Paladin D Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 [b][i]Catholic vs Catholic Debate A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. *Effective immediately, any negative criticism of the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators. This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father.[/b][/i] Why then are such threads not being closed and deleted, nor the members having their warning levels raised? I'm so friggon sick and tired of seeing the Debate Forum being flooded with such garbage, while we should be focusing on more important matters! Where are the moderators? Of course I have seen threads shut down, but it seems those that start the Catholic VS Catholic debates go unpunished. What's the deal? [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50336"]Do you support the SSPX?[/url] [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50940"]there is only one Holy Catholic Church..., why refer to Church as either NO or TLM?[/url] [b](The topic starter isn't the one in error, but a few individuals have jumped the bandwagon to bash the NO)[/b]
stbernardLT Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 [quote name='Paladin D' date='Apr 18 2006, 09:13 AM'][b][i]Catholic vs Catholic Debate A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. *Effective immediately, any negative criticism of the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators. This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father.[/b][/i] Why then are such threads not being closed and deleted, nor the members having their warning levels raised? I'm so friggon sick and tired of seeing the Debate Forum being flooded with such garbage, while we should be focusing on more important matters! Where are the moderators? Of course I have seen threads shut down, but it seems those that start the Catholic VS Catholic debates go unpunished. What's the deal? [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50336"]Do you support the SSPX?[/url] [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50940"]there is only one Holy Catholic Church..., why refer to Church as either NO or TLM?[/url] [b](The topic starter isn't the one in error, but a few individuals have jumped the bandwagon to bash the NO)[/b] [right][snapback]952049[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Agree 100%
Myles Domini Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 The sad fact of these debates is that often they're not even debates. Though I dont agree with schismaticism there are some legitimate criticism's that can be made of certain aspects of Catholic life as it exists in the 21st century. Scholars like Aidan Nichols, Edward Oakes, Christoph Cardinal Shonborn etc. have written books on them in fact. At the same time certain aspects of early 20th century Catholic life were not exemplary either and books were written on the same subject by men like Guardini, DeLubac and Danielou. Whether or not their observations are/were apt one can debate yes but most of whats going on is not debate just idle arguing and finger pointing. I'm not against Catholic vs Catholic debates they can be enlightening and intellectually stimulating. However, the threads to which Paladin alludes amount often to little more than unsubstantiated CAPS LOCKED ARGUMENTS insisting on the rightness of one's own position.
jasJis Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 How can you know if you're being good & holy unless you have someone in real life to compare yourself to?
Lil Red Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 it's called the report button. i don't have time to read every single thread. and how do you know people aren't getting warned? ya know, it's not like people are supposed to go around blabbing about their warning level. give us a break, for goodness' sake. we do the best we can.
jezic Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 i understand lil red. I just don't read those anymore. They only go around in circles. Would you like us to report them?
Paladin D Posted April 18, 2006 Author Posted April 18, 2006 [quote name='Lil Red' date='Apr 18 2006, 11:50 AM']it's called the report button. i don't have time to read every single thread. and how do you know people aren't getting warned? ya know, it's not like people are supposed to go around blabbing about their warning level. give us a break, for goodness' sake. we do the best we can. [right][snapback]952219[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I apologize, I didn't mean to come off as if I was blaming the moderators . I'm just frusterated, and it's not just one thread or one post, it's a large trend that I've seen happening on Phatmass lately, and it makes me upset. It just appears as if not much is being done, I'm [b]not[/b] stating this as a fact, but as an observation by someone who does not have moderating controls. How am I to assume warnings are being given out, considering I've seen these types of threads and posts for months now? Wouldn't some of these individuals already be banned by now? This is the most pre-Vatican II's/SSPX's users I've seen since my entire membership here on Phatmass.
