LouisvilleFan Posted April 16, 2006 Posted April 16, 2006 This is purely a hypothetical situation that I got to thinking about the other day. Take a Catholic priest who is secretly presiding over black masses. If you're not aware of satanic rituals (this isn't the same as wicca or witchcraft), a black mass essentially mocks everything about a Catholic mass. They will usually gain possession of a consecrated host in order to desecrate it during a black mass, and an even "better" black mass is presided by a Catholic priest. Of course, we all know that as long as a true priest is consecrating the bread and wine, transubstantiation occurs because the miracle relies on God's Word and not on the faith of the priest. But let's say that a priest privately presides over a Liturgy of the Eucharist in the company of satanists for the sole purpose of consecrating a host that would then be used in their satanic worship. He is properly ordained, fully intends to do what the Church intends, and probably follows the GIRM more faithfully than most other priests . However, would it be fair to speculate that God could intervene in this situation and perform a miracle by [i]not[/i] performing a miracle? In other words, despite everything being done "by the book," transubstantiation does not occur and the bread remains only bread. Going by the logic that the sacraments are tied to God and His grace, but God is not tied to the sacraments, it's entirely possible God would not consecrate the bread and wine in that situation. Of course, everything I've read in the Catechism or other Church teaching says the faith of the human participants doesn't affect whether transubstantiation occurs or not. I think it's an interesting question and just wanted to throw it out there for anyone's thoughts.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted April 17, 2006 Posted April 17, 2006 I don't know if you could say the priest in this situation "fully intends what the Church intends". I would have serious reservations about the priest's understanding of the Eucharist were he a priest presiding over a satanic ritual. I can't say for sure, but it seems he would have only a superficial understanding and intention. But, in all honesty, I don't think anyone can really give a definite answer to the question. We ought to just pray that such a sacrilege would be prevented.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now