Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Legionaries Of Christ


Recommended Posts

Spiritual_Arsonist
Posted

My beloved PhatMass Phamily,

I will be in Chesire, Conneticut with the Legionaries of Christ from December 26-31 for a Discernment week. Please pray that the Holy Spirit is with me. Pray that God will show me which order I will join.

:priest:

Posted

I only hear really good things about the Legionaries, and the more I read about them, the more impressed I am.

For those of you know who manCHILD of Mars ILL is--he was brought into the Church by the Legionaries this past Easter, and even thanks them on his album cover (Backbreakanomics).

I'm actually looking into lay opportunities with the Legionaries through Regnum Christi...

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

I only hear really good things about the Legionaries, and the more I read about them, the more impressed I am.

For those of you know who manCHILD of Mars ILL is--he was brought into the Church by the Legionaries this past Easter, and even thanks them on his album cover (Backbreakanomics).

I'm actually looking into lay opportunities with the Legionaries through Regnum Christi...

DISCLAIMER: I do not necessarily agree with what I follows.

You have heard only good things? I've heard a very large nuumber of good things, and an equally large number of horrifyingly scary things. Now, I'm not saying I believe them, but there are a very large number of people out there calling the Legion a dangerous cult which refuses one medical care and contact with the family, that has very little in the way of psychological screening, that uses cult-like behavior to get you to stay if you want to leave, and so on.

I neither confirm nor deny these, as I am not a part of the LC. They are, however, enough to get me to look elsewhere.

Posted

Now, I'm not saying I believe them, but there are a very large number of people out there calling the Legion a dangerous cult which refuses one medical care and contact with the family, that has very little in the way of psychological screening, that uses cult-like behavior to get you to stay if you want to leave, and so on.

Who says this?

  • 3 months later...
Posted

its well known i have friends who say the same thing, they attended seminary for them out in New Hampshire and they said they controlled every aspect of their life.

Posted

The Legionaires ROXXOR!!1

Posted

Hey everyone,
For those of you who read my post earlier [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=10583"]What do I say?[/url], I have been warned about the Legionaries and Regnum Christi as well. However, my first hand experience with them has been nothing of the sort! Before joining Regnum Christi, you have to learn all about their organization, what they stand for, what they expect from their members, etc. To do this, I have been reading "Christ is My Life" which is a book of an interview with Fr. Marical Maciel, the founder of the Legionaries and Regnum Christi. I HIGHLY reccommend this book to anyone who wants to know more about them or has heard bad things. In it, he is asked just about any question you could ever think of, including if they are a cult, if they are overly controlling, etc. His answers are very straightforward.

I encourage all of you to look to the source before making a judgement about them, hearsay is not a reliable source. From my experience, what happens is a semi-orthodox Catholic has bad experiences with them because they are completely faithful to the teachings of the magisterium and refuse to compromise them. Then, they go tell their other Catholic friends of their bad experiences. Their other Catholic friends do not realize the semi-orthodox nature of the person's beliefs, and then relay the negative message on further.

True, the Legionaries are very demanding of their priests. However, this is something that is publicly known. It is not for everyone, and that should be taken into account.

If you'd like to get the book, here's a link for buying it cheap!
[url="http://www.allbookstores.com/book/compare/1928832970"]Allbookstores.com[/url]

Posted

He also isnt allowed in the United States due to the fact that if he enters he will be arrested for five counts of child molestation cases.

On another point he can say what he wants but I have a good friend two doors down from me who was in their seminary in New Hampshire he is still messed up from the formation he received there. He was seriously overcontrolled to the point of his phone convos being tapped, letters being read and opened, etc etc

Spiritual_Arsonist
Posted

I have spent extensive time with the Legion and know one of their priests. I encourage all who have questions to instant message me by using my AOL AIM name. Please fell free to contact me.

Posted

Again read and respond to my previous post please. I dont want to start anything but at the same time i want honest and thought out answers as to why this is happining in their seminaries instead of guys just saying they "rock" because they spent a discernment weekend with them.

