Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

OK, so I just got a release about PEN Products from the Depratment of Correction here in Indiana. It's a "company" that sells products made by DOC prisoners ... the tagline is "Quality Products made with Conviction."

:lol_roll:

Seriously, though, isn't that a little weird? Isn't that like slave labor or something? It just doesn't feel right.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

That's funny...

They should get paid. Many jails and prisons offer trade-learning courses.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:02 AM']That's funny...

They should get paid.  Many jails and prisons offer trade-learning courses.
[right][snapback]936313[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I think they do get paid, something like a dollar an hour plus free room and board. :mellow:

Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' date='Apr 5 2006, 06:30 AM']OK, so I just got a release about PEN Products from the Depratment of Correction here in Indiana. It's a "company" that sells products made by DOC prisoners ... the tagline is "Quality Products made with Conviction."

:lol_roll:

Seriously, though, isn't that a little weird? Isn't that like slave labor or something? It just doesn't feel right.
[right][snapback]936266[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


About an hour south of where I live there is a town that has, when combining all the jails, detention centers and prisons. . about 6-8 of them. They have a corner store, which sells products made by the inmates. Seriously, while these prisons are on the edge of town, they are RIGHT on the edge of town, no long road to get to them etc. It's sad to look at.

I haven't been in the store and don't know what they've made, don't know the cost, and I don't know the recompense for the prisoners. Oh, wait! But looking at the website. . .

[quote]"It gives them a good, healthy, constructive outlet," Ms. Longmeyer said of the inmate artists. "In addition to the economic benefits."

The state corrections system draws 25 percent of an item's selling price to defray costs of operating the outlet store. Private prisons keep 30 percent to defray inmates' incarceration costs.

Last fiscal year, the entire Arizona Correctional Industries program – which offers a variety of inmate-produced products ranging from baked goods to mattresses – recorded gross revenues of $2.5 million, and earned net income of $1.4 million. Although profits for the prison store have fluctuated, Ms. Longmeyer said it just about breaks even.

"Taxpayer benefits, correctional benefits, and inmate benefits – it's just a good thing," she said.[/quote]

Here is the full website. It's an art and craft store!
[url="http://www.azcorrections.gov/ACI/Arts&Crafts/Directory.htm"]Arizona Prison Arts and Trades Outlet[/url]

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' date='Apr 5 2006, 09:06 AM']I think they do get paid, something like a dollar an hour plus free room and board. :mellow:
[right][snapback]936319[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Gotta start with something. :idontknow:

Posted

Buying products from inmates, I would rather see them suffer a little, not use my hard earned money to buy drugs and cigarettes.
My neighbor was shot 4 years ago, a good Christian man who never hurt anyone, was waiting to go in to work, when drug dealers pulled up to the space next to his in a parking lot. He started to go in to work, when they didn't like him being so close and they shot him in the abdomen point blank. He was 51 years old, critically wounded, spend 6 months in the hospital, had a colostomy, urostomy and he died last year from complications. Left a wife and children behind. The people who did this, got a slap on the wrist and six months in jail.
My Mother was attacked when she was walking to work just 2 blocks from our home. The people took her change purse(which had a whopping 2 dollars in it in change), threw her to the ground and kicked her for good measure. Nothing was done to them
Buy products from inmates, no way. And don't dare preach to me about charity. Ask my neighbor how they feel.

Posted

they make mattresses?

That is just weird.

Cow of Shame
Posted

[quote name='alicemary' date='Apr 5 2006, 10:07 AM']Buying products from inmates, I would rather see them suffer a little, not use my hard earned money to buy drugs and cigarettes.

Buy products from inmates, no way. And don't dare preach to me about charity.
[/quote]

You've apparently never been in jail. Being in there is a lesson in suffering. It's a big assumption that any earnings they make automatically go to drugs or cigarettes.

