curtins Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 ok so I just got back from Mass this morning (not at my parish- at my aunt's ) and there was deffinatly a liturgcal abuse that really bugged me: after the 2nd reading before the aleluia and the Gospel a hymn was sung- Jesus Christ is risen today. I'm pretty sure ur not supposed to that . but If im wrong, do correct me. Then- im not sure if this is a liturgical abuse but during the sign of peace the priest called all the children up to the alter and gave each a hug. 2 things that bugged me that weren't ligurgical abuses but -crying kids -music-- they had a keybord and bass guitar and little kids and some other people singing. I'm not trying to be critical or u know like im above everyone or anything but I just didn't feel right about those things and they bugged me and honestly took some of the joy out of this great day and the beauty of the mass. well thanks for listening to me pham a happy and joyful Easter to all you guys.
dspen2005 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 i hate to rub it in... but i'm going to do it anyway.... to all, if you are ever in Philadelphia -- the Overbrook section -- go to Our Lady of Lourdes Parish. at the Easter Vigil, the choir was beautiful... we had gregorian chant and polyphony. all of the psalms were chanted in Latin, the Gospel was chanted by the priest -- in English.... during the Baptisms, a Latin polyphony was sung as the priest pronounced the Rite. Then to top off the musical repertoire, the chorus sang the Regina Caeli from Mascagni's Cavelleria Rusticana -- BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!! we had none of this guitar, banjo garbage... no Marty Haugen, Haas, Schutte, or any of those people are done at OLL... we take our music from the Liber Usualis, Roman Graduale... so when you attend the Solemn Latin Mass at OLL, you are attending what is basically a Pontifical Mass in Rome...... EAT YOUR HEARTS OUT!!!!! hahahahaha Happy Easter!!
Andrea348 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='curtins' date='Apr 16 2006, 11:05 AM']ok so I just got back from Mass this morning (not at my parish- at my aunt's ) and there was deffinatly a liturgcal abuse that really bugged me: after the 2nd reading before the aleluia and the Gospel a hymn was sung- Jesus Christ is risen today. I'm pretty sure ur not supposed to that . but If im wrong, do correct me. [right][snapback]948965[/snapback][/right] [/quote] the hymn after the second reading is called the easter sequence. we did it too. this is what it says in the hymnal: [quote]The General Instruction of the Roman Missal directs that the Sequence is to be sung before the Gospel Acclamation on Easter Sunday.[/quote]
Church Punk Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 I had quite the dynamic this Triduum. I attended Holy Thursday and Good Friday at my parish in Windsor, it was the most beautiful liturgies. All prayers were done in Latin Gregorian Chant and during the veneration of the cross the hymns were also in Latin gregorian chant. It felt so Holy. In contrast to this I attened Holy Saturday and Easter Sunday mass at my parents parish, a far more liberal parish. It was different but good for the most part. The began Holy Saturday outside with a holy fire lit in the courtyard which then was used to lite the Easter Candle and the insense. We then Followed the Procession into the near pitch black church to begin the service. It was really quite good, even though some of the music seemed rather cheesey. The only thing that rubbed me the wrong way was they had a liturgical dancer carry up the holy water for baptism. I felt this to be both abuse and coagulated milk, they could have at least made the dance a little better than the way she was. But all in all it was a good experiance.
Paladin D Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='dspen2005' date='Apr 16 2006, 09:10 AM']i hate to rub it in... but i'm going to do it anyway.... to all, if you are ever in Philadelphia -- the Overbrook section -- go to Our Lady of Lourdes Parish. at the Easter Vigil, the choir was beautiful... we had gregorian chant and polyphony. all of the psalms were chanted in Latin, the Gospel was chanted by the priest -- in English.... during the Baptisms, a Latin polyphony was sung as the priest pronounced the Rite. Then to top off the musical repertoire, the chorus sang the Regina Caeli from Mascagni's Cavelleria Rusticana -- BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!! we had none of this guitar, banjo garbage... no Marty Haugen, Haas, Schutte, or any of those people are done at OLL... we take our music from the Liber Usualis, Roman Graduale... so when you attend the Solemn Latin Mass at OLL, you are attending what is basically a Pontifical Mass in Rome...... EAT YOUR HEARTS OUT!!!!! hahahahaha Happy Easter!! [right][snapback]948967[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Gotta love Philly.
shortnun Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='curtins' date='Apr 16 2006, 09:05 AM']I'm not trying to be critical or u know like im above everyone or anything but I just didn't feel right about those things and they bugged me and honestly took some of the joy out of this great day and the beauty of the mass. [right][snapback]948965[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I truly am sorry that these experiences too away some of the beauty from the Mass for you. Liturgy is a powerful means of prayer that we pray [i]as a community[/i]. I'd rather that we as a Phatmass community give praise to our Risen Lord today instead of commenting up the liturgical abuses we've seen. God's peace and abundant blessings.
Colleen Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='curtins' date='Apr 16 2006, 10:05 AM']2 things that bugged me that weren't ligurgical abuses but -crying kids -music-- they had a keybord and bass guitar and little kids and some other people singing. [right][snapback]948965[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well, actually, the keyboard and bass guitar really aren't appropriate for Mass. As for the crying children, well, to quote a Priest I know, "Crying babies at Mass are a sign that the parish is alive and healthy." And there's nothing really wrong with little kids singing. Unless they're singing something inappropriate for Mass.
curtins Posted April 16, 2006 Author Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='Andrea348' date='Apr 16 2006, 09:32 AM']the hymn after the second reading is called the easter sequence. we did it too. this is what it says in the hymnal: [right][snapback]948970[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thank you for the clarification- I assumed it was an abuse because I had never been to a mass before where that was done. Thanks again
Dave Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 Wait ... regarding the sequence ... can it be replaced with another hymn? Because normally the sequence to be sung or said before the Gospel is specified in the missal, and "Jesus Christ Is Risen Today" is just a regular Easter hymn, not the sequence to be used. But are priests allowed to choose another hymn in place of the sequence the rubrics prescribe?
