Fidei Defensor Posted April 11, 2006 Posted April 11, 2006 I am not quite sure how to even go about talking about this. I can basically sum it up in two words: depressed despair. I do not know why, but I am cursed with a skeptical mind. And unhealthy skeptical mind. Not the kind that can bring about good in the realm of reason, but the kind that plagues the mind with unneed worry. But why should you care? I have been constantly looking for help. I cant seem to let go of the notion that Jesus could possibly be a made up mythical character, and not a real historical person. Its been haunting me. The more I try to find the evidence, the more i am left empty handed. When I ask for help, the only answer i get is that of laugher and I am told "no one disputes that Jesus existed." However, the argument from common agreement doesnt prove anything to me. I am guessing that I will only be laughed at again for even bringing this up. I shouldnt even bother. I should just pray I guess. But even that hurts me. If God is there, he doesnt want to hear me. I have cried to him, but I am left alone. Just imagine how this makes me feel, makes my faith that much weaker. Perhaps If i had but a mustard seed of faith, I could see that because Pascha is approaching, perhaps satan is trying to break my will. But I just dont know anymore. I shouldnt be bother anyone with this. This is my problem, and I will just have to live in perpetual night, carry my cross and smell of elderberries it up. As a matter of fact, just ignore me. All i really want is attention. Just pray for me and pretend i never said anything more.
Cathurian Posted April 11, 2006 Posted April 11, 2006 Don't feel like you shouldn't have posted this. You need help, and we're here for you. It's not self-centered or attention seeking to tell us about your problems. I know you want answers more than anything, and I'm sorry I can't give them to you. I can't imagine how painful it must be for you. But if it's any consolation at all, I'm praying for you. Mother Mary and all the angels and saints too.
Lil Red Posted April 11, 2006 Posted April 11, 2006 when all else fails, pray. turn off the media...the phone, the cell phone, the radio, the computer, the tv, the mp3 player....turn off everything and go pray in front of Jesus. ask Mary to help you. God bless you! [quote]There is not one avenue of sense or thought, but the figure of Christ stands in it; not one activity open to man, but the "Carpenter's Son" is there; beneath the stone, and in the heart of the wood. The more minute our search, the more delicate is his presence. The more wide our vision, the more illimitable is his power. So, little by little as we go through life, following with a hundred infidelities and a thousand blunders, with open defiances and secret sins, yet following, as Peter followed through the glare of the High Priest's fire to the gloom of penitence where Christ's eyes could shine - as we go, blinded by our own sorrow, to the ecstasy of his joy, thinking to find him dead, hoping to live on a memory, instead of confident that he is living and looking to the "today" in which he is even more than yesterday - little by little we find that there is no garden where he does not walk, no doors that can shut him out, no country road where our hearts cannot burn in his company. -- Monsignor Robert Hugh Benson[/quote]
Mary-Kathryn Posted April 11, 2006 Posted April 11, 2006 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Apr 11 2006, 05:07 PM']I am not quite sure how to even go about talking about this. I can basically sum it up in two words: depressed despair. I do not know why, but I am cursed with a skeptical mind. And unhealthy skeptical mind. Not the kind that can bring about good in the realm of reason, but the kind that plagues the mind with unneed worry. But why should you care? I have been constantly looking for help. I cant seem to let go of the notion that Jesus could possibly be a made up mythical character, and not a real historical person. Its been haunting me. The more I try to find the evidence, the more i am left empty handed. When I ask for help, the only answer i get is that of laugher and I am told "no one disputes that Jesus existed." However, the argument from common agreement doesnt prove anything to me. I am guessing that I will only be laughed at again for even bringing this up. I shouldnt even bother. I should just pray I guess. But even that hurts me. If God is there, he doesnt want to hear me. I have cried to him, but I am left alone. Just imagine how this makes me feel, makes my faith that much weaker. Perhaps If i had but a mustard seed of faith, I could see that because Pascha is approaching, perhaps satan is trying to break my will. But I just dont know anymore. I shouldnt be bother anyone with this. This is my problem, and I will just have to live in perpetual night, carry my cross and smell of elderberries it up. As a matter of fact, just ignore me. All i really want is attention. Just pray for me and pretend i never said anything more. [right][snapback]943879[/snapback][/right] [/quote] No one is laughing. First, you need to seek the wisdom of a good and learned priest...he can help you more than my poor words can. We all go through our trials and stumbles...all of us. Anyone who hasn't at my age, I'd like to shake the hand of that saint! This is the time when you need to hold on to your faith. Do it with a gritted teeth-stubborn-white knuckled-screaming of your will attitude. Well, you may want to skip the screaming part But you understand. Second, I know this is extremely personal, but make sure that what you feel isn't depression. This is where a priest could help you so much more than a woman typing out a post somewhere in the distance. He will know what to tell you. Please see a priest and know that no one is laughing at your pain. Mary-Kathryn
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Please, PM me at any time if you want to talk.
