Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Jesus Could Have Walked on Ice, Scientist Says


Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://news.yahoo.com/s/space/20060404/sc_space/jesuscouldhavewalkedonicescientistsays"]Jesus Could Have Walked on Ice, Scientist Says[/url]

This just seems silly to me, but I thought it interesting. It seems like some people try too hard to come up with explanations for the miraculous. :idontknow:

Posted
:rolleyes: Yea, and those ice floes were just coincidentally arranged in a pattern leading directly to the boat. And the boat did not, in any way, knock those ice floes out of sync. :rolleyes: I mean, coming up with a scientific explanation is plausible, but this explanation isn't.
Brother Adam
Posted (edited)

I wonder what Catholic evolutionists say about this...Wouldn't it make sense that we have a scientific explanation to the truth about faith that this passage of the Bible teaches us? :)

This week...Jesus did not really walk on water.
Next week... Jesus did not really change water into wine.

Edited by Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 4 2006, 05:41 PM']I wonder what Catholic evolutionists say about this...Wouldn't it make sense that we have a scientific explanation to the truth about faith that this passage of the Bible teaches us? :)
[right][snapback]935577[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Yah. Because if one part of the Bible is not literal, EVERYTHING must not be literal. That's sound logic. :rolleyes:

Posted (edited)

Absolutely, it just sounds. ..well, reaching, when I read about it. It just so happens, that Jesus knew that if the boat went in this section of the lake, and He walked at such and such time, when the salt was a certain concentration . .. then He would be able to make it look like He was walking on water. I mean, He's all knowing, but wow, a lot of elements would have to be in play for Him to be able to do that. . .

Edit: interestingly enough, ice from saltwater is easier to see, not harder to see. But then, those silly Apostles were just so flummoxed to see Him walking on the water, they never thought about looking down to see if He was walking on ice.

Edited by PCPA2Be
stbernardLT
Posted

Whether a miracle can be disproved or not shouldn't matter. Our faith shouldn't be in the miracle itself but in the message behind the miracle. It is kind of like spending time talking about how the white stuff went from the chalk to the board instead of studying what was written by the white stuff. Miracles were not done as magic tricks to amaze people, but as a sign from God to teach people about being holy. Whether or not they can be disproved is what the devil wants us to argue about so we lose sight of what Jesus walking on water or "ice" really meant, FAITH. We should spend more time discussing the message instead of the mailbox.

Posted

Well, if he were unable to perform the miracle of walking on water...
Would he have tried to walk on the ice????
Silly demythologizers....

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='stbernardLT' date='Apr 4 2006, 05:05 PM']Whether a miracle can be disproved or not shouldn't matter.  Our faith shouldn't be in the miracle itself but in the message behind the miracle.  It is kind of like spending time talking about how the white stuff went from the chalk to the board instead of studying what was written by the white stuff.  Miracles were not done as magic tricks to amaze people, but as a sign from God to teach people about being holy.  Whether or not they can be disproved is what the devil wants us to argue about so we lose sight of what Jesus walking on water or "ice" really meant, FAITH.  We should spend more time discussing the message instead of the mailbox.
[right][snapback]935599[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Right, I agree. But what do you do when scientists are able to explain the resurrection? Or would the Christian evolutionist have to insist that is the one legitimate miracle of the Bible?

Posted

Wow. didn't know that you could walk normally on "ice". I don't know how everyone else walks on ice, but just on a wet floor I can't walk right.

Posted

JMJ
4/4 - St. Isidore

A good scientist will support the explanation that requires the fewest number of events to occur for a particular action. I mean, we COULD posit that water comes from space aliens, but that would require all sorts of implausibilities; it's simpler and more plausible to believe that it comes from the fusion of two hydrogen atoms with an oxygen atom. Christ COULD have walked on ice (despite the fact that it was during a RAGING storm), but it's much easier and more plausible to believe that He walked on water.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 4 2006, 06:24 PM']Right, I agree. But what do you do when scientists are able to explain the resurrection? Or would the Christian evolutionist have to insist that is the one legitimate miracle of the Bible?
[right][snapback]935626[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
More like that's the one miracle (along with the incarnation) that Christians have to insist can't be explained away. Not that the other ones weren't miracles, but they really aren't as important. The mentality that nothing is a miracle is dangerous, though, and reflects a wrong kind of theology.

Posted

That is soooooo stupid.

Posted

This is definitely one of the silliest attempts at "explaining away" a miracle I've seen.
He was walking on an ice-flow during a storm??!
Jesus must've had some gnarly surfing skills, dude!

It would be much less credulous to simply believe Christ is the Son of God, than to believe all the ludicrous and strained attempts to "explain away" all His miracles.

Another one I heard was that Christ calmed the waters by dumping a barrel of oil overboard.

These "rationalistic" explanations are anything but rational.

Posted

Of course Christ could have walked on ice.


But then again we all can if its thick enough.

Its when he walked on open water that was impressive

Posted

This theory is really treading on thin ice!

homeschoolmom
Posted

If I could walk on ice, it'd be a miracle... 37 years on the northern climes, and still can't do it well...

Laurentina1975
Posted

I saw that article too and read like... a sentence... and was done.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' date='Apr 4 2006, 07:46 PM']This theory is really treading on thin ice!
[right][snapback]935748[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Hardy har har :rolleyes:

Posted

Ah, so Jesus grabbed some ice during the storm, walked out into the middle of the sea on it to see the Apostles, convinced Peter he was walking on water and not ice, and then caused the ice to slowly sink so Peter would think he was screwing up. It all makes so much sense. :rolleyes:

Guest Rick777
Posted

Yah, your right this is just nonsense.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...