Era Might Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 I reported the thread, so hopefully one of the mods will delete it...
Balthazor Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 By the way, don't freak out too much.... the guys here know what they are talking about, we have a lot of good sheparding going on on this site.... they would not let anyone fall into sin if they can help it.
HisChild Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 I've come across a site of monks (don't know if this is the site, because I haven't gone to it. . .) who have broadcast online a live feed of their adoration chapel. I'm wondering, now, why would these monks (assuming they are not all ignorant) post something like this online. I don't want to hear binary, or 'accidents of bread' (which sounds. . .I don't know. bizarre). Speculate for a moment, if you will. . .what would be their motivation for doing so?
alicemary Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 Have you people lost your ever loving mind. This is a site put out by contemplative nuns to help spread devotion to The Blessed Sacrament. I personally go to this site several times a day to take a break and offer a few prayers, especially when I am working 10-12 hours and can't get to a church. An occasion of sin.....it is merely an image, a rememberance of our Beloved Lord. It is wonderful for those who are housebound who can't get to a church. And I dont know about your churches, but mine does not have Benediciton. I think you all take this stuff too seriously. You will worry yourself into an early grave. And if the mods remove this site, I will doubt their sanity too.
shortnun Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [quote name='alicemary' date='Apr 9 2006, 10:11 PM']Have you people lost your ever loving mind. This is a site put out by contemplative nuns to help spread devotion to The Blessed Sacrament. I personally go to this site several times a day to take a break and offer a few prayers, especially when I am working 10-12 hours and can't get to a church. An occasion of sin.....it is merely an image, a rememberance of our Beloved Lord. It is wonderful for those who are housebound who can't get to a church. And I dont know about your churches, but mine does not have Benediciton. I think you all take this stuff too seriously. You will worry yourself into an early grave. And if the mods remove this site, I will doubt their sanity too. [right][snapback]941613[/snapback][/right] [/quote] :applause: Amen!
HisChild Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 I don't think Jesus is going to cast you into hell and scream IDOLATRY! Because He knows that those who ARE housebound or don't have Adoration at their church (or those nearby), will look at this picture. . .well, with the reverence that would be reserved to Him, were they actually there.
Era Might Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 (edited) [quote name='PCPA2Be' date='Apr 10 2006, 12:11 AM']I've come across a site of monks (don't know if this is the site, because I haven't gone to it. . .) who have broadcast online a live feed of their adoration chapel. I'm wondering, now, why would these monks (assuming they are not all ignorant) post something like this online. I don't want to hear binary, or 'accidents of bread' (which sounds. . .I don't know. bizarre). Speculate for a moment, if you will. . .what would be their motivation for doing so? [right][snapback]941611[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm sure their motivation is fine. Hell is paved with good intentions, as they say. I specified OBJECTIVE idolatry, because people who accidentally worship this are not culpable. Full knowledge and consent are required for that. Edited April 10, 2006 by Era Might
Balthazor Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 Would you all just lighten up a little? My goodness.. everyone here has good intentions this is not something to fight about. Christ knows all of our hearts, and while I truly doubt anyone is going to go to hell or fall into sin because of this, I do think he is laughing at our neuroticism.
Guest Rick777 Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [quote name='PCPA2Be' date='Apr 9 2006, 08:11 PM']I've come across a site of monks (don't know if this is the site, because I haven't gone to it. . .) who have broadcast online a live feed of their adoration chapel. I'm wondering, now, why would these monks (assuming they are not all ignorant) post something like this online. I don't want to hear binary, or 'accidents of bread' (which sounds. . .I don't know. bizarre). Speculate for a moment, if you will. . .what would be their motivation for doing so? [right][snapback]941611[/snapback][/right] [/quote] ha. I had to laugh when I read this cuz recently I heard our parish priest talking about the accidents of bread and I thought he was being heretical......I actually had too look up some stuff and found out he just meant the physical sight of the Eucharistic.
Tink Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 (edited) [color=#ff0066]Finally, someone who posts exactly what I was too busy to type... Amen to what Alicemary saidt![/color] Edited April 10, 2006 by Tink
Era Might Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 The problem is not the picture. The problem is the live feed. It's pointless. It would be the same thing to just take a snapshot of the host and post it up. The live feed makes people think that they are in some sort of "special" presence, when they are not. They're just looking at an image, and if they do anything with that image, it should be no more than they would do to an icon or a holy card, because that's all it is.
Tink Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [color=#ff0066]True it is just a picture, but in the same respect televised Masses are just 'dots on a screen' as you say. I think what is important is not the particulars and technicalities of it all, but the intention in the hearts of those viewing the site. I also, with all due respect, think y'all are being a bit snappy about the whole thing. Calm down, please, and remember all should be done with the hope of drawing people to Christ, who is Love.[/color]
Era Might Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 (edited) Televised masses are different, because you can actually join in the vocal prayers. You are getting something you can't get from a holy card - voice and chant and scripture readings. The same norms apply to television masses. It's just dots on a screen. You can unite yourself to the Mass wherever it is happening, but the image on the screen is just a bunch of dots. The particulars ARE important because this is idolatry at stake. Personal culpability is another matter. Edited April 10, 2006 by Era Might
Tink Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [color=purple]I'm fairly sure that several orders of devout religious would not be endorsing/approving/encouraging it if it were heretical or seriously dangerous to one's faith. I'm also fairly sure that no one will actually worship the image rather than our Lord being represented by the image. I think it's kind of the spirit of the law vs. the letter of the law. Sure, it's just an image which is technically idolatry, but I think everyone who views this will be worshipping Christ the Lord in their hearts, not an internet web page.[/color]
Era Might Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Tink' date='Apr 10 2006, 12:33 AM'][color=purple]I'm fairly sure that several orders of devout religious would not be endorsing/approving/encouraging it if it were heretical or seriously dangerous to one's faith. I'm also fairly sure that no one will actually worship the image rather than our Lord being represented by the image. I think it's kind of the spirit of the law vs. the letter of the law. Sure, it's just an image which is technically idolatry, but I think everyone who views this will be worshipping Christ the Lord in their hearts, not an internet web page.[/color] [right][snapback]941691[/snapback][/right] [/quote] It's not "heretical". It's the same as drawing a picture of the Eucharist, or making a holy card. Unfortunately, ordinary people aren't able to make distinctions between substance and accidents, presence and image. I'd be willing to bet most of the people who look at this don't even know how the heck that image gets to their screen. There is no reason to have a live feed. I'm done here. Do with the information what you will. God bless. Edited April 10, 2006 by Era Might
Tink Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [color=purple]Okay I guess. You're the scholar. [/color]
philothea Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' date='Apr 9 2006, 09:19 PM']The problem is not the picture. The problem is the live feed. It's pointless. It would be the same thing to just take a snapshot of the host and post it up. The live feed makes people think that they are in some sort of "special" presence, when they are not. They're just looking at an image, and if they do anything with that image, it should be no more than they would do to an icon or a holy card, because that's all it is. [right][snapback]941641[/snapback][/right] [/quote] So... is watching the mass on EWTN when it's "live" equally idolatrous?
Era Might Posted April 10, 2006 Posted April 10, 2006 I never said this is idolotrous. I said it is highly misleading, and will inevitably lead to objective idolotry. Ok, I'm really done now. Why do I always get wrapped up in these threads?
Recommended Posts