My friends from Denver said when they recruited them they were very nice men and treated them very well but as soon as they were in the actual seminary it was a pure hell. And again i raise issues of overcontrolling problems etc.

I dont have a problem with the legionaries being orthodox etc I myself am very orthodox. BUT I do have a problem with how they form their men. It is psychologically unhealthy.

Please address my concerns

Vianney

Posted

[quote name='vianney' date='Apr 16 2004, 10:54 AM'] He was seriously overcontrolled to the point of his phone convos being tapped, letters being read and opened, etc etc [/quote]
I don't see anything wrong with this. I'm sure it's not for everyone, but with [b]complete[/b] submission and obedience comes great rewards. Besides these claims, you've not given any specifics as to how the Legionnaires are harmful. It does sound like hearsay. It also sounds like the exact same things people criticize Opus Dei for.

Posted

Please read and explore this site:
[url="http://www.legionaryfacts.org"]http://www.legionaryfacts.org[/url]

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I know people who had great experiences with LoC and people who had less good experiences. Of the people I know who had bad experiences, I wouldn't use the word "controlling" necessarily, but for lack of a better word, the atmosphere was too "controlling" for them to remain there, they felt that they were not being allowed the ability to discern if they were indeed called to join by God or if they were being pressurred into it. I don't have the full story on why they didn't like it--I have a brother in law who went to the Legionaries for high school and a sister in law who went to Regnum Christi for HS and neither of them recommend it. I also know other people who have joined and are extremely happy there.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='vianney' date='Apr 16 2004, 10:54 AM'] He was seriously overcontrolled to the point of his phone convos being tapped, letters being read and opened, etc etc [/quote]
As for this... the phone conversations being tapped... that would freak me out, but I think its quite normal to have your letters opened and/or shared with the community. My good friend is in a convent where they share all their mail. The sisters there take great joy in sharing their family news with everyone. I know they all love when I send pictures of Adrienne. lol

Posted

they were forced to have their letters opened and read and all letters sent out read they didnt have a choice.

Dust; You can obtain a spirit of obedience while at the same time having individual freedom to grow as a healthy humanbeing. It is UNHEALTHY to do what they do. They are not able to eat ANY food with silverwear all men must use forks to cut grapes and bannanas and if they refuse they are punished. Trust me it isnt hersay my friends would lie about their experiences and I was once recruited by LoC and they are deceptive. They dont tell you how controlling the enviro will be until you actually get there. They put on a good face to get you in there and once they do it is hell.

I have no problem with obedience and discipline but I also know there is a line that needs to be drawn and the LoC cross it. You may have your own opinion about it or what not but I also know that my Bishop wouldnt allow them to eneter our diocese. They were kicked out so to speak and I have heard the same for a number of other dioceses. I dont know what else you want me to tell you. I think that at the core it is a good order but their formation methods are whacked out. I think that I of all ppl should be able to comment on this considering I am in formation in seminary and know what needs to be done to form a man. My rector also agrees who has had years and years and years of experience in the formation of men. Im not blowing smoke around to piss ppl off or start a fight. If you disagree with me that is fine but dont tell me that what I am saying is unfounded because I cant give you documents.


Even Spiritual Arsonist in a private PM convo agreed with me as to why he wont post publically I dont know.

I know some who have gone and liked it and some who have gone that are now getting pyschological help because they are so messed up. Dont tell me what I am saying is unfounded their formation methods are UNHEALTHY.

Posted

Please read and explore this site:
[url="http://www.legionaryfacts.org"]http://www.legionaryfacts.org[/url]



I have read over this site and found nothing to answer my question directly about the over controlling aspects of the order. I already researched that site before you posted that info to.

And to be honest I am not interested in reading what Fr. Marical Maciel has to say about the order considering he cant even come into the United States right now due to his fear of being put in jail for his molestation charges against him.

And to further my reservations for the order they were kicked out of a diocese in California because the Bishop asked them to help the poor at a shelter and they refused because they dont "work with that type of ministry"

They have been known to only work with rich and influencial ppl and sometimes when asked to do ministry work with the poor they refuse. Where is the obedience in that?

