hopeful1 Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 I"ve been talking with my spiritual director about using a lectio divina with the daily mass readings. This was originally intended for lent, but unfortunately due to scheduling we weren't able to discuss it until it was 3 weeks into it but i may continue using after the seasons over.he pointed me to [url="http://www.valyermo.com/ld-art.html"]Accepting the Emabrace of God: the Ancient Art of Lectio Divina[/url] and [url="http://www.beliefnet.com/story/38/story_3879_1.html"]beliefnet.com[/url] ( a condensed version of the other article) for more info on it, however one of the things he suggusted using before reading scripture was the centering prayer. Knowing it's reputation on PM, it kinda put up a red flag, but everything else i've tried to get into the readings hasn't been working (unless if i'm doing the lectio divina incorrectly). Although i trust my spirtual director would never intentionally suggust something unorthodox or anything that would hurt me spiritually, i'm very cautious to try the centering prayer. however the discription of it from the link of the beliefnet article for the lectio divina seems very benign: Centering Prayer Guidelines 1. Choose a sacred word as the symbol of your intention to consent to God's presence and action within you. Examples of possible sacred words are Abba, Jesu, Mary, Love, Yes, Shalom, etc. 2. Sit comfortably with your eyes closed. Settle briefly and silently, to yourself, introduce the sacred word as the symbol of your consent to God's presence and action within. 3. When you become aware of thoughts, sensations, feelings--any perception whatsoever--return ever-so-gently to the sacred word. 4. At the end of the prayer period, remain in silence with eyes closed for a couple of minutes. Is this the same concept of the centering prayer you're all familiar with? if so, how is it harmful and why should it be avoided? also, any suggestions on what i should do instead?
shortnun Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 Hopeful, The outlines for centering prayer you have above are what I'm most familiar with (both in personal practice and in literature I've read). I've neevr understood how it could be harmful, or why one would think it ought to be avoided. It's a wonderful way to open yourself to the ever-present Spirt and allow yourself to go deeper into the Sacred Scriptures. I too would love to hear other people's experiences....
hopeful1 Posted April 9, 2006 Author Posted April 9, 2006 i don't understand how it could be harmful either
Lilllabettt Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='hopeful1' date='Apr 9 2006, 12:53 PM']i don't understand how it could be harmful either [right][snapback]940842[/snapback][/right] [/quote] The iffy thing about centering prayer is that it has roots in oriental religious practices ... and the thing about most oriental "prayer" or meditation is, that its objective is to employ (often highly effective) techniques (similar to "centering prayer") to "trick" the conciousness into a sense of peace, or induce a tranquil sensation. In Christian meditation, inner peace is something God does for us, not something we can acheive for ourselves, using a technique. That said, as long as you're very careful to keep things Christocentric, and remember that the sense of peace is NOT the objective ...
hopeful1 Posted April 9, 2006 Author Posted April 9, 2006 would it be a safe bet then, that this wouldn't be recommended practice for those who feel like they lack a sense of peace, or trust from God, because it wouldn't be genuine?
Theologian in Training Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 The biggest problem, as it see it, is that quite simply, this is not prayer. Focusing on a specific word to open yourself to the "spirit" is not really prayer, because prayer, as we understand it, is, for lack of a better word, conversation with God. We are not really saying anything, but meditating upon a word and that word becomes our prayer? Also, as lillabett pointed out, we are the ones in control, because we are doing relaxation exercises with our body, which is fine, however, we then begin to associate that relaxation as a form of prayer, and think that the only way to feel the presence of God, is to be entrenched in this deep relaxation. The biggest problem is that though it credit the "spirit" with that relaxation, it is really not the spirit as much as us controlling our bodies to relax. Typically, in prayer, say praying a rosary or spending time before the Blessed Sacrament, we naturally become calm, not