Paphnutius Posted April 7, 2006 Posted April 7, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' date='Apr 6 2006, 08:42 PM']I know Ratzinger wrote it was as CDF. Does it not require the assertion as BXVI to be a settled matter. [right][snapback]938402[/snapback][/right] [/quote] You've lost me...I would say that it is a grave matter. I could be mistaken, but I will look into it. Generally all sexual matters are grave due to their nature.
Theoketos Posted April 7, 2006 Posted April 7, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' date='Apr 6 2006, 08:42 PM']I know Ratzinger wrote it was as CDF. Does it not require the assertion as BXVI to be a settled matter. [right][snapback]938402[/snapback][/right] [/quote] NOPE~! It is a matter for Moral Law not revelation, so the Pope does not need to settle the matter. And Nick, forgive me if I am ignorant, but as I uderstand it procreation is indeed the first cause for marriage, but the unitive aspect has equal dignity. I will post more later, but I promised my wife that I would be in bed before midnight.
Ziggamafu Posted April 7, 2006 Author Posted April 7, 2006 wait...what? what's the grave matter we're talking about? jswranch's post threw me off, lol! o_0
phatcatholic Posted April 7, 2006 Posted April 7, 2006 [quote name='Theoketos' date='Apr 6 2006, 11:21 PM']And Nick, forgive me if I am ignorant, but as I uderstand it procreation is indeed the first cause for marriage, but the unitive aspect has equal dignity. I will post more later, but I promised my wife that I would be in bed before midnight.[right][snapback]938539[/snapback][/right][/quote] well, the passages i have been posting seem to indicate otherwise, and i'm not sure if our more recent documents from the second vatican council and john paul II were meant to change this understanding. for now, i guess i am undecided (does that make [i]me[/i] the ignorant one? )
Ziggamafu Posted April 7, 2006 Author Posted April 7, 2006 (edited) yeah...could this be an issue that was never formally defined and thus subject to change? that's what my friend says...I've just developed the habit (probably unfortunate) of automatically writing off ANY doctrinal statement by a liberal as suspect. on social or health issues, it's pretty much reversed but on doctrinal or moral issues, I would never trust a liberal. Edited April 7, 2006 by Ziggamafu
Paphnutius Posted April 7, 2006 Posted April 7, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Apr 6 2006, 09:23 PM']wait...what? what's the grave matter we're talking about? jswranch's post threw me off, lol! o_0 [right][snapback]938552[/snapback][/right] [/quote] [quote]Is it correct to say the use of contraception is a grave matter?[/quote]
phatcatholic Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [b]Arcanum (On Christian Marriage)[/b] [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/ENCYC/L13CMR.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/ENCYC/L13CMR.HTM[/url] Pope Leo XIII[list][b]10.[/b] Furthermore, the Christian perfection and completeness of marriage are not comprised in those points only which have been mentioned. For, first, there has been vouchsafed to the marriage union a higher and nobler purpose than was ever previously given to it. By the command of Christ, it not only looks to the propagation of the human race, but to the bringing forth of children for the Church, "fellow citizens with the saints, and the domestics of God";[16] so that "a people might be born and brought up for the worship and religion of the true God and our Savior Jesus Christ."[17] [/list]
Era Might Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 (edited) Pope Paul VI writes in "Humanae Vitae": [quote]And finally this love is fecund for it is not exhausted by the communion between husband and wife, but is destined to continue, raising up new lives. "Marriage and conjugal love are by their nature ordained toward the begetting and educating of children. Children are really the supreme gift of marriage and contribute very substantially to the welfare of their parents."[/quote] He goes on: [quote]And if each of these essential qualities, the unitive and the procreative, is preserved, the use of marriage fully retains its sense of true mutual love and its ordination to the supreme responsibility of parenthood to which man is called.[/quote] Notice that he calls them both "essential". Why? Because a husband and wife can't enter into a full "communion" with one another unless they speak the language. (I don't need to go into detail, but obviously, the act of intercourse points to a "giving", or "donation".) This "donation" is as much physical as it is spiritual, which is why they form one act. Even if a human life does not actually result, this "donation" still expresses the total self-giving of each person, and also fulfills the natural end of intercourse. So I wouldn't say the Church has changed what she taught, but rather, she has more fully rounded it out. I think someone cited "Love and Responsibility" above, where John Paul points to the primary order of procreation. This can be understood in the sense that grace builds upon nature. The unitive dimension is not so much subordinated to