LouisvilleFan Posted April 11, 2006 Posted April 11, 2006 A Baptist friend of mine and I were talking the other day about Catholic beliefs and practices when he mentioned the canonization and veneration of saints as one of the major reasons he cannot accept Catholicism. In his words, the Catholic Church has a committee that "votes people into Heaven". I explained the canonization process in which miracles must be investigated that attest to the potential saint's intercession before God. For example, I remember hearing recently that a nun in Europe (i want to say France) was cured of Parkinson's disease as a possible miracle due to John Paul II's intercession. But how does the Church determine whose intercession provided the miracle? As a related question, is it sinful to pray to those who have died but are not saints, since we cannot know for sure where their soul is?
Pio Nono Posted April 11, 2006 Posted April 11, 2006 JMJ 4/11 - Tuesday of Holy Week LouisvilleFan, If we elected people into Heaven, I have a feeling that more Popes, kings and world leaders would be saints. Since we discern the saints God chooses, though, we wind up with people like St. Bahkita from the Sudan, St. Agnes and St. Aloysius Gonzaga. The Church can determine whose intercession provided a miracle (normally) by finding the person who asked for the miracle and asking them in a straightforward manner if they asked that particular person (in this case, John Paul II) for that particular miracle for that particular intention. It's scandalously particular, but our God is like that. If something comes up during the course of the investigation that contradicts part of this (i.e., the person prayed for another intention), then the miracle has to be disregarded. It's no less miraculous, but we can't be sure that it came through that saint's intercession. Also, on a personal level, it is fine to have private devotions to those who led holy lives. However, this cannot be publicly sanctioned (i.e., praying for that person's intercession at Mass, for instance). I personally have a devotion to Venerable Pope Pius XII, the Servant of God Simon Gabriel Brute' de Remur (first bishop of Vincennes, Indiana), and a local priest named Fr. Joseph Kundek (who died in the 1850s). Hope this helps. Yours, Pio Nono
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now