Posted

i have heard poxitive and negitive things about them...all the positives and the negitives mentioned here....I have been very impressed by the LC's I have met before good, holy, prayerful priests. they have a very high vocation numbers, BUT persevrance rate is very far from 100%

Posted

[quote name='vianney' date='Apr 16 2004, 01:51 PM'] they were forced to have their letters opened and read and all letters sent out read they didnt have a choice.

Dust; You can obtain a spirit of obedience while at the same time having individual freedom to grow as a healthy humanbeing. It is UNHEALTHY to do what they do. They are not able to eat ANY food with silverwear all men must use forks to cut grapes and bannanas and if they refuse they are punished. Trust me it isnt hersay my friends would lie about their experiences and I was once recruited by LoC and they are deceptive. They dont tell you how controlling the enviro will be until you actually get there. They put on a good face to get you in there and once they do it is hell.

I have no problem with obedience and discipline but I also know there is a line that needs to be drawn and the LoC cross it. You may have your own opinion about it or what not but I also know that my Bishop wouldnt allow them to eneter our diocese. They were kicked out so to speak and I have heard the same for a number of other dioceses. I dont know what else you want me to tell you. I think that at the core it is a good order but their formation methods are whacked out. I think that I of all ppl should be able to comment on this considering I am in formation in seminary and know what needs to be done to form a man. My rector also agrees who has had years and years and years of experience in the formation of men. Im not blowing smoke around to piss ppl off or start a fight. If you disagree with me that is fine but dont tell me that what I am saying is unfounded because I cant give you documents.


Even Spiritual Arsonist in a private PM convo agreed with me as to why he wont post publically I dont know.

I know some who have gone and liked it and some who have gone that are now getting pyschological help because they are so messed up. Dont tell me what I am saying is unfounded their formation methods are UNHEALTHY. [/quote]
I'm assuming you feel that Marine basic training in the military is unhealthy as well?

Posted

[quote name='vianney' date='Apr 16 2004, 01:58 PM'] And to be honest I am not interested in reading what Fr. Marical Maciel has to say about the order considering he cant even come into the United States right now due to his fear of being put in jail for his molestation charges against him. [/quote]
Do you have a source for this information?

Posted

To help clear up the question of the rigidity and discipline of the seminary, I decided it might help if I quote the following in full text:

[quote]{Interviewer}49. Now that you mention being radical, some people think the Legionaries are too demanding, too rigid in their discipline, too serious in their formation. What do you think about that?

{Fr. Maciel}
To form a person, and especially a priest, you have to be very precise, like making a fine watch. Nothing can be missing; all the pieces have to fit together and they must be put together properly for the mechanism to work. The formation of Legionaries is somewhat like that. If we want to form priests to be models of Christian life for the faithful, we need to ensure all the elements that go into the integral formation that a man consecrating his life in the Catholic priesthood should have: his human, intellectual, spiritual, and apostolic formation.

So it all depends on how you understand the terms "demanding," "rigid," and "discipline." Earlier I spoke of being demanding, but not of being rigid. I believe Christ was demanding with his own, but never rigid. When we say someone is rigid, it conjures up the impression that he is inflexible, unable to adjust to reality. Christ was realistic. He knew perfectly what was inside people, inside each person. That is why, even though he presented the gospel ideal with all its demands, he always understood people's failings, falls, and weaknesses. The most obvious case is St. Peter. Christ never lowered the ideal for Peter, not even after he denied him. Remember the wonderful passage where the two of them are on the shore of Lake Tibarias and Christ asks about his love: "Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these others do?" (John 21:15). But when Christ demands, he is full of motivation, affection, tenderness, sincere interest in the other person's good. It's in this positive vein that you can say the Legion is demanding with its members, because it presents them the gospel ideal in all its beauty. But the Legion, like Christ, understands the weakness of man, wounded by sin and full of shadows amid the brilliant light of grace. But I would neither apply nor accept the adjective "rigid," which smacks of intolerance, attempting to apply preconceived patterns without taking into account a person's actual situation.