the procreative as it "builds" on it. Both are equal, in the same way that God's mercy and justice are equal. Yet mercy is always primary. In other words, the Church hasn't changed the teaching, she has changed the perspective. Whereas before she spoke of "ends" and emphasized the natural order, she now speaks of "communion" and emphasizes man as a total person, body and soul. This may appear to contradict the natural law perspective, but it only integrates it as part of a fuller personalistic vision. I would recommend checking out some of Alice and Dietrich Von Hildebrand's writings on the difference between the "meaning" and the "purpose" of marriage. It's something they drew from the philosophy of phenomenology, and it goes a long way to understanding John Paul's own teaching on this matter. Edited April 9, 2006 by Era Might
Era Might Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 (edited) Here's the text from "Love and Responsibility", for reference: [quote]As we come to the end of this part of the discussion, which was intended to give a correct interpretation of the sexual urge, in part by eliminating incorrect interpretation, some conclusions connected with the traditional teaching on the ends of marriage ask to be drawn. The Church, as has been mentioned previously, teaches, and has always taught, that the primary end of marriage is [i]procreatio[/i], but that it has a secondary end, defined in Latin terminology as [i]mutuum adiutorium[/i]. Apart from these, a tertiary aim is mentioned -- [i] remedium concupiscentiae[/i]. Marriage, objectively considered, must provide first of all the means of continuing existence, secondly a conjugal life for man and woman, and thirdly a legitimate orientation for desire. The ends of marriage in the order mentioned are incompatible with any subjectivist interpretation of the sexual urge, and therefore demand from man, as a person, objectivity in his thinking on sexual matters, and above all in his behavior. This objectivity is the foundation of conjugal morality.[/quote] He goes on to make the point I alluded to above, about how conjugal love cannot be a "using" of the other for natural ends: [quote]At the same time the personalistic norm contained in the Gospel commandment to love points to the fundamental way to realize the ends, which in themselves are also natural to man, and to which -- as the preceding analysis has shown -- he is oriented by the sexual urge. Sexual morality and therefore conjugal morality consists of a stable and mature [i]synthesis of nature's purpose with the personalistic norm[/i]. If any one of the above-mentioned purposes of marriage is considered without reference to the personalistic norm -- that is to say, without taking into account of the fact that man and woman are persons -- this is bound to lead to some form of utilitarianism in the first or second meaning of the word "use". To regard procreation in this way leads to the rigorist distortion, which the "libidinistic" distortion is rooted in a similar attitude to the tertiary end of marriage -- [i]remedium concupiscentiae[/i].[/quote] So basically his point is that, whereas licentious people elevate the unitive to the exclusion of the procreative, Christians had a tendency to elevate the procreative to the exclusion of the unitive. This is why the Church has reframed her argument, so that marriage is not seen as a "baby-making machine", but as a communion of two persons which is so powerful that it has the potential to create. That way, it's easier for a married couple not to look at themselves and say "Well, we have to focus on the procreative, and worry about the unitive after", but to look at the "language" of the body, and see it entirely as one expression of personal love which is always open to that primary natural end of procreation. He goes on: [quote]If there is an intimate co-operation between the man and the woman in a marriage, and if they are able to educate and complement each other, their love matures to the point at which it is the proper basis for a family. However, marriage is not identical with the family, and always remains above all an intimate bond between people.[/quote] In other words, "marriage" is a Sacrament, but "procreation" is not. Procreation is the primary END of marriage, but not the meaning. This is where the Church has developed her teaching; not by denying the primary end of procreation, but by assuming it into a more personalistic theology, as I explained above. Edited April 9, 2006 by Era Might
journeyman Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' date='Apr 5 2006, 02:43 PM']Is it correct to say the use of contraception is a grave matter? [right][snapback]936911[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I don't remember the cited authority, but this was mentioned during Father Phil's discussion on Lust at [url="http://www.secularoratory.com/capitalsins.htm"]http://www.secularoratory.com/capitalsins.htm[/url] . . . His Lenten talk on February 20 . . . your choice of outline, powerpoint slides or audio
Ziggamafu Posted April 9, 2006 Author Posted April 9, 2006 I thought it was commonly held as universal teaching that contraception is a grave matter?