LSW Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Apr 11 2006, 04:07 PM']I am not quite sure how to even go about talking about this. I can basically sum it up in two words: depressed despair. I do not know why, but I am cursed with a skeptical mind. And unhealthy skeptical mind. Not the kind that can bring about good in the realm of reason, but the kind that plagues the mind with unneed worry. But why should you care? I have been constantly looking for help. I cant seem to let go of the notion that Jesus could possibly be a made up mythical character, and not a real historical person. Its been haunting me. The more I try to find the evidence, the more i am left empty handed. When I ask for help, the only answer i get is that of laugher and I am told "no one disputes that Jesus existed." However, the argument from common agreement doesnt prove anything to me. I am guessing that I will only be laughed at again for even bringing this up. I shouldnt even bother. I should just pray I guess. But even that hurts me. If God is there, he doesnt want to hear me. I have cried to him, but I am left alone. Just imagine how this makes me feel, makes my faith that much weaker. Perhaps If i had but a mustard seed of faith, I could see that because Pascha is approaching, perhaps satan is trying to break my will. But I just dont know anymore. I shouldnt be bother anyone with this. This is my problem, and I will just have to live in perpetual night, carry my cross and smell of elderberries it up. As a matter of fact, just ignore me. All i really want is attention. Just pray for me and pretend i never said anything more. [right][snapback]943879[/snapback][/right] [/quote] You and I should get together and go bowling, which means we have alot in common. I also have a skeptical mind as you. Whenever I have these doubts about Christ I simply think about the Church. There is absolutely NO WAY that the Church could exist for this long if Jesus was merely a mythical figure. There is no other institution like it on earth nor was there anything like it in history nor will there be anything like it in the future. I also think about the martyrs that shed their blood for their faith. People don't suffer like this for lies they suffer like this for the Truth. There are also little things that strengthen my faith. I remember watching EWTN once and there was a program about Rome and how the Church was established there. I remember them showing a very old engraving that depicted a crucified man with the head of an ass. I believe it was dated way back to the first century. Anyways this is a type of "drawing" drawn by pagan roman school children who were mocking their friend who was a Christian. Now I forget what this Christian boys name was but the words inscribed underneath the drawing where "____ worshiping his God" or something to that effect. It hangs in a museum in Rome. Things like this help me at least. Hopefuly it will help you.
LSW Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Oh by the way stay away from television, radio programs that question the claims or validity of Christianity. Like all these shows about the Davinci Code and all that. I'm sure you know its all bunch of baloney but for people like us who struggle with doubt they certainly don't help. Peace
prose Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 I think we all have those struggles on some level. Especially during holy week. I, myself, was struggling with the distance I had put between me and my faith over the past few months. I found confession REALLY helped. Not sure why. I will pray for you. Remember, it is normal to doubt. The problem comes when we allow ourselves to wallow in doubt. I have lots of intellectual reading stuff to if you want some sugestions.
alicemary Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Don't feel you are alone in all this....everyone goes through these times. It is normal and quite wonderful to question, don't stop the process. Hang in there through those dark times, know your phamily is always here, and we share the good and the bad times.
avemaria40 Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Trust me, I know where you are, I'm at this point myself. I can be pretty skeptical at times and it smells of elderberries. It's hard because I have a lot of friends who are not Christian and many people challenge my beliefs every day. I get challenged for what I believe about God, my stances against abortion and birth control, and my beliefs in modesty. When I get home, I'm the religious one in my family, which makes it harder since I get faced with the same things as at school. At times, it feels like there is no escape from it all. Sometimes I wonder if Jesus really was God or if the Bible is true and it's not a game of historical telephone. Things that help me stay strong are reading the Scriptures, saying the Rosary (which is very relaxing as well as bringing you closer to God), and also remembering all the miracles. Like there are examples of phenomena, such as stigmata, crying statues, miracle cures, visions of Our Lord, the Blessed Mother, and the Saints that scientists can't explain and people realize there is Someone behind it. Most of these kinds of miracles, that I have heard of any way, only happen in Catholicism. There are times at Mass when I find it hard to concentrate but once I receive the Eucharist, no matter my state of mind, I always snap to attention and I know that it is real. I'll be praying for you and please know that Jesus loves you so much, even when it seems like He isn't there. We all go through the dark night of the soul, even the greatest saints have done it. Remember the love of God this week, especially as we enter the Triduum. He gave us His Body and Blood to strengthen us, died on the Cross for us so we could share eternal life, and defied Death itself by rising again. Stay strong, you will make it.
avemaria40 Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 It also helps to know that Jesus went through the Dark night of the soul as well, when He was in Gethsemane. He knows what it's like and He will help you through this.
AngelofJesus Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Have you read chapter 9 book 1 of the dark night of the soul? If not read it. If you have, read it again, while you pray.
Fidei Defensor Posted April 12, 2006 Author Posted April 12, 2006 Thank you for your prayers everyone.
Tarcisius Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 if youve got free time, pick up Kierkegards(sp?) A Sickness Unto Death. You will realize you dont have depression.
philothea Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 [quote name='AngelofJesus' date='Apr 11 2006, 06:17 PM']Have you read chapter 9 book 1 of the dark night of the soul? If not read it. If you have, read it again, while you pray. [right][snapback]943994[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I am curioius to know why do you think this applies? I kind of assume that fidei is speaking metaphorically. St. John's "Dark Night" is a difficult prayer transition. Fidei sounds like he's is dealing with an ongiong temptation. (Prayers, BTW.) Fidei... keep in mind that faith is not proven by how you feel, or even what thoughts are running through your mind, but [i]what you do[/i]. You are very virtuous when you continue to be a faithful Catholic despite constantly nagging doubts.
blovedwolfofgod Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 I always think of the Eucharistic miracles when I doubt. How could what is bread become literal flesh and wine become literal blood where you can study what part of the body the flesh is from and what blood type the blood is? How could people have lived solely on the Eucharist for decades at a time, only eating communion? Without God, they cant. And if Jesus wasnt God, why would our beliefs be reinforced with these miracles? When in doubt, think of the miracles.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now