Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

JMJ
4/11 - Tuesday of Holy Week

This is something that I had to get off my chest in order to pre-empt some "atti-tuve" that will surely show itself in the near future.

If you're keeping up with news in the Catholic world as of late, you would have heard that a big letter concerning the Sacred Liturgy is to be released by His Holiness the Pope sometime during the Triduum this year. From all reports, it seems like he will be liberalizing the current policy with regards to the Tridentine Mass, namely, that any priest would be allowed to celebrate it with no permission needed from his bishop. I wouldn't take this seriously were it not for the fact that many Italian news agencies and Catholic World News have asserted this for some time now with no statement from the Vatican (Vatican Radio has confirmed the existence of a document but not its contents).

It saddens me that I have seen many people compare this (whether explicitly or implicitly and not on Phatmass) to Gorbachev's policy of Perestroika, which eventually led to the fall of the Soviet Empire.

Essentially, the argument goes that the Pope is releasing the Tridentine Mass for wider use; this dose of "traditionalism" will spread in ways that the Vatican does not want it to, and it will eventually lead to the fall of the current Novus Ordo Mass (and ultimately of things like [i]Dignitatis Humanae[/i] and [i]Nostra Aetate[/i]) and the reestablishment of early 20th century Catholicism. It is disappointing that people would think in such a way. This line of thinking is essentially Protestant and contains a number of dangerous ecclesiological attitudes.

There is nothing wrong with early 20th century Catholicism, R. Garrigou-LaGrange, the Tridentine Mass, or so-called "traditional" spirituality (which is suspiciously nebulous and undefined). We need to realize, too, that there is nothing inherently wrong with the pastoral documents of Vatican II, with H. U. von Balthasar, and the Novus Ordo Mass. There is nothing wrong with any of these because the Church approves of them all. To disapprove of these things simply because we don't like them or because we perceive a contradiction within them is essentially to deny the authority of Holy Mother Church in these regards. As the great Augustine says, "I would not accept the authority of the Gospels were it not for the Church." The Church is the one who makes these decisions, not myself, and I must be obedient to her.

In addition, we must remember that spiritual joy is an infallible indicator of the work of the Holy Spirit. Attitudes that desire the fall of any of the things listed above (especially the two major liturgies of the West) do not spring from a heart filled with love and joy, but from one that harbors distrust and malice. Let us pray continually for the movement of the Spirit in our lives and in the Church.

That's all I had to say. I'll step off my soapbox now.

Posted

Step back up on the soapbox!

Why would the Vatican want to do this? Seriously? What are they hoping to accomplish?

The NO can be done today in such a way that it could look and feel very much like a TLM but it's not happening. There is nothing stopping pastors from adding more Latin to the Mass. They could adopt an ad orientem posture, but they don't. They could limit the music to chant and organ only, but they don't. They could forbid altar girls, but they don't.

Are we to believe that with a universal indult we'll all of the sudden see TLMs popping up left and right?

I'm not buying it.

God Conquers
Posted

I'm guessing that the Vatican bets a universal indult would encourage those things you're talking about within the NO, thus strengthening it, not weakening it.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

A few comments coming from someone who has never attended a TLM. My parish does offer a beautiful Sunday mass in Latin, but it is in the current Pauline rite.

1) One of the things that troubles me is the constrast between the hostility toward the Tridentine rite vs. the laxity of bishops/priests in the face of liturgical abuses. In this, I empathize with those who wish for TLM. I am comforted by the recent efforts by the Vatican (e.g. [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccdds/documents/rc_con_ccdds_doc_20040423_redemptionis-sacramentum_en.html"]Redemptionis Sacramentum[/url]), but we've got a long way to go before we've got conformity in worship. When I travel, it can be a game of roulette to find a parish where the priest hasn't coopted the mass and turned it into something that doesn't resemble what is described in the current GIRM.

2) While I'd be happy to see a "wide and generous" availability of the 1962 missal (see [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/motu_proprio/documents/hf_jp-ii_motu-proprio_02071988_ecclesia-dei_en.html"]Ecclesia Dei[/url] by John Paul II), I would not want this to split the church further. For example (note: please correct me if my impressions are wrong), I recall that in the Anglican Church, they did experience something of a split between "high church" and "low church" Anglicans. If we Latin rite Catholics have two rites, we may follow the same path. My fear would be that orthodox Catholics would generally move to TLM mass; first for the attraction to its beauty; but also because they needed to escape from liturgical abuse, as some Novus Ordo parishes experienced even higher concentrations of "Low Church Catholics" willing to bend the Pauline (i.e. N.O.) liturgy into whatever they wished.

In short, there is a field of landmines ahead.

Posted

Although I do not think a universal indult will be given (the Holy Father argued against it in "The Ratzinger Report"), I agree that he is interested in a positive Liturgical pluralism. He's not just trying to placate people.

In fact, just the opposite of trying to "replace" the Mass of Paul VI, I would say if anything, greater permission for the Tridentine Mass would be to "replace" the SSPX. If the Tridentine Mass is available more, the thinking may be that borderline SSPX people will attend the indult instead of the SSPX, and the Society will die out in a few years.

stbernardLT
Posted

I think this would be cool but at the same time I think it might confuse a lot of people and maybe create even further division, but hopefully not.

popestpiusx
Posted

I have been following these reports and rumors for several weeks now. One of the intentions of our family Rosary is that they are true. One of the reports claimed that the document is simply going to acknowledge that every priest has the right to say the traditional Mass because it was never abrogated (as was 'decided' by the commmision of cardinals appointed to study the question in 1986). This is what I would like to see, but any liberalization of the TLM will be most welcome.

