Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Some of you may recall that this summer I plan to read many anti-Catholic books... well, I couldn't wait and noticed James G. McCarthy's "Conversations with Catholics" while I was picking up a Protestant commentary on Romans (Karl Barth's..).

Anyhow. This book is a joke. And I mean, seriously, as a piece of literature, and as a refutation of Catholicism. There is not one piece that he seems to actually know what he's talking about.

Example: One second he's claiming all Catholics believe they're saints with no sin (i.e., we're good enough people to get to Heaven) and the next he's bashing Confession and calling prayers like the Act of Contrition "holy poetry" because Catholics don't honestly believe they've offended God... pray tell, then, what IS the point of Confession and "going to a priest for forgiveness" if we don't think we've sinned (as he claims)? :ohno:

:idontknow:

I don't know if I can finish the book. I'm so confused as to what he's arguing... we don't take sin seriously or ever really think we've sinned, yet confession locks us in the guilt of our SINS we've committed.

Brother Adam
Posted

Maybe I can write the refutation on this one like Gary wrote on the previous "The Gospel of Rome"

James White can debate better than McCarthy

Posted

Falsehood will only confound itself. Truth is the only coherent thing out there.

missionseeker
Posted

nuh uh, everyone is told the truth by the Holy Spirit. God loves all the differing versions and confusion.

phatcatholic
Posted

some more of his handywork
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/278"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/278[/url]

Posted

Is there anything we do not have in the directory? Honestly. It seems like every topic is covered. If it isn't, something will be added within the week...I made this statement long ago, but I will say it again: I am surprised that the Vatican has not either recruited phat or abducted him.

You are really a Jesuit agent aren't you?!

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Apr 7 2006, 09:47 PM']Is there anything we do not have in the directory? Honestly. It seems like every topic is covered. If it isn't, something will be added within the week...I made this statement long ago, but I will say it again: I am surprised that the Vatican has not either recruited phat or abducted him.

You are really a Jesuit agent aren't you?!
[right][snapback]939693[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Hear Hear!

We love Phatcatholic. I was going to send him a thank you email card thing but I don't have his email address. lol

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Yeah, yeah... I guess I was just expecting more considering the popularlity of his stuff. I don't see how anyone, Protestant and rabid anti-Catholic or not, could take this seriously. I would be embarassed to publish something of that "caliber"... it's like a sixth grader telling a story and jumping all around.

Of all the Catholic opposition, you would think no one would mention his name and Protestant apologists would be ashamed to even link to anything of his. I mean, seriously, I cannot think of a less scholarly nor less coherent writing... ever. My non-practicing mother would be able to read this and toss it aside as a joke.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Apr 7 2006, 10:47 PM']You are really a Jesuit agent aren't you?![right][snapback]939693[/snapback][/right][/quote]
:evil:


[quote name='missionseeker' date='Apr 7 2006, 11:17 PM']Hear Hear!

We love Phatcatholic. I was going to send him a thank you email card thing but I don't have his email address. lol[right][snapback]939730[/snapback][/right][/quote]
phatcatholic at yahoo dot com :thumbsup:

missionseeker
Posted

sweet

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Apr 7 2006, 09:47 PM']Is there anything we do not have in the directory? Honestly. It seems like every topic is covered. If it isn't, something will be added within the week...I made this statement long ago, but I will say it again: I am surprised that the Vatican has not either recruited phat or abducted him.

You are really a Jesuit agent aren't you?!
[right][snapback]939693[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Another conniving Jesuit! Islam, the Titanic, World War I, World War II, and now this!?

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Apr 7 2006, 11:28 PM']Yeah, yeah... I guess I was just expecting more considering the popularlity of his stuff. I don't see how anyone, Protestant and rabid anti-Catholic or not, could take this seriously. I would be embarassed to publish something of that "caliber"... it's like a sixth grader telling a story and jumping all around.

Of all the Catholic opposition, you would think no one would mention his name and Protestant apologists would be ashamed to even link to anything of his. I mean, seriously, I cannot think of a less scholarly nor less coherent writing... ever. My non-practicing mother would be able to read this and toss it aside as a joke.
[right][snapback]939744[/snapback][/right][/quote]
is it better or worse than Alexander Hislop's [i]The Two Babylons[/i]? i haven't seen anything worse than that......

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

I've seen some JM tracks. He's a fool. Distorter extraordinare. But then there are few protestant apologists who are really intellectually honest about anthing. I actully debated a little with James White over on Catholicconvert.com, SteveRay's site, a while back. He has very little patience and time when he's not in the public eye. And again, intellectual honesty is not hist stong suite either. :ohno:

Edited by thessalonian
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

No.. it's not even distortion... it's just... bad writing. From any perspective. I don't see how he's become legitimate in any sense...

It seriously it like picking up one of those stories some kid wrote in 5th grade and trying to read it.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Apr 8 2006, 11:00 AM']No.. it's not even distortion... it's just... bad writing. From any perspective. I don't see how he's become legitimate in any sense...

It seriously it like picking up one of those stories some kid wrote in 5th grade and trying to read it.
[right][snapback]940085[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

In all honesty judging from the writing ability and intellecutual capicty of a website you and I frequent, that's about the level he would have to frequent.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I'm hoping his other books are a bit more scholarly.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Apr 8 2006, 02:17 PM']I'm hoping his other books are a bit more scholarly.
[right][snapback]940095[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

No they are not. However, I was overly disappointed with our Catholic representation of the faith in his book where he dialogues with a priest writing letters back and forth. The priest did a poor job presenting our own faith, but given the publisher, I would not be surprised if he was not accurately presented.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Well this book has testimonies from former Catholic priests and nuns (most of whom, the names are "changed to protect privacy") but, after reading most of it, I'm wondering if any of them were every really priests/nuns since the level of understanding they demonstrate is that of Protestant walking into a Catholic Church and observing. They don't sound like people with Catholic backgrounds who've left the Church (I've talked to more than my share), they sound like Protestants walking in to a Catholic Church for the first time and making observations.

A Catholic man, 2 of his sons are Jesuit priests, one reads the Bible and leaves the priesthood, so the man reads the Bible and then "goes to Mass like he always does"....
[quote]What are we doing with a statue in the church? Bernard asked himself. And those people up there, what they're doing is pure idolatry. It's wrong. God forbids it. In fact, what are we doing with statues in here at all? What's happened to us? And what's that altar doing in here? he asked himself, marveling at what he was seeing. We're not supposed to have an altar. Sacrifice went out with the dying of Christ on the cross. And who does that man up there think he is, all dressed up in vestments like the pagan priests of Rome?[/quote]

Talking to a nun about why she would go to Rome to gain a plenary indulgence, she responds...
[quote]"Christ has done His 99 percent," Sister Teresa answered. "We have to cooperate by doing our 1 percent."[/quote] (pg.171

Brother Adam
Posted

Sounds like he is just taking from the other book then, Far From Rome, Near to God. Sometimes I'm not sure why we bother with the anti-catholics. They have little to no credibility in Protestant circles anyway. Chick is thought of as an embarressment to Fundamentalists.

Posted

Sounds str8 out of a Jack Chick comic. I can almost picture the cheesy drawing of a man on his deathbed sweating out the last few drops of divine retribution. :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...