Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Stop! Break a fortune Cookie


Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted (edited)

So...the one young man who will be baptized at our huge Easter Vigil service at FUS, who I've been working with all semester, went to a FOP. Scared the bejesus out of him. He mentioned how one girl "started screaming at the top of her lungs and that it sounded like the screech of a bird and then dropped to the ground" (now if I ever saw that happen I'd be likely to call 911), and other various horror stories. A charasmatic who is also a sponsor of one of them asked them what they thought of 'tongues'. [b]All [/b]of them nervously laughed and shook their head, and said "yeah, umm....just no."

Interesting.

Edited by Brother Adam
Brother Adam
Posted

charasmatic "Festival Of Praise" where you get all variety of speaking in tongues, resting in the holy spirit, and other outbursts that just make ya' question the sanity of some people there. I don't reject everything in the charasmatic movement, but some stuff makes ya' wonder.

sweetpea316
Posted

Ooooh right. My friend who used to go to FUS was telling me about that. ^_^

Posted

Screamin' huh? Thats just damned scary.

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

[quote name='Luthien' date='Apr 6 2006, 02:48 PM']Screamin' huh? Thats just damned scary.
[right][snapback]937848[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

You know what is scary.

When you are possessed, oppressed, or obsessed with demons, and those demons are reacting in terror to the avenging and loving God who is rescuing his beloved child from the grasp.

I have been involved in the charasmatic movement, and i find, the people who make the biggest shows, tend to be dealing with a lot of deeply embedded pains. Sometimes, they involve demons.

For the rest of us people who have never been wounded, hurt, or experienced unforgiveness and other pains associated with it, then the charasmatic movement is not for you. But if you are a terrible sinner, who has suffered the consequences (myself for example), and have been in the muck and mire of suffering, then the charasmatic movement may be for you.

SHALOM

The devil has wreaked havoc on mankind for the last century, i suppose that God is getting the upperhand in the charasmatic movement.

Brother Adam
Posted

The Church did just fine for 1900 years without it. :)

Posted

It just seems a tad too Protestant for my tastes.

Brother Adam
Posted

I don't know that I would label it "protestant" persay. Anglicans and Lutherans are Protestant but are very, very liturgical. Protestantism being doctrinal heresy, of course played into liturgy, but "praise and worship" isn't meant to be part of the liturgy, but, if it is appropriate, part of personal or communial devotion. The Church has a very wide variety of devotions, so if someone wants to sing a song to God with a guitar, cool. The specific gifts that come with the territory, most of the time I make no judgment on, though I think it can become spiritually dangerous.

I have so many charasmatic friends here, i try to give the benefit of the doubt. However, just the fact that all of those coming into the Church here implicitely thought something was wrong, made me wonder.

Posted

[quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' date='Apr 6 2006, 03:09 PM']You know what is scary.

When you are possessed, oppressed, or obsessed with demons, and those demons are reacting in terror to the avenging and loving God who is rescuing his beloved child from the grasp.

I have been involved in the charasmatic movement, and i find, the people who make the biggest shows, tend to be dealing with a lot of deeply embedded pains.  Sometimes, they involve demons.

For the rest of us people who have never been wounded, hurt, or experienced unforgiveness and other pains associated with it, then the charasmatic movement is not for you.  But if you are a terrible sinner, who has suffered the consequences (myself for example), and have been in the muck and mire of suffering, then the charasmatic movement may be for you.

SHALOM

The devil has wreaked havoc on mankind for the last century, i suppose that God is getting the upperhand in the charasmatic movement.
[right][snapback]937869[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Which is why its scary. :mellow:

I didnt say it was wrong.

Posted

That [i]is[/i] scary.

Posted

Interesting fact:

You know why the Religious Society for Friends are known as Quakers? The name comes from the fact that, when they started, they too felt compelled by the Holy Spirit, but rather than speaking in tongues, they just convulsed, or [i]quaked[/i]. Same thing goes with the Shakers, too.

Posted

Look up Fr. Sudac... he's still alive and has a stigmata.

I read a few interviews with him... there are some real charismatics, but in regards to tongues, someone should not speak in them unless there is someone who can understand them because they could be blasphemying God.

Here is the interview...
[url="http://www.stjeromecroatian.org/eng/frsudac.html"]http://www.stjeromecroatian.org/eng/frsudac.html[/url]


God Bless,
ironmonk

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

But it was just in the last century that Satan was in the last one hundred years that Satan was given to wreak havoc, according to Pope Leo XIII (that is why he, through much prayer composed our ever favorite St. Michael the Archangel Prayer)

What i am trying to say is not that the Charasmatic Renewal is not some kind of absolute mandate on mankind, revealed in our "modern times." Neither am i trying to say that "charasmatic masses" are appropriate.

What i am trying to say, is that there is a lot of people who will be fine without it.

But i will say for myself, and many others that i know, if there was no charasmatic renewal, i would not have found the healing and new life that my soul needed.

So, if you are reading this, DO NOT FEEL THREATENED BY ME, i am not trying to impose any kind of charasmatic ideas in here, i am trying to say, in my faith walk, God used it to bring healing to me, which would eventually allow me to become the man whom God made me to be.

And heck, the charasmatics that brought me up in the faith held these in priority...