Though I will certainly be overjoyed by the news, and the affirmative answer to my (as well as countless other's) prayers, I do have a certain fear that such a decision could open up the TLM to the abuses often experienced in the NO due to a generally undiciplined clergy. On that, I will simply have to trust the Holy Father and Divine Providence.

Until we know for sure what, if anything, will be announed I (and countless others) will continue to pray and fast for this intention.

Posted

PioNono, I can understand why you say what you do, but recommending von Balthasar is a scandal - which I take no pleasure in saying. :( But that man is bad news.

I sincerely pray your Lent and Easter is just what Our Lord wants it to be for you.

Posted

JMJ
4/13 - Holy Thursday

I can understand why someone could have misgivings about von Balthasar, but his writings are solid. Otherwise, he wouldn't have been made a Cardinal for his theological work shortly before his death. Also, Adrienne von Speyr never wrote anything of her own; most (if not all) of her writings are transcriptions of her visions written by von Balthasar. In addition to all this, let's remember that Josef Cardinal Ratzinger was and is a major supporter of "Casa Balthasar" in Rome.

Posted

It's 3:30 Rome time. Seems kinda late to announce anything.

^_^

Posted

[quote]One of the reports claimed that the document is simply going to acknowledge that every priest has the right to say the traditional Mass because it was never abrogated (as was 'decided' by the commmision of cardinals appointed to study the question in 1986). [/quote]

This is not the case.

[quote]We must attach to this refusal to respect the liturgical norms laid down a special grievousness in that it introduces division where Christ's love has gathered us together in unity, namely, into the liturgy and the eucharistic sacrifice. For our part, in the name of tradition, we beseech all of our children to celebrate the rites of the restored liturgy with dignity and fervent devotion. Use of the old Ordo Missae is in no way left to the choice of priests or people. The Instruction of 14 June 1971 provided the celebration of Mass according to the former rite would be permitted, by faculty from the Ordinary, only for aged or sick priests offering the sacrifice without a congregation. The new Ordo Missae was promulgated in place of the old after careful deliberation and to carry out the directives of Vatican Council II. For a like reason, our predecessor St. Pius V, after the Council of Trent, commanded the use of the Roman Missal revised by his authority.

--Pope Paul VI, Consistory allocution of May 24th, 1976[/quote]

I highly doubt the Holy Father will contradict the manifest intention of Pope Paul VI.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Donna' date='Apr 13 2006, 02:26 AM']PioNono, I can understand why you say what you do, but recommending von Balthasar is a scandal - which I take no pleasure in saying. :(  But that man is bad news.
[right][snapback]945793[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
:idontknow:

von Balthsar rocks. He's not scandalous at all! :blink:

brendan1104
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Apr 13 2006, 08:42 AM']:idontknow:

von Balthsar rocks. He's not scandalous at all! :blink:
[right][snapback]945874[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

are you joking? :huh:

Posted

A cool joint book from Papa Benedetto and Von Balthasar:

[url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/158617018X/002-7500093-9749628?v=glance&n=283155&s=books&v=glance"]Mary: The Church at the Source[/url] (Link)

Posted

The Holy Father is doing the evening Mass of the Lord's Supper, so I guess there's still a chance he could announce something, during or after Mass. If there's nothing by 2 our time (8 Rome time), I'd guess the rumors were not true.

popestpiusx
Posted

The sources said it would happen during the Triduum. The commentators have all speculated that it would happen on Holy Thursday, but that did not necessarily come from any of the sources that I have read.

Posted (edited)

Yah, it's possible it could happen still, but I think it would be kind of weird to announce something like that on Good Friday, Holy Saturday, or Easter Sunday. Today makes sense because we celebrate the Mass in a special way...

Edited by Era Might
Posted

It's getting late in Rome...

Posted

I have nerveousness.

popestpiusx
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Apr 13 2006, 07:28 AM']This is not the case.
I highly doubt the Holy Father will contradict the manifest intention of Pope Paul VI.
[right][snapback]945863[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


From Cardinal Stickler:

Did Pope Paul actually forbid the old rite?
Pope John Paul II, in 1986, asked a commission of nine cardinals two questions. Firstly, did Pope Paul VI, or any other competent authority legally forbid the widespread celebration of the Tridentine Mass in the present day? No. He asked Benelli explicitly, "Did Paul VI forbid the old mass?" He never answered - never yes, never no.

Why? He couldn't say "Yes he forbade it." He couldn't forbid a mass which was from the beginning valid and was the Mass of thousands of saints and faithful. The difficulty for him was he couldn't forbid it, but at the same time he wanted the new Mass to be said, to be accepted. And so he could only say, "I want that the new Mass should be said." This was the answer all the princes gave to the question asked. They said: the Holy Father wished that all follow the new Mass.

The answer given by eight of the cardinals in '86 was that, no, the Mass of Saint Pius V has never been suppressed. I can say this, I was one of the cardinals. Only one was against. All the others were for the free permission: that everyone could choose the old Mass. That answer the Pope accepted, I think; but again when some bishops' conferences became aware of the danger of this permission, they came to the Pope and said, "This absolutely should not be allowed because it will be the occasion, even the cause, of controversy amongst the faithful." And informed of this argument, I think, the Pope abstained from signing this permission. Yet, as for the commission -I can report from my own experience- the answer of the great majority was positive.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...