by any means of our own, but by just allowing the Holy Spirit to come upon us. The difference, though subtle, is that we did absolutely nothing for that to happpen, except fall upon our knees and start to pray. Further, and this is one a more spiritual level, is that in opening yourself up to a "spirit" how are you sure that that spirit is indeed the Holy Spirit? My biggest problem is if this were a viable method of prayer, why were the greatest prayers that we have been taught by Jesus and the Church those that are entirely Scripturally based? If we meditate on "Yes," we may be drawn to think about Mary's fiat, but what greater way to meditate upon that fiat, than by meditating upon the "Hail Mary." Re-reading this thread, I would aslo add that The Lectio Divina is not the same thing as centering prayer, and I am wondering if he wasn't trying to help you get focused or "centered" before approaching the Scriptures. Was it actually centering prayer that he recommended or was it something else? God Bless
hopeful1 Posted April 9, 2006 Author Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='Theologian in Training' date='Apr 9 2006, 01:47 PM']The biggest problem, as it see it, is that quite simply, this is not prayer. Focusing on a specific word to open yourself to the "spirit" is not really prayer, because prayer, as we understand it, is, for lack of a better word, conversation with God. We are not really saying anything, but meditating upon a word and that word becomes our prayer? Also, as lillabett pointed out, we are the ones in control, because we are doing relaxation exercises with our body, which is fine, however, we then begin to associate that relaxation as a form of prayer, and think that the only way to feel the presence of God, is to be entrenched in this deep relaxation. The biggest problem is that though it credit the "spirit" with that relaxation, it is really not the spirit as much as us controlling our bodies to relax. Typically, in prayer, say praying a rosary or spending time before the Blessed Sacrament, we naturally become calm, not by any means of our own, but by just allowing the Holy Spirit to come upon us. The difference, though subtle, is that we did absolutely nothing for that to happpen, except fall upon our knees and start to pray. Further, and this is one a more spiritual level, is that in opening yourself up to a "spirit" how are you sure that that spirit is indeed the Holy Spirit? My biggest problem is if this were a viable method of prayer, why were the greatest prayers that we have been taught by Jesus and the Church those that are entirely Scripturally based? If we meditate on "Yes," we may be drawn to think about Mary's fiat, but what greater way to meditate upon that fiat, than by meditating upon the "Hail Mary." Re-reading this thread, I would aslo add that The Lectio Divina is not the same thing as centering prayer, and I am wondering if he wasn't trying to help you get focused or "centered" before approaching the Scriptures. Was it actually centering prayer that he recommended or was it something else? God Bless [right][snapback]940891[/snapback][/right] [/quote] he recommended using the centering prayer to get focused or "centered" before approaching the scriptures for the lectio divina.
hopeful1 Posted April 9, 2006 Author Posted April 9, 2006 (edited) btw, i would never use the word "yes" as a meditation because it's too broad of a word to use b/c it could be applied to anything, besides her fiat. I know it was one of the examples in the guidelines, but i would've probably thought of something more along the lines of "jesus" or "come holy spirit, come" of course if this is improper to do, this is a moot point, but this is just my .02 Edited April 9, 2006 by hopeful1
Theologian in Training Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='hopeful1' date='Apr 9 2006, 03:19 PM']he recommended using the centering prayer to get focused or "centered" before approaching the scriptures for the lectio divina. [right][snapback]940928[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Still, I would think spending some time in silence, praying for guidance and the Holy Spirit to assist you while meditating upon the Scriptures to be more effective, then meditating upon a word. But, that is just me. God Bless
Seven77 Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 Like Theo said.. meditating on Scripture is key. That leads to contemplation---which is something GOD does on His part. In Lectio God 'centers' you on His Son---like St. John resting on tthe Sacred Heart. Just keep 'showing up' and He will do the restt!
