/i] respected in its particular identity and for its historical stature, but equally considered as something which is living, and not as a dead thing, a relic of the past.  All the Liturgy of the Church is always a living thing, a reality which is higher than us, and is not subject to our decisions and our arbitrary intentions.[/quote]

-J. Ratzinger, [i]Looking Again at the Question of the Liturgy with Cardinal Ratzinger: Proceedings of the July 2001 Fontgombault Liturgical Conference[/i], 152-3.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...