Resurrexi Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 At the indult I went to there was liturgical abuse also. -The gospel was chanted by the priest rather than by the deacon -The song sung after the Credo by the chior was in English, which is not allowed. -half the women werent veiled woe is me! These liturgical abuses were so great that my whole day was ruined /sarcasim/
Dave Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 If I may hijack this thread for a moment to respond to Tyler ... I take it, then, that it was a Solemn High Mass? If so, then it would definitely be an abuse for the priest to read instead of the deacon. However, if it was a Low Mass or a Sung Mass (Missa Cantata -- without deacon and subdeacon), then it wouldn't be. And as for women not being veiled, my indult parish doesn't require it (although it DOES highly encourage it). So if there's no rule at your indult that says women MUST have their head covered, then it can hardly be considered an abuse.
Resurrexi Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 Is a sung Mass different than a solemn high Mass? The priest uses incense, there is a Vidi Aquam/Asperges Me, etc. Is that not high Mass
Dave Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 (edited) [quote name='StThomasMore' date='Apr 16 2006, 02:23 PM']Is a sung Mass different than a solemn high Mass? The priest uses incense, there is a Vidi Aquam/Asperges Me, etc. Is that not high Mass [right][snapback]949191[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I believe "sung Mass" can refer to a Solemn High Mass, but it's normally used to describe a Mass that has chant, incense, etc. BUT NOT a deacon or subdeacon. It's essentially a cross between a Low Mass and a Solemn High Mass. And curtins, I apologize for hijacking your thread. Now let's get back to the original topic. Edited April 16, 2006 by Dave
goldbug16 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 Our Mass was beautiful. Of course being done by Padre Paulo...
Tink Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [color=#58aa1f][b]I am truly sorry that these things disturbed you rather than made you sing for joy! You people really sadden me... liturgical abuse? Half the women werent veiled? Songs in English rather than Latin? Little kids messing up your Easter 'experience'? That makes me sick! Not to be rude, but it all sounds so unchartiable and based on structure... the letter of the law vs. the spirit of the law. This morning at Mass, I sat next to a couple with 6 children, all under the age of 9, who had to get past me and out of the pew every 4 or 5 minutes. They were giggling, whimpering, talking, and doing tons of other things, and I felt so blessed and so filled with joy to be able to sit next to them. As for children singing with a piano, how in the world is that liturgical abuse? Children are the most innocent of us all, so isn't their praise considered just as good, if not [i]more[/i] acceptable to God, than our own? Easter is a time for celebrating LIFE, both that of Christ and of His Bride, the Church! I am a devout Catholic and I love the Lord with all my heart but I don't wear a veil. I think a lot of you need to take a step back and look at how you're approaching your faith if you are this concerned about it. Why don't you stop focusing on what you're deeming as 'liturgical abuses' and begin to rejoice with a childlike faith in the real and holy presence of our Lord on Easter!? Christ looks at the heart, not at the minute and very petty details you're describing here. Your servant in Christ and Mary, Erin[/b][/color]
avemaria40 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 I agree with Tink. Yeah, liturgical abuses smell of elderberries, but don't let that stop you from giving God all the praise you can while you're at Mass. You go to Mass on Easter Vigil/Easter Sunday to rejoice that our Savior has conquered death so that we all may live with Him. Yeah, I noticed a lot of differences at Easter Vigil Mass at my parish and I'll admit, I was dissapointed but I realized that it doesn't matter. We should be singing with joy. Our Lord rose again! That's what's important! Half the women weren't veiled? Why is that so wrong? I have nothing against wearing veils at Mass but who has the right to judge the women for it? It was in English instead of Latin? How do you know God isn't pleased by our worship of Him, no matter the language, as long as that's what our hearts intend? And about the kids, Jesus said, "Let the children come to me" And if they're singing, what can be wrong with that if it's God they are singing to? Jesus also said that we must be like little children if we hope to enter the kingdom of Heaven. Be grateful of their innocense and joy in the Lord and pray that they don't lose it. Don't worry so much what you can get while at Mass, think about the praise you can GIVE to Our Lord! That's what's important!
dspen2005 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 i think that there is a tendency to focus solely on what went wrong at Mass; rather than what went right... and that is that the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Our Lord Jesus Christ was confected in the EUcharist. THAT IS THE ONLY THING THAT GOES RIGHT, ALL THE TIME!!!!! (N.B. according to the approved Rites and rubrics of Mother Church)
Cam42 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' date='Apr 16 2006, 04:23 PM']Is a sung Mass different than a solemn high Mass? The priest uses incense, there is a Vidi Aquam/Asperges Me, etc. Is that not high Mass [right][snapback]949191[/snapback][/right] [/quote] A High Mass is any Mass that is sung. A Missa Cantata is a High Mass sung with no deacons. A Solemn High Mass is a sung Mass with two deacons.
Cam42 Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 [quote name='Dave' date='Apr 16 2006, 04:06 PM']Wait ... regarding the sequence ... can it be replaced with another hymn? Because normally the sequence to be sung or said before the Gospel is specified in the missal, and "Jesus Christ Is Risen Today" is just a regular Easter hymn, not the sequence to be used. But are priests allowed to choose another hymn in place of the sequence the rubrics prescribe? [right][snapback]949179[/snapback][/right] [/quote] No, it cannot. The sequence must be the proper sequence for the occasion. It is an abuse to substitute.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now