prose Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Was recording songs of the radio in the 80s onto cassettes a sin too? If not, what is the difference?
Era Might Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 Songs on the radio are not a product you have to pay for. They were free.
prose Posted April 12, 2006 Author Posted April 12, 2006 So if I record off online radio onto a CD, it wouldn't be a sin?
Era Might Posted April 12, 2006 Posted April 12, 2006 I would say no, because radio stations play songs that the artists release for free to the public. The songs are intended to be a tease for you to buy the rest of the album. It's the same with videos.
Era Might Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 ...of course, if you have doubts, you should ask a Priest.
philothea Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 Radio stations pay very large fees to be able to broadcast copyrighted songs, partially because people can record them. Of course, the recording from an FM station isn't nearly the quality of the recording you can purchase. Music companies get upset about digital copying and downloads because you can get very good copies easily, and they think this discourages sales. (They are wrong, but that doesn't really affect the morality of the issue.) BTW, most online "radio stations" do not pay these fees, and are -- according to RIAA -- illegally "broadcasting". (Though, technically internet is point-to-point, not broadcast, and I don't know how this has gone down legally. RIAA annoys me.)
goldbug16 Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 I dont download music. Maybe it is just because I dont know how. jk
philothea Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 I download music [i]all the time[/i]! But I pay for it.
Mrvoll Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 [quote name='prose' date='Apr 12 2006, 01:51 PM']Was recording songs of the radio in the 80s onto cassettes a sin too? [right][snapback]944891[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I do that
OverheadNite Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' date='Apr 12 2006, 06:22 PM']...of course, if you have doubts, you should ask a Priest. [right][snapback]945329[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I have no doubt in my mind. No need to ask a Priest. Did we all have to ask a Priest if recording our favorite tv show or a tv movie on a vhs was a sin? Or how about todays modern tivos or dvrs? Which you can in turn connect to your choice of a vhs or dvd recorder and transfer what you've "tivoed" Nope, no sin at all here. Just an outcry from the record companies because its money they can't get their filthy hands on. Personally I do believe its a sin if, just as with any recorded tv show or movie, you turn around and sell that copy. If you are netting a profit off of someone else's work, then yes you should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. But if it is for your own personal use, then they have no right to tell you that you can't. Find me the constitutional ammendment that says its illegal? The same uproar occured when the vhs recorder came out. Give them time to regulate breathing, they'll be fine.
OverheadNite Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 (edited) I'm flaclempted. Discuss amongst yourselves. Edited April 13, 2006 by OverheadNite
Era Might Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 [quote name='OverheadNite' date='Apr 13 2006, 08:57 AM']Did we all have to ask a Priest if recording our favorite tv show or a tv movie on a vhs was a sin?[right][snapback]945846[/snapback][/right] [/quote] If you had doubts about it, yes.
OverheadNite Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' date='Apr 13 2006, 06:01 AM']If you had doubts about it, yes. [right][snapback]945849[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well I don't see how anyone could have their doubts about it. As Catholics we are supposed to follow all just laws. The law never states that it is illegal to record a tv show, if it did then a vhs recorder or dvr would be an illegal device to have in any home in the united states. These items such as a cd or dvd burner would be contraban. But I suppose you could be right, burners were first being sold with the ideal that you can make a backup copy of something you've purchased. I guess its like giving a child a book of matches and then tell him not to play with fire. I personally will continue downloading music until the law says otherwise. I think its ridiculous to prosecute a 12 year old girl for downloading a bunch of N'sync and Backstreet Boy songs. If anything I download as a way of "sticking it to the man" if you will.
Era Might Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 (edited) [quote name='OverheadNite' date='Apr 13 2006, 09:12 AM']Well I don't see how anyone could have their doubts about it. [right][snapback]945854[/snapback][/right] [/quote] People have doubts about a LOT of things. It's just part of the moral life. The fact that it is a topic of conversation shows that some people here have doubts about it. If they do, they should see their Priest. Edited April 13, 2006 by Era Might
OverheadNite Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' date='Apr 13 2006, 06:15 AM']People have doubts about a LOT of things. It's just part of the moral life. The fact that it is a topic of conversation shows that some people here have doubts about it. If they do, they should see their Priest. [right][snapback]945855[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I think you make an agreeable point. You are very right, it is always best to dig deep for your answer if you're are unsure. I guess I'm just very sure, so its hard for me to see any doubt in the matter.
morostheos Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 Also remember that "back in the day" it was illegal to even have two VCRs set up to record off of each other unless you had a license or could demonstrate a legitimate need or something (I don't really remember). So even back then it was illegal to copy a VHS tape. The only difference here is that someone else does the copying and passes it on via the internet.
heyyoimjohnny Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 (edited) getting from radio or TV = free stuff anyways getting stuff online = controversial you're not supposed to pay for radio. you [b]are[/b] supposed to pay for CD's and movies to own them. but some fellas download them off the internet. do the places they download from own the copyrights or have permission from the artists to put the stuff up there? anyways, those are my bold and provocative questions for all o' ye who download junk off the internet. sometimes I wonder about it myself, but I usually end up going ascetic and cuttin' stuff out cuz I'm scrupulous. p.s. hows it goin, jon? Edited April 13, 2006 by heyyoimjohnny
Excelsior1027 Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 (edited) I used to download music off the internet, but I stopped, because, well, I think it's wrong. I mean, it's copyrighted music, and all of those songs that you're downloading are illegal copies. How would you feel if you made your own professional music album, but no one bought it because they could just get it for free off the internet? Edited April 13, 2006 by Excelsior1027
philothea Posted April 13, 2006 Posted April 13, 2006 [quote name='OverheadNite' date='Apr 13 2006, 06:12 AM']Well I don't see how anyone could have their doubts about it. As Catholics we are supposed to follow all just laws. The law never states that it is illegal to record a tv show, if it did then a vhs recorder or dvr would be an illegal device to have in any home in the united states. These items such as a cd or dvd burner would be contraban. But I suppose you could be right, burners were first being sold with the ideal that you can make a backup copy of something you've purchased. I guess its like giving a child a book of matches and then tell him not to play with fire. I personally will continue downloading music until the law says otherwise. I think its ridiculous to prosecute a 12 year old girl for downloading a bunch of N'sync and Backstreet Boy songs. If anything I download as a way of "sticking it to the man" if you will. [right][snapback]945854[/snapback][/right] [/quote] It has always been illegal to record shows for archival purposes. There's a copyright notice on all broadcast programming. The legal use of a VCR or DVR is "time shifting" -- meaning you record something you'd otherwise miss, so you can view it later. You really ought to look up the law before making stuff up. This has all been hotly and publicly contested. There may be unclear details of copyright law, but this stuff isn't it. Downloading copyrighted songs because you don't want to pay for them is stealing. Period. You are breaking both human laws and God's commandment. If you're fine with that, then there's something wrong with your conscience.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now