Devotion to the Eucharist, within and outside of Mass.
Obedience to the Traditional teachings of the Church.
Devotion to Mary.

I don't appreciate stereotypes.

SHALOM

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

[quote name='ironmonk' date='Apr 6 2006, 08:21 PM']Look up Fr. Sudac... he's still alive and has a stigmata.

I read a few interviews with him... there are some real charismatics, but in regards to tongues, someone should not speak in them unless there is someone who can understand them because they could be blasphemying God.

Here is the interview...
[url="http://www.stjeromecroatian.org/eng/frsudac.html"]http://www.stjeromecroatian.org/eng/frsudac.html[/url]
God Bless,
ironmonk
[right][snapback]938321[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

But did you read the whole interview. He didnt say that you shouldnt pray in tongues.

"But if in that moment, a person with the gift of understanding tongues does not come forward, then that gift, in that moment is not given for the building up of the community, but for the individual building up of that person. Then I recommend that that person pray quietly to himself."

But of course, nobody here is required to accept what Fr. Sudac says. I do. But you are not required to.

SHALOM

toledo_jesus
Posted

Tongues...hahaha

You do need to have certain criteria met in order to verify that it's really a gift of the Holy Spirit and not somebody looking for attention.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='ironmonk' date='Apr 6 2006, 11:21 PM']Look up Fr. Sudac... he's still alive and has a stigmata.

I read a few interviews with him... there are some real charismatics, but in regards to tongues, someone should not speak in them unless there is someone who can understand them because they could be blasphemying God.

Here is the interview...
[url="http://www.stjeromecroatian.org/eng/frsudac.html"]http://www.stjeromecroatian.org/eng/frsudac.html[/url]
God Bless,
ironmonk
[right][snapback]938321[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Isn't it true that only Padre Pio has been confirmed by Rome as having true stigmata? Or was that St. Francis? How many confirmed stigmatists are there?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' date='Apr 6 2006, 02:13 PM']He mentioned how one girl "started screaming at the top of her lungs and that it sounded like the screech of a bird and then dropped to the ground" [/quote]

In my four years there, I had never once seen anything like that. I've never seen it anywhere else either. Strange.


[quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' date='Apr 6 2006, 08:27 PM']What i am trying to say, is that there is a lot of people who will be fine without it.

But i will say for myself, and many others that i know, if there was no charasmatic renewal, i would not have found the healing and new life that my soul needed.

So, if you are reading this, DO NOT FEEL THREATENED BY ME, i am not trying to impose any kind of charasmatic ideas in here, i am trying to say, in my faith walk, God used it to bring healing to me, which would eventually allow me to become the man whom God made me to be.

And heck, the charasmatics that brought me up in the faith held these in priority...

Devotion to the Eucharist, within and outside of Mass.
Obedience to the Traditional teachings of the Church.
Devotion to Mary.

I don't appreciate stereotypes.

SHALOM
[right][snapback]938347[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'd have to echo that too. :thumbsup:

stbernardLT
Posted

This (the screaming) happens several times every year at the Steubenville South Youth Conference. It happens right as the Eucharist is brought out for adoration or even sometimes during consecration at Sunday Mass. The really interesting thing besides the fact that the scream sounds nothing like a person but more like a witch's cackle, is that with over 5,000 teens singing at the top of there lungs and a huge praise band playing you can still hear one person screaming above anything else. I used to be very sceptical of this until I had someone screaming next to me one year, and when the priest walked over and blessed the person, it stopped immediately, made me proud to be Catholic. Whenever this happens prayer ministers and the priest take the teen out of the assembly not to distract everyone else and brings them into a separate adoration chapel and proceeds with getting rid of the demon (i'm not sure if the actually have an exorcist on staff). The devil uses this as a last resort to distract those who are trying to focus on Christ in the Eucharist.

This can be very scary, but again who said war wasn't. :starwars:

Posted

[quote name='stbernardLT' date='Apr 7 2006, 10:34 AM']This (the screaming) happens several times every year at the Steubenville South Youth Conference.  It happens right as the Eucharist is brought out for adoration or even sometimes during consecration at Sunday Mass.  The really interesting thing besides the fact that the scream sounds nothing like a person but more like a witch's cackle, is that with over 5,000 teens singing at the top of there lungs and a huge praise band playing you can still hear one person screaming above anything else.  I used to be very sceptical of this until I had someone screaming next to me one year, and when the priest walked over and blessed the person, it stopped immediately, made me proud to be Catholic.  Whenever this happens prayer ministers and the priest take the teen out of the assembly not to distract everyone else and brings them into a separate adoration chapel and proceeds with getting rid of the demon (i'm not sure if the actually have an exorcist on staff).  The devil uses this as a last resort to distract those who are trying to focus on Christ in the Eucharist.

This can be very scary, but again who said war wasn't. :starwars:
[right][snapback]938824[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Same deal at the Steubenville East Youth Conference. I went for the first time last year and the same thing happened. There were girls screaming at the top of their lungs, they were running out of the tent screeching and beside themselves. It was scary because I couldnt imagine why they would want to leave when he was present. After a while I didnt hear anyone around me. I tuned it out, but only by the grace of God Im sure.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...