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 My learning of Centering Prayer is not devoid of Conversation with God... But one other thing is worth mentioning. The Cloud of Unknowing was a book, which i recently studied, written in England in the Thirteenth Century. It suggests the same formula of Sacred Word. However, it is hard to see how there were any Eastern Influences whatsoever. The only influence i can find on the writings is the work of Pseudo-Dionysius. What the Cloud of Unknowing does is put an emphasis on Love. That is prayer as love reaching out to God, and God loving in return. I prefer Lectio Divina, because i Do feel God breathe life in the Scriptures. I also pray St. Augustine's prayer to the Holy Spirit before all mental prayer: Breathe in me Holy Spirit, that my thoughts may be Holy. Move in me Holy Spirit, that my actions may be Holy. Attract my heart Holy Spirit, that i may love only what is Holy. Strengthn me Holy Spirit, that i may defend all that Holy. Protect me Holy Spirit, that i may always be Holy. Of course, it is always healthy to look with a slight skepticism on Catholic Monks who use Zen techniques to "enrich" Catholic Prayer. However Centering Prayer didnt just spontaneously generate from Buddhist mysticism. SHALOM
OLAM Dad Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 hopeful, Your desire to focus closer on your lectio divina is laudable. Centering prayer is dangerous though and I'm glad you're suspicous. Here is a link to an article entitled, [i]The Danger of Centering Prayer[/i]. [url="http://catholiceducation.org/articles/apologetics/ap0005.html"]http://catholiceducation.org/articles/apol...ics/ap0005.html[/url]
shortnun Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='Lilllabettt' date='Apr 9 2006, 01:17 PM']The iffy thing about centering prayer is that it has roots in oriental religious practices ... and the thing about most oriental "prayer" or meditation is, that its objective is to employ (often highly effective) techniques (similar to "centering prayer") to "trick" the conciousness into a sense of peace, or induce a tranquil sensation. In Christian meditation, inner peace is something God does for us, not something we can acheive for ourselves, using a technique. That said, as long as you're very careful to keep things Christocentric, and remember that the sense of peace is NOT the objective ... [right][snapback]940865[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thomas Merton is a great example of a man of prayer who listened and learned from/about Easter forms of prayer and saw how they supported Christian faith. Lilllabet is quite correct in that like that "mountain top" experience of our Transfigured Christ, we cannot stay there forever. We must return to the bottom to share Him with others. The same can be said with "going within." Finding our Emmanuel (our God within us) can bring us great peace. But it is not enough to sit and hoard Him. We must share that peace with others. I could be wrong, but I think it this point that Lilll and TinT are trying to emphasize. [quote name='Theologian in Training' date='Apr 9 2006, 01:47 PM']My biggest problem is if this were a viable method of prayer, why were the greatest prayers that we have been taught by Jesus and the Church those that are entirely Scripturally based? If we meditate on "Yes," we may be drawn to think about Mary's fiat, but what greater way to meditate upon that fiat, than by meditating upon the "Hail Mary." [right][snapback]940891[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Theo, I must respectfully disagree. Centering prayer is indeed a form of prayer. And historically it is very connected with [i]lectio[/i]. (The writings of John Cassian and Benedict come to mind as precursors in the development of centering prayer.) And are you saying that all prayer must be scripturally based? Centering prayer would look at "Fiat" or "yes" because of their connection to scripture. It wouldn't just pick out "pancake" or "lightbulb."
shortnun Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' date='Apr 9 2006, 03:41 PM']Of course, it is always healthy to look with a slight skepticism on Catholic Monks who use Zen techniques to "enrich" Catholic Prayer. [right][snapback]941063[/snapback][/right] [/quote] So you don't read any Thomas Merton?
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted April 9, 2006 Posted April 9, 2006 [quote name='shortnun' date='Apr 9 2006, 02:54 PM']So you don't read any Thomas Merton? [right][snapback]941079[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes i have read Thomas Merton. Reading him inspired my vocation... I was referring to other Monks who went further than Merton did. SHALOM
hopeful1 Posted April 10, 2006 Author Posted April 10, 2006 [quote name='Theologian in Training' date='Apr 9 2006, 02:41 PM']Still, I would think spending some time in silence, praying for guidance and the Holy Spirit to assist you while meditating upon the Scriptures to be more effective, then meditating upon a word. But, that is just me. God Bless [right][snapback]940964[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm doing this already with "come holy spirit, come", but i'm still struggling with it.
morostheos Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 I think you are right to be worried about centering prayer. I would agree with what Theo said, so I'll not rehash the same reasons. One thing I do before prayer to help me get focused is to pray to the holy spirit (as you already do), then to make acts of Faith, Hope and Love. Exercising the theological virtues is a good way to help open yourself to God's grace. It's best if you make these acts in your own words, but here are some basics: Faith - You will be in God's presence, speaking with him. You don't have to make him present since we are always in God's presence whether we realize it or not. But you do need to make yourself aware of this reality. Hope - It consists in turning to God as your supreme good, your Savior, from whom you trustfully hope for grace and help in your need. Love - Renew your awareness that God, with whom you are speaking, is your Father, and you are his beloved child. Address him, then, as a child speaking to his father.
Azriel Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 This, to me, is not prayer, but meditation. I use meditation and progressive muscle relaxation as a way to reduce anxiety. It stops physical symptoms. I don't use it to attain peace ... as much as to feel calm enough to continue to function. I see no harm in what was described, as a meditation, but some take it as a way to acheive some sort of divinity, which isn't possible.
philothea Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 For a long thread about the dangers of centering prayer, [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=46981&hl="]click here.[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now