As regards discipline, we would also need to clarify what kind of discipline we mean and how we understand the word. Some social groupings impose discipline externally, but that is not the discipline we are looking for. We foster a discipline motivated by love, with deep supernatural meaning, that will also be a means for apostolic effectiveness and formative ascesis. If you want to pray; of follow Christ who is poor, chaste, and obedient; or acquire a solid human and intellectual formation, you need to subject yourself to discipline. But this discipline is never a straitjacket. No one forces it on you. You yourself, given the specific purposes you seek, see the need to choose the appropriate way to reach the same. That is why we speak of motivated discipline and personal conviction. If discipline is merely external, it will only work as long as the structures that impose it remain in place, but once they dispappear discipline will also. You build a man from within, from his will, freedom, and reason. This is where he needs to disciplin himself voluntarily. If this is your understanding of discipline, then I would say the Legion esteems it highly, as long as it is guided by faith, love, freedom, and reason, as I just said.

Discipline also has pedagogical and spiritual value. As I mentioned, it has value relative to the goal you seek. You need discipline, for example, to study. If you want to learn a given branch of science systematically, you necessarily have to follow a measure of mental discipline and method. If you want to be effective in military undertakings, you need personal discipline. In this sense, discipline is a means to a goal. It is not the goal in itself. A student and a soldier both need discipline, not to practice it for its own sake but to achieve their goals more easily.

A Christian, too, needs discipline to pray and be virtuous. It is a necessary means. Besides, you see people today put themselves through the toughest discipline to stay healthy, for example, or simply to stay in good shape. No one criticizes their enormous sacrifices for these purposes that are good in themselves, so why should people criticize the discipline it takes to live the gospel? Christ was very realistic in this regard when he told the disciples to strive to enter by the narrow gate, since the gate that leads to perdition is wide (Matt 7:13-14). St. Paul himself employs the image of an athlete training to win his race and win a perishable crown. He concludes that he himself, seeking an everlasting crown, must strive that much harder than those who compete for a perishable prize (1 Cor 9:24-27).

A man who is preparing for priesthood, or is already a priest or religious, likewise has to maintain a personal discipline in line with his vocation. For example, if you want to live in priestly celibacy or take the vow of chastity you need the discipline in your lifestyle that will enable you to be faithful to that commitment. Not to know this would mean operating outside of a healthy concept of man - not just on the Christian but even on the merely human level.

I do not believe in discipline for discipline's sake, but I do believe that man, wounded by original sin, has tendencies that can lead him to evil. The Council of Trent, borrowing an expression from St. Paul, calls this concupiscence. In Romans 7, St. Paul vividly describes the inner battle waged in the theater of the human heart: "I cannot understand my own behavior. I fail to carry out the things I want to do, and I find myself doing the very things I hate...with the result that instead of doing the good things I want to do, I carry out the sinful things I do not want. In my inmost self I dearly love God's Law, but I can see that my body follows a different law that battles against the law which my reason dictates. This is what makes me a prisoner of that law of sin which lives inside my body. What a wretched man I am! Who will rescure me from this body doomed to death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!" (Rom 7:15, 19, 22-24).

We all have to wage this battle against our passions. This is undeniable. Discipline, motivated by love for God, helps us to come out on top in this battle. All the elements of discipline that we use are there for a higher goal and motivated by love. This produces free and mature men, not men with complexes, stunted in their faculties or unfulfilled. Just take some time to observe the seminarians and priests who live the classical elements of Church discipline (the only kind that we demand), and see if they give you the impression of not living life fully. Quite the opposite: This discipline, living in the balance given by faith and the harmoney of the nobler faculties, helps them live what St. Augustine called [i]libertas maior [/i]. They radiate freedom, composure, and self-mastery. They radiate freedom - be they Legionaries of Christ, regular Christians, or members of any other religious congregation or new community. When you practice discipline out of love and in an atmosphere of personal and community balance, it does not enslave, but liberates.[/quote]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...