DemonSlayer
Posted

Doesn't seem like a great idea.

nowak.chris
Posted

Let them store up a little money (even if they can only use for certain things or when they get out), also let 'em contribute to their own support. Jails don't run themselves. Plus the added benefit of job experience/training. I think this should be standard practice.

chris

Posted

I think its a good idea. Better for them to spend their time doing something useful and constructive rather than being drawn into prison gang activities. Plus they have something to take pride in- especially with the arts and crafts thing- perhaps gain a sense of self-worth that might otherwise have been lacking and which led them to a life of crime and/or drug abuse to begin with.

Posted

Obviously many people do not realize what kind of people are in our jails...of course many are not there and should be. Jail time is meant to be punishment for crimes done. I don't care if they are locked in a room and never let out. And feeding them should be optional. Have them earn money, sorry, money should be given to the victims...remember them? Again, charity, I have none for jailbirds. If one of your family is in jail, I am sorry for YOU but not for them. And hate to disagree with you Cow, for I surely usually see eye to eye with ya. But I am standing on my soapbox for this one.

Posted (edited)

This isn't a matter of being on the 'side' of the victim or the criminal. I've too been a victim of a crime, actually a couple in my life, so I know what it's like to be a victim. Maybe not the family of a murder victim. . . But being scathing and hard hearted is not the approach to take. It doesn't fix the problem of the prison situation, it only affects you, it makes you hard hearted. . .having an unforgiving heart impedes your way to the Heart. And I've learned in the past, when it comes to forgiveness, that by not doing so, only affects myself, as the person who 'did me wrong' either doesn't know of my feelings? Or doesn't care. So, I'm the only one still suffering but CHOOSE not to let it go. Doesn't mean I have to be best pals with the person, doesn't mean I ALLOW or ACCEPT the situation, but I rise above it and allow our Lord to work in MY heart, which, at times like these, is the one He needs to work on most. (well, and the perp, but that's not the issue here right now)

There are MANY different kinds of people in jail. Just as in other situations, it's really unrealistic for one to stereotype the prison population. If we just 'get on our soapbox' and look down on the prisoners with loathing, we are not being a part of the solution, but part of the problem. Anyone can stand upon a box and rail about their intrinsic evil and how all prisoners, no matter their circumstances, should be 'locked in a room, food optional'.

How amazing would a person be, who works for change in the prisons so that these criminals don't return to society, 'punished' and then go out and commit the same crimes again. (Yes, jail time is for punishment, but it SHOULD be used ALSO to rehab them, so they don't go back out and do the same or similar thing all over again. How is 'just punishment alone' helping them. . .or us, the victim or possible future victim? It doesn't help. [b]At all.[/b]) Our diocese has a specific prison ministry who are able to get closer to some of these prisoners. . .and from what they've shared with me not ALL are are the evil that we imagine, just incredibly lost in a system with no solutions.

Most of the prison systems out there just punish, and wag their fingers saying 'you're wrong and bad, you did a bad thing'. They don't teach why, they don't teach any alternative so that when these people are released, they can go out and make something of their lives. . .something that they probably never knew was possible.

I think they *should* be given a job whereby they earn their food, they earn their privileges, etc. I think they should be given classes in learning how to clean a home, how to get a job, and get along with co-workers and their bosses. I think they should learn ADLs or Activities of Daily Living, like how to go in and buy groceries, go home and cook their food and learn how to raise a family.

There are many jails /prisons that have TVs, libraries, gyms, etc. where prisoners can use, depending on their crimes, at will. Prisoners are the way they are because of our penal system. (There seriously needs to be brave souls who can lobby for prison reform.) They are criminals because that's all they know. They know that if they get out, do what they always do, and that is, commit a crime, they can go back into a system where they are given free room and board, free food, free gym membership etc. Granted, many of their activities are restricted, but it's not as bad, to the repeat offenders, as living out in the world, trying to be a contributing member of society.

I have no 'sympathy' for prisoners, but I know there are many who, in prison ministry, help teach these people that this is NOT the only way. This isn't a 'way of life'. Yes, there are hardcore prisoners to whom any sort of reconciliation with our Lord, any education of their lives will fall on deaf ears, but there are also many prisoners who just believe it's the way to live. . .their friends, their neighbors when growing up, even family members all were on the wrong side of the law. . .and they're just following a familiar path.