journeyman Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='phatcatholic' date='Apr 4 2006, 04:26 PM']in her article [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=5822"][i][b]On the Primary Purpose of Marriage[/b][/i][/url], Jennaya Arias writes: "Traditionally speaking, the primary purpose of marriage is the generation and nurturing of offspring; the second purpose is the mutual help of spouses, and the third is the remedy for concupiscence."[b]1[/b] what we are interested in is the footnote, which reads:[list][b]1[/b] Ludwig Ott, [i]Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma[/i] (Rockford, IL: Tan Books, 1974), p. 462. Here Ott references the 1944 decision of the Holy Office, which clearly reaffirmed that the primary purpose of marriage is the procreation and upbringing of children. Even though many (if not all) of the documents of the Magisterium on this topic since Vatican II have not explicitily organized the ends of marriage in terms of primary and secondary, nonetheless, none of these documents teach anything which cannot be interpreted in terms of the 1944 decision of the Holy Office. That in the Pope's mind, at least, no change has been made on this matter of Church teaching, can be seen in the Holy Father's work, [i]Love and Responsibility[/i], trans. H. T. Willetts (San Francisco: Ignatius, 1981), pp. 66-69. Therein, the Holy Father lays out, in no equivocal terms, the traditional teaching of the Church on this matter both as unchanged and as unchangeable. Although this work is non-magisterial in character, it is nonetheless quite significant insofar as it expresses the mind of the Holy Father. In the same section of the work, the Pope also makes the important point that the second end of marriage, namely, "mutual help," should not be translated as "mutual love," as it sometimes has been. This would be a mistake since it would seem to limit love between spouses to the second end of marriage, as if it were somehow separable from the first and third ends. Rather, the Holy Father teaches that love must be the indispensable moral environment in which the three ends of marriage are pursued. This present essay should be read as in complete agreement with what the Holy Father says on these matters. [/list] [right][snapback]935634[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Ott's text Section 2. Purpose and Properties of Marriage 1. Purpose The primary purpose of Marriage is the generation and bringing-up of offspring. The secondary purpose is mutual help and the morally regulated satisfaction of the sex urge. (Sent. certa.) CIC 1013, Par 1.) (Codex Iuris Canonici) In their efforts to evaluate marriage as something more than a personal contract, many modern theologians, as against the traditional teaching of the purpose of marriage, whose principal exponent is St. Thomas, have submitted that the primary prupose of marriage is the mutual completion and personal perfection of the marriage partners, or their mutual love and unity. The Holy Office, in the year 1944, in answer to an enquiry, re-asserted the traditional teaching, according to which the primary purpose of marriage is the generation and bringing up of children, and according to which the secondary pruposes of marriage are essentially subordinate to the primary one. D 2295. (Denzinger/Rahner, Enchirdion symbolorum, definitionum et declarationum de rebus fidei et morum) CIC 1013 Canon 1013 (1917) S. 1. The primary end of marriage is the procreation and education of children; the secondary [end] is mutual support and a remecy for concupiscence. S. 2. The essential properties of marriage are unity and indissolubility, which in Christian marriage obtain special firmness by reason of the sacrament. 1013 was replaced by 1056 in the 1983 revision - which repeats only the second section. Bouscaran and O'Connor Canon Law Digest (Vol VI, 1967 at page 590) notes: Ends of Marriage: The Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World omits mention of the "primary" and "secondary" ends of marriage as such. Hence this aspect of the subject is open to further elucidation. The concept of S. 1 of 1013 was restated in Canon 1055 - The Fundamental Nature of Marriage. (formerly Canon 1012) Canon 1012 (1917) S. 1. Christ the Lord raised the marriage contract itself to the dignity of a sacrament among the baptized. S. 2. Therefore among the baptized there can be no valid contract of marriage without its also being a sacrament. Canon 1055 (1983) S. 1. The matrimonial covenant, by which a man and a woman establish between themselves a partnership of the whole of life, is by its nature ordered toward the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of the offspring; this covenant between baptized persons has been raised by Christ the Lord to the dignity of a sacrament. S. 2. For this reason a matrimonial contract cannot validly exist between baptized persons unless it is also a sacrament by that fact. Coriden, Green & Heintschel, The Code of Canon Law, A Text and Commentary (1985) The comments note the new canon replaces "contract" with "covenant" "Unlike canon 1013 of the 1917 Code, Gaudium et Spes avoided setting forth a hierarchy of ends of marriage. This omission does not mean that the purposes of marriage are arbitrarily determined by the spouses. By natural and divine determination marriage is ordered to the good of the spouses (bonum coniugum) and the procreation and education of children. The two ends are intimately related. They are what marriage is about. The unselfish giving in the context of the marital community promotes the natural and spiritual good of the spouses. Naturally, one may ask what acts or attitudes are necessary for the community of life. An exhaustive list is not possible since much depends on society, culture, and personality. Yet certain basic attributes are to be expected: heterosexual companionship, interpersonal friendship, spiritual and material support. Here we find that mutual assistance, formerly considered a secondary end, is now rightly included in the very essence of marriage. . . . . While the existence of a true marriage does not depend on procreation (marriages of the aged and sterile), there must nevertheless be an openness to procreation by all who choose this sacrament. The fulfillment of this purpose of marriage is not exhausted with physical procreation. The spouses are obligated to see that the children procreated receive a Christian education. This formation takes place primarily in the context of the marital community wherein the children learn the meaning of love of God and neighbor through the loving example and instruction of their parents. Such an understanding of the comprehensive nature of the purpose of marriage is rooted in Augustinian and Thomistic theology. fn cites to Augustine, De civitatte Dei 15 16; Aquinas Summa Theologiae 111 29 2; Raymond of Penafort, Summa de matrimonio 11 12 There is an updated text and comments volume dated 2000 ish -
phatcatholic Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Apr 9 2006, 04:53 PM']I thought it was commonly held as universal teaching that contraception is a grave matter? [right][snapback]941077[/snapback][/right] [/quote] it is. no one has said otherwise.
Ziggamafu Posted April 10, 2006 Author Posted April 10, 2006 hmm...yeah, it just seemed like some replies on this thread were acting like it wasn't common knowledge. there have been some very informative replies to the initial topic and i still think they should be put into a tract or something.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now