jasJis Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 Go figure. And I have a 10% warning level from when I was Catholic. If you're phishy or 'Hello, I don't rep the Church', you can get by with a little more. It's technically not Cath vs Cath. LOL
Lil Red Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 [quote name='jezic' date='Apr 18 2006, 10:51 AM']Would you like us to report them?[right][snapback]952223[/snapback][/right][/quote][b]YES[/b] this is what the report button is for. if you see someone breaking phorum guidelines (found [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?act=boardrules"]here[/url]), please hit the 'report' button and also reference the post number. [quote name='Paladin D' date='Apr 18 2006, 10:57 AM']It just appears as if not much is being done, I'm [b]not[/b] stating this as a fact, but as an observation by someone who does not have moderating controls. How am I to assume warnings are being given out, considering I've seen these types of threads and posts for months now? Wouldn't some of these individuals already be banned by now? This is the most pre-Vatican II's/SSPX's users I've seen since my entire membership here on Phatmass. [right][snapback]952233[/snapback][/right][/quote]actually, you are assuming that nothing is being done. when in fact, things are being done. chill out. and, indirectly, thank you for bringing this threads to our attention. although, in the future, please use the 'report' button instead of making a thread about ti.
Noel's angel Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 you do know you're gonna get an influx of reports now...
rkwright Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 (edited) I agree 100%, but don't blame any of the moderators. But it is sad that once a website that brought me some peace of mind and catholic fellowship has turned into extremely heated arguments that leave me almost angry. Maybe I'm alone here? But I know a few share my feelings, and a few extremely intelligent people have left phatmass due to these threads. just venting... but I think the moderators are doing their best! and thanks for the 'service'! Edited April 18, 2006 by rkwright
dUSt Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 A smaller phatmass doesn't necessarily mean a weaker phatmass. If people leave, they leave. I only concern myself with the people who stay. Anything else is out of my control. But yes, please report posts. If we don't receive reports, we usually don't see the infractions.
Apotheoun Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 [quote name='rkwright' date='Apr 18 2006, 09:40 AM']I agree 100%, but don't blame any of the moderators. But it is sad that once a website that brought me some peace of mind and catholic fellowship has turned into extremely heated arguments that leave me almost angry. [. . .][right][snapback]952318[/snapback][/right] [/quote] The only way to have peace of mind in the Debate Table is to forbid debate entirely, which is hardly productive. Moreover, I am concerned that real intellectual debate is going to be squashed on this phorum. I am also concerned by what I see as a growing trend among some members of phatmass that promotes the false notion that practically everything under the sun is a [i]de fide[/i] teaching of the Church, and that theological debate of any kind is somehow going to undermine people's faith.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 [quote name='Paladin D' date='Apr 18 2006, 10:13 AM'][b][i]Catholic vs Catholic Debate A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. *Effective immediately, any negative criticism of the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators. This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father.[/b][/i] Why then are such threads not being closed and deleted, nor the members having their warning levels raised? I'm so friggon sick and tired of seeing the Debate Forum being flooded with such garbage, while we should be focusing on more important matters! Where are the moderators? Of course I have seen threads shut down, but it seems those that start the Catholic VS Catholic debates go unpunished. What's the deal? [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50336"]Do you support the SSPX?[/url] [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=50940"]there is only one Holy Catholic Church..., why refer to Church as either NO or TLM?[/url] [b](The topic starter isn't the one in error, but a few individuals have jumped the bandwagon to bash the NO)[/b] [right][snapback]952049[/snapback][/right] [/quote] for Catholic VS. Catholic debating: Who qualifies as Catholic under these rules? Would a person, who many of you consider to be "schismatic" be considered a Catholic?
Fidei Defensor Posted April 18, 2006 Posted April 18, 2006 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Apr 18 2006, 02:22 PM']for Catholic VS. Catholic debating: Who qualifies as Catholic under these rules? Would a person, who many of you consider to be "schismatic" be considered a Catholic? [right][snapback]952416[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I, personally, still do them as Catholics. However, Catholics in imperfect communion.
qfnol31 Posted April 22, 2006 Posted April 22, 2006 [quote name='Paladin D' post='952233' date='Apr 18 2006, 11:57 AM'] [...]This is the most pre-Vatican II's/SSPX's users I've seen since my entire membership here on Phatmass. [/quote] What do you mean by pre-Vatican II's? I haven't really notice but three current active members you could label as such. I think maybe one here goes to the SSPX Mass (I could be wrong). [quote name='fidei defensor' post='952677' date='Apr 18 2006, 03:09 PM'] I, personally, still do them as Catholics. However, Catholics in imperfect communion. [/quote] By that definition, and applying the word subsists, many current Catholics think the same about all other religions.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now