These prisons who teach them or allow them to do something constructive. . . well, it's a knee jerk reaction to think that all the money goes to drugs, cigarettes and booze, but I doubt that's only where it's going to or where it's going in all cases. I'm not trying to be too optimistic, or unrealistic. Just trying to point out that while some cannot be rehabilitation. .. many can, if given the opportunity, for those who are willing to give them a chance to change. Granted, some of these people do those crafts to work the system. However. .. if one is afraid that's where the money is going, why not work for a system where, when they sell their items, the monies can be used as credit, be put in an account, so to speak, where it has to be spent in a store within the prison that sells food, or be given to family members? BTW As shown on that site, the prisons take a cut from the sales, helping pay for guards, etc. But it's not, to use a blanket statement, 'all bad'.

And maybe, just maybe, this teaches them that when returning to society, they have a talent they could use. . .to use in the workforce, instead of doing whatever put them there in the first place.

May God grant you peace.

Edited by PCPA2Be
Mary-Kathryn
Posted

[quote name='alicemary' date='Apr 6 2006, 08:57 AM']Obviously many people do not realize what kind of people are in our jails...of course many are not there and should be. Jail time is meant to be punishment for crimes done. I don't care if they are locked in a room and never let out. And feeding them should be optional. Have them earn money, sorry, money should be given to the victims...remember them? Again, charity, I have none for jailbirds. If one of your family is in jail, I am sorry for YOU but not for them. And hate to disagree with you Cow, for I surely usually see eye to eye with ya. But I am standing on my soapbox for this one.
[right][snapback]937554[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

When I lived in Arizona years ago, there was a sheriff that I thought was great. The prisoners ate green bologna, worked on chain gangs and wore pink prison uniforms. However, I don't believe any of them had very serious offenses [like murder]. I wonder how he would have went over as a prison warden?

Posted

[img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v485/flowery/ZZthread_topic_veering.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='Mary-Kathryn' date='Apr 6 2006, 10:35 AM']When I lived in Arizona years ago, there was a sheriff that I thought was great.  The prisoners ate green bologna, worked on chain gangs and wore pink prison uniforms.  However, I don't believe any of them had very serious offenses [like murder].  I wonder how he would have went over as a prison warden?
[right][snapback]937644[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

i remember hearing all about that a year or so ago when it was kind of a big thing. i think it's funny, i'm sure it was a great way to teach the inmates, and it didn't hurt them. just a new idea to go along with the classic making of license plates...

Mary-Kathryn
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Lil Red' date='Apr 6 2006, 10:59 AM'][img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v485/flowery/ZZthread_topic_veering.jpg[/img]
[right][snapback]937662[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


:idontknow:

~reads thread~

Ohhhhhh...the thread has gone this-a-way and that-a-way. Therefore it is in danger of becoming a debate and not a conversation?

sorry if I participated in the meanderings of the wayward thread ^_^

Edited by Mary-Kathryn
Brother Adam
Posted

I agree prisoners should work for money, and that money should primarily go to pay for their incarceration so tax payers don't have to. And as everyone said, it really depends on the crime, the circumstances. If they are actually guilty even. I do believe they have a right to food and water, that is something we cannot deprive anyone, and that food and water should not be contaminated as to physically harm them. The idea shouldn't be that they get out even more dangerous than they went in. I have family by marriage that are in jail, and they deserve to be there, jail should be for punishment, but I believe like Warden Norton, everyone should also receive spiritual direction. Punish the crimes, but offer the oppertunity for them to redeem their souls.

Posted

I think it's better that the prisoners are doing productive labor.
It's not "slave labor" - is it better that the prisoners be idle and useless?

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' date='Apr 5 2006, 08:06 AM']I think they do get paid, something like a dollar an hour plus free room and board. :mellow:
[right][snapback]936319[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